7 ms·
A number of other silly ideas that still hold traction and do actual damage despite being out in the open and actively refuted: Moon landing conspiracy Anti-v
by mrguyorama 8y ago
A number of other silly ideas that still hold traction and do actual damage despite being out in the open and actively refuted:
Moon landing conspiracy
Anti-vaccers/Vaccines cause autism
Fad diets and "detox"s
Anti-intellectualism
Alex Jones (to the tune of millions of subscribers on his recently killed youtube)
Global Warming
etc
- lylecubed 8y agoAnd who decides what is and isn't a silly idea? For 40 years, Americans were told by the government to believe that low fat high carb diets were the key to a healthy life. Not only is that not true, but it's never been true. There was never any evidence to support that stance. And yet, that was the official government policy and subsequently the commonly held belief for 40 years. "It ain’t what you don’t know that gets you into trouble. It's what you know for sure that just ain't so." - Not Mark Twain
- yifanl 8y agoIf the problem is "what determines truth", then there isn't an organization out there that could resolve the issue (barring something like the Chinese government, I suppose)
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoDid you just organically come up with the Ministry Of Truth?
- qu4z-2 8y agoI think their point was that unless you're willing to accept Minitrue you don't have an authoritative source of truth to check against.
- mrguyorama 8y agoThat's all fine and dandy, but is there actual factual standing behind the positions I listed?
- lylecubed 8y agoYou posted them as examples of "bad ideas." Shouldn't you be able to tell me the factual standing behind the positions you hold?
- mrguyorama 8y agoAre you asking me to go through each of them and give a thorough post about the background of the issue, the facts as they lay, the most reasonable conclusions, the possible influences/biases from each side and their possible agendas etc etc etc? And you're saying that I should do this each and every single time someone wants to discuss a (IMO) discredited study or blog post or something? Do you not see how easy that is to abuse by people acting in bad faith? It's a pretty classic DDOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gish_gallop
- lylecubed 8y agoIsn't that what you tried to do to me? You asked me this: "is there actual factual standing behind the positions I listed?" First of all, why are you asking me about the factual standings of your examples? And second, you didn't just allege that the ideas you listed were 'silly'. You said they do "actual damage" despite being out in the open and actively refuted. Is it so much to ask that you provide proof? Had you just said "I think these are silly ideas" we wouldn't be having this conversation.
- scarejunba 8y agoHang on, just to check, which of the specific things called out as "bad ideas" do you take issue with?
- ubernostrum 8y ago
- anigbrowl 8y agoAnd who decides what is and isn't a silly idea? This is a bad faith argument. I say so because the purported mechanism for such decision-making is actually spelled out upthread, and because this rhetorical question is then followed by a glaring fallacy of composition that seeks to draw a general conclusion from a single and highly over-simplified example.
- will_dev_4_food 8y agoIt’s not a silly example but rather a common one. Many years ago it was only the fat that were attractive because they were the financially secure. Many believed that royalty were th only form of legitimate government, and colonial activity among “savages” was doing them all a favor. Science, academics, and even personal experience vary with time. Not all variance that follows is truthful...some is exaggerated purposefully or accidentally, though most is considered good information at the time.
- anigbrowl 8y agoI didn't say it was silly. Please try to differentiate between the quotation that I'm responding to and what I said in response.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- partiallypro 8y agoSo, the anti-GMO movement, far and away has more blood on its hands than even Alex Jone's dumb theories (see golden rice.) Should we police that speech? I believe anti-GMO is a silly idea, and a deadly one. Far more deadly that Jones claiming Sandy Hook wasn't real, far more deadly than a 9/11 conspiracy theory. Yet, we allow it, in fact in many cases we encourage it on the corporate/company level (see Chipotle.) There are tons of "mom blog" type pages on Facebook that push this crap, it's a much much bigger industry than Jones. Where is the outrage there? Is it ok to ban their speech from a corporate platform? It does way more societal damage. Gwyneth Paltrow pushes things with her company "Goop" that can cause serious health problems. Should we ban her from Facebook? I just wonder where you draw the line, because if we're talking raw statistics on society damage, InfoWars or virtually any form of "hate speech" isn't even in the top 10.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> And who decides what is and isn't a silly idea? Any private, non-common-carrier party that is asked to relay it. That is what freedom of speech/press means: people are free to evaluate content and decide for themselves whether to participate in spreading it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- BryantD 8y agoI think that's the core question right there. For a while, various governmental bodies got to be the authority figure deciding which ideas were widely propagated. It's interesting to consider the outsized influence of Texas school boards here; the people who decided which textbooks would be used in Texas were elected officials. Texas has a huge textbook market. Accordingly, textbook vendors were incentivized to publish textbooks which fit Texas standards, and other states who didn't have the same influence wound up with those textbooks. So: "who decides what is and isn't a silly idea?" Texas elected officials. That's suboptimal in my view. It is also not great that four or five major companies have the same decision-making power. Fixing the problem is difficult, but I take some comfort in knowing that it's not actually a new problem.
- polanon 8y agoI don't know about moon landing, vaccines or whatever internet stories, but revisionism about gaz chambers and the 6 millions number is heavily documented. I read quite a bit about it to make my own idea and it's... disturbing. And the anti-revisionists do not answer with facts or science, so it's even more "disturbing". Some historians have publicly gave up trying to fight revisionists with facts, because they can't - there is no material to help them. Calling revisionism silly is literally anti-intellectualism. BTW, the only story I want to believe is the MASSIVE CONSPIRACY WITH CHEMTRAILS :D
- mrguyorama 8y agoIn your understanding, did millions of jews die in the holocaust as part of a German plan to eradicate a race?
- t3soro 8y agoLog-lost diary of German officer Alfred Rosenberg vindicates his testimony at Nuremburg. https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/long-lost-diary-of-nazi-alfred-rosenberg-turned-over-to-holocaust-museum/2013/12/17/b422b260-6738-11e3-8b5b-a77187b716a3_story.html?utm_term=.40b2807dfa0e https://www.washingtonpost.com/local/long-lost-diary-of-nazi... > Scholars had been eager to see what this longtime Nazi from Hitler’s inner circle had to say in the missing journal. But details of the Nazis’ grand plans for genocide and brutal domination are absent from the pages. Rosenberg testified in Nuremberg that there was no such plan for the wholesale murder and eradication of the Jewish race, and that the idea had never even crossed his mind. In other words, the only plans the Germans had was to expel the Jews from their territory. Nonetheless, he was not believed and sentenced to execution by the court.
- tpush 8y agoYou missed this parts of the article: > "Rosenberg does occasionally raise the issue of Jews. On March 28, 1941, he referred to the opening conference of his brainchild, the Institute for Research into the Jewish Question. I regard the conference as a success,” Rosenberg wrote. “It is, after all, for the first time in European history, that ten European nations [were] represented at an anti-Jewish conference with a clear program to remove this race from Europe. “And now this perception of a historic necessity is backed up by force.”
- ddingus 8y agoSo? Laugh at them, and then contribute facts. Next. At any given time, these things are all part of the conversation. Suppressing them only adds to the allure. Attempting to manage it, "for their own good" will not end well, and it won't end well because way too many people will fail to trust, share that and undermine it all. As they should. That problem is why there is a First Amendment in the first place. I know that does not apply here, and I know why too. Not my intent. The dynamics that lead to having a First Amendment are my point. The moment people begin to mistrust, and that catches fire and spreads is the moment the dialog gets toxic and hostile. See my comment up thread.
- mrguyorama 8y agoAnd people like my mother? Who didn't do so well in statistics and science and math and therefore do not have the tools to rationally judge one claim versus another? How do we help them not get pulled into, often alluring and attractive, circles of hate?
- ddingus 8y agoI love you mom, but those people are fucking clowns. How can I help? (Have had this exact exchange. Took a while, but did resolve. Human problems take human work.)
- anigbrowl 8y agoLane Davis's dad tried that approach, arguing to his son that he (the son) had fallen down a neo-nazi rabbit hole. Davis denounced his dad as a 'leftist pedophile' and stabbed him to death. I could supply a laundry list of examples, but the basic point I'd like to communicate is that once someone signs up to an eliminationist philosophy we have (to misquote Churchill) established what they are, and the only question is in what order they intend to pursue that project. I want to be careful here to distinguish between ideas that mre merely wrong and those that involve imposition of their calculus upon others. For example, I consider flat earthers ridiculous but it's not like they are threatening to flatten out anything they consider overly curved.
- partiallypro 8y agoNote that most of these existed well before the internet and were just as widespread. Generally the people who post this stuff are the people already preconditioned to believe it. These people also have their views emboldened when they see it is banned...they view it as some conspiracy to hide the "truth." IMO, these bans against Alex Jones aren't going to have the good intended result they were meant to. If anything, this could drive more direct ad dollars to him and allow him to expand into another vertical that may attract and empower even more like him. But I'm biased, I am generally against any form of censorship unless it is exploiting someone against their will (see snuff films, pedophilia, etc.) Slightly unrelated, but I fear that the Russian boogeymen is going to creep its way into outright censorship in the West via corporate America...which ironically is an outcome Putin and other Western adversaries desire.
- acdha 8y ago> Note that most of these existed well before the internet and were just as widespread. Do you have a citation for that? It seems unlikely that the Internet didn’t increase the reach for fringe views by making them available to everyone rather than just the few who requested conspiracy materials by mail.
- partiallypro 8y agoAre you really suggesting that conspiracy theories such as JFK, Roswell, Area 51, Antivaccine/"mark of the beast," Moonlanding, Big Foot etc weren't already in popular culture before the internet was popularized? Because, in fact, many of them spread because there was no wide usage of the internet (Roswell, probably being the #1.) It helps create lore. Even X-Files, a show that I adore, was really pre-popularized internet era. Think of Ruby Ridge, Waco, etc. Those conspiracy theories led to the Oklahoma City bombing. And they were widespread prior to the internet being a big thing. Think of the Turner Diaries which was big in the early 90s, there are too many examples to even list. 9/11 was maybe the first popular internet spread conspiracy, but I would make a strong argument that without the internet it may have been more widespread because there is less online debunks. I don't know if you've ever argued with a conspiracy theorist but their minds were made up before any major theory was proposed. It's a natural distrust of authority. Do I have hard data? No, and I am willing to be that it would be incredibly hard to measure that anyhow, but I do have tons of anecdotes and history to back up the claim that it's nothing new. It's human nature.
- Turing_Machine 8y ago> A number of other silly ideas that still hold traction and do actual damage Worst idea that still holds traction and has caused actual damage: Marxism. >100 million people murdered so far, and it's still going strong. If we're going to start banning bad ideas from the Internet, maybe we should start with that one.
- spaginal 8y agoAmen.