4 ms·
Consumption and production are both inelastic and storage costs are high. Traditionally when a producer produces more of a good than consumers want to buy, the
by nostrademons 8y ago
Consumption and production are both inelastic and storage costs are high.
Traditionally when a producer produces more of a good than consumers want to buy, the price drops, consumers buy more, and producers produce less. If consumption & production are both inelastic, consumers won't buy more and producers can't produce less. The excess goes into inventory, where it's treated as an asset and then sold (often at lower prices) when supply and demand equilibrate.
You can't put electricity into inventory, at least not without batteries or similar tech, which cost money and leak charge. Hence, if you produce extra, you have to pay someone to manage the storage or usage of that extra current.
There are a few other industries that function like this. Garbage is a big one: you have to pay someone to take your garbage because demand for garbage is much less than supply and storage has non-zero cost.
- petermcneeley 8y agoRight but Garbage almost certainly has a negative value so it makes sense.
- nostrademons 8y agoAt the instant where there's too much electricity on the grid and too few people using it, that electricity has negative value too. And you can't store it (without paying somebody) till some later instant.
- WalterBright 8y ago> Consumption and production are both inelastic and storage costs are high. Consumption is inelastic because the electricity rates are fixed 24/7. Allow variable pricing based on supply, and you'll see very elastic behavior. For example, people will charge their car batteries when the rates are cheapest. Same for running the electric hot water heater, and the A/C, refrigerator, etc.
- Dylan16807 8y agoI'd say it's more "slightly elastic" than "very elastic". A lot of people won't spend the mental energy to optimize anything more than the most major consumptions, and even then most of what they can do is rearranging loads, not reducing them.
- WalterBright 8y agoIt's not about reducing them, it's time-shifting them. The big electric consumers are A/C, heating, refrigeration, hot water heating, and car battery charging. All of those are very amenable to time shifting, and this shifting can be automated.
- Dylan16807 8y agoI would only categorize car battery charging as very amenable to time shifting, and the various kinds of heating and cooling as slightly to moderately amenable. With refrigeration especially, you want to keep it in a very narrow temperature band. You could design a fridge that keeps an ice reservoir worth several hours, but without that you have very little ability to time shift.
- WalterBright 8y agoWith minor engineering changes, you can timeshift quite a bit. Consider hot water heaters. When power goes out, mine will keep water hot enough for a shower for 2 days. Two days. That means the design can be changed to heat water up to, say, 200 degrees, and then mix it with cold water to bring it down to 100 or so when demanded, and one should never need to run the heater more than a couple hours a day when power is cheap. Storing hot and cold water can also timeshift heating/cooling your house with a simple and inexpensive system (little more than a controller and a water tank). Much, much cheaper than battery storage.
- Dylan16807 8y agoSure, that works well if you're willing to wait 20 years for devices to be replaced. Though batteries keep improving and eating in to the amount you can save by doing that.