4 ms·
On the subject of drilling math, I would like to hear if any of you other readers have had experience with Kumon. I've been taking my kid to it, but I'm getting
by lordnacho 8y ago
On the subject of drilling math, I would like to hear if any of you other readers have had experience with Kumon. I've been taking my kid to it, but I'm getting increasing resistance from his side, while also not seeing quite why I'm doing it.
Kumon is basically a daily set of very similar questions (1+3=, 2+3=, 8+3=) with a weekly workshop where you do the same. The goal is to have all the arithmetic drilled into memory, so the workbooks are very repetitive.
On paper it sounds great to be drilling math questions, and I used to do it myself. But his Kumon stuff is very slow at changing, and my son is complaining that he already knows the stuff and is doing more interesting things in school. School happens to be doing Singapore Maths, which is yet another philosophy of math teaching.
The problem is the kid is understanding what I understand, which is that endless drilling isn't math. I'm a bit more ambivalent having done a load of math beyond his level, and knowing that it's useful to memorize a few things. But I can't but feel he's right and even I am bored doing the workbooks over his shoulder.
There must be some alternative way I can regularly show him interesting stuff in math.
- leonroy 8y agoI did Kumon from about 9 till about 14 and I sure complained about it a lot to my parents! They persisted thank goodness because it fundamentally altered the way my brain ‘sees’ numbers. I can’t speak for that happening in every case but it was incredibly valuable for me and I’ve always found mathematics straightforward and immensely satisfying since then. I’ll be ensuring my children go once they’re old enough - you can be certain of that!
- zaarn 8y agoIn my experience, drilling doesn't lead to an understanding and rather to simply repeating the exercise from memory. A true understanding of the matter will get you farther than being able to recite past exercises, especially once you write an exam where the numbers and exercises have changed a lot so they will require understanding.
- dbtqgoat 8y agoYou’re correct that it won’t create a better understanding but it will increase performance.
- Viliam1234 8y agoRight. Understanding and performance are both necessary for mastery. Without understanding, if you ever misremember something, you will be unable to find and correct your mistake. And if you forget something, then it's gone, until you find a textbook and memorize it again. On the other hand, solving larger problems in math requires solving dozens of smaller problems along the way. When you have to stop and think about the small problem, you lose the big picture, and then you need to backtrack, which slows you down and frustrates you. Understanding needs to come first, but practice is the necessary second step.
- blarg1 8y agoMy mum made me do kumon for a while when I was a kid. Not exactly sure if it's because of kumon, but I know the value of number combinations eg 5+8 I know is 13, so something like 45+78=40+70+13 Also I still know the times table off by heart (mum forced me to learn that as well) so I can calculate most things in my head, something I was surprised to learn most people can't do.
- agret 8y agoI can only recall certain number combinations and I never bothered to do the drills to learn my multiplication tables. I can multiply very basic things (fives, tens, elevens) but aside from that I gotta use a calculator. Takes me awhile to calculate things in my head and i'm often off by around 5-9 from the actual answer when I do work it out. I know a bunch of methods of solving things though so if I have a calculator handy I can calculate the stuff I want but mental arithmetics was never something I valued as a kid.
- blarg1 8y agoI actually have a bit of trouble recalling the numbers sometimes, so I tend to rely on what feels right. Like numbers up to a certain point (eg 1-44, 2^(0 to 12)) all feel different to me and some numbers feel related (eg 5,9,45). I have a bunch of methods too though they aren't very good compared to the ones I've seen other people use.
- dvfjsdhgfv 8y ago> There must be some alternative way I can regularly show him interesting stuff in math. Of course there is, but you need to get creative. Math textbooks are notoriously bad at this, although there are some exception. My tip: use play and riddles. Use characters he could identify with. Like "Han Solo received secret transmission about two magic numbers. If you add them, you get 11. When you subtract one from another, you get 3." Sounds like a very easy riddle, doesn't it? Whereas in fact you can use it as a gentle introduction to systems of equations with two variables which becomes clear as you increase the numbers so the kid can't solve them by trial and error easily. "And now I can show you the secret way of solving it!" The key is that you (1) always need do present a concept with a concrete application, (2) the application has to be relevant and interesting to the kid, (3) just like with all games, it must not be too easy nor too difficult.