4 ms·
Using explosions to put out fires isn't an entirely novel idea: it's actually used in oil-well firefighting[1]. That said, I have some serious concerns about t
by mindcrime 8y ago
Using explosions to put out fires isn't an entirely novel idea: it's actually used in oil-well firefighting[1]. That said, I have some serious concerns about the applicability of this technique to wildland firefighting.
In the interest of full-disclosure, I am a former firefighter, but I was mainly focused on structural firefighting. We did respond to wildland / brush fires, but only got involved in direct suppression activities on the smaller fires. Larger wildfires we just provided protection for exposed structures and let the Forestry Service handle the primary suppression efforts. Anyway...
One of the main dangers of wildland fires involves something called the "wildland / urban interface"[2]. This is where homes and urban construction border on and/or intermingle with wildland areas. When you hear about "Wildfire X destroyed N homes" this is usually referring to events that happen in the WUI. I don't think it's hard to see how dropping bombs in this area could be problematic - even using the specially tuned bombs referred to in the article.
Also, a wildland fire isn't like an oil-well fire in that you don't have all the fire concentrated in one small, well-defined area, where you can quickly "snuff" it out. In a wildland fire - especially in the driest, most dangerous conditions - it seems likely to me that the same shockwave that snuffs out flames in a certain area, might well spread embers that actually spread the fire to an even larger area.
Maybe there's something to this, but overall I'm somewhat skeptical.
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_well_fire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oil_well_fire
[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildland%E2%80%93urban_interface https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wildland%E2%80%93urban_interfa...
- tonetheman 8y agoWhat an excellent comment. This is probably a naive question would it help on the leading edge of the fire? Maybe there is not such a thing. Large fires might not have a leading edge. thanks!
- mindcrime 8y agoI mean, I can imagine some scenarios where this might be useful, but I see a LOT of open questions that I'm not sure anybody has the answers to yet. OTOH, I'm not a specialist in wildland firefighting specifically, and it's entirely possible there is research out there related to this topic that I'm just not familiar with. Which is, I suppose, a long winded way of saying "I'm not sure". :-
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dredmorbius 8y agoVery much this. Most effective bushfire combat involves fuel denial, rather than directly putting out flames. And one of the most effective forms of fuel denial is setting backfires. Fires spread generally via embers. Bombing bushfires does nothing against fuel, and will likely increase ember spread. And the prospects for ground crews encountering UXB might be problematic.
- exabrial 8y agoI believe the thinking is that a giant crater doesn't burn, and a thermobaric bomb consumes all of the oxygen in a wide area for a short while.
- mindcrime 8y agoBut that isn't going to help with embers that are pushed ahead of the leading edge of the fire by the shockwave. And burning embers stay hot and can spread fire over surprisingly long distances. If you've ever seen news footage where a wildfire "jumped" an 8 or 12 lane wide highway, you can bet that it was ember spread that was responsible. I'm not going to say that this idea has no merit; and I think it may be worth further investigation. But at the moment I have some major concerns about it.
- ummonk 8y agoI assume the idea is to drop the bomb in front of the fire so the shockwave pushes the embers backwards?
- mindcrime 8y agoI mean, yeah, probably. But it might not be that simple. Which is why I say I'm skeptical, but don't claim to be sure this wouldn't work well. Consider that air currents tend to be chaotic systems in general, mix in a shockwave from a bomb, and ask "can we really predict where the embers are going to go?" Especially as they rise and encounter different air currents that are moving around helter-skelter. Remember, large fires can release so much heat energy that they create their own hyper-localized weather. Anyway, again, just to be clear: I'm skeptical, but I don't want to sound completely dismissive. I do think this merits further study. I just see a lot of potential ways this could fail to work out.
- komali2 8y agoAlso, it isn't just an out of the box solution. At the beginning of the 20th century the United States army tried this as a "solution" to the San Francisco earthquake and ended up blowing up the city and setting new fires on their own.
- msds 8y agoIn 1666, it worked quite well for London.
- kraftman 8y agoWhat about the Sonic boom idea?
- rl3 8y agoNot to mention the risk of accidentally bombing firefighters on the ground.
- walkingolof 8y agoAlso, one important thing that is missing in the article, the fire in question in Sweden, was (partially) on a large training range for the Army that had been in uses since the 60's, which made it easy to go ahead and test dropping a bomb on the fire.
- bcaa7f3a8bbc 8y ago> Using explosions to put out fires isn't an entirely novel idea: it's actually used in oil-well firefighting Probably the most powerful explosive used in such firefighting was an atomic bomb, which was used by the Soviet Union in 1966 to put out a large oilwell fire in Uzbekistan. photos and the video... https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/soviet-union-detonates-nuke-underground-11169169 https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/world-news/soviet-union-detona...
- mikeash 8y agoThe word “probably” seems highly unnecessary.
- sjwright 8y agoI agree, this article just seems to strain credibility. Forest fires aren't candles. You can't just "blow out" a solidly burning piece of tree. And after the explosion, you still have a lot of fuel hanging around—it's just going to start burning again moments later... long before any fire crew can traverse the safe distance from a FREAKING BOMB DROPPED FROM A PLANE. (The key reason bombs work for oil fires is because the fuel gushing out of the well isn't hot. Blowing it up denies it oxygen for enough time to deny it heat. Plus any hot oil gets flung a good distance from the well head.)
- DoctorOetker 8y agoprobably a dumb idea, but perhaps automated tracking and targetting embers from a mobile platformm? either speed up their combustion in flight (CO2 laser? releasing oxygen?), or stop their combustion (small targetted water jets?)