12 ms·
I think the hypocrisy and self righteousness of some movements like fanatical cycling particularly gets people worked up online. (Complaining about car drivers
by chrisseaton 8y ago
I think the hypocrisy and self righteousness of some movements like fanatical cycling particularly gets people worked up online.
(Complaining about car drivers being unsafe but then constantly running red lights themselves.)
- belorn 8y agoData over traffic accident and injuries should define which transportation is more unsafe, especially since most traffic laws exist in order to prevent accidents. To my knowledge, speed and braking distance is the biggest factor for accident rates and injuries. The average bike speed in a flat city was last time I checked around 12km/h (7mph), which has a very short braking distance. Unsurprising the accident rate of bike hitting pedestrians is extremely rare for a flat city, where the top listed accident rate for bikers here in Sweden is 1) person falling off the bike with no other person involved, 2) car hitting bike in a crossing where the car is running a speed usually above the speed limit. A typical car driving at 50km/h (30mph) has a reaction distance of 21m, braking distance of 14m and total stopping distance of 35m. This is why efforts to reduce high accident rates for crossing involving cars is done by reducing the speed through speed bumps, cameras that publicly display the speed, and additional traffic lights. In the cases where those efforts are not enough there is usually talk about separating the traffic since the lowest speed limit is 30km/h and that still produce a risky braking distance for highly trafficked crossings.
- m0nty 8y ago> constantly running red lights themselves A motorist runs a red light, it's one stupid motorist. A pedestrian crosses a road dangerously, it's one stupid pedestrian. A cyclist runs a red light, it's all cyclists. I have no idea how that works.
- pja 8y agoIt's a classic example of in group / out group thinking: Cyclists are the out group, so any action of one of them is perceived as representative of the whole group. In group members are perceived differently - wrongful actions are perceived as the individual's responsibility and are not extended to the group as a whole.
- m0nty 8y agoIt's strange how cyclists have become an outgroup though. Carlton Reid ("Roads Were Not Made for Cars") suggests it goes all the way back to the 1880s and reckless young men on "pennies". Still one of the common criticisms is "young hoodlums on bikes terrorising the neighbourhood". At least that distinction implies it's not all cyclists, just the "hoodlum" variety.
- Tomte 8y agoIt works the same in the other direction. Cyclists also generalize about all car drivers. It‘s a human tendency to extract patterns from singular, highly emotive situations.
- Jonnax 8y agoI don't think that's so much of a factor. I've met plenty of people that do not use the internet have irrational hatred for cyclists in the UK. It seems like it's a car culture thing. And whenever a driver sees a cyclist doing something wrong it confirms the idea to them. Regardless of whether there's any merit to it.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoThe media like to stir it up, the Daily Mail in particular seems to have a hatred for cyclists. My own parents regurgitate this hatred at me even though they know I'm a cyclist.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoI wouldn't take it personally, Daily Mail readers like to regurgitate misinformed hatred at anyone who will listen (and often at people who'd rather not).
- 7952 8y agoWe apply very draconian rules to motorists, and then people get upset when those same kind of rules are not applied to other users. It is very inconsistent and that makes people angry. But this ignores the fact that motor vehicles are exceptional in terms of the harm they can cause simply due to weight and speed. That is why we need draconian and annoying laws, but only for motor vehicles. The risk posed by bikes and pedestrians is so small that strictly enforced rules would be authoritarian and restrict freedom to an unacceptable degree. I do agree that cyclists should follow rules. But the magnitutde of danger caused by rule breaking is massively lower and that should be acknowledged. A dangerous driver is committing a worse crime than a careless cyclist. Also, cyclists are not some homogeneous group. The person complaining about dangerous drivers is not neccessarily the person going through a red light.
- zaarn 8y agoWhy do Cyclists get to be special? Where I live, the same rules apply for cyclists as for drivers up to loosing your drivers license for biking drunk (including biking ban). A bike can do a lot of damage and harm once it goes beyond walking speed and even at walking speed it can be quite dangerous. I get that not every cyclists runs the red lights but those that do are a clear danger to traffic safety.
- 7952 8y agoYou could also have a rule that bans drunk pedestrians. Because they could cause an accident by making a car swerve. They are also more dangerous in terms of committing other crimes. The difference is that pedestrians and cyclists don't weigh several tonnes and are able to move at very high speeds. I am not suggesting that bad behaviour should be legal. Merely that it is not morally comparable to dangerous driving.
- maxerickson 8y agoLots of places do have laws that ban people from being intoxicated in public. They often aren't severe, more so police are able to remove extremely intoxicated people from a public location.
- lmm 8y agoI find the way car drivers go on about running red lights (which is not inherently dangerous, so there's no contradiction between running red lights and caring about safety) to be hypocritical given how often drivers break speed limits (which is just as much a violation of the rules of the road and much less safe).
- dang 8y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17731908 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17731908 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]