4 ms·
>recognition that the status quo is people's preference...I'd argue in the scheme of things, it's not really that broken Continuing the status quo means the pe
by slg 8y ago
>recognition that the status quo is people's preference...I'd argue in the scheme of things, it's not really that broken
Continuing the status quo means the people in power stay in power. It therefore isn't surprising that the people in power prefer preserving the status quo. It also isn't surprising that the people who believe the system is broken and are most against the status quo are those that belong to historically oppressed groups. If you really think the system isn't broken, I suggest you look through the Twitter mentions of politically active famous women, POC, or LGBTQ members. The harassment they receive on a regular basis wouldn't be allowed in the physical world. Why do we allow it in the digital world?
- atomi 8y agoAs long as it isn't libel/slander or 'fighting words', we do allow it in the physical world. Shouting words at someone is not illegal.
- slg 8y agoWe have to separate the words from the action of saying those words. The words on Twitter do sometimes include slander and threats which would make them illegal. However, often the words themselves are perfectly legal. That doesn't mean the action of speaking those words are legal. Using your example, imagine someone standing just outside your property and yelling at you 24/7. The words themselves might not be a problem but it doesn't mean they can't be charged with any number of crimes from disturbing the peace to harassment. Social media bots can function in a similar way.
- atomi 8y ago> imagine someone standing just outside your property and yelling at you 24/7 People protest all the time in similar ways. Also, you can block people/bots on social media.
- slg 8y ago>People protest all the time in similar ways. Sure, that is why protesters are routinely arrested even though the first amendment exists. >Also, you can block people/bots on social media. The sole responsibility of policing and punishing this behavior should not fall on the victims of this behavior.
- zdragnar 8y agoProtesters are routinely arrested (in the US) for things like blocking traffic, unlawfully carrying weapons or other safety issues, not because they are voicing disagreement with "the man". Blocking someone is neither policing nor punishing, it's simply ignoring; actual censorship still falls to the platform itself.
- jack9 8y ago> The words on Twitter do sometimes include slander and threats which would make them illegal. The idea of a nebulous "illegality" is simplistic and wrong, in the US. They might open an individual to civil liability, but they aren't in violation of a criminal code, nor tort law. > That doesn't mean the action of speaking those words are legal Speech is always legal, in the US. What you think "legal" means is up for debate.
- karmelapple 8y agoNot all speech is always legal in the USA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Illegal_speech_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Illegal_speech_in_the...
- nostrademons 8y agoNote that the cases where speech is not legal are significantly more narrow than most people think they are. The category you link to has only 11 pages, and half of them are court cases where the Supreme Court decided against limiting free speech. (In particular, the famous "shouting fire in a crowded theater" quote is from a 1919 case that was overturned in 1969, and shouting fire in a crowded theater is not, in fact, illegal. Inadvisable, probably, and likely to get you banned from that theater for life, but not illegal.)
- paulddraper 8y ago> someone standing just outside your property and yelling at you 24/7 Around the clock shouting in residential neighborhoods is likely to get you fined for disturbing the peace. But, you can send hate mail, or shout in some public spaces and be just fine. Sending angry emails or tweets sounds most like the former.
- foolrush 8y agoDepending on the words, it is entirely illegal in many countries around the world. The USA is behind the curve on that.
- slg 8y agoI don't want to make a value judgement by using a word like "behind", but I do think most Americans are simply not aware of how extreme our country's stance on free speech is compared to the rest of the world. Countries like the UK, France, and Germany seem to function just fine with their more restrictive laws on speech.
- foolrush 8y agoLook to Germany. I said "behind" because it requires a certain national hubris to not acknowledge the horrific turn of events that came out of a country, and in turn, acknowledge what they have learned from it.
- h4b4n3r0 8y agoCould be that it’s only “fine” in the short term. Just 80 years ago Germany was very far from “fine”.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 8y agoThere were a lot of hate-speech laws when Hitler came to power. He even used the fact he was prevented from speaking publicly as propaganda. And yes, a lot of legislation of Weimar to censor spoken and written word has been extended by the Nazis after they came to power. People arguing for more moderation and more censorship generally lack perspective when they refer to fascism in the same breath. Free speech is a most effective disinfectant against fascism.
- foolrush 8y ago
- 77777777 8y agoThe status quo today is diversity programs pushed by top corporations. "Whiteness Studies" courses aiming to "deconstruct White people" in top universities. Generous affirmative action. Language policing by internet hate mobs (who primarily police the language of people who are not PoC). And a popular culture that celebrates LGBTQ people and PoC pretty much non-stop year around. People have been politically mobilized by the idea of "change" since the beginning of democracy. But that's just because the idea of "change" has a certain energy to it that is important for campaigning. Most people don't like the idea of supporting the existing status quo because it seems ... low energy. So anyway. You'll find a lot of professional activists working at big tech companies (a lot of companies now have 'racial equity' orgs which essentially exist to do political activism), having their concerns heard by people in power, and all the while talking about smashing the status quo. But they aren't really trying to smash the status quo. They are just taking the existing status quo step by step to its logical conclusion. The people trying to smash the status quo are usually the ones having laws passed against them. Who don't have corporate leaders pandering to them. Who don't get celebrated by the media. It's the anime avatar having people on Twitter, who constantly break taboos with their speech, who are against the status quo and that's why the current power structure wants to shut them down. (I'm not saying you are wrong for supporting the existing power structure, but it _is_ wrong to pretend that the current power structure isn't pro-LGBTQ and PoC because it is emphatically so.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gi-RfWz1W8Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gi-RfWz1W8Y