4 ms·
I always thought division by zero was, at best, + and - infinity, depending on the path, which is why we leave it undefined. How would a path lead to 17?
by wodenokoto 8y ago
I always thought division by zero was, at best, + and - infinity, depending on the path, which is why we leave it undefined.
How would a path lead to 17?
- KenoFischer 8y agoTake the path (x,y)=(17a,a) as a goes to zero one dimensionally.
- gpm 8y ago24 / 2 17 / 1 1.7 / 0.1 0.17 / 0.01 0.017 / 0.001 ... 0 / 0
- MereInterest 8y agoTake the limit as x goes to 0 of (17*x)/(x). Both numerator and denominator go to 0, so this is a representation of 0/0. The limit is then equal to 17.
- tigershark 8y agoThis just means that 0/0 = 1. It doesn’t mean that any number / 0 tends to 17.
- phyzome 8y agoRight, it just means the limit of that path tends to 17. It's not a well-defined limit. In a function of one-variable, there's a distinction between one-sided and two-sided limits. I don't know what the terminology would be for multivariable functions, but this is closer in nature to a one-sided limit.
- zormino 8y agoBut think about what a limit is. Think of X and Y as their own functions. so something more like X(g) / Y(g). As g increases, X and Y can take any path across the plane that they want. We get to arbitrarily choose what X and Y are. All we are doing is describe how our limit behaves as we slide along the scale towards infinity. Just because g increased by went from 10 to 11 doesn't mean that X and Y behaved the same way. We can arbitrarily choose X and Y such the limit as g approaches infinity is 0 for both, but the way that X and Y are changing is different. Like the example above, if we choose X and Y such that X(g)/Y(g) is 17 for all g, but the X and Y both approach 0 as g approaches infinuty, then as g approaches infinity X and Y go to 0, but X / Y (0 / 0), goes to 17. It's not a true 0/0, because the functions we chose got to 0 at different rates.
- phyzome 8y agox=170, y=10 x=17, y=1 x=1.7, y=0.1 x=0.17, y=0.01 The answer keeps being 17, even as x and y both get vanishingly close to zero. I encourage you to play around with a 3D graphing calculator and see all the different paths you can take along that surface to reach the singularity. They all "reach" it at different heights.
- DoctorOetker 8y agoyou are explaining why 0 / 0 can approach 17, this is much less controversial, and is often considered the bottom element...
- Jach 8y agoIn calculus you're supposed to learn that y/0 with y != 0 is "undefined" (±Inf with limit expressions), while 0/0 is "indeterminate" (can construct any value using a limit expression that contains x/x with x -> 0).