5 ms·
more frequently breaking traffic law I can't find it right now but there was some research done in the UK recently that showed the opposite was the case.
by tonyedgecombe 8y ago
more frequently breaking traffic law
I can't find it right now but there was some research done in the UK recently that showed the opposite was the case.
- robinwassen 8y agoMight be so statistically, but people do not experience statistics and build their perspective from it. Emotionally seeing someone running a red light or making up their own lane has a higher impact than someone speeding in a car lane. I think it has to do with cultural acceptance.
- rogual 8y agoSurprising. In London at least, when you cross at a crossing, you always have to check for cyclists skipping the lights.
- InitialLastName 8y agoSure, but what % of the drivers habitually go faster than the listed speed limit? In the parts of the US I live in, the difference between that number and 100 is imperceptible, especially on the roads with speed limits on the lower end (~25 mph).
- pja 8y agoIIRC the two road users tended to break the rules in different ways, so it's unsurprising that as a pedestrians you might be more aware of one class than the other.
- twak 8y agoa counter point: when cycling in London you have to be aware that 30% of the time there will be be a vehicle stopped the protected bike zone in front of the lights...
- Symbiote 8y agoWhen I'm in London, I check that the first car is going to stop at the crossing. That's by no means guaranteed. Once the first car is stopped, the others have no choice. All cyclists reaching the crossing can pass on red if they choose, so the comparison needs to take that into account.
- foldr 8y agoIt's certainly routine to see cyclists running red lights in London. I'm sure cars do that sometimes, but I can't recall ever having seen a car do it while I was crossing the road.
- Arnt 8y agoIndeed. But if a car does it someone may die. Even a fast cyclist needs a lot of bad luck to run over and kill someone. Finding a fair way to count these things is really difficult.
- foldr 8y agoSure, but cyclists can't use that as an excuse for bad behavior. I mean, if I punch someone, it's unlikely to kill them, but that doesn't mean I can just take a swing at someone whenever I feel like it.
- quicklime 8y agoSure, it's in no way a valid excuse. But one act is much more dangerous than the other - a cyclist running a red light and a driver doing it are not morally equivalent, and it's slightly offensive to cyclists to claim that it is.
- Tomte 8y agoOf course it is just as dangerous. We‘re not talking about a cyclist killing a car driver, we‘re talking about a cyclist getting killed. That can easily happen with a cyclist running a red light. I find it strange that cyclists love to discuss things as if bad outcomes to themselves didn‘t matter as long as they are the ones responsible. That‘s no way to sensibly talk about traffic safety.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoAt some UK junctions a cyclist riding through red will make virtually no difference to anyone; in the same way as motorist on some sections of motorway (ie freeway), in good conditions, driving over the speed limit will make virtually no difference. A car jumping the light leaves no room for another car; a cyclist doing it leaves more than enough room. Yes, if they're busting through a pedestrian crossing with pedestrians on, or going on to a narrow junction, etc.. then you're in to dangers similar to "not indicating" (something that puts me in danger as a pedestrian every day). A cyclist hitting a car, it's extraordinarily unlikely to kill anyone including themselves. The contrary is not so. That's why cyclists don't worry as much about the possibility of hurting others on the roads. Of course interactions with pedestrians are bad all round, but much worse physically for cyclists than for vehicle drivers. There are imbalances, ignoring them doesn't make anyone safer.
- Arnt 8y agoIt may plausibly depend on how you add your apples and oranges. How are you going to count a traffic accident with two deaths against a bicycle leaning against a shop's display window (that's a really extreme example, yes)?