13 ms·
YouTube Bans Alex Jones, Following Facebook's and Apple's Lead
- api 8y agoI have mixed feelings about this. I fear it will actually make Jones' brand of demagoguery and crackpot theories more appealing and sexy. The best thing to do might be to let far-right conspiracy theory propaganda die in the mainstream, since the mainstream is where things go to die.
- anigbrowl 8y agoI'm not so sure about your theory of mainstream mortality, could you offer some examples? I feel this might be a cliche among technologists who associate mass adoption with a slowdown of innovation or at least of novelty.
- stuckinarut 8y agoMore likely it makes him harder to find and limits his reach more.
- bdcravens 8y agoHe's atop Google search today, and articles on his site about "the purge" have far more engagement than others, so apparently many are seeking him out in light of the news.
- stuckinarut 8y agoAnd not one person is getting him as a suggested video on YouTube, shared on Facebook, etc... Deplatforming is effective.
- bdcravens 8y agoI suspect his fans will be pointing others to his website, and probably twisting the narrative ("The truth Facebook doesn't want you to hear!")
- api 8y agoIf mere exposure to irrational ideas is this dangerous then this basically means the neoreactionaries are right and democracy is not viable. If people are that dumb they should not be able to vote. I think the answer is much simpler but equally pathetic. The center right and center left are both so vapid and devoid of vision that they are helpless to address the "alternative" of Alex Jones. It is our elite that have failed and left a vacuum to be filled with whatever happens to be loudest. If we had real public intellectuals and a real media and real politicians with vision Jones would be completely marginalized. He only succeeds because the culture is so empty.
- hsnewman 8y agoSo your saying you would want Jones' demagoguery to be mainstream?
- api 8y agoI think the best scenario would be for people to see en masse that his predictions amount to nothing. Some people will never catch on but many will. Over time this will discredit his movement.
- NegativeK 8y agoAlex Jones has been around for a long, long time.
- waterphone 8y agoUnfortunately, he's been pretty well known for well over a decade, and he's just grown significantly in popularity in that time.
- zrobotics 8y agoThis is a hard question. There are certain people who are predisposed to this type of thinking, and the YouTube auto play algorithm does seem to funnel people to these types of content (likely due to high engagement). But banning him from the platform plays perfectly into Jones'narrative that he is fighting the shadowy forces that control media. In a way, it almost legitimizes him to his audience.
- dashmatte 8y agoIt's so easy to discover him on youtube especially on their youtube feed. You have no idea how many times I was recommended conspiracy videos on my feed just because i watched a Ben Shapiro video.
- nasredin 8y agoPardon me, if I misunderstood you. Jones is already mainstream. He is not going to get smaller if you give him bigger platforms. Unrelated question. Can somebody explain to me, how he went from "9/11 was inside job, police are jackbooted thugs, anti Bush, anti Obama" to being pro police, pro government? I want to understand the logic behind this.
- sergiotapia 8y agoHow indeed? Best not talk about it here on hackernews though, it's wrongthink and will get you banned. Remember there's no conspiracy to control the narrative. It's totally a coincidence that Alex Jones got banned from Youtube, itunes, and Facebook simultaneously.
- dang 8y agoI'm surprised that such an established HN user as you would say something that absurd about HN moderation.
- sergiotapia 8y agoI've been here long enough right? I've seen it happen, my share of [dead] comments.
- dang 8y agoMaybe so, but "wrongthink"? That's not even close to accurate.
- komali2 8y ago>logic Unfortunately your question starts with an untenable premise ;)
- dragontamer 8y ago> The best thing to do might be to let far-right conspiracy theory propaganda die in the mainstream, since the mainstream is where things go to die. Last time I checked, my mother still thinks Obama is Muslim. So no. Crackpot theories become more widespread once they hit mainstream. And they stay there forever.
- tchaffee 8y agoIn other discussions about this action, I've seen lots of confusion about what the 1st Amendment guarantees. Too many people think it guarantees an outcome: that the government must protect your right to free speech and make sure you have a platform for free speech. When in fact it's almost the opposite: it prevents the government from interfering with free speech, specifically Congress can not pass any laws that interfere with free speech. Keeping in mind that free speech includes the right to not say things you disagree with. I'd be curious if any legal experts know of other laws that might apply in this case.
- javagram 8y agoThere is something else to keep in mind which is that the government can evade the 1st amendment by pressuring companies to take action against speech it doesn’t like. “Hostile environment” laws around workplace conduct are a good example of this; the strict interpretation of the first amendment might not allow the government to directly regulate such speech by employees, but the threat of EEOC lawsuits can compel companies to fire or discipline employees. I’m not sure how much this truly happens but I’ve seen some legal people on twitter talk about it. E.g. http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/hostile.htm http://www2.law.ucla.edu/volokh/hostile.htm
- gamblor956 8y agoThere is something else to keep in mind which is that the government can evade the 1st amendment by pressuring companies to take action against speech it doesn’t like. No, what you have described is a free speech violation and US courts have already addressed this point many times. And you clearly misunderstand why hostile environment laws have survived First Amendment lawsuits. The government cannot interfere with the content of what someone says. But saying (or doing) something isn't just a form of communication--it can also be an act with non-communicative results. The government can regulate behavior, so long as it is agnostic to the communicative content accompanying that behavior.
- javagram 8y agoI linked to an article by a law professor explaining the issues. Courts cannot always address such issues anyway due to the doctrine of “standing”. For instance, government in the 90s pressured the video game industry to self regulate by establishing a rating system and prohibiting the sale of M rated games to minors in various chain stores. If the government themselves had passed such a law it would have been subject to lawsuit under the 1A, but because it was a voluntary action by the industry there is no one to sue (after all, by suing the industry who put these standards in place, one could say that you’re now violating their right to free speech and association!) But to summarize it simply, the government cannot outlaw using a racial slur under common 1st amendment doctrine. However it can outlaw a company allowing an employee to use a racial slur in the workplace. While this is a good result (I don’t want to work somewhere where my coworkers use such slurs) it’s an interesting example of how the power of government is less limited by 1A than one might think at first. Similarly, YouTube, Facebook, etc have been getting a lot of flack from the government lately over Russian bots, trolls, etc. Moves like these to boot InfoWars could be smart business to placate the Democrats who may soon be in power. Infowars has been awful trash for years, and plenty of awful stuff remains on their platforms after all.
- danso 8y agoAs others I've seen on Twitter have pointed out, the "Infowars Official" app and Infowars Magazine creator page is still available on the App Store: https://itunes.apple.com/us/developer/infowars-magazine/id697158581 https://itunes.apple.com/us/developer/infowars-magazine/id69... I don't peruse the Podcast listings, or news about podcasts that much. Is Apple generally not as stringent about policing Podcasts as it is for iOS Apps?
- Tomminn 8y agoFrom Wikipedia: "The InfoWars website receives approximately 10 million monthly visits, making it more visited than some mainstream news websites such as The Economist and Newsweek." This bothers me. Say what you like about his content, but it is not fringe. He is the preferred "thinker" of a significant fraction of the population. If you think the solution is to deplatform him, you're thinking about the problem wrong. He is an opportunity. By becoming a lightening rod and focal point for a large fraction of a country's misguided thinking, he has made that misguided thinking more fragile. Easier to dislodge. Because now you just need to find a combination of words that helps his followers see him for what he actually is. And if you succeed, everyone who sees will get a lesson in thinking more clearly. They will be more resilient to a future charlatan. So if Alex Jones makes your blood boil, then put that emotion to work. Raise his platform. Discuss him. Debunk his ideas one by one. Use whichever tools appeal to you. If youtube wants to help, then youtube algorithms should be tweaked to encourage people to view both sides of the debate.
- rurounijones 8y ago"Raise his platform. Discuss him. Debunk his ideas one by one. You use whichever tools appeal to you" You are assuming this would actually have an effect. Given recent history I am pretty sure people would A) Not see your debunking because it isn't in their little echo chamber of targeted fitlered online news and content. B) Wouldn't believe you or critically think about any debunking anyway. There is a reddit bot that tries to post alternative news sources to subreddits for a given story to encourage a balanced news diet which is a laudable step in this direction. https://www.reddit.com/user/alternate-source-bot https://www.reddit.com/user/alternate-source-bot Just have a look at it's log to see which subreddits it is banned from: https://www.reddit.com/r/alt_source_bot_log/ https://www.reddit.com/r/alt_source_bot_log/
- Tomminn 8y agoIf you can't persuade his base, then I guess you're not the person whose job it is to persuade his base. Be patient. One will come.
- trukterious 8y ago>Conspiracy theorist and online troll Alex Jones >The decision comes hours after Apple and Facebook made similar moves So I guess Mr Jones will have to report on this particular conspiracy elsewhere. I for one would like to hear it...
- pithic 8y agoSophisticated people understand that there are no actual conspiracies, only baseless conspiracy theories.
- trukterious 8y agoConspiracy theories are usually bad explanations and leave unexplained stuff like how new conspirators are recruited without exposing the conspiracy. Yet a small fraction of conspiracy theories are true, e.g. Guy Fawkes. A more sophisticated treatment acknowledges this and understands that these are frequently labelled 'conspiracy theories' in attempts to discredit them.
- mehblahwhatevs 8y agoI don't necessarily like this action. People are quick to point out that FB and Youtube are private entities and such but the reality is that they've become so ubiquitous in our lives that if they start censorship based on the company's preferred politics, beliefs, etc. than it will have an effect on all of us. Can mobile apps (like WhatsApp) inspect messages and decide to boot users if they're saying things that aren't in line with the company's positions? Can ISPs do that too?
- komali2 8y agoWhatsApp can do that, yes! People are talking about "the line" society would draw, and I expect you just found it! ISPs should not do that, it violates net neutrality.
- undseg 8y agoThat completely arbitrary. There's no reason WhatsApp shouldn't be treated as a "dumb pipe for messaging" just like an ISP is widely regarded as necessary to be treated as such for data in general. Where's the difference? Both are companies that want to make profits and face competition. If ISPs were a public state service, then that would be where to draw the line.
- jlarocco 8y agoSame here. I don't agree with anything he says, but banning him from these platforms sets a bad precedent. The way to fight ignorance is with education. If anything, this will enforce their persecution complex. Now Alex Jones will say, "See? Big media doesn't want you to know the things I'm telling you." And he'll be right.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dragontamer 8y ago> The way to fight ignorance is with education. And ignorance fights back with education. Removing Thomas Jefferson from textbooks for example. Or replacing evolution with creationism / intelligent design theory. https://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/13/education/13texas.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/13/education/13texas.html People rewrite education to suit their political slants. You ain't gonna win in education until you win at politics.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- digital_trench 8y agoPrediction: Jones will be back on all these platforms before 2019.
- pavlov 8y agoWhy?
- e40 8y agoNow that he knows where the line is, he'll step back behind it. The pressure from the many fans of his will pressure the companies to put him back on, because he promised to be good. Just a guess.
- gamblor956 8y agoI would predict he'll be back for a different reason. He'll simply create new accounts, and on this new account he'll toe right up to the line without going over it (until 2019). The pressure from his many fans will have no effect, because they're not a market that any company wants to be associated with.
- myf01d 8y agoEven though Alex Jones is one of the most retarded people on Earth and he is a walking meme, CNN and other liberal media aren't really much different since 2016 or even a little earlier. Tech industry is owned and controlled by liberals, if you aren't a member of the liberal cult, you must be a Nazi or white supremacist. Except for FOX news, there are near to 0 non-liberal media outlets. When all media outlets are on the same ideology, this is called dictatorship.
- myf01d 8y agowhat did I expect from HN anyway except purging non-liberal ideas with their downvoting SS force?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dang 8y agoIf you continue to violate the site guidelines we are going to ban your account. Please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and use HN as intended.
- myf01d 8y agoI don't see where I violated your guidelines, maybe I am not liberal enough? why am I always downvoted massively whenever I post a non-ultra-liberal comment? why? what if I posted a comment ridiculing the current POTUS and praising the former POTUS? will I get upvoted or downvoted do you think? I think you know the answer
- pvg 8y agoThey're right in the thingie you were asked to please read. "Please don't use Hacker News primarily for political or ideological battle." and "Please don't comment about the voting on comments."
- pcunite 8y agoThe default SafeSearch filter for Google is turned OFF. That tells you all you need to know about their morals.
- beart 8y agoSorry, what does that tell me about their morals?
- bdcravens 8y agoBefore today, I could care less about Jones's views. Naturally, with the news of these bans, I visited his site. Looks like all the articles about the ban have the most comments. Presumably these aren't just the usual site visitors. And of course right now he's atop today's Google searches: https://trends.google.com/trends/trendingsearches/daily?geo=US https://trends.google.com/trends/trendingsearches/daily?geo=...
- skepticmoron 8y agoRight thing to do. Let’s learn from the mistake bill nye made by debating that idiot who built the ship in the Midwest.
- j-c-hewitt 8y agoI think the reason why Alex Jones became popular is because the mainstream news websites like CNN and even sections of the NYT became more Jones-like in their reporting. When people are just choosing between different sensationalist conspiracy theory websites it becomes much more challenging for ordinary people to pick a quality outlet. The thing is that most of the web and the printed word is spam that will actively confuse you the more that you read it. Compare the newspaper to a cookbook. The cookbook, if it's good, can be tested for effectiveness quite readily even allowing for variations in things like your ingredients and how your oven functions as compared to the one in the author's test kitchen. The news isn't all that different from Maury Pauvitch and it seems to get worse every year. You would probably at least learn a little about how small claims court works by watching daytime TV but you learn less than nothing from having poorly sourced propaganda piped into your brain at 1080p/60fps. People who watch Maury aren't under the impression that they're being elevated, but people addicted to the news are suffering from that delusion.
- torpfactory 8y agoOh please. What a load of hogwash. NYT and CNN aren’t perfect but making some kind of comparison to the rantings of a lunatic like Jones is absurd. Get a grip.
- malvosenior 8y agoThe NYT just hired a full blown racist to their editorial board so I think it's a very apt comparison.
- jimejim 8y agoNo, they didn't. The people that think Sarah Jeong is a racist are the kind of people that take Alex Jones seriously.
- malvosenior 8y agoI and many others think she's racist and in no way take Alex Jones seriously.
- internet_user 8y agoFirst, they came for Alex Jones.
- mk951 8y agoHe's not the first, but I see where you coming from. My immediate questions are 1) are they payment processors going to ban him as well and are we going to have to endure the 'its a private company' argument ad naseum 2) how deep is the purge going to go? I think Alex Jones is mostly right on a some accounts (9/11) and pretty much everybody in this forum is acting like Bolsheviks, its quite sad. Reminds me of the time the Canadian mail denied David Irving a postal address but that's another story.
- gamblor956 8y agoNo, first Alex Jones demanded the assassination of our sitting president. Then he demanded that someone kill the woman running to replace the president. Then he accused a pizza shop of running a pedophilia ring, almost resulting in the deaths of multiple employees and customers when someone took him up on the offer. Then he accused parents of murdered children of staging a false flag event for money. Then, despite all this, he was still allowed to spew his nonsense. Until one day his own supporters starting chanting about fake reporting in the media. And it turns out he was one of the biggest sources of fake news. So they finally got rid of him.
- nkassis 8y agoI think this key here. Jones was free to make up crazy stuff if he wanted but inciting violence or continuing to make up libel against individuals leading to people being harrassed or endagered crosses a line that goes beyond simple free speech. Free speech doesn't allow you to endanger others.
- krapp 8y ago>First, they came for Alex Jones. You know, it's interesting how often this poem, written to warn people about the dangers of the Nazis, is almost exclusively invoked nowadays in defense of Nazis and people who share their ideology. I mean, I get the free speech argument... even though this is less an argument and more a lazy attempt at pseudointellectual concern trolling... but why is it only ever a slippery slope to come for the Nazis, but never a slippery slope to let the Nazis come for us?
- cartercole 8y agofree speech is dead
- nwsm 8y ago"free speech entitles you to saying what you want, not to a microphone"
- cartercole 8y agofree speech is for the government not a private organization
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- mesozoic 8y agoInteresting if anyone could pursue a lawsuit over this stuff Jones could. Will be interesting to see how far that goes in the court system.
- americangreen 8y agoCongrats, you just made Alex Jones cool and officially counter culture cool. This will not end the way silicon valley thinks.
- buth_lika 8y agoWhile you're thinking of the adults, please also think of the children. https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=kids+learn+colors+baby+fun https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=kids+learn+colo... https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=learn+colors+syringe https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=learn+colors+sy...
- thespider 8y agoCongratulations to everyone at InfoWars! They have done such an incredible job, that the lies can't compete any longer and the censorship taking place is just a last resort. Me and all of my colleagues (left of the aisle and to the right) with any of these social media accts will be deleting them, and moving onto other more innovative, true free speech platforms that promote real diversity and tolerance of all viewpoints.
- buth_lika 8y agoCovering for ElsaGate while patting each other on the back. Fantastic.