4 ms·
I’ve never bought into the Fermi thesis. We’re still burning petroleum instead of using it for its other amazing uses and blowing each other up over myths - but
by ianai 8y ago
I’ve never bought into the Fermi thesis. We’re still burning petroleum instead of using it for its other amazing uses and blowing each other up over myths - but we think we know the fundamental nature of all life in the universe enough to say we should see it.
- d0lph 8y agoThere's a huge list of explanations on wikipedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox#Hypothetical_explanations_for_the_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fermi_paradox#Hypothetical_exp...
- roywiggins 8y agoAll life? No. But if life is very common, what are the odds that absolutely none of it looks like something we would recognize? If that's true then we are absolutely unique in the universe. It just takes one civilization with a runaway von Neumann probe to drop huge monoliths on every single rocky body in the Galaxy over a couple millennia, and since evidently nobody did that in our solar system, the question is why not. If there's a rule that forbids it, what is the rule and does it apply to us? That's the question posed by the Fermi paradox.
- joe_the_user 8y agoWe know that a star burns the available fuel and then expires, with a hard limit existing on the size of it's size based on various factors. We know that algae bloom similarly exhausts it's medium and shrinks. However, the going assumption of the Fermi thesis is intelligent life is different. Intelligent life forms civilizations that are expected to naturally expands forever, eating planets, stars and so-forth. So far, human behavior looks much like the other phenomena that expand to the limit of their fuel and then die. And, if somehow against all odds, we wise up and stop exhausting the resources needed for our existence, well, then that infinite expansion tendency quite likely won't be there. "If we humans are now on the cusp of colonizing our solar system, and we are not much faster than other civilizations, those civilizations should have completed this colonization long ago and spread to other parts of the galaxy." But what if we aren't on the cusp of this colonization, if one can argue such colonization would happen by quite a few technological advances that are purely hypothetical, that "colonizing the solar system" only seems plausible by incorrect analogy with the colonization of various areas of earth by various local societies. Space seem wholly hostile to human from it's lack of gravity to its lack of all other components needed by us. Our era has gone from believing "space the final frontier" to seeing just how fragile our condition on earth is.
- tomp 8y ago> So far, human behavior looks much like the other phenomena that expand to the limit of their fuel and then die. Are you sure about that? It seems to me that humanity has often made a "leap" in the past... Romans "fed" on slaves, then collapsed, and eventually we found coal. The industrial revolution "fed" on coal, then we found "oil", there's probably the next thing!
- joe_the_user 8y agoI shouldn't have implied the feed-and-collapse sequence could only happen once. There can be repeats even with bacteria and sure, humans are more complex than bacteria, the process can be more complex. The only thing not justified is the expand forever thing.