3 ms·
More generally, not all bad behavior is or should be illegal. Not all bad behaviors are illegal but calling for active, illegal harassment of an individual, wh
by joe_the_user 8y ago
More generally, not all bad behavior is or should be illegal.
Not all bad behaviors are illegal but calling for active, illegal harassment of an individual, which other people carry out, is, in fact, illegal and given this is often Jones' modus operandi, his activities are illegal and his overall strategy has involved staying one step ahead of lawsuits.
- nailer 8y agoHas he done that? Jones is an asshole, I think the Sandy Hook thing was awful (and could be constituted as harassing them himself) but I haven't heard of him 'calling for active, illegal harassment of an individual' before. Not saying he wouldn't do that, it's just that the ban doesn't mention this and I haven't heard of it.
- jessriedel 8y agoSounds like a job for the courts. I don't think any in this thread is remotely informed about the facts of the case.
- joe_the_user 8y agoWell, when a company is looking at someone using their platform for a activities that look blatantly illegal, it's common for them to preemptively ban them. These platforms have no obligation to wait for a court ruling. In case of Jones, He blatantly defamed the parents of Sandy Hook victims in a fashion that had considerable negative consequences for the parents due to constant harassment by Jones followers. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/31/us/politics/alex-jones-defamation-suit-sandy-hook.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/31/us/politics/alex-jones-de...
- jessriedel 8y agoI agree this would be a reasonable response if this were the actual justification. But in fact, all the coverage I've seen of this cites his hate speech as the justification, not illegal activity. https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/lifestyle/2018/08/apple-pulls-controversial-podcast-from-itunes.html https://www.newshub.co.nz/home/lifestyle/2018/08/apple-pulls... https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/aug/06/apple-removes-podcasts-infowars-alex-jones https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/aug/06/apple-rem... Hate speech is correctly generally protected by the first amendment, and it should likewise be protected as free speech by private parties.
- joe_the_user 8y agoHate speech is correctly generally protected by the first amendment, and it should likewise be protected as free speech by private parties. Hate speech is not protected by the first amendment. It is correct that something being hate speech by itself not sufficient cause for it to lose first amendment protections. But hate speech can loose first amendment protections for all the reasons other speech can; commercial speech, fighting-words and liable/slander included. And of course, the first amendment doesn't require Apple or Facebook to host anyone so them banning first amendment protected hate speech is not a problem by itself, which is to say the second part of your claim isn't justified. I mean, Jones' vicious rants are hate speech, slander, and falsehoods. They are intended to damage innocent, a-political, private individuals and have indeed damaged a-political, innocent private individuals. Which reason a company actually gives to ban Jones probably involves a PR calculation ("hate speech" sounds best) but whatever the given reason, I can't see this as unjustified.
- jessriedel 8y ago> It is correct that something being hate speech by itself not sufficient cause for it to lose first amendment protections.... "Hate speech is correctly generally protected by the first amendment" obviously does not mean "all hate speech is protected regardless of other properties it may have". That's the entire point of the word "generally". The point is that Apple and others are using "hate speech" alone as the justification. > the first amendment doesn't require Apple or Facebook to host anyone so them banning first amendment protected hate speech is not a problem by itself, which is to say the second part of your claim isn't justified. I have explained at least half a dozen places in this thread why it's a mistake to think there's no moral imperative for private individuals and organizations free speech just because the first amendment applies only to the government. I didn't want to repeat myself, so I explicitly acknowledged in the comment you're replying to that it is an additional moral claim. Your comment just states your disagreement without actually arguing for it, or engaging with any of the arguments I have given elsewhere.
- joe_the_user 8y ago