8 ms·
Discovery of nitrogen-fixing corn variety could reduce need for added fertilizer
- selimthegrim 8y agohttp://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/journal.pbio.2006352 http://journals.plos.org/plosbiology/article?id=10.1371/jour...
- marchenko 8y agoThanks for the link to the paper. This is potentially very exciting news - the benefits of Three Sisters agriculture with one of our staple crops.
- ohiovr 8y agoVery interesting. Also interesting to see how tall corn can grow near the tropics! Roots in the air, all that is interesting. I noticed that corn in Ohio seems taller this year. I call it monster corn, but I've never seen corn quite as gigantic as mexican corn. We have a saying "knee high by july" but for the last 10 years or more it is more like knee high by the first week of june or better.
- rmason 8y agoThis is a very big deal. Scientists have been looking for five decades for corn in the wild that fixed its own nitrogen. Commercial nitrogen fertilizer is made from natural gas using the Haber process: http://guichon-valves.com/faqs/nitrogen-fertilizers-manufacturing-process-of-nitrogen-fertilizers/ http://guichon-valves.com/faqs/nitrogen-fertilizers-manufact... Now it may take a decade or more for corn breeders to create a new variety of this corn that produces commercially viable yields but it will change not just the fertilizer industry but farming overall when it happens.
- nerdponx 8y agoIs this potentially a route to engineering other self-nitrogen-fixing crops?
- rmason 8y agoLong term for related grasses like sorghum I'd say yes but crops like cotton or potatoes I'm more doubtful. Other grasses such as rice or wheat I'm just not sure because they're so different.
- flukus 8y ago> Long term for related grasses like sorghum Would that include rice? That would make it an even bigger deal wouldn't it? How important is nitrogen fixing in combating desertification and could discoveries like this ultimately help reverse it?
- roel_v 8y agoAre there any nitrogen fixing plants that live in water like rice? I have problems envisaging the biochemical processes there, but I don't know much about it in the first place.
- masklinn 8y agoAzolla (water fern / mosquito fern). In fact, using Azolla as rice companion plant is a long-standing practice in China: after flooding, rice paddies are seeded with Azolla, it multiplies (very) rapidly covering the surface and suppressing weeds (Azolla mats are very dense so water weeds get little to no sun) then releases nitrogen for the rice plants when it dies and rots.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- roel_v 8y ago
- sampo 8y agoThe corn is feeding sugars to the microbes that do the nitrogen-fixing, this has to mean some energy cost to the corn itself. Can anyone comment if this makes a notable dent in the yield of the corn, compared to a situation when the corn gets the nitrogen for free from fertilizers? Or perhaps the extra energy expenditure is so small that it doesn't matter in practice? Of course, in situations when a farmer simply cannot afford to buy nitrogen fertilizers, the potentially lower yield doesn't matter, because the only alternative is no yield at all.
- fabian2k 8y agoNitrogen fixation is a very expensive process in terms of energy, and it has to be as N2 is a really stable molecule and it simply takes a lot of energy to convert it to something else. No way to get around the thermodynamics of that reaction. I did a quick search and found an abstract of an old paper (https://www.nature.com/articles/267149a0 https://www.nature.com/articles/267149a0) that estimates around 15% of total energy used for nitrogen fixation. The value probably depends a lot on various factors, but it is certainly a significant amount.
- dnautics 8y agoIt's not just that, but biology has evolved nitrogenase only once (it's not trivial) and the process is very inefficient. Something like five? Molecules of hydrogen get produced, that's not counting the six hydrogen atoms that get incorporated in to the ammonia. It's enough of a big deal that some microorganisms salvage the leftover hydrogen for energy. There are some microorganisms that salvage their neighbors leftover hydrogen. Also nitrogenase is very porous and oxygen sensitive so for photosynthetic organisms sequestering the nitrogen fixation away from co2 fixation is a major challenge. Nostoc deals with it by evolving terminal cell differentiation... Cyanothece has a night/day genetic switch, and higher plants fix nitrogen as far away from the leaves as possible.
- raverbashing 8y ago> but biology has evolved nitrogenase only once (it's not trivial) and the process is very inefficient. Something like five? Molecules of hydrogen get produced, that's not counting the six hydrogen atoms that get incorporated in to the ammonia. It's enough of a big deal that some microorganisms salvage the leftover hydrogen for energy. There are some microorganisms that salvage their neighbors leftover hydrogen. Wow that's crazy. And to think life absolutely depends on it, so I guess it used natural sources of ammonia. (And to think the same substance that's so dear to plants is excreted by animals, including us)
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- sciencerobot 8y agoPivot Bio (http://pivotbio.com/ http://pivotbio.com/) is testing nitrogen-fixing microbes on corn this year. And we are hiring: http://pivotbio.com/careers http://pivotbio.com/careers
- estsauver 8y agoThis is great! Our company sells seed and fertilizer to smallholder farmers, and so I feel pretty comfortable saying that under application of Nitrogen on crops in the developing world is one of the biggest causes of poor yields and also an incredibly difficult problem to solve. (We do an incredible amount to make distributing fertilizer in 100kg increments and it's still a logistical nightmare.) It's a 9 month variety instead of a 3 month variet, and so if I was making a rough guess, I'd say that the most likely outcome is that this leads to a ~20-25% reduction in fertilizer use after it's bred into main crop lines (at least initially.) Honestly though, now that this trait is around, it's going to be a lot easier for big seed companies to breed improvements into this. This is huge, and incredibly exciting.
- jstsch 8y agoWow, in-species nitrogen fixation. Shame of the recent EU ruling on CRISPR (considering it GMO). Now we can't grow this in Europe.
- tempestn 8y agoSeems fairly clear that a CRISPR-modified plant would indeed be a GMO. What's a real shame is blanket banning GMO crops. I admit a great deal of ignorance in this realm, but from what I understand, a ban on over-use of pesticides (which appear to be the cause of most/all harm attributed to GMOs) would make more sense than a ban on GMOs, which can be for plenty of things besides pesticide tolerance (like nitrogen fixation!)
- bobcostas55 8y agoGMOs and pesticides are complicated. Some GMOs increase the use of pesticides, some decrease it. Overall the effect appears to be negative. http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600850 http://advances.sciencemag.org/content/2/8/e1600850 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21645698.2016.1192754 https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21645698.2016.1...
- strainer 8y agoCan we have confidence in our ability to protect biological systems from unforeseen and less accounted for effects of increasingly powerful technologies? From the state of things in 2018 - surely this is not a paranoid concern. I am all for research into GMO and controlled applications in medicine and secure problem cases, but find the history of industry and mass agriculture can not yet be trusted with it.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- beerlord 8y agoThe majority of corn is used for Ethanol production: https://www.forbes.com/sites/austinfrerick/2018/08/06/10ethanol/#264ee0b5780f https://www.forbes.com/sites/austinfrerick/2018/08/06/10etha... Which has negligible environmental benefit, and is a pointless long-term strategy given that the vehicle fleet is becoming increasingly electrified. Its a shame that political solutions to more effectively use the Earth's resources are more difficult than bioengineering corn.
- mchannon 8y agoNot technically true that the majority of corn is used for ethanol (other uses combine to make it a plurality, rather than majority), but still, amazingly true that ethanol is now the leading use of corn acreage planted (which I did not know and is why you get the upvote).
- bkmartin 8y agoJust another reason for big Agriculture to create more GMOs. /s This would really be amazing. Honest concern... How does the fertilizer industry fight this? There are billions of dollars a year at stake here. Nobody faces billions of lost revenue without a fight.
- golem14 8y agoMy guess: it's shaping up similarly to the solar/wind <--> coal fight. At some point, there's not enough money you can lobby with compared to the real world needs and competing lobbies (here: food/nmonsanto etc) and the balance shifts. Also, in non-US countries people might take a more pragmatic approach, giving new tech a leg up. E.g., China, India might not care so much about the US fertilizer lobby.
- bkmartin 8y agoThe only way to really fight something like this is to make GMO's and the people who produce these plant varieties into some sort of boogeyman, no? We see this happen all over the world, not just in the US. The current level of misinformation about the safety of GMOs is already very overblown in the world. Don't get me wrong, GMOs are being weaponized for monetary purposes in, what I believe, are very unethical ways. But those arguments are not what you see most when arguments against them are made. I just don't see any other angle to attack nitrogen fixing corn other than to make some sort of GMO boogeyman out of it. It is really amazing the amount of misinformation that is populating the world for the purpose of protecting cash cows. sidenote Thanks for the downvotes :) apparently my sarcasm hit a nerve.
- golem14 8y agoThat's an interesting point. I think there is some truth to that in the US and Europe. I have a hard time believing that this will become a huge problem in China and India particularly. The gov there isn't interested in giving these storylines a leg up, and people have other problems, such as Melamine-contaminated baby formula (or having food shortages)
- jamiegreen 8y agoI have been hoping that we could use CRISPR or something like that to make perennial nitrogen fixing wheat. Making cereals into a perennial and fix their own nitrogen could be huge. I also presume it may not happen for a very long time as most of the big seed companies would be presumably very against it.
- phkahler 8y agoSeed companies would love it assuming they can get it. Fertilizer companies would hate it. A company that produces both might suffer some kind of breakdown.
- webmaven 8y agoMany of the seed companies now are fertilizer (and pesticide/herbicide) companies.
- phyzome 8y agoExternally applied nitrogen has the benefit that the wheat plant doesn't need to divert sugars to the symbiotes for nitrogen production, and can instead spend it on making heads of grain. As cool as it is, I'm not clear that it actually helps efficiency in industrial agriculture. Partly depends on how efficient the symbiotes are vs. how expensive synthetic fertilizer production is.
- jamiegreen 8y agoInteresting. I am not an expert, and it sounds like you are, so thanks for adding that. Even if it wasn't quite as efficient, could it be worth the trade-off in terms of reduced CO2? As the application of synthetic fertiliser etc is very fossil fuel intensive?
- phyzome 8y agoI'm not an expert either, I just know some and have heard of some of these issues—so I don't have anything definitive to say, just that it's not a clear win in my eyes. I also don't know if the wheat plants are even sugar-limited, for that matter! I guess what I'm saying is "plants are complicated". :-P
- baxtr 8y agoThese are very exciting news. The most interesting part: The study found the Sierra Mixe corn obtains 28 to 82 percent of its nitrogen from the atmosphere. To do this, the corn grows a series of aerial roots. Unlike conventional corn, which has one or two groups of aerial roots near its base, the nitrogen-fixing corn develops eight to ten thick aerial roots that never touch the ground. During certain times of the year, these roots secrete a gel-like substance, or mucilage. The mucilage provides the low-oxygen and sugar-rich environment required to attract bacteria that can transform nitrogen from the air into a form the corn can use.
- phyzome 8y agoDon't get too excited. Beans also partner with nitrogen-fixers, but farmers fertilize them with nitrogen anyway. Why? Higher yield. And then the beans stop partnering with the nitrogen-fixers because they're already getting nitrogen for free without having to feed and house the microbes. So this is great for people who don't have access to fertilizer (as the article notes!) but it will do nothing to solve the overapplication of fertilizer in industrial agriculture. (Those "roots" look hella cool, though.) UPDATE: I may have been mistaken about the exact relationship -- it's possible this could reduce nitrogen inputs somewhat for industrial ag, but maybe only if the soil isn't already saturated with N. Need to go back and look at sources... https://igrow.org/agronomy/soybeans/application-of-nitrogen-fertilizer-in-soybeans/ https://igrow.org/agronomy/soybeans/application-of-nitrogen-... has some of the info.
- TheRealPomax 8y agoAm important note that no one has raised yet: this is NOT a discovery, this has been a very long running project, run between scientists and native peoples. The headline steamrolls the fact that this is absolutely not an accident, but the payoff on over a decade of research and hard work. Shame on you, U.C.Davis. Your own article literally explains this, why the disingenuous headline?
- schoen 8y agoI think "discovery" is commonly used both for serendipitous discoveries and for successful research efforts (though sometimes it may have a connotation more of the former). (There's also the metaphysical and marketing question about things being invented vs. discovered.)
- phyzome 8y agoWithout having looked at the article, I interpreted it as "we found something in the wild or already in cultivation, not already known to us", not "we made dis".
- lostlogin 8y agoIt’s great that this was found and that the locals hadn’t gone for growing the standard varieties that are used elsewhere. It’s striking when in South America how many varieties of farmed plants are grown. Local markets are selling tens of varieties of potatoes and corn in a rainbow of colours. A local told me it was partly done as an insurance policy against disease. It makes you wonder what else is out there.
- narrator 8y agoKind of interesting that Mars, the candy company, is funding this. Good for them. The world needs more competition in the agricultural business with the Monsanto/Bayer merger. It's nice that they are pursuing traditional hybridization instead of GMO everything.