8 ms·
Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged
- zeteo 16y ago"Message" implies an actual quote from the man. "Example" would be more appropriate in this context.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- r7000 16y agoLike many words in English it does not have such a discrete meaning. A story or experience can have a "message" the same way it might have a "moral". In fact "moral" is often defined as: the message conveyed by a story. "Example" would have been a poorer word in its place.
- senthil_rajasek 16y ago"Babbage's message..." and "A message from Babbage's Life...". are not identical. The former is a personal article or note from Babbage. I got down voted for exactly what zeteo said...
- r7000 16y ago"A message from Babbage's Life..." is too long. A title can trade ambiguity for elegance if the essay is clear.
- senthil_rajasek 16y ago"Babbage's heart-warming message for the middle-aged" and "A message from Babbage's life for the middle-aged" to me both titles sound elegant but the former is misleading and the latter is correct. The title is not trading ambiguity, it is just misleading.
- zeteo 16y agoYes, a story can have a message, but "Babbage" is a person, not a story. "This story's message" has a different agent from "Jim's message". Jim is always the _author_ in the second meaning. "Babbage's message" made the title shorter, but also misleading. A complete title of "Babbage's heart-warming" would have made it even shorter, but I hope you're not advocating in favor of that!
- r7000 16y agoReflecting today I believe Jim's inspiring message to us is to live life to the fullest even if that requires participation in extreme sports. Jim did not write a letter. He was the "author" of the sentiment (according to the speaker) by the way he lived his life.
- bhjodokast 16y agoIt implies that to you? Is that due to your nature or your nurturing?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- hugh3 16y agoSo Babbage, the guy who is best known for starting work on the first mechanical computer but dying before completing it, is a heartwarming example? If he'd started at 20, he would have finished it.
- emilsedgh 16y agoThats like saying the first one who made a wheel never completed it, because he never managed to get a car! What we know today as computer is probably far from what he imagined.
- konad 16y agoYou're assuming he wasn't working on them. In 1810 aged 19 he started University at Trinity, Cambridge. In 1812 aged 22, disappointed with the level of mathematical tutorage formed the Analytical Society, translating Lacroix' works on differential and integral calculus into English. He transferred to Peterhouse and they gave him a degree without him even having to sit an exam. He also got married during this time. 10 years later his wife and 5 of his 8 children were dead. And he stood up again and invented a fucking programmable computer made out of wheels!! I think I can cut him a bit of slack.
- borisk 16y agoFrom what I've read it seems extremely likely that he did build (in secrecy) a working computer. One that was used by the British secret service to decrypt enemy communications.
- kragen 16y ago[citation needed]
- jakevoytko 16y agoI believed that age mattered until I met a super-coder for the first time. He is over 60 years old, and completes entire projects by himself. A team of five decent programmers would likely complete these projects late and over budget. He has high standards, a razor-like focus on implementing The Right Thing, has a great eye for reusing old code, and isn't afraid to split the world apart to make life easier for the client. I'm glad I met him as early in my career as I did; I unlearned a lot of falsehoods about software engineering.
- darwinGod 16y agoThat is a strong departure from the stereotype! I'm really interested to know more.. Does this person have a blog?What type of projects has he worked on? Would be great be if you could elaborate on what had unlearned!
- BrandonM 16y agoI would also be interested in hearing some of the lessons the grandfather poster learned, and the preconceptions he unlearned. Maybe a blog post is in order? Edit: I removed a rant that I had here which went too far off-topic.
- solutionyogi 16y agoI don't think darwinGod was trying to put the person down because he doesn't have a blog. He was rather interested in learning more about this person and his experiences and the lessons which jakevoytko learned from him. I think your rant is misplaced.
- BrandonM 16y agoNo, I don't think he was trying to put him down either, that's not why I made the comment. darwinGod's comment inspired my line of thinking, so I inappropriately replied to it. Since my comment was so off-topic, I decided to delete most of it and reply to the parent. Sorry for making your comment seem out of place.
- konad 16y agoAnd a heart rending message too from Tuesday's Babbage installment http://blog.jgc.org/2010/10/babbages-other-woman.html http://blog.jgc.org/2010/10/babbages-other-woman.html: His wife, Georgiana died age 31, Ada Lovelace died aged 36 and Countess Teleki died a year before Babbage aged 34. Only three of his 8 children survived into adulthood.
- jacquesm 16y agoLife expectancy back then was quite different than it was today.
- Cushman 16y agoWow... that puts his lifelong quest to build a machine that can think into terrifying perspective.
- 8ren 16y agoPerhaps his longevity was because because his work made him active physically, just as Leonardo was a sculptor. As a programmer, I try to automate everything; but it can be healthier to do (physical) tasks the long way.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoMy dad is still programming at 79. Go dad!
- lelele 16y agoPlease, let us know what he does. Had he worked as a programmer or is he an hobbyist? Thanks.
- JabavuAdams 16y agoHe used to be a math teacher. I believe he took some programming courses (as an adult student), and we had a computer in the basement back in 1978. I think he's developed a couple of websites for pay. I just remembered that he worked for a while at the McLuhan centre at University of Toronto. Now he's mostly working on personal research projects for education.
- dabent 16y agoI've heard there are two kinds of genius, one that blossoms at an early age and those that develop their craft over time to achieve great things later in life. http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.07/genius.html http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/14.07/genius.html
- dctoedt 16y agodabent, you should post the Wired piece separately -- it's worth reading just for the account of the metrics Galenson used to decide on the "value" of art produced by artists, poets, etc. at different points in their lives (it was not just the prices of the different pieces, but their citations in textbooks, a la Google's PageRank algorithm).
- dabent 16y agoI would, but it was submitted less than a month ago here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1678415 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1678415 It really is a good article and worth the read.
- Hipponax 16y agoFitzgerald died at 44, Mozart at 35 so neither lived long enough to get into the old group.
- shiven 16y agoA very relevant book on this aspect is: http://www.amazon.com/Truth-Beauty-Aesthetics-Motivations-Science/dp/0226100871/ http://www.amazon.com/Truth-Beauty-Aesthetics-Motivations-Sc... The author compares and contrasts the differences between early blossoming and late blossoming intellects. The science/math geniuses belong usually to the former and the artists to the latter. Perhaps, programming is more art than we have been led to believe.
- maushu 16y agoSomeone is feeling old. It makes me confused when a old person simple doesn't learn anything new that could possible help with their life. Heck I've been trying to convince a family member with the iPad (possible the easiest "computer" to use).
- gschorno 16y agoI see most people my age (50) "closing off", they don't want to learn anything new. I think a lot of it is learned behavior, not wanting to be embarrassed or made fun of by their peers.
- tomlin 16y agoIt's common to find a 70+ year old electrician or plumber because those trades have had high demand for generations, ours is still young enough where stereotypes still have some hold over coming reality.
- johngalt 16y agoI've never bought into ageism. I've known too many brillant older guys. My grandfather was an aerospace engineer, and sharp enough to put me to shame until the day he died. Overall I'd say its confirmation bias. Think about how many people we encounter every day that don't have a clue. That ratio doesn't change with age. Age just becomes a convienient scapegoat.
- MikeCapone 16y agoAbsolutely. Ageism is terrible. If we can cure the diseases of aging that affect our mental and physical performance, we'll hopefully get rid of this sad state of affairs. It's such a waste that so many incredibly brilliant people are seeing their mental functions decline because of the accumulation of beta amyloids in their brains or whatever other problem that happens to be in evolution's blind spot (humans didn't use to live that old, and rarely reproduced at that age if they did). A huge waste for humanity.
- ivank 16y agoYet another example: Lars Bak wrote V8 in his 40s. There are some details in "The genius behind Google’s browser" http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/03775904-177c-11de-8c9d-0000779fd2ac.html http://www.ft.com/cms/s/2/03775904-177c-11de-8c9d-0000779fd2...
- senthil_rajasek 16y agoThe title is very misleading. The article is more like, "What the middle-aged can learn from Babbage's life". I give credits for the authors perspective, though. I am calling this out because I was expecting a reference to an original article written by Charles Babbage and did not see one. Imagine if someone wrote an article titled "Einstein's final message to the world" and you only see a list of life achievements of Albert Einstein from the authors perspective.
- jmspring 16y agoI'm actually working on getting my dad up and going on Android development. He has an app addressing a vertical he is involved with. He's in his early 60s. Hell, considering when I wanted games growing up, his solution was to give me the K&R book and told me to write my own. I guess this is the least I can do.
- wtracy 16y agoYour dad is awesome.
- BrandonM 16y agos/programmers by young/programmers be young/
- goodgoblin 16y agoIf there is a preponderance of younger success stories w/r/t age of the founders of successful internet companies, or the average age of programmers working for those companies, my bet would be that is due to an increase to risk aversion as folks get older.
- njharman 16y ago> where there's currently a cult of youth I hear that a lot. I've worried about it since mid-eighties when my father sued US Government for age discrimination. But, I've not see it. I'm almost 40, not old enough? Maybe I got another decade or two before the kids kick me off their lawns? Maybe cult of youth exists more in "corporate"/"enterprise" world? Where naive, cheap, workaholics are greatly desired and always in supply?
- forensic 16y agoI think it's just a holdover in the comp sci biz from the days when COBOL programmers found their COBOL hacking to be obsolete and chose to retire rather than retrain Truth is, old dogs CAN learn new tricks. But it takes more energy than just repeating their old tricks.
- dbrannan 16y agoOne only has to ready Gladwell to realize that becoming a master of any craft takes time, patience, experience, and lots of practice (10,000+ hours) - none of which is likely at an early age. My mentor was 20 years my senior. His ability to read into other people's code, see potential problems, bottlenecks, and keep our code optimized has been invaluable.
- InclinedPlane 16y agoI wonder how much age is relevant in software development merely due to the commonality of awful working environments (which younger workers are more likely to put up with).
- da5e 16y agoYes, but Babbage didn't ship.
- VladRussian 16y agoBabbage's work was a bleeding edge of the science. As far as i know there is still no "cult of youth" in the areas what are bleeding edge of science today. Most people are getting to the bleeding egde and starting to produce their first significant science results only at 30+ . Dismissing 40-50+ year olds at the top of their scientific work would be just like throwing gold in thrash. Programming isn't a science (it is barely an engineering) and thus comparison with Babbage just isn't valid.
- danilocampos 16y agoAgeism sucks. At 25, I'm an idiot – I mean, truly a moron by comparison to some people ten, twenty, thirty years my senior. Not because of what I know, though that always needs work, but because of how I think. How passion can funnel into trivialities. How unfortunate events can discourage good ideas, while optimism can blind me to reality. Youth can be applied to do great things but it has its disadvantages. Ageism becomes, unfairly, a proxy for determining something important: The creative humility of being able to embrace and extend new ideas. The thing is: Someone in their 20's can just as easily become set in their ways as someone in their 40's or 60's. Becoming jaded and self-important is easy. Losing your curiosity is easy – boy, some people lose it by age 10. I can't stand people who decide they've learned everything there is to know about the world around them – whether they're 22 or 82. Especially when selecting people to help you build something, buy into people with creative insight, curiosity, humility and passion. Those can be found at any age. (Fun example: Watch a David Attenborough nature documentary from the BBC. One where he actually shows up on camera, in the middle of a remote habitat. Watch how delighted he is, even after decades of study and exposure to what he's talking about. He doesn't take anything for granted. He and his work are wonderful.)
- SkyMarshal 16y agoIt is there an actual market opportunity somewhere in this problem of ageism in tech? You've got all these undervalued veteran hackers, could there be a way to provide a way for them to pool their abilities, either on a company, or a freelancing collective or LLC or the like, in order to maximize their full value?