3 ms·
Your description of experimental quantum physics exactly matches the work done in state of the art biology. It basically takes 10-20 years of training and exce
by dekhn 8y ago
Your description of experimental quantum physics exactly matches the work done in state of the art biology. It basically takes 10-20 years of training and excellent brains to reproduce your competitor's paper in a way that lets you build on top of it. Many people who complain that papers aren't reproducible just don't have the skill to move the state of the art, because it's become so esoteric and challenging to run the critical experiments.
I used to be a "everything must be replicable by even the simplest of people" person, but I changed to "for progress to be made there must be <X> competent people who can reproduce challenging experiments and run new ones".
- BoiledCabbage 8y ago> because it's become so esoteric and challenging to run the critical experiments. Maybe more people would be able to run the experiments if papers detailed how to do so. The knowledge would no longer be esoteric.