5 ms·
It does say it's only being approved in special cases. I wouldn't expect the building industry to suddenly start using it again. How many of those 3000 are a l
by dmix 8y ago
It does say it's only being approved in special cases. I wouldn't expect the building industry to suddenly start using it again.
How many of those 3000 are a legacy of the previous eras misunderstanding of the chemical? I doubt any company would ignore that risk and produce a product that put people at a direct and unknown risk, especially given the legal liability since we now know the full risks of the chemical and the alternatives the market has long ago developed in every category.
- mrguyorama 8y ago>I doubt any company would ignore that risk and produce a product that put people at a direct and unknown risk Those companies did exactly that! Asbestos companies knew the dangers internally. It's no different than cigarette companies suppressing the science of how smoking is dangerous
- adventured 8y agoMost of those companies were destroyed for it. That's why the parent is speculating companies wouldn't do it now that the medical dangers are fully understood and the matter has been turned into a vast, lucrative profit field in the legal realm.
- nemacol 8y agoThe cases per year are going down and the average age of diagnosis is 69. So you are right in that most of this is legacy. But we know now and knew then that it was dangerous. Much like the radium girls in the early 1900's - where the people delivering the paint would wear leaded protective equipment and then management would watch (and encourage) the girls lick the paint brushes to keep the tip pointed. They knew it was bad. They just didn't give a fuck.
- hfdgiutdryg 8y agoI'd never heard of radium girls and found this interesting: https://www.cnn.com/style/article/radium-girls-radioactive-paint/index.html https://www.cnn.com/style/article/radium-girls-radioactive-p... I'm slightly confused why the public at large was ignorant of the danger of radium (and even thought it was healthy), but the radium girl managers knew the danger...?
- nemacol 8y agoIt is a compelling story. As for why the public was ignorant to the danger; radiation was only discovered in 1895 (x-rays). First injuries the following year from x-ray exposure. First death in 1904. I am no expert, so I can only speculate. Thinking that pre-internet, information moved slower and scientific information slower still. The radium they were using was "different" and really trendy. Even a handful of deaths wouldn't repel the masses. It was only 12 years after the x-ray deaths. If I can be cynical for a moment, this is a cycle that replays far too often. Some industry uses a product that is more or less known to be dangerous and it is only with years or decades of evidence, public outrage, and government intervention does that industry change its ways. Not always is it malicious or intentional, but this kind of thing does seem to happen a lot.
- markvdb 8y agoThe material stil has to be mined. Even with US companies treating the health risks to their employees in an exemplary way (hah!), there still would be extra deaths in asbestos mining and processing in Russia or Brazil...
- gHosts 8y agoMy uncle was a geologist, spent some time on an Asbestos mine... and it killed him. As user nemacol said above..... What an awful way to die. Really really nasty.
- kartan 8y ago>I doubt any company would ignore that risk and produce a product that put people at a direct and unknown risk History contradicts your statement. The most recent one https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal They knew. They did it anyway. But I agree that most companies, and most people, will not take that path. But you just need a very few to create a global health problem.
- manicdee 8y agoWhat is the oversight for approvals? Is it just the 45th president and his mates saying, “Vladimir says it’s okay to put asbestos in brake pads and drywall”?
- pi-rat 8y ago>>> I doubt any company would ignore that risk and produce a product that put people at a direct and unknown risk. I'm sorry, but they have done and still do exactly that all the time in the name of profit! Often it takes decades for the public to learn the truth. Here's a few examples: - 3M knew already in 1970 that PFOA and PFOE (used in their non-stick frying pan coatings) was toxic and accumulated in peoples blood[1]. - Volkswagen emission scandal[2] - Oil companies' continuous support of fake science, lobbying, advertisement and grant making to oppose regulation. Exxon knew about climate change 40 years ago[3]. - Leaded fuel.. And that's just the few I could think about at a moments notice.. [1]: https://theintercept.com/2018/07/31/3m-pfas-minnesota-pfoa-pfos/ https://theintercept.com/2018/07/31/3m-pfas-minnesota-pfoa-p... [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Volkswagen_emissions_scandal [3]: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/exxon-knew-about-climate-change-almost-40-years-ago/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/exxon-knew-about-...