3 ms·
Is he unaware that planes have millions of lines of code? Writing robust software is possible, but nobody wants to pay for it when it isn't safety-critical.
by IshKebab 8y ago
Is he unaware that planes have millions of lines of code?
Writing robust software is possible, but nobody wants to pay for it when it isn't safety-critical.
- TeMPOraL 8y ago> Is he unaware that planes have millions of lines of code? He's an ex-NASA engineer, so he's perfectly aware of that. > Writing robust software is possible, but nobody wants to pay for it when it isn't safety-critical. That's the core reason why the field of software engineering is bad at what it does, while aviation isn't. Somehow, aviation can get people to pay for doing the job right, while software cannot.
- odyssey7 8y agoI had hoped "software engineer" would have meant more of a focus on making systems reliable, vs "software developer," but in my experience it's only a trendy job title preference.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y agoIn Canada you can't call yourself an engineer unless you're an actual engineer. While I don't know if it helps actual software quality, it can't hurt that there's been at least some rigor applied. When the title is totally users choice and interchangeable with software developer/programmer/code monkey/Mr. Pill the Wonderful Computer Magician, it doesn't mean anything. Though now I am wondering if there have been studies correlating work performance and title. My initial thought is there is no correlation, considering all the technical support analysts running around.
- philipov 8y agoMoreover, designing to not crash is a task requiring understanding of the laws of physics, which is something that STEM education is good at providing. Meanwhile, protecting against hacking requires large doses of empathy, which is something that the profession seems to weed out. I would trust engineers to design against physics long before I'd trust them to even design an interface for a non-technical user. The laws of physics don't try to adapt to your security measures.
- SketchySeaBeast 8y ago> Somehow, aviation can get people to pay for doing the job right, while software cannot. I believe it's because "software crash" and "plane crash" carry slightly different weights.
- IshKebab 8y ago"bad at what it does" can't be inferred from the fact that a lot of software is buggy. People want buggy cheap software. If there were a market for unreliable cheap planes I'm sure the aviation market would provide. You can get crap cheap microphones, and nice expensive ones but we don't claim that microphone designers are "bad at what they do" because the cheap ones they make sound bad.
- NullPrefix 8y agoPlane engineers use the software, not make it. It's totally possible they believe software is reliable.