6 ms·
There's really not much you can do with this without more investigation. For example, what about ages? Are male doctors more likely to be older and it's actual
by crazygringo 8y ago
There's really not much you can do with this without more investigation.
For example, what about ages? Are male doctors more likely to be older and it's actually a generational effect, say, of not listening? Or to the contrary, are male doctors more likely to be older and more experienced, and riskier female cases are sent to them disproportionately out of some bias towards extra care? If a male has more female colleagues, does this affect his behavior or is this simply because they tend to be better-run institutions in general which already seek to be more diverse?
It feels like there are a million ways it could be sliced, and while I'd totally buy the "men without the influence of women tend to not listen to women or pay as much attention to them" if that were backed up causally... it also seems like it's jumping to a click-baity conclusion whose causality is completely unsubstantiated. (No mention that they also measured how much a patient felt listened to, for example.)
- jamra 8y agoI spoke to a doctor about publishing statistics and the major concern with him and his peers was exactly what you mentioned. Riskier cases will make your statistics drop, but the more experienced doctors would almost always get the most difficult cases.
- candiodari 8y agoThat's not true ... after all, that would mean putting MBA type managers in charge of hospitals (like is being done all across the US) is going to lead to disastrously bad decisions as they will institute individual incentives. Giving those experienced doctors little choice : either refuse cases that might die ... or get fired.
- wahern 8y agoRight, which is why some experienced doctors can be overly conservative. The ones that take up the hard cases are therefore penalized even more. You see the same thing with lawyers. The ones with a 100% trial success rate are very choosy about which cases they accept or are more inclined to pressure clients to settle. The phenomenon is real. Whether it exists at the heart of this study or is simply being used to excuse underperforming doctors....
- fragmede 8y agoThat's sarcasm, right? Because that's what has happened, and been happening while healthcare in the US is treated as a for-profit enterprise.
- MarkMc 8y agoI wonder what the doctor thinks of publishing risk adjusted statistics. That is, publishing the difference between expected and actual outcome.
- ksenzee 8y agoEd Yong at the Atlantic looked into that: "These differences persisted even after the team accounted for factors like the doctors’ years of experience and the patients’ age, ethnicity, other diseases, educational level, or the hospitals to which they were admitted." https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/08/women-more-likely-to-survive-heart-attacks-if-treated-by-female-doctors/566837/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/08/women-mo...
- epicureanideal 8y agoYears of experience isn't the only way to measure skill. There are software engineers with 20 years experience that aren't as good as one with 2 years experience. I'd like to see the skill levels of the doctors normalized by something else, like whether they can somehow be identified as part of a group that specializes in high risk cases.
- bduerst 8y agoIsn't this Ageism? There are tons of 20-year experience engineers who are better than 2-year experience engineers. Yes, there are outliers, as with any normalized population, but typically years of experience in a skilled field correlates with ability to do the job well.
- nv-vn 8y agoIt's just as ageist to assume that a young person doesn't know anything
- learnstats2 8y agoOccam's razor is pretty clear here. Before the other million possible but less likely considerations, we should first consider/investigate whether male doctors work with unconscious sexism that is affecting health outcomes for women. It is important that we consider the implications of the most obvious case, rather than deflecting away from it.
- komali2 8y agoI agree that we should investigate it, but without that investigation, Occam's razor becomes more of an undiscerning broadsword.
- Pica_soO 8y agohttps://www.cdc.gov/dhdsp/data_statistics/fact_sheets/fs_heart_disease.htm https://www.cdc.gov/dhdsp/data_statistics/fact_sheets/fs_hea... https://www.cdc.gov/dhdsp/data_statistics/fact_sheets/fs_women_heart.htm https://www.cdc.gov/dhdsp/data_statistics/fact_sheets/fs_wom... https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5106a3.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm5106a3.htm "..finding that cardiac deaths out-of-hospital were more likely to occur among women than men is consistent with findings that women more often delay seeking help for heart attack symptoms (4). Early recognition of heart symptoms and signs leads to earlier artery opening treatment or defibrillation that results in less heart damage and deaths." Education and media efforts should inform the public about heart disease... " (4) Goldberg RJ, Yarzebski J, Lessard D, Gore JM. Decade-long trends and factors associated with time to hospital presentation in patients with acute myocardial infarction: the Worcester heart attack study. Arch Intern Med 2000;160:3217--23.
- rcoveson 8y agoThis is a misapplication of Occam's Razor. If a study discovers a correlation between two variables, the Razor does not take the side of either causal direction. In this case, the "simplest" explanation as far as the Razor is concerned is not that doctor and patient's gender influences outcomes, and not that probability of some outcome influences the gender of the chosen doctor. I believe (somebody please correct me if I'm wrong) the side the Razor takes is that there is no direct causal relationship at all, which is why the burden of proof is traditionally on the experimenter to demonstrate that such a relationship does exist.
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoHere is a link to far more specific data from the main study in the article. I suggest people look over the data themselves. http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2018/07/31/1800097115.DCSupplemental/pnas.1800097115.sapp.pdf?bcsi_scan_e37e3cdb4dc1fe17=guyu7gXOKbf8P6pHGjl97AiZQwMPAAAA9MepTg==&bcsi_scan_filename=pnas.1800097115.sapp.pdf http://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/suppl/2018/07/31/1800097115... The data appears to not be in the friendliest of formats (tables with an axis labeled 'X'? No way my professors would've let that slide).
- efm 8y agoThere's also a mis-labled column in table S2. Which one is Female Doctors Male Patients?
- tedsanders 8y agoThe third column (according to the top rows of the table).
- PurpleBoxDragon 8y agoIn the table it also specifies which is male and which is female.
- 08-15 8y agoThanks for the link. With that paper in hand, I can say confidently that the Scientific American article is a flat out lie, starting from the headline. Chart S1 plots the distribution of the predicted probability for survival in four conditions. The distributions for "Male Doc, Female Patient" and "Female Doc, Female Patient" are visually indistinguishable and peak at around 0.96. "Female Doc, Male Patient" peaks at around 0.97, "Male Doc, Male Patient" at 0.98 or so. The difference in the position of the maximum is real, but tiny; the distributions for female patients are much wider (which visually exaggerates the difference). The math seems to agree with my reading, as it says: "when physician gender (male / female) is regressed upon (ŷ), conditional upon controls, there is no significant correlation between ex ante probability of survival and the gender of the physician." So, dear "Scientific American": It is completely untrue that "Women Die More from Heart Attacks Than Men—Unless the ER Doc Is Female". The data says that "Women Die More from Heart Attacks Than Men—No Matter Who Treats Them" and that "Men Die More from Heart Attacks Than Other Men—When the ER Doc Is Female" No thanks for turning a study that found tiny differences into a politically charged statement. But then why would Brad Greenwood, the author of the study, state that "All of those are statistically indistinguishable except for male doctor–female patient", when it's obvious to the naked eye that there are other difference? I guess one difference made it over the arbitrary threshold of significance, and others didn't. That's just the nature of SHIT (Statistical Hypothesis Inference Testing).
- dahdum 8y agoI’d also posit that female ER doctors could as a group, simply be better than the average male. Not inherent to their gender, but because they are a more motivated group to overcome the systemic bias in medicine to get there. If you get to 50/50 this would mean the stats converge, but the same findings would need to be repeated across other conditions as well.
- Axsuul 8y agoThen we would've seen the same trend with female doctors treating male patients.
- majos 8y agoNot necessarily. It could be that only good doctors treat female patients well, while all doctors treat male patients well. For example, if women patients are in some way harder cases while male patients are not, then treatment of women patients may separate good doctors from the rest.
- wahern 8y agoAlternatively, women patients speak differently to male doctors in ways that make it more difficult to make accurate and reliable diagnoses. Educated professionals are certainly capable of exhibiting bias. But professionals are also more aware of the issue, and are even taught (formally and informally) compensating strategies. People off the street? Not so much....
- Broken_Hippo 8y agoOR just that female doctors paid more attention to the fact that heart attack symptoms are different for women than for men. This may be as simple as it affecting them. If the male takes longer to recognise heart attack symptoms of females, it could easily produce worse results. https://www.healthline.com/health/heart-disease/heart-attack-symptoms https://www.healthline.com/health/heart-disease/heart-attack...
- 08-15 8y ago
- bsder 8y agoI'd also like to see if the female doctors simply follow the checklist better than male doctors. ER outcomes have been shown over and over to improve when there is a checklist available and followed.
- Axsuul 8y agoThat would only apply if we saw the same trend with female doctors treating male patients. > The researchers divided 500,000-plus cases into four categories: male doctors treating men; male doctors treating women; female doctors treating men; and female doctors treating women. “All of those are statistically indistinguishable except for male doctor–female patient,” says Brad Greenwood
- tedsanders 8y agoFYI, just because effect A is statistically distinguishable from zero and effect B is not statistically distinguishable from zero, that does not imply effect A is statistically distinguishable from effect B. It could still be the case that female doctors are better overall, even if it was only distinguishable from zero in a single branch. (I looked at paper myself but am not confident I can interpret it correctly.)
- pseudalopex 8y agoThe article mentions that women are more likely to present with "atypical" symptoms (which actually may be typical for women). Maybe almost all men present with "typical" symptoms or female doctors are more diligent about checking women for "atypical" symptoms.