18 ms·
Article like this always seem to ignore/forget that you can charge your EV at home, and that this is usually where you charge it the majority of the time. It's
by LeoPanthera 8y ago
Article like this always seem to ignore/forget that you can charge your EV at home, and that this is usually where you charge it the majority of the time.
It's an understandable thing to forget, since you can't fill up your gas car at home.
I own an EV and I only use public chargers extremely rarely.
- goatlover 8y agoNot everyone can charge at home. Everyone can gas up at filling stations almost everywhere they go. For mass adoption, chargers need to be as available for everyone.
- elif 8y agothat is an absurd standard to hold. In most cities, the cost of time to park long enough to charge would exceed the cost of electricity. Alternatively i would suggest: when the paradigm has shifted, the ancillary processes shift accordingly rather than cling onto some cloned reliquary husk of gasoline culture.
- rimliu 8y agoGas pumps have much better throughput though. I can fill up the 45 litres tank (good for ~750km) in less than a minute. How long would charging for the equivalent range take?
- tjohns 8y agoAssuming you own your own home. If you live in an apartment complex or otherwise only have street parking, you likely don't have access to electricity. Or at the very least, would need to negotiate with the landlord to have a new outlet installed -- which is going to depend on how much you get along with said landlord.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoThere are solutions for street parking (both standalone and equipment that can piggyback off street lamp installs). In this case, you do need municipal buy in for the installation and maintenance of this infrastructure.
- IshKebab 8y agoYes the problem with that is you kind of need it everywhere all at once, whereas if you have a home with a drive you only need to install it when you buy an electric car and only in one place.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoYou really don't. You just need to pace the installs to EV vehicle uptake (which you can monitor with vehicle registrations and the addresses vehicles are registered at). Install where cars are being bought and garaged (or in this case, street parked).
- closeparen 8y agoWhat happens when someone else nabs that space?
- toomuchtodo 8y agoLaws are already on the books that penalize non-EVs for parking in EV charging spaces. My statement assumes you'd overbuild in order to ensure spots (one EV in neighborhood? build capacity for 3 to charge).
- closeparen 8y agoStreet parking spaces aren’t reserved for individuals. Anyone else with an EV (visitor? neighbor who just bought one?) is equally entitled to those spots. You would own a car rather than rent or take public transit (esp. in an urban area) because you need it to be available and working every time, not just under ideal circumstances. Gambling your work attendance on getting a particular street parking spot the night before isn’t smart.
- mikeash 8y agoThe better EVs available now will support a typical commute without charging for a week or more.
- fpgaminer 8y agoNot a problem in California at least: "Assembly Bill 2565 would give tenants the right to install an electric-car charging station at their residence, provided the tenant submits a written request to the landlord and pays for the installation costs." (Passed already)
- gav 8y agoAt a cost of at least $1000 for a charging station and installation, I can’t see many people wanting to pay for this if they are renting.
- fpgaminer 8y agoI'd be curious if there are loan options that would cover the cost. Then it's not such a crazy thing for renters to consider installing a charger. (I mean, they're already paying ~$30k for a car on loan; another $1k isn't much).
- jschwartzi 8y agoI move every 3 or 4 years, so I'd basically be paying each landlord to make improvements to their place and then leaving those improvements behind.
- logfromblammo 8y agoIf the landlord bought the charger station, they'd up your rent by what the market would bear for parking spots with EV-charging capacity. So you install it at your expense, sell it at the depreciated price when you move out, and the landlord recovers the cost by upping the rent for the next EV driver looking for a new apartment. Or they don't, and you remove it and take it with you when you leave, paying the electrician labor again on both ends.
- nostrademons 8y agoThe demographic that would currently buy an electric car in California can easily pay for $1K for a changing station. If you're going to spend $30K on a Leaf or plug-in Prius or $50K on a Model 3 (vs. $18K for a Corolla or Fit), $1K is a drop in the bucket. It's also a tiny fraction of rent in Northern California, roughly 12 days worth.
- reaperducer 8y agoAssuming you own your own home Pretty much every significant apartment building built in Chicago in the last decade has had EV chargers in the garage. The problem is that there aren't enough EV spaces to go around for all the residents who have electric cars. If you're renting a stand-alone home, isn't there an EV station you can plug into a regular outlet? Naturally, the charging time would be slower than a 220V connection or whatever is needed, but if it's charing overnight, is that not an option? (Don't own an electric car yet, so I'm not up on chargers)
- outworlder 8y agoPretty much every EV out there comes with a "granny cable" that you can use to very slowly charge. It won't fully charge overnight (works out to about 4 miles an hour), but if you are topping off it can be adequate. I have used it many times, including one time where I actually ran out and had the car towed. Towed the dead car home, plugged in. Went to work fine the next morning and plugged there. That's if you are in the US, actually, where most outlets are 110V. If you have access to 220V or you can rewire an outlet, then charging time should be similar to public level 2 charging stations. Beware that not all charges will support 220v and will blow up (but some can be modified). 110v is the biggest barrier for adoption everywhere, that and old electrical installations. As an EV owner, I'd say that you need either a place to charge at work, or at home (great if you have both). If you do, then it is more convenient than pulling up at gas stations (more so if you are trying to get the cheaper ones in the likes of CostCo). If you do not, then relying on the public infrastructure is stressful and time consuming.
- reaperducer 8y agoThanks for the detailed response. One of the cars in my family only drives eight miles a day, and never on weekends. So I'm thinking about replacing it with an EV. Sounds like a granny cable might be all I need.
- outworlder 8y agoMy commute today is exactly 8 miles (4 each way). With a 2015 Leaf, I could go for two weeks without even bothering to charge if I'm only commuting. Since I can charge at work for free, I do it every Friday. And it's fantastic. My previous commute was 50 miles a day. Using only a standard 110v, I would top off every day, and that worked just fine. I could even forget once (but not twice in a row!). It took about 12 hours to charge what I used up during the day. So yeah. Just grab an extension cord (make sure it is rated for the current), and plug into whatever outlet you can find.
- rconti 8y agoThat's not going to be a serious obstacle to that 5 million figure, though. It obviously hurts individuals plenty, but in aggregate, enough people own their own homes that adoption can be orders of magnitude greater than it is now before the renter issue is figured out.
- Johnny555 8y agoEven if you down own your home, it's no guarantee. I live in a condo with a detached garage, which is on the far side of another row of condos. So getting power from my meter to the garage means trenching through a sidewalk, under a block of condos, then through about 20 feet of pavement. Alternatively, I could trench through 100 feet of pavement from the power vault where our complex's transformer is and have the power company install a new meter for me. The garage has a light bulb + garage door opener circuit, but the panel that feeds it wouldn't support a single charge station, let alone enough for the 8 garages that the panel serves. The HOA isn't interested in running enough power to let residents install an EV charge station in the garage, and I'm not interested in paying for it either. So unless I can get my neighbors to help share the cost, I'm not going to be able to install a charge station.
- emiliobumachar 8y agoJust a thought: a sufficiently smart EV and a sufficiently smart garage door could talk to each other to share a circuit. The car just stops charging when the door needs to move, which shouldn't add up to too much time. Not practical for an individual to develop to solve their individual problem, but maybe it could become a selling point for any particular EV.
- tialaramex 8y agoThe problem isn't "sharing" the circuit, the problem is that the EV charger wants power, as much power as possible, and the circuit to that garage has been sized to allow for just enough to run a bulb and some trivial electrics like a door opener. Say 150W. If you divert that 150W to an EV charger, so little power will make no perceptible difference to the charge overnight. Maybe 3-4 miles per night. And in fact a smart charger might conclude the circuit is faulty and cease charging altogether at this very low input.
- jlv2 8y agoFor instance, in California, it is now law that apartment renters can install EV charging stations (at their own cost). So even those who do not own a house can charge at home.
- deathanatos 8y agoThat seems like it would result in a random hodge-podge of chargers getting installed? At least, until a landlord had enough of it and redid it.
- outworlder 8y agoWhy does it matter? The actual charger is in the vehicle, the stations are basically only talking to the vehicle and regulating power flow.
- joshlittle 8y agoSmart landlords would hopefully require a standard 50A NEMA 14-50R outlet. Those are compatible with almost all EVSEs.
- closeparen 8y agoWhat would it even mean to install EV charging in a stacker?
- joshlittle 8y agoThis rule is a lifesaver. I’m renting a single family home in San Francisco. I drive a Chevrolet Bolt EV. Using a little known SF electrical code that allows DIY electrical work in a fully detached house, I installed a 50-Amp 250v NEMA 14-50 outlet in my garage. I did 50A service for room to upgrade the stock EVSE in the future. My landlord is fine as I’m insured, followed all National Electric Code guidelines and laws. It cost me $100 in parts/wire. I then created a NEMA 14-50P to a NEMA 5-15R adapter to plug the GM stock EVSE in at 250v. It’s a little known fact about the Chevy Bolt that the included EVSE charger supports 250v - by wiring each blade on the NEMA 5-15 plug to a 125v hot lead; then wiring the ground pin to neutral. I then locked the NEMA 5-15 plug/receptacle extension cord in a lockbox clearly labeled. While a normal 40A EVSE Gives 7.2kW, this setup- still limited to 12A due to GM/Clipper Creeks firmware - gives me around 3kWh. That’s perfect for my use. I am not tempted to really upgrade this set up a time soon, but can if I want to. It’s also easy enough to take with me. Total installation of level 2 charging in my San Francisco rental? $150ish. (Please don’t try this at home if you have no idea what you’re doing when it comes to working with electric. this is only informational, not an endorsement!)
- megaman22 8y agoSo, most people are going to have to completely rework their electrical system in order to put in an EV charger, going by the Tesla specs[1], up to including a larger service. Not too many people have an extra 40 amps of capacity kicking around, much less 60 or 90. And let me tell you, it's not exactly cheap to redo an electrical panel, particularly once you get in there and then have to bring up any other things that were grandfathered in up to newer code. [1] https://www.tesla.com/support/home-charging-installation https://www.tesla.com/support/home-charging-installation
- fpgaminer 8y agoYour point is valid, but I'd mention that I doubt most people need >40 amp installation. If we talk about your average Joe who gets a Model 3 or equivalent than they're already getting 30mi/h charge at 40 amps. Average Joe only drives 16 miles to work. We have the 40 amp installation and have never wanted for more. Somewhat related, but a neat hack might be to get solar installed at the same time. Re-doing the panel would be included as part of the project, which means you can A) get a loan to cover everything, and B) get a 30% credit from the government (in the U.S.). [I say might; our solar installer explained to us offhand that many people do things like that and get other upgrades as well like new water heaters, etc. You'd have to check with your CPA to confirm.] Considering that solar is cheaper over the long-term it's a pretty good deal depending on what loan terms you can get.
- mikeash 8y agoI recently moved and have been lazy about getting a charger installed at the new place. I’ve been plugging into a standard outlet in the meantime. Turns out that’s plenty. I still want to get something faster because it’s more efficient and it would be nice before and after long trips, but there’s no rush.
- yuhong 8y agoYea, it is a good starting point as many EVs use 30-32A charging (including the short range version of the Model 3 in fact), and fits into the 200A service that most homes since the 1980s have pretty easily.
- TheAceOfHearts 8y agoUnfortunately, almost everyone I know that would be a candidate for buying an electric vehicle doesn't own a house. Definitely a big issue in places with sky-high housing prices like San Francisco. Almost everyone that I know in my age-group is nowhere close to being able to afford buying a house.
- jotm 8y agoTime to build a smart charger that can plug into several outlets at once and regulate power draw heh
- cbhl 8y agoThat doesn't help if the underlying cable leading to that circuit isn't thick enough to handle the current draw.
- olyjohn 8y agoOr if all of the outlets are on the same circuit.
- jotm 8y agoYeah it's a stupid idea. But outlets can't all be on the same breaker, otherwise you would not be able to run an average home. Having something like a Powerwall that's always plugged in, and fast charging your car off of it overnight (or faster) could work. Very expensive, though.
- djrogers 8y ago> Unfortunately, almost everyone I know that would be a candidate for buying an electric vehicle doesn't own a house. See, that’s the problem with anecdotal evidence based on your own bubble. I’m in the exact opposite position - literally everyone I know that would buy (or already owns) an electric car also owns a house.
- perl4ever 8y agoI don't know if people are forgetting that. My apartment complex with hundreds of units has a built in parking garage, and there is one (1) electric charging station. Two pools though. Not all houses have connected garages either.
- gambiting 8y agoYou need a home with a driveway. Out of all my friends in the UK, I can count two who have such a thing - if you live in a terraced house, apartment, or even a regular house but without a driveway, how are you going to charge your EV? Where you park at night is completely arbitrary - one night you get a spot close to your door, the other you have to park on the street nearby because there is no room. Public fast charging stations are the only solution to this.