3 ms·
I think that negative prices are prima facie evidence of a market economy not functioning "well". Negative prices seem to me to be to be equivalent to fines fo
by perl4ever 8y ago
I think that negative prices are prima facie evidence of a market economy not functioning "well".
Negative prices seem to me to be to be equivalent to fines for doing things that aren't socially useful. If they proliferate, that's a suggestion something is out of whack.
- bjoernw 8y agoOnly if they stay negative
- perl4ever 8y agoThat's reasonable. The headline says it's spreading though.
- xigma 8y agoIt's spreading because the market is oversatured with renewables because of government subsidies. A sound investor would stop (or go bankrupt) when the negatives outweigh the positives.
- perl4ever 8y agoSubsidies seem to be on the decline. In fact, I was just reading that due to the Chinese government cutting back, people are predicting PV prices will plummet in the next year.
- Dylan16807 8y agoIn this case "spreading" means "happening more often". And you could have a stable rational market where power prices go negative for an hour every day.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pitaj 8y agoIt's certainly not a free market economy because almost every electricity utility is a state monopoly.
- WalterBright 8y agoWhen markets get "out of whack" it's almost certainly due to government regulation. In this case, it's the government setting fixed electric rates for consumers.
- Install_Gentoo 8y agoIt's always the government and them dang corporate subsidies. Everything would work out fine if every aspect of our lives are dominated by fiefdoms of companies battling out against each other. On a less sarcastic note, companies/corporations failing to the point where government has to bail them out at all is sign that this system is not working.
- blihp 8y agoIt depends on whether or not someone is able to demand delivery at that price and what other forces are in play. i.e. presumably there are regulatory requirements that some minimal amount of capacity must be available as generators typically can't quickly spin up based on the whims of the sun/wind... but what if the generator provides it and there are no takers which a zero/negative price would indicate? Of course that's not sustainable for long it becomes a persistent situation: at some point the generator must be subsidized, or can absorb a loss over brief periods for the 'privilege' of being a provider the rest of the time, or goes bankrupt. Running parts of businesses at a loss isn't unheard of provided the governments responsible for overseeing it are OK with and/or mandate it (a wide variety of services to rural customers here in the U.S. comes to mind) and the impacted business makes up for the loss elsewhere.
- perl4ever 8y ago"Running parts of businesses at a loss isn't unheard of" A negative price seems fundamentally different than just running at a loss though.
- amluto 8y agoI admit I’m confused by negative pricing. Presumably solar can be curtailed for free. But with something like wind, I think production is all or none, and switching back and forth is a bit slow. It’s more economical to pay a tiny amount to get someone to dump the power. On a smaller scale, it’s common for off-grid hydro to have a giant heater waste power as needed.
- bluGill 8y agoNegative prices a perfectly possible in the ideal free market. The market of course requires the overall prices be positive, but given the very low ongoing costs of wind/solar it makes sense to build even if prices are sometimes negative - the alternative is to shutdown, but then the wind/solar operator needs to do something with that power, which in itself has costs. So long as the times the times of positive prices balance out you are fine with some negative. In addition, there is probably some advantage to encouraging other parties to develop uses for cheap power as part of long term planning. Of course as others point out nothing is every an ideal market.
- fogetti 8y agoYou are right, although it's not clear for me if you refer to the old/traditional coal plants or not. If you refer to the coal plants I agree, the 'negative prices are prima facie evidence of' coal plants 'not functioning "well"'.