8 ms·
Upwork Freelancers Who Want Guaranteed Pay Have to Opt in to Tracking Software
- candiodari 8y agoAnybody who dealt with upwork knows perfectly well that "guaranteed" ... there is nothing guaranteed with these systems. And in my experience, the people wanting more control want it because they know that they themselves would, given the chance, betray the trust. If someone demands this happen, you can bet they're looking to exploit you. You don't want to work for these people, you don't want to touch them with a 10-foot pole.
- duxup 8y agoI worked at a company with multiple teams doing basically the same job at multiple sites. The guys out in CA were always talking on the conference calls about the metrics being gamed by some other sites. It was all blame and innuendo with these jerks. Their numbers weren't as good as other sites (despite being paid substantially more than anyone else). Finally the guys in CA got their wish and a stupid amount of energy was put into finding who might be gaming the system..... it turned out to be the people who worked for the guys in CA... their own direct reports.
- ChicagoDave 8y agoThe old Elance was great. Miss it a lot.
- devoply 8y agoI wonder if anyone in developed countries can actually make a living from something like Upwork. It seemed to me whenever I have looked at it, that it's mostly people and companies from the developing world who work for less than minimum wage or close to it in developed countries... and the expected cost matches these sorts of rates. So it does not make sense for anyone other than the most desperate people in the first world to try to get work on these sorts of sites. As such that sort of labor is easy to exploit. They have no bargaining power and are already working for peanuts.
- cornellwright 8y agoIt probably depends on the domain - I've hired people domestically across a few different fields for rates in the $50 - $150/hr range when I was looking for specific expertise that I wasn't able to find in my network. It's sort of niche and I don't know if they were making a full time living from it, but I think we paid fair and got what we paid for.
- mistercow 8y agoI did vworker for a big part of my income years ago. Almost all of my business came from a tiny number of repeat clients (in fact, mostly one) who had already learned the pain that comes from optimizing only for cost. The money still wasn’t great (although I could have made it better if I were assertive enough to raise my rates on existing clients), and there’s no way in hell I would have done it if I’d had to use tracking software, but it was sort of kind of feasible.
- lemonghost 8y agoIt's definitely a race to the bottom but it also represents a good opportunity for junior developers even in developed countries. I've gotten $35/hour jobs before which isn't great but it isn't peanuts either.
- x0x0 8y agoWe're paying approx $45/us hour to someone in a developing country. I'm pretty sure that goes pretty far there.
- devoply 8y agoCan you elaborate on the sort of work and what you would be paying locally for the same sort of work... i.e. is it something that requires quite a bit of specialization, etc.
- x0x0 8y agorails + ruby + a bit of frontend. It's not super specialized but rails can easily become a huge mess if you don't know what you're doing. So we're definitely interested in more senior talent, ideally someone that has made all the new rails eng mistakes in someone else' codebase. We would pay more locally, but we're mostly not on upwork because of money. We just needed someone we could get soon. I will say that what $45/h gets you on upwork is far more than what you get in sfbay.
- lemonghost 8y agoAs far as I know this has always been the case. oDesk had a screenshot tracking program too for hourly jobs prior to the merger and rebranding.
- maerF0x0 8y agoIt did/does. I did not have an issue with it, besides occasionally having to go delete a ton of screenshots when I accidentally left the tracker running while I wasnt working (not attempting to be fraudulent, just careless)
- hkai 8y agoOdesk and upwork is the same website. They rebranded.
- sparrish 8y agoEven with this screenshot tracking, I've been swindled on Upwork by fake devs. They take the time to fake it, why not just do the work?
- nihil75 8y agoHad a dev use macro keystrokes to cheat it. worthless.
- shawn 8y agoHahaha. What? That’s awesome. What did the macros do? I’ve always wanted to make a plausible code generator based on markov chains. It still seems like an effective way to trick people into thinking you’re working on some hard problem.
- nihil75 8y agoNo need for pseudo-code, random clicks/strokes will do (he used the arrow keys to move around code and switch open Atom tab).
- bredren 8y agoThe thing is if you are working on a serious team there is no value to cheat. You need to generate quality code at a reasonable pace. Custom solutions don’t appear out of nowhere. So sorry to say but your dev setup was not good because you get 2 weeks to dispute this. I know because I have hired on here too and been scammed once. I raised all the red flags and ended up getting some money back even past the guarantee. Thing was that if I had reviewed the screenshots it was obvious it was bullshit.
- nihil75 8y agoYou get one week to dispute, and let me tell you - Upwork staff are not quick to accept your claims. By the time my dispute was manually reviewed the payment was already passed to the freelancer and could not be reclaimed. Only the most recent week's pay was refunded, even though the evidence suggested the developer was cheating for a long period of time. I didn't catch on because he was producing good code and just used the macro to "inflate" his hours by about 30%. I caught on by pure chance when he happened to tweak his background macro tool just as the hourly screenshot was taken.
- Roritharr 8y agoRecently a friend of mine pointed me towards TopTracker. It's an interesting concept, having kind of a papertrail for what you worked on can be really valuable in any setting, even the most friendly ones, because even yourself can loose track of all the yaks you've had to shave to fix a certain bug or make a gizmo spin a certain way. I've seen so many freelancers waste company time and endangering otherwise great projects in the past and have even done so myself that I really think a proper, fair and well balanced tracking suite would have benefited all parties as it would have created a much more formal and clear reminder of what screentime in this setting is for. Obviously the flip side is that through the "invasive tracking", work stays work and everything not-work needs to happen on another machine. This means less mixing of private stuff into your work life which many consider something positive, but is counter to what the larger trends in IT are. (Corporate Campuses that fulfill every need...) At the end of the day i'm really not sure where I stand on this, as it opens so many positive possibilities (f.e. proactive encountering of procrastination) but also so many negative ones (abuse of power). Surveillance is never an easy topic.
- poulsbohemian 8y agoWould you say the same thing about employees standing around the water cooler planning the company picnic or talking about their spot in the company fantasy football league? There are good freelancers, there are poor ones. Same goes for any type of employment. This is quite apart from whether it is appropriate or necessary to micromanage their keystrokes.
- Roritharr 8y agoDisclaimer: I was working as a freelancer/subcontractor for most of my career, am now a CTO with all sorts of employees & (a few) freelancers in my team. The biggest difference between a freelancer and an employee is one of expectations on both sides. The freelancer doesn't/shouldn't expect the company to provide him with a career path, personal growth opportunities and job security. He expects to be paid for services rendered, a service he in many cases only can provide because of the specific freedoms he enjoys that allowed him to develop himself into a position that is particular valuable and not present at the contracting company. An employee on the other hand is a completely different beast and can and should expect the aforementioned things and more of the company, at least in Germany where our company is based and which labor laws & and history influences our/my attitude towards these things. To your question: An employee planning the company picnic is actually doing his job, discussing their spot in the company fantasy football league could be seen as "enjoying, participating and nourishing workplace culture". A freelancer doing the same would be out of place, simply because he isn't awarded those privileges one gains with employment. It's not part of the contract, neither the physical one, nor the social one. Some companies blur the lines between freelancers & employees to foster more cooperation and give their employees access to more outside viewpoints, but this is largely a factor of company style. Netflix for instance in their famous Company Culture Deck [1] even mentioned in the very beginning that "Our hourly salaried employees are important, but have more structure job roles". From this point of view, "to micromanage the keystrokes" is basically just an extension of that, more structure, less freedom in the way the service is rendered and more transparency for all involved. As a former freelancer it bothered the heck out of me seeing freelancers that I knew negotiated higher rates just slacking of and parading my work around. The only recourse was talking to managers of the customer and working on being viewed as a better "friendly problem solver" then the other freelancer. Any structured way to ensure there was some kind of fair measurement of productivity would have been a giant boon back then. [1] https://de.slideshare.net/BarbaraGill3/netflix-culture-deck https://de.slideshare.net/BarbaraGill3/netflix-culture-deck
- swedish_mafia 8y agoRun the tracker in a virtual machine running locally. Run your “work” apps in that vm. This is so stupid.
- juice_bus 8y agoThis is what I was planning to do when I landed my client but they trust me and enabled the option to log "manual hours". I don't trust UpWork anymore than I trust PayPal so as far "guaranteed" hours are concerned it doesn't matter - I withdraw my funds every week.
- 628C6l0 8y agoBut couldn't the tracker become self-aware and realize it's living inside a similulation?
- prepend 8y agoThis work should not be hourly. I think if I don’t know someone well enough to trust them logging hours, I don’t pay hourly.
- naeemtee 8y agoNot to shamelessly plug, but this Upwork monolith (and the general sub-optimized gig economy right now) is harmful not just for the freelancers themselves, but also the clients (from a price optimization perspective). We're trying to solve it with a blind marketplace model at ContentFly (http://contentfly.co/ http://contentfly.co/)
- AngeloAnolin 8y agoWould you care to elaborate how you see the Upwork Monolith is trending to become harmful to freelancers? It would be nice to see your thought on this. I'd like to see a more balanced Upwork type of freelance work, where perhaps a lot more people are given the chance to participate through quality, rather than quantity.
- slig 8y agoI've been looking for a service like yours. Are all your writers native speakers? They work "in house" or they're contracted? Thanks
- debt 8y agoI don't think this is a bad idea at all. Micro-work should be tracked for both the worker and client's sake. Paying hourly is highly inefficient as we all know it's very difficult to work every second of an hour. So if something could more precisely track how often you work during an hour it may encourage you to work less not more as you'll be able to see when you start to taper off; the longer you work the less efficient you may become.
- SN76477 8y agoI just allow manual hours. If I dont trust them to do the right thing why would I even get a freelancer the job?
- Kagerjay 8y agoSemirelated but I run timesnapper, which is a private tracking software running only on my PC so I can check if I've forgotten to save a doc and wanted to see what it looked like 2 hours ago.
- severine 8y agoInteresting! Link: http://timesnapper.com/ http://timesnapper.com/ What would be the *nix alternative?
- mmel 8y agowhile : ; do scrot ss-$(date +%s).jpg ;sleep 60 ;done
- Kagerjay 8y agoGreat question, I needed a macOS equivalent for my macbook. Technically this is *nix since its unix flavored https://alternativeto.net/software/timesnapper/ https://alternativeto.net/software/timesnapper/ I haven't tried any personally, but digging through the alternatives I actually didn't see any resembling it. All the other alternatives were designed to manage employees & their time. None of them seemed to offer video playbacks like timesnapper, only screenshots. And they worked online which is a giant red flag for me. The closest one I could find though for linux and macOS is this one called productivity-peach https://www.etopian.com/software/automatic-screenshots-windows-mac-linux/ https://www.etopian.com/software/automatic-screenshots-windo... . I strictly wanted to avoid "remote monitoring" or "employee-tracking" type software I did pay $30 for timesnapper (one license works on more than 1 PC). Timesnapper is nice, you can playback your entire day and see everything that was done. Super useful if you do sysadmin stuff as well, sometimes you might change a setting on AWS/cpanel/etc and it screws up everything. Now you can go back and see what you changed. You can add a password too which I do as well, your video playbacks are encrypted
- severine 8y agoFunny, I did the same thing. The answer below by mmel is more appealing to me after looking through those alternatives... I agree, that the closest is Productivity Peach, but being a closed source Java app, and my circumstances, that one liner could be going more my way, thanks Kagerjay and mmel!
- homero 8y agoThey've done this for a decade since odesk. I've caught many freelancers watching porn or one was trying to sell data off the backend and freely chatting about it. But I like the feature as an employer. I like seeing the process of the work being done.
- aclimatt 8y agoI'm a consultant and have been for a long time, and I know this business. I don't think counting keystrokes and in many cases screenshots make any sense, so I think the implementation of this is totally bogus, but the concept makes complete sense. "I've never had a client expect to be able to look over my shoulder" Right well UpWork isn't your client. I don't think your clients should, and to another person's point, yes your clients should trust you. But this is in the case of when you do the work and the client _doesn't_ pay. This is UpWork covering your ass, when they really have no obligation to. They want a way to prove that you are least did some work, so likely they can go after the client later and recover costs. This seems absolutely reasonable and honestly a heck of a bargain. Again, I think the implementation of counting keystrokes seems like a stupid way to do it, but coming up with a tracking method to _optionally_ guarantee payment even in the case of client non-payment is the deal of the century in the freelance world. Don't believe me? Try freelancing for a while and see how many clients stiff you after you've completed the job. There are literally advertisements in the NYC subway about it. (Yes, retainers, payment up front, et ceteta -- no the world does not always work that way.)
- riffraff 8y agoIsn't there some deliverable that proves the work was done?
- aclimatt 8y agoOf course, and if you're delivering work and that's working out all well for you, then great. And it appears that you can go that route instead on UpWork, agree on milestones, and no tracking required. But, if like many people you are getting burned by non-payment, then turning this feature on seems like a pretty good route to go for stability in your wallet.
- candiodari 8y agoCould you explain a bit why Upwork, who are a company that have countless forum posts, blog posts, ... about non-payment, clawing back payments in entirely unjustified circumstances with zero recourse, ... I'm saying they have a very bad reputation in this regard. Why would giving these people more power over you result in more payment ? They are looking to exploit these freelancers, and this gives them more power. Why would any reasonable person expect that giving cheaters more power over you result in less cheating ? It will obviously increase the chance that you, as a freelancer, won't get paid. https://hackernoon.com/why-you-should-never-use-upwork-ever-5c62848bdf46 https://hackernoon.com/why-you-should-never-use-upwork-ever-... https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.elance.com https://www.trustpilot.com/review/www.elance.com https://entrepreneurs.maqtoob.com/a-top-rated-freelancers-advice-on-actually-making-money-using-upwork-3f948e67c621 https://entrepreneurs.maqtoob.com/a-top-rated-freelancers-ad... https://screenshotmonitor.com/blog/how-to-avoid-scams-on-upwork-and-freelancer/ https://screenshotmonitor.com/blog/how-to-avoid-scams-on-upw... http://launchastartup.com/odesk-vs-elance/ http://launchastartup.com/odesk-vs-elance/
- boxingdog 8y agonot only upwork, some companies use hubstaff which is even worse, they have a setting where you cannot delete a screnshot after it is taken
- kschlagel 8y agoShamefully hijacking, I’m actually building something similar but it _does_not_track_keystrokes_or_take_screenshots_ because we agree that that is too intrusive. It’s made for lawyers to match their file activity with time entries. https://griffn.io/ https://griffn.io/ We’re also YC Winter 18 hopefuls..!
- rob_b 8y agoI believe ‘his’ should be ‘he’ in this context - “His has built widely used software ranging from award-winning individual apps to corporate workforce software.”
- chuckgreenman 8y agoI do some freelance work through Upwork. I like the tracking software, it shows that I'm doing work, all my hours are verified and they are guaranteed to be paid. It's completely worth it, people who have been stiffed on contracts before, its a no brainer.
- bredren 8y agoMe too. I did 40k of work for an employer who ended up stiffing a ton of employees but I was protected because of upwork’s setup. I used to hate it and still I exit the app unless I’m actively working. But it assures payment which is important.
- lechiffre10 8y agoThat doesn't even scratch the surface of Upwork issues though. Has anyone recently seen how much clients are willing to pay for work? I'm seeing avg pays of about 9-10$ an hour for mid-complexity jobs. Even see some clients willing to pay 600$ for fully functional IOS, Android and Web App iterations of an App.
- x0x0 8y agoThere definitely are clients who are happy to pay $40-$75 an hour for senior full stack eng talent. We are such a client, and two VPE friends also commonly use upwork for 1-3 month gigs where they don't want to pay $175/hour for an sfbay contractor. The reason you're not seeing them is good clients eventually find a good contractor and either just run fulltime ongoing work through upwork (for eg payment convenience) or move off upwork.
- mrhappyunhappy 8y agoI was earning $95/hr as a ux UI designer. Now I run a consultancy and charge per project which equates to 260-300$ an hour. Upwork has many issues and limitations but if you do well by good clients you can make it work pretty well.
- fdchn2017 8y agoI once worked on Upwork. Getting the 1st project is really hard. And seeing quotes of USD 500 for entire fully functional applications was depressing. There were people from India remote places like small city Chandigarh or small town in Kerala or people from Bangladesh who would actually bid for these. I finally asked Upwork for a feature where I could blacklist clients who I thought that the price offered was too low. I wanted a feature like - "dont show me any bids from this client" . But unfortunately Upwork didnt create such a feature
- icelancer 8y agoWe pay $20-25/hr for entry-level developer work and $40-50/hr for intermediate developer work from Eastern European countries, which is super competitive over there. We've got a pair of excellent developers that we've had for a long time and we're extremely happy. Yeah, if you live in SV and want to make $120/hr on Upwork, go pound sand. But those salaries are pretty good for people who live in modest Midwestern towns or countries that are not America.
- Hello71 8y agoI see many comments saying that this is fine because it's optional. Based on the previous posts discussing Upwork (https://hn.algolia.com/?query=upwork https://hn.algolia.com/?query=upwork), it seems to me like today this is optional and tomorrow this will be mandatory and the next day it will add machine learning webcam face detection technology.
- mike503 8y agoI’m not a fan of it, but it is a necessary evil sometimes. I had a client dispute my work after he asked me to spend hours on tangential crap, then claim I wasted his time (he asked me to do the work and bill the time, approved of it at the time too, but later reversed his decision) Upwork’s mediation process was hokey at best but in the end they reviewed the time logs and gave me all but a couple 10 minute chunks of time worth of payment. I have just gotten used to being monitored while the clock is on, and don’t do sensitive things while it’s happening... I can always turn off the clock quick if needed. I do feel like if I was buying services I would want some way to guarantee someone isn’t billing me time for doing nothing, this encourages some sort of transparency and attempts to curb timecard “fraud”
- kumarvvr 8y ago> approved of it at the time too, but later reversed his decision This is a very serious problem with upwork. I once had a client accept a finished project, give me an amazing review and then, close the project and complete the payment. A month later, he reversed the rating and review and started an issue with the Upwork system. The problem was that the third-party software service I used (as per the clients instructions) to perform a set of tasks, changed their policy and stopped allowing remote clients to their service. I explained to the client during the development phase itself that this could happen. He explicitly told me that it was ok, and to go ahead. Inspite of showing Upwork all the communications, my warnings, etc, they still sided with the client, blocked my account and transferred some balance amount in my account to the client. The last time I used Upwork.
- dopeboy 8y agoI've been consulting off and on for the past five years and I've steered way clear of these marketplaces. It's a very obvious race to the bottom sort of situation they're plotting for which I get. I'd be optimizing for that outcome too if I were one of them. Here's my advice to developers who want to freelance: network and network some more. Write blogs, create content marketing material for yourself. Go to meetups, tap your alum networks, go to hackathons, and work your networks. There's a lot of noise on LinkedIn but if used correctly, it can yield a lot for you. Every single client I've had is someone I've met in person. I get to know them, they get to know me, we establish trust. Any sort of opening meeting or two is free. Formally, we use it to talk requirements. Ostensibly, we use it to vet each other.
- techdragon 8y agoI’d like to extend your point about the first meeting being free. I have a long standing principle I borrowed from lawyers. The first consultation is free. I try to keep it to an hour, but I don’t hold clients to that time limit, if it takes half a day to wrap my head round a project, that’s what it takes and it’s still just one consultation and it’s free. I’m not about to charge you to find out that I’m the wrong guy for you, or that you’re the wrong place for me. It’s always worked well. So well in fact that I’m pretty sure I’ve beaten out less expensive people by virtue of being first through the door, signing paperwork and seeing source code... because I’m “free”. It might not work for everyone. But it’s working for me.
- ahmadss 8y agoJust chiming in that this is how the bigger software dev agencies do it as well. I worked at Viget (www.viget.com) and now at Pivotal (pivotal.io) on the biz dev / sales side and spending time on pre-sales analysis is key to making a software project successful and thus winning the deal / securing the contract.
- dopeboy 8y agoThis is pretty fascinating to me, thanks for sharing. The analysis you're referring to - how long does it take for the big clients you deal with? Is it mostly meetings?
- ikeboy 8y agoKnowing multiple business owners who have complained about remote employees faking hours, installing mouse simulators to trick time tracking software, etc, I'm not particularly sympathetic.
- nmg 8y agoI've been using Upwork for side gigs since it was Odesk. The tracking system (which has scarcely changed in 5+ years) has always seemed fair and flexible to me. the tracker works well cross platform.. I can move from OSX to Win10 to Ubuntu (previously they supported Debian, and in the past I've managed to get it tracking successfully on Slackware) .. minimal downtime, good communication from their engineers. Being able to selectively trim the fat from my diary in 10 min increments on Sunday night is helpful in preparing clean weekly reports and reviewing my own workweek.
- davidgatti 8y agoI'm confused, why is this news? This is how its been for ever. I get my most interesting projects form upWork since I can check before applying what the job is about, which is something carder to do when you talk with a client of the street. Not to mention that you get guarantee pay every week. You don't have to spend time and energy to force the client to pay you. Which is the best part of upWork. Sure they get a 10% cut, but perennially is well worth it for the ease of mind. And the tracking app also allows me to organize my work by living notes to the clients to let them know what I worked on. Which is always appreciated. To sum it, up – not sure where the problem is. This is what it is, it works and if you are good you'll make plenty of money for yourself and upWork ;)
- King-Aaron 8y agoWe use 'TimeDoctor' as our tracking app at work, and it does an alright job. It also takes screenshots and checks for user activity. A lot of people bitch and moan about it. But if you go work in a factory - for instance - you'll be clocking in and clocking out just the same.
- jasonkester 8y agoA lot of people bitch and moan about it. ... and your best people will leave. Over time you’ll be left with just the ones who don’t have any options to go anywhere else. It’s kind of a self-inflicted Dead-Sea Effect that you’ve set up.
- supercanuck 8y ago...meanwhile, books on managing anxiety are soaring.
- cleansy 8y agoI am absolutely not surprised about this BS tracking software stuff. I was interviewing with Upwork a couple of month back. I live in "western Europe" and what they offered me was actually less pay than being employed full time here. For the moment I accepted but more out of interest to see what the rest of their interview looks like. The questions they had were quite specific about corner cases of the language used. I liked that a lot. However, it's also just stuff that you can read in a couple of blog posts about python corner cases. What struck me the most was that they seriously asked me to write up a program to prove my coding skills - despite having send samples - at which point I dropped out. Several things just turned me completely off about Upwork: 1) They claim that they have the "1%" of the best developers in the world. BS. With the kind of money they offer: forget about that. Maybe you have a couple of imposters who don't know that they can charge easily double of what they offer but the majority will be mid level for sure. So this claim is a lie. 2) They obviously cannot guarantee that you will be assigned a project anytime soon once you complete the interviews. But asked as well for a lot of engagement from your end to go through the process. 3) It was something like $6.000 per month - market rate for a contractor in Germany with comparable skills and experience is more in the range of $12.000 However, and that's my take from it: if I ever have to hire mid level developers for remote positions I definitely will look at Upwork's portfolio and pirate them away. Put the 20% that UW charges on top of their salary and the deal should be golden.
- primeblue 8y agoAnother reason to never ever become a developer. This is worse than being a mechanic or contractor.
- kapauldo 8y agoI hate upwork.