16 ms·
Honest question: Why such vitriol against "climate deniers?" The term "climate denier" is loading with negative connotation just on it's face, and it's rarely
by freedomben 8y ago
Honest question: Why such vitriol against "climate deniers?" The term "climate denier" is loading with negative connotation just on it's face, and it's rarely used in isolation in an otherwise respectful way.
There will always be people that disagree with you about something. Some are honest, some are not. Why be an asshole and treat people poorly and disrespectfully? That makes you as bad or worse than them IMHO. Even when they are being assholes (which many are), it is an act of immaturity to lower yourself to that level.
How do you expect to win over hearts and minds when you approach people like that? The worst thing you can do when trying to convince someone of your opinion is offend them by stereotyping, generalizing, and straw-manning their position. How do you feel when people do this to you? Do you find yourself intellectually engaging with them, thinking that they might have some good points?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- IlGrigiore 8y agoSince you do not like the term "climate deniers", what's your proposal for an appropriate and respectful term or definition to aggregate the people that believe that climate change is not happening?
- freedomben 8y agoThat's a decent point. I do find it unfortunate that the term has become polarized because it is a convenient and descriptive categorical term. I don't have any better solutions, other than maybe something more specific that tries to understand the position of the person rather than sticking them in a large group identity with which they likely don't conform to entirely. I generally like to ask people how they identify themselves, and then call them that. If they identify as climate deniers, then the term is completely fine. We find it terribly rude to label somebody with pronouns like "he" or "she" when they prefer something else. I don't see this as much different.
- leppr 8y agoYou could say the same thing about the term "conspiracy theorist". It's just more convenient to label opposing voices with a single, derogatory connotated, term. Especially when the aforementioned group is comprised of many genuinely stupid/malicious individuals. Now the problem with those groups is that their borders are made intentionally blurred. In the case of climate change: industrial/government lobbyists and shills try to mingle with genuinely skeptical citizens. Grouping all these people in a single group is one of the only ways to fight against that, especially when the raw information dissemination power of the opposing party is so much stronger.
- mikelward 8y agoClimate sceptic is the established term.
- DmenshunlAnlsis 8y agoThey’re not skeptical though, that word already means something. They’re in denial, hence denier. “Climate skeptic” is right up there with “pro life” for cynical lack of sincerity. Frankly “climate denier” is already the respectful term, with the more common appellations being some combination of an adjective and “idiot”. Given that a minority of ideologues, religious zealots, and moneyed interests are going to be the death of us all, I’m finding it hard to care about feelings in this debate. If anything, less PC and more hatred might actually lead to a solution, if a messy one. There was a time when denial of this issue was really skepticism, and a time for debate, but it was decades ago. At this point it’s like debating with tobacco companies who wanted to claim that smoking was good for you. It’s not a real debate, it’s dealing with people who are arguing in bad faith for selfish reasons at the cost of human lives. Why should ignorant, dangerous people (at best) and disingenuous people (at worst) be afforded any respect or time? Just because those people pretend (sometimes) to be scientific, skeptical, rational, or sincere doesn’t mean anyone else should be compelled to meet them on their own corrupt terms. It’s like “debating” Creationists, and it’s a waste of time and it demeans the concept of debate. Don’t let cynical bastards drag you down because they learned how to just barely pretend to be skeptics or scientists.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoPerhaps the adjective your looking for there is “useful” https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Useful_idiot At least that combination grants them the opportunity to be victims rather that villains
- dagss 8y agoIt is not as clear cut as that at all. Wikipedia has a page on Denial.. What is "established" is part of the debate too and obviously it is in some deniers interest to instead label themself sceptic. Apparently there has been a debate about this: https://ncse.com/library-resource/why-is-it-called-denial https://ncse.com/library-resource/why-is-it-called-denial https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_denial https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_denial
- Udik 8y ago> to aggregate the people that believe that climate change is not happening? First of all, you shouldn't "aggregate" them. Very few if those who are usually called "climate deniers" actually believe that climate change is not happening. Did you know that? In general, apart from total deniers, there's people who think climate change might not be as bad, or extreme, or as manmade, or that catastrophic predictions need some check. Labelling them all as "deniers" is just a very handy (and toxic) way to close the conversation.
- briandear 8y agoNobody on the mainstream sides of the climate debate are claiming the climate isn’t changing. We are claiming that human causes have an effect less significant than the alarmist side claims. Basically, if we all stop running our air conditioner, it isn’t going to have any significant effect on long term global temperatures. Basically we object to the idea that lowering standards of living is a meaningful cure for rising temperatures. Humans absolutely cause pollution, nobody “denies” that and most of us care deeply about actual pollution. But once CO2 started being considered some kind of pollutant, the environmental movement essentially jumped the shark in my view. CO2 is just as much a pollutant as oxygen but it is being treated by politicians as if it were benzene.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoActually “CO2” in the context of climate change discussions shouldnt be seen as the specific gas with the same name. Usually it’s a short hand for CO2e https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_equivalent https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_equivalent
- drdeadringer 8y agoIf not CO2, what do you consider pollution which influences climate change? How do you consider oxygen to be causing climate change? What would you suggest Humans do to reduce their negative impact on climate change if not "turning off the AC"?
- gnulinux 8y agoCO2 is a pollutant just like O2 is a pollutant. The earth has a certain balance and the physical phenomena as well as the biosphere collectively support and rely on this balance. If you add too much O2 you'll get a mass extinction. This was the causes of one the earliest mass extinctions on the earth. [1] CO2 is an essential gas for life to be sustained, arguably as important as O2, but that doesn't mean you can arbitrarily add CO2 to the system and expect similar outcome. At some point you'll break the system. This is true for other "good" gases too such as O2, N2, H2 etc... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
- luckydata 8y agoBecause their stupidity is going to kill us all. I'm very vitriolic against people that are trying to kill me and my family, I can't help it.
- AndrewUnmuted 8y agoDo you not see how your reply to the OP's sincere question amounts to the same lackluster, overgeneralized, and lazy intellectual stance that the people you're criticizing take on climate science? You couldn't have more aptly proved the OP's point.
- froogie 8y agoHonestly, I do not see it that way. To me it seems as if sizable chunk of people believe in nonsense, and the nonsensical beliefs and actions based on such beliefs are detrimental not only to the people holding such beliefs, but every single living entity on this planet, future generations included. How is that acceptable? With what right do the people holding these beliefs keep acting the way they do? It is the reaponsibility of the rest of us to stop this madness as soon as possible. It is the responsibility we as species hold to our ancestors and future generations. If it is all in vain for you. Fine. But please do consider other living organisms as as important as you, for you are one of us. We are in this together.
- antisthenes 8y ago> Do you not see how your reply to the OP's sincere question amounts to the same lackluster, overgeneralized, and lazy intellectual stance that the people you're criticizing take on climate science? Do not give equal weight to nonsense beliefs and beliefs supported by decades of science. That's the real toxicity - when you try to attempt to give them equivalency despite different efforts having gone into forming them. I'm sorry that isn't clear to some people, but that doesn't make nonsense any less excusable or valid or show a need to 'win their hearts'.
- luckydata 8y agoThere was nothing sincere about OP's question just as there's nothing lackluster about my answer. You can play your two-sideism game with people that buy that bullshit, I don't.
- dirkgently 8y agoTo generalize, "why such vitriol again science-deniers?". It's one thing to talk to Bible thumpers, but science-deniers are not Bible thumpers. They use pseudo science to discredit science. They gave an agenda against science. And in the USA, they tend to align well with alt-right. They deserve all the vitriol they get, and some more.
- saudioger 8y agoSame reason for the vitriol against anti-vax. These are people who are claiming to know better than the vast majority of the scientific community (seriously, it's something like 99%+), despite having little to no expertise in the field. Multiple independent governments, thousands of peer reviewed studies across multiple disciplines, data collected from satellites, billions of dollars across decades of research... but still not enough. It's stupid and dangerous. To be capable of thinking that it's a hoax requires a severe lack of understanding of the simple scale of humanity. I find it more believable to think that you've been personally abducted by aliens than any segment of humanity having the ability to pull off a trick of such magnitude.
- 78h321sadfh7z 8y agoAppeal to authority is not a legitimate argument in a discussion. Neither is reducing one side of the debate to climate change being a "hoax". The general debate in the scientific community resolves around the question as to what extent humans are involved, and this debate is still alive even if the majority wants it to be suppressed. The fact that the majority of scientists behaves irrational and pushes inadequate models into politics doesn't make their arguments any better.
- mjfl 8y agoAll this may be true, but appeal to authority is still a logical fallacy. You can't just shame people into believing something they don't understand because "smarter" people believe it. It's a shameful failure of communication more than anything else. And I don't understand why people like you don't understand that.
- jaredklewis 8y agoSpecialization is an unavoidable fact of life. Not everyone can be an expert in everything. If my car mechanic (or 99 out of 100 car mechanics) says I need new brake pads, and I don’t know anything about car maintenance, why would I reject their diagnosis? I would not only be endangering myself, but other drivers. If I am going to reject my mechanic’s diagnosis I need to have strong evidence and reasoning to support my position. Climate deniers don’t have that, and their pigheadedness puts everyone at danger. Efforts to summarize the scientific evidence for global warming for laymen are myriad. The arguments and evidence for global warming are extremely accessible. I don’t see how the blame isn’t on the climate deniers.
- gt_ 8y agoDoes “* denier” really count as vitriol? I don’t personally use this language, but for what I think is a different reason: if removing a noun-forming suffix yields a verb which defines the extent of a category, I just think this results in an extraneous lack of specificity (you could instead just describe the subject as performing the action). I also think it’s collectively beneficial to not go out of our way to categorize each other, but I wouldn’t be so quick to apply that to personal situations. So, I can’t understand taking “climate denier” to be personally offensive or vulgar. If you don’t like your own view, you’re entirely free to just change your mind.
- freedomben 8y ago> Does “* denier” really count as vitriol? Great question. I agree with your logic, and that on its face it isn't vitriolic, or even really offensive (or shouldn't be at least). However I've only ever really seen the term used by people that are using it as a pejorative. For that reason I take more of a structuralist view on the meaning, which is subjective. I've never heard somebody (excluding trolls) describe themselves as a "climate denier" either.
- drdeadringer 8y ago> I've never heard somebody (excluding trolls) describe themselves as a "climate denier" either. How do they describe themselves?
- mirimir 8y agoFirst, most of the credentialed ones are funded by fossil fuels industries. Either directly or via shells to obscure sources. And so their objectivity is at least questionable. Second, there's support from public relations firms, also clearly funded by fossil fuels industries. It grew out of the "smokers rights" campaign in the early 80s, which was funded by the tobacco industry. And indeed, the "climate-change denial" campaign is basically a clone of that. Involving the same firms, but with much broader funding. So basically, virtually none of the climate-change deniers have a clue about the underlying science. So "intellectually engaging" with them is pointless. You could maybe help them see how they've been manipulated. But that too is probably pointless, because they're up to their noses in a smothering meme swamp.
- briandear 8y ago“Ridicule is man's most potent weapon." "Keep the pressure on." "The threat is usually more terrifying than the thing itself." "The major premise for tactics is the development of operations that will maintain a constant pressure upon the opposition." "If you push a negative hard and deep enough it will break through into its counterside" "Pick the target, freeze it, personalize it, and polarize it." From Saul Alisky’s Rules for Radicals. These are precisely the tactics being used against climate skeptics. Rather than actually caring about debating the science, the alarmist side instead uses phrases like “virtually none of the climate-change deniers have a clue about the underlying science.” The whole debate stopped being about science years ago and it has instead become a battle of economic ideology. It’s impossible to have a rational debate when the leadership of the debate engages in ad hominem attacks as a matter of tactics. We talk about “science,” yet hold up an Inconvenient Truth as some sort of inflatable prophesy, as if Al Gore were Moses holding the Ten Commandments. Despite all sorts of debunked aspects of that film, to call it into question means we are somehow intellectually inept. One would be intellectually inept to not call it into question! As far as realizing how we have been manipulated — that manipulation cuts both ways: many people actually think the debate is still about the climate. It’s not. It’s about economic systems and the means of production. I’ve stopped caring about the debate and just quietly vote for candidates with whom I agree. There is an expression about wrestling pigs that comes to mind when I think about the climate debate..
- guelo 8y agoHow can you read a post about denier's deliberate bad faith manipulation and then complain that they're the ones being treated unfairly. Almost makes me think you are not arguing in good faith.
- freedomben 8y ago> How can you read a post about denier's deliberate bad faith manipulation and then complain that they're the ones being treated unfairly. Almost makes me think you are not arguing in good faith. I don't see anywhere that I complained that they are the ones being treated unfairly (which implies that I think they are being treated unfairly but the "climate accepters" (not sure of a good term here) are not. Nor do I think that. I think both sides have people that treat each other that way. It's counterproductive regardless of which side is doing it. I don't find it relevant so was going to omit this, but since you questioned my personal "good faith," I will say that I generally accept the climate science. I wouldn't consider myself a purist, but I find the evidence compelling. So I'm "on the team." Is that what you needed to know to evaluate my position?
- colllectorof 8y agoPolitical brainwashing, that's why. This is exactly how it works. You take an issue (social, cultural, scientific, religious - does not matter), use it as a division line between "us" and "them", pick a side, them bombard "us" with messages that dehumanize "them" to the point where there is no possibility of rational conversation between the two sides. Bam. Now you have political control over a group of people, and that control can be exercised outside of the context of the original problem. It is very unfortunate that ecology was chosen as one of the issues to politicize, because it already was one of the most complex fields of research there is, not to mention that issues in that field have potential to affect most of the people on the planet. My advice? De-escalate the rhetoric wherever you can. That's the only way forward in the long run, for everybody.
- bjourne 8y agoBecause climate change denial is completely equivalent to Holocaust denial: You have a theory (yes theory!) that completely and convincingly explains all the available evidence: millions of Jews and others were murdered in German concentration camps. Opponents to this theory has absolutely nothing. They can sow doubt, but can't offer up a theory that explains even a fraction of the available evidence. You have another theory that convincingly explains all the available evidence: CO2 emissions from human activity increases the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere which causes more sunlight to be reflected back to the surface of the earth which causes warming. Opponents to this theory has absolutely nothing. They can not offer up any alternative theory that explains the observed warming. All they can do is sow doubt.
- briandear 8y agoWe have pictures and first person accounts of the Holocaust. With human-causes global warming, we have hyperbole and predictions that fail to happen again and again. “Climate Denial” isn’t the same as Holocaust denial, it’s more akin to blasphemy. Replace “global warming” with “God” and the debate would be identical: each side tries to prove there case, but not a single person who has already picked a side will be convinced otherwise. However normally, it’s ok for people to have disagreements, but when one side attempts to impose Sharia then the debate hits a fever pitch because it affects the core of our very way of life.
- cm2187 8y agoI think part of that is a sign of our time, everything is either black or white, the good guys against the villains, "whoever disagrees with me is a bastard, no discussion, no debate, let's aim at the throat". At the moment the right is taking the blunt of these insults. Whoever disagree with the current feminist campaign is a misogynist bigot, a traditional patriarchy advocate. Whoever disagrees with the black lives matter movement is a racist. Whoever voted for Trump is an ignorant fascist. Whoever posts a comment agreeing with something Trump does is an alt-right, russian troll. Whoever voted for Brexit is an old uneducated racist. This is why I kind of agree with hn's policy of banning political debate. It very quickly ends up with name calling and we all have better things to do of our time.
- CuriousSkeptic 8y agoProblem is that most of your examples are things where disagreement is actually a valid thing. They’re are all political in nature and different opinions are just that, opinions. Climate change isn’t. It’s a scientific fact. On the same footing as the second law of thermodynamics at this point. There just is no disagreement to be had that isn’t as ludicrous as debating political sides of the flat earth “theory” The only thing we should be disagreeing on is what to do now that we know these facts. Not on wether they are facts.
- cm2187 8y agoThe change in temperature observed is a fact. The explanation is a mathematical model of a very complex mechanism that we barely understand. For instance there was an article on hn recently about how the ocean could capture a lot more co2 than anticipated [1]. And none of these models had the benefit of being tested for their capacity to predict the future. Anyone who has toyed with any predictive model knows how easy it is to overfit a back-testing. I am not saying that there is no global warming, neither than human co2 emission plays no role (and there are many other good reasons to reduce pollution anyway). But I wonder what makes everyone else so confident that they know that for a fact that it is entirely caused by human activity. And the problem is that name calling, or mixing what should be scientific considerations with all sort of political considerations (about the sins of capitalism, the relations of man with nature, etc) is only going to aggravate those who doubt, not convince them. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17704479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17704479
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Why such vitriol against "climate deniers?" Climate deniers are either dishonest people spreading lies aimed at sacrificing the future of humanity for short-term personal gain or people following them in the destruction of humanity out of tribal allegiance. There is literally no conceivable level of verbal vitriol that isn't far better than they deserve; the only reason for any restraint in that dimension is tactical, and even there excessive restraint i can be counterproductive; rational debate few of emotional charge may be a Vulcan ideal, but it is not, empirically, ideal in most broad human contexts. It's m it is important to be able to engage rationally in seeking the truth, but as long as that's not what everyone else does, it's going to remain less than ideal for spreadin the truth and mobilizing action based on it.
- nkurz 8y agoClimate deniers are either dishonest people spreading lies aimed at sacrificing the future of humanity for short-term personal gain or people following them in the destruction of humanity out of tribal allegiance. This seems a little extreme. Do you really think everyone labelled a denier is dishonest, in that they actually know the "truth" and instead are choosing for personal gain to spread "lies"? Is there really no room for "misguided", or even simply "wrong"? Here's the autobiographical note for the originator of the graph that's being skewered: https://stevengoddard.wordpress.com/who-is-steven-goddard/ https://stevengoddard.wordpress.com/who-is-steven-goddard/. He describes himself as a bicycle-riding lifelong-environmentalist who worked to get the clean air act passed. He says he never uses heat or air conditioning, and guesses that he has "the smallest electricity bill in Columbia, Maryland because I am very careful not to waste". This isn't the self-narrative I'd expect for someone "aimed at sacrificing the future of humanity for short-term personal gain". Instead, he sounds like someone who genuinely believes there are flaws in the current version of climate science, and that a better approach is necessary to save (not sacrifice) humanity. What makes you so convinced he's dishonest, rather than a true believer with different beliefs?
- xg15 8y agoOoh, I see. So he created a deliberately misleading graph by cherry-picking data and ignoring scientific best practices because he wants to help climate science. Now it makes sense.
- mnm1 8y agoYou're asking why we're not polite to the people destroying the world around us with their stupidity. Because politeness is secondary to having a world that's livable in. People get angry when others mess with their life and livelihood. We want to live, not to die and if others get in the way, politeness and kindness are inappropriate responses. It's not much different than responding with politeness when a country is invaded by others. Destruction is the end result in both cases so people get angry and rightfully so. It's either that or allowing your own destruction to happen. Not to mention that people do not listen to logic or reason. Trying to convince others who are fanatical about their beliefs with reason and logic is a waste of time.
- hobs 8y ago1. Because its gaining traction, its not something that is becoming less of an issue over time, and people in power are promoting it for their own vile ends. 2. No, treating people poorly who continually spread misinformation and lies does not make you bad or worse than them, this is a silly misrepresentation that would almost arise to this question fitting classic sealioning. 3. There is no expectation to win over hearts and minds, and this isnt a debate - its simply evidence being denied out of hand because it doesn't fit the person's narrative. It should be dealt with just as much scorn as a flat earther. There's no good points when someone isn't willing to bring table stakes of "willing to acknowledge evidence"
- loco5niner 8y ago> treating people poorly who continually spread misinformation and lies does not make you bad or worse than them So, from their perspective, they should be able to treat you poorly. See how behaving badly towards people you disagree with goes both ways?
- wdr1 8y ago+1 I believe there's sufficient evidence to justify action on climate change. However, it's a complex topic with complex solutions. I've found even basic questioning results in a kneejerk "climate denier!" reaction from most. Sadly, it's actually counterproductive for making progress on a very important issue.
- Tycho 8y agoOr going the another way, why such faith in the climate fitters? Global warming skepticism has got almost nothing to do with “climate denial PR campaigns” and everything to do with people having functioning BS detectors. To wit: * lofty claims of certainty based on computer models that can’t be effectively tested with out-of-sample data * argument relying on “consensus” of the scientific “community” * unseemly behaviour of said community revealed in “climategate” emails * second rate academic talent jumping on a career long gravy train * stipulations by leftist politicians for concentration of vast powers to control the economy to fix the problem * creeping attribution of all sorts of other problems as second order effects of warming * rebranding if the language from “global warming” to “climate change” * the ridiculous idea that “trusting science” is the same thing as trusting scientists. Nobody actually trusts scientists, they trust feedback loops and well-aligned incentives. Take those things away and the trust rightfully evaporates.
- pas 8y agoThese are the same people who think Trump is always right. So maybe their BS detector is biased or something ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- Tycho 8y agoHoodwinked by Russian bots no doubt. Certainly nothing to do with the low credibility of the political establishment.
- subsection1h 8y ago> Global warming skepticism has [...] everything to do with people having functioning BS detectors. To wit: [...] LOL. Notice that none of your points address any specific studies. I've never met a self-identified climate change skeptic who reads the journals of the American Geophysical Union[1], like I have since the 1990s. But you people have "functioning BS detectors", "common sense", etc. -- just like all the creationists I've met. [1] https://publications.agu.org/journals/ https://publications.agu.org/journals/
- 8y ago
- ttonkytonk 8y agoI think this is a good point in general. I often find myself sympathizing with those who are otherwise wrong simply because of the tone of the criticism.