8 ms·
Tech Billionaires Hack Their Taxes with a Philanthropic Loophole
- nbisfuor 8y agoSo essentially Donor Advised Funds are better in every way for the donor, including but not limited to being more private, way less arbitrary restrictions (donate 5% a year -- why?) and allowing them control of where they donate. And this is competition for non-profits of other kinds, that are mostly just a way for people to pay themselves giant base salaries, relative to a donor-controlled fund. And further, this article is basically calling out a person in particular for putting $500M into a fund for the purpose of philanthropy (sooner or later) and then not having made enough donations (it would better if he had to donate 5%/year -- again, why?). Then goes on to quote a professor calling it fraud, despite it still being legitimately a way for people to donate assets like stock to charity in a one-way vehicle that they control, as if that is bad somehow. Evidently people are so angry at successful people at this point, they are not going after their charity too, again not clear on why.
- dmoy 8y agoNot clear why this comment is getting downvoted, seems like a reasonable summary to me. From the title I was expecting the article to be more nefarious, like "donating" to a charity that pays obscene salaries to friends & family for cushy jobs or something.
- danso 8y agoIt's not a reasonable summary. From the parent commenter: > And further, this article is basically calling out a person in particular for putting $500M into a fund for the purpose of philanthropy (sooner or later) and then not having made enough donations (it would better if he had to donate 5%/year -- again, why?). From the article: > But four years on, there is almost no trace of the Woodman Foundation, or that $500 million. The foundation has no website and has not listed its areas of focus, and it is not known what — if any — significant grants it has made to nonprofits...If the benefit to the needy is difficult to see, the benefit to Mr. Woodman is clear. After GoPro’s initial public offering, he faced an enormous tax bill in 2014. But by donating via the Silicon Valley Community Foundation, he eased his tax burden in two ways. First, Mr. Woodman avoided paying capital gains taxes on that $500 million worth of stock, a figure that most likely would have been in the tens of millions of dollars. He was also able to claim a charitable deduction that most likely saved millions of dollars more, and probably reduced his personal tax bill for years to come. The parent commenter goes on to sum up the article as thus: > Evidently people are so angry at successful people at this point, they are [now] going after their charity too, again not clear on why. The article asserts early on that the problem is lack of transparency: > Mr. Woodman achieved this enticing combination of tax efficiency and secrecy by using a donor-advised fund — a sort of charitable checking account with serious tax benefits and little or no accountability...So while donors enjoy immediate tax benefits, charities can wait for funds indefinitely, and maybe forever.
- dmoy 8y agoI still don't quite see how it's an issue. The money can't not go to a charity, it's just a question of when. Why is the time lag such a cause for concern? Say I donate money towards an effort that takes 10 years to get tangible results, so what? If there's some shady behavior later to try to illegally claw back charity donations, then sure, that's messed up. But just delaying it N years? So? It still goes to charity at the end. By the same logic, do people get super upset when someone doesn't donate to charity during their life and instead just donated the vast majority of their estate on death? It has nearly the same effect. Maybe people do get upset about that, I dunno.
- downandout 8y agoWhy is the time lag such a cause for concern? It's not a cause for concern. It just makes for nice clickbait headlines, and stories full of innuendo with zero proof of actual wrongdoing. In this case, they don't even really make a clear accusation of wrongdoing. This way, they won't get sued over this drivel, but they will get clicks, and those clicks will cause ad impressions.
- _jal 8y agoIn public policy, when you insert a time-lag between reward and behavior for which one is rewarded, there is at least cause for concern. See basically every metro-telecom deal ever for evidence. And transparency is vital. Any time there are dark corners, people find a way to fester in them. See every society, ever. Finally, there's really just a degree of gided-age wealth-fatigue. You have to expect it at a certain point - humans are exquisitely attuned to status differences; it is just how they're wired.
- Washuu 8y agoIf I suddenly had billions in stock laying in my lap I would be wishing to donate a bunch of money to help offset that tax bill. I know what I could do with $10,000,000 right this moment. The remaining $490,000,000 from the example in the article? I do not know yet, but eventually I will find something.
- petilon 8y ago> allowing them control of where they donate They are also not required to disclose how the charitable dollars are spent. You don't see the problem here? How do we, as taxpayers, know the money is even being spent for real charitable purposes? See for example this story: https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/06/14/new-york-attorney-general-sues-close-trump-foundation-misuse/ https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2018/06/14/new-york-attorne...
- woolvalley 8y agoThe same way the IRS audits donations and non-profits in general? How is this any different from a person directly donating $X dollars other than the ability to sit and wait and think about it? Do I get to see what a private citizen donates to directly unless that organization that receives the money discloses who donated how much?
- petilon 8y ago> How is this any different from a person directly donating $X dollars You have to disclose the recipient of the donation to IRS. That's the difference. These "Donor Advised Funds" apparently don't have to report disbursements.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- astura 8y agoI don't think that's the case. > And because organizations that manage D.A.F.s are not required to report which funds give money to which causes, it is impossible to know how much money individual donors are giving away to nonprofit organizations. That doesn't mean the donor advised fund isn't required to report the givings the fund makes, it means it isn't required to report who gave to whom. I would be shocked if the DAF managers aren't required to report spending/giving, because they are also 501c3 themselves.
- kharms 8y ago
- greglindahl 8y agoThe 5% rule was created relatively recently to prevent infinite growth of charities... which has been an actual problem since the Golden Era of Robber Barons.
- downandout 8y agoYeah I don't see the controversy here. Clearly the author has an agenda. Look at this gem: "...[Mr. Woodman] was giving away much of that wealth — some $500 million worth of GoPro stock — to the Silicon Valley Community Foundation...Mr. Woodman avoided paying capital gains taxes on that $500 million worth of stock, a figure that most likely would have been in the tens of millions of dollars..." Of course he avoided capital gains on the stock he gave away - he couldn't sell it anymore because it was no longer his. The entire section about Nick Woodman strives to imply that something improper has occurred, but all I see is a successful entrepreneur that gave away a large part of his fortune. Regardless of how long it takes for that money to be distributed by the charitable fund, the money is forever no longer his.
- hundt 8y agoIt's at least little bit fishy that you can get a $500 million deduction for giving away stock that is never worth $500 million to anyone (since giving it away tanked the sale price, and selling it would presumably drive it down even farther). Of course the main reason for that is other parts of the tax code, not DAFs. But I think DAFs get targeted for criticism because they make it a lot easier to exploit these kinds of flaws.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- wgjordan 8y ago> It's at least little bit fishy that you can get a $500 million deduction for giving away stock that is never worth $500 million to anyone (since giving it away tanked the sale price, and selling it would presumably drive it down even farther). I'm not entirely sure you can, based on my reading of 26 CFR 1.170A-1(c)(3) [1]: > (3) If a donor makes a charitable contribution of property, such as stock in trade, at a time when he could not reasonably have been expected to realize its usual selling price, the value of the gift is not the usual selling price but is the amount for which the quantity of property contributed would have been sold by the donor at the time of the contribution. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.170A-1 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.170A-1
- ChristianBundy 8y ago> Evidently people are so angry at successful people at this point Because "successful" people are laughably just capitalists whose only success is extracting wealth from people who actually work for a living. Capitalism isn't a system that benefits the vast majority of people and being a "successful" capitalist is bad for our planet and society.
- WalterBright 8y ago> extracting wealth from people who actually work for a living This is the Labor Theory of Value, which is regularly debunked. Capitalists create value, they don't take it from others. (You can see this on the balance sheet - the business is worth more than its "book value".) > Capitalism isn't a system that benefits the vast majority of people The vast majority of immigrants arrived in the US with little more than a suitcase, yet capitalism made them wealthy. > bad for our planet and society Non-capitalist societies are far more destructive to the planet.
- ChristianBundy 8y ago1. You're conflating owners and managers. Private ownership of the means of production doesn't add anything of value, but of course organizing people and resources is valuable. My point is that you don't need to have a monoply (or oligopoly) of power concentrated in private shareholders. 2. I'm not interested in myths. Look up statistics on immigrant poverty under capitalism and let me know whether you'd like to continue this line of reasoning. 3. Some, yes. All? Of course not.
- ghufran_syed 8y agoAbout point 2: Almost all wealth in this country is owned by people who do not identify as Native American. The US is the most successful society economically over a long period of time. The US has a capitalist system, probably more so than most other countries. Doesn’t that imply that the wealth in this country was generated by immigrants (and their descendants) under a capitalist system?
- 8y ago
- cm2187 8y agoMaybe I misunderstood, but isn’t the tax reduction for charitable donations effectively allowing you to donate based on pre-tax revenues as opposed to post tax. If you really donate these assets/income, you are still left with less money than if you hadn’t done the donation. So the tax deductibility isn’t really in question. What it is question is donating an asset of which you still enjoy the usage. Right?
- ghufran_syed 8y agoBut I think the only “usage” you can have is to choose where to donate it - and you can’t just donate it to your family or business associates , it has to be a registered charity subject to the usual rules.
- radiantswirl 8y agoI have the exact same question as you.
- elchief 8y agoYa my old boss did this (the family foundation style). He was worth about $500M at the time I knew him. And ran his little "charity" that gave away 5% a year Meanwhile all that money was managed by some hedge fund and was making 30% returns (this was '08, right before the Great Recession) He owned the most expensive house in the Hamptons and had a private jet and complained about all the sycophants We did get catered lunches by his personal chef every day at work, so I'm not complaining...
- downandout 8y agoMeanwhile all that money was managed by some hedge fund and was making 30% returns (this was '08, right before the Great Recession) If the charity was making 30% returns, how is that a bad thing? Those gains don't flow back to the donor.
- elchief 8y agoI wouldn't say it's a bad thing. Just contrasting it to the 5% outflow
- throwaway76543 8y agoYour objection is that he earned a 30% return and only donated 5%?
- greedo 8y agoDespite your disclaimer, you are complaining. The scare quotes around charity, the cost and location of his house, his private jet, and his complaint about sycophants; none have to do with the NYT article, just an anecdote from you with your complaints.
- darawk 8y agoI don't really understand the criticism here. The NYT is acting like they are evading taxes, but as far as I can tell, they can't use this money on themselves personally. So, maybe it's just sitting in the DAF accumulating interest, and I guess that's not productive...but it doesn't really seem like tax evasion? Unless i'm missing something, they still eventually have to spend it on charity, right? So, whether they do that today or twenty years from now after accumulating interest seems kind of irrelevant to me. It'd be one thing if the NYT had done some reporting that showed these guys were exploiting some loophole to spend the money on themselves without paying taxes. That'd be a big story, and worthy of criticism. But as it is, I don't really see it. Am I missing something here? Anyone who disagrees care to tell me why i'm wrong?
- walshemj 8y agoYes the 1$ salary for ceo's is "evading" taxes this is just a charitable deduction. The only problem is if the "charity" isn't really a charity in that case the "pastors" of mega churches who have multiple private jets need to be looked at first.
- darawk 8y agoYa totally. If the NYT was reporting here that the GoPro guy used his DAF to buy a private jet and fly himself around the world, i'd be all for this story. But as it is, they've really uncovered nothing at all, as far as I can tell.
- shakestheclown 8y agoPart of the problem is that no one really knows where the money goes. So we wouldn't really know if he had a charity jet purchased by the company. Charity can be used to cover a lot of things: dinners, galas, trips, vehicles, lucrative jobs, etc.
- Woberto 8y agoOne issue mentioned by NYT is using DAFs to "obscure their political activity" since donations don't have to be made public and non-profits don't have to disclose donors. Another issue is that the tax savings felt by the donors is tied to the original contribution's valuation and not the valuation at the time the money is used. So in the case of GoPro's Nicholas Woodman, he got a tax break based on $500 mil, but the shares have dropped around 93% so if they're used for charity now it's like he only donated a fraction of that amount. NYT also reports that the fees for some of these DAFs can be significant and so a portion of these donations are going to e.g. Goldman Sachs, Fidelity, and similar firms.
- dang 8y agoAlso about this, from two months ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17126875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17126875.
- rmoxley 8y agoThis article is fundamentally misleading here: > When it comes to D.A.F.s, the United States tax code rewards the promise of good intentions. Wealthy donors — including many of the Silicon Valley billionaires who have asked the public to trust them with their digital lives — pledge to distribute their funds to charity once they get their tax break. A contribution to a donor advised fund is irreversible. Once the donor has given that contribution, it is no longer "their funds." The NYTimes makes it sound like the donor could make a gift and then later spend that money on themselves. That's not how it works. They have the ability to advise the DAF where the grants go, but the grants must go to charities recognized by the IRS. Giving money to a donor advised fund is giving money to charity. You don't get it back. It's not a promise to give later. It's a charitable donation. I'm bewildered by the tone of this article. If the author wants to take a donor to task for giving to charity X instead of charity Y, that seems fair even if I disagree. But asserting that someone who gives hundreds of millions of dollars to a DAF -- an irreversible charitable gift -- is "Hacking Their Taxes" and somehow cheating is just disingenuous.
- adventured 8y ago> I'm bewildered by the tone of this article. It's a propaganda article that intentionally lies about what's occuring. It's very unlikely that the NY Times writer simply didn't understand anything about what they were writing on. The most plausible argument is that they're pushing an agenda and are willing to lie to do it. It's at least semi-widely believed that large foundation giving by eg Gates or Buffett (or any other billionaires), is a tax dodging scheme for their own benefit (as though they can freely spend billions in foundation money on themselves). You'll see those comments by the droves across forums when this topic comes up, despite the anti-logic, anti-factual nature of the claims. It's a sort of 'the rich are evil, even in charity' dog whistle for people that buy into that ideology (the Times writer is pitching to their base here).
- Woberto 8y agoI thought the tone was reasonable - I don't think NYT said anything about donors spending the money on themselves later. Here are the issues it points out (I had posted this somewhere lower): One issue mentioned by NYT is using DAFs to "obscure their political activity" since donations don't have to be made public and non-profits don't have to disclose donors. Another issue is that the tax savings felt by the donors is tied to the original contribution's valuation and not the valuation at the time the money is used. So in the case of GoPro's Nicholas Woodman, he got a tax break based on $500 mil, but the shares have dropped around 93% so if they're used for charity now it's like he only donated a fraction of that amount. NYT also reports that the fees for some of these DAFs can be significant and so a portion of these donations are going to e.g. Goldman Sachs, Fidelity, and similar firms.
- crb002 8y agoIssue is that charity should come after tax.
- astura 8y agoThe article makes it seem like donor advised funds are only for millionaires but your average Joe can set one up online in a few minutes at Fidelity or Vanguard. Last I checked Fidelity's minimum investment to set up a donor advised fund was only $5,000. If you're going to give even only a few hundred to charity over the next 10 years it might make sense to set up one during a year when your tax bracket is high (like a year you have a windfall) or you already have a lot of deductions. It's definitely a "tax hack" as it's often done to (hopefully) minimizing taxes, but it's legal and the charitable contributions are 100% real and you can't spend that money any other way other than on charity. It's like claiming people who are contributing to 401ks are "hacking their taxes." It's not nefarious as this author it making it out to be. I was intending to set one up myself during the years when I was itemizing deductions, because I don't plan on having enough deductions to itemize for the rest of my life and I'd like to give to charity throughout the years. Then the tax reform passed very suddenly, I'm going to claim the standard deduction this year, so I missed my window to save thousands on taxes. Oh well.
- kregasaurusrex 8y agoHow does tiered voting stock donated to these companies operate? Does the owner of said stock still retain voting control even though the stock is now owned by the DAF? There's also an issue with how these sorts charities are privately incorporated which aids in hiding them from public scrutiny regarding how and when funds are spent. For example, a 501(c)3 Organization requires tax forms to be disclosed and available to be audited in order to see all associated expenses. The cost of filing and completing the yearly form is minimal enough not to inhibit any undue stress in record-keeping to follow GAAP, even such that no outside advisors would need to hired in order to file.
- throw2016 8y agoYou should get a tax break when you donate to charity, not when putting it into an intermediary vehicle that holds the funds. This is just asking for abuse. This is exactly the kind of self serving 'financial engineering' wall street has become infamous for, and now they get to suck their fees from the charity sector too. Their fees are a parasitical tax on funds that should have gone to charity and used today given the tax breaks have already been given. The fact that the banking sector can still successfully lobby and get bills passed to operate in secrecy without accountability reflects how badly broken the financial system has become.
- AdamM12 8y agoYou are always giving away more money than you receive in tax benefits. People forget that.
- habosa 8y agoThis is a pretty poorly presented article. There are good points for and against DAFs but they're hard to find in here. And backing up, I feel like we don't often question the idea of giving nearly unlimited tax breaks for charitable donations. The Economist did a very good job explaining the history, pros, and cons of this practice in 2012: https://www.economist.com/briefing/2012/06/09/sweetened-charity https://www.economist.com/briefing/2012/06/09/sweetened-char... For what it's worth I donate a good amount every year to causes I care about and I am certainly motivated by the tax break. While that's rational, I do sometimes wonder about the ethical side. After all, I am basically saying that I should get to self-direct a large chunk of my own taxes. The govt has an idea of what it would do with my income taxes but I can donate them to a cause of my choosing. And there's very little vetting about what causes count, as long as they're not for profit. I could be giving thousands to a charity that wants to give citizenship to dolphins, and depriving some good state and federal programs of those funds. I do think that there's a good reason to give some limited deductions for charitable giving. After all the world is probably better when people give to each other, no matter the cause. But allowing someone to get a billion dollar windfall and use this tax break to redirect many millions to a cause of their choosing rather than the public is probably taking it too far.
- tonfa 8y agoDo I get it right that in the US charity donations are a tax credit, with no limits? Where I'm currently resident we simply get to deduct it from income, iirc you can deduct up to 20% of your yearly income. That might avoid the ethical concern about not paying tax.
- perl4ever 8y agoIn my experience (as a US taxpayer not a tax advisor) charitable donations in the US are a deduction from income, not a credit, up to a limit of 50% of your income, or less. However, if you donate more than 50% of your income you can carry it over for a limited number of years. It eventually vanishes, though, unlike capital gains losses.
- habosa 8y ago
- dan-robertson 8y agoIs this particularly related to tech, or even new? Isn’t giving to charity (or things that claim to be charity) quite a common thing for the rich to do to reduce their taxes? And something that’s been done for decades too?
- NelsonMinar 8y agoI'm going to repost a comment I made last time we talked about DAFs (three months ago) I set up a DAF when Google went public in 2004. I've spent 25-50% of it in the intervening 13 years, despite best intentions. I sure took that full tax break in 2004 though and have compounded the value of that annually. So in my case the DAF has not worked as a great way to funnel money to actual charities. It just sits idle, compounding. The tax break I got seems to outweigh the public benefit. The psychology of having the DAF is funny. I sort of feel the virtue of having donated to charity every single year, just looking at the balance. When I do make a grant from the DAF I don't really feel like I'm doing anything more worthwhile. Also it's a bit impersonal because you have to recommend the grant then wait several days for the DAF to actually allocate. OTOH it's nice having a pile of money I've already "spent" that I can use to give to things at a whim. I think the solution is to require DAFs spend some large portion of their balance every single year. Charitable foundations are required to distribute something like 5%, but I think 10% or more makes more sense for an individual's DAF. There's also a strong argument that charitable donations shouldn't be tax deductible at all, remove this whole tax gimmick and economic distortion. I'm not sure I fully buy it (and the transition would be brutal) but it is worth reading: https://www.economist.com/briefing/2012/06/09/sweetened-charity https://www.economist.com/briefing/2012/06/09/sweetened-char... Update (August 2018): since writing that comment I felt guilty and have made more grants. Current events had something to do with it too, turns out there's a lot of immigrant legal aid charities that need the money right now.
- wgjordan 8y agoLet's read the GoPro example closely: - $500m of GoPro stock was donated at about $95 per share, but actually sold by the fund at $18 per share (or so the article implies). - Assuming the highest marginal tax rate (39.6%), the $500m tax-deductible donation would produce a net gain of $198m from reduced income taxes over the next 5 years. - Selling all the stock at $18 per share would have produced a net gain of $76m ($94m minus $19m in 20% capital gains taxes). So by 'donating' the large block of stock at its highest price point, the donor profited an extra $122m over what the stock was ever actually worth, in addition to the positive publicity associated with generously donating $500m (that was actually only worth $94m). My reading of this is that the 'loophole' in this example has less to do with the particular recipient of the donation, and more to do with the supposed misrepresentation of the 'fair market value' of the stock donation, which the article implies was closer to $94m than $500m. However, there appears to be a law specifically prohibiting this kind of inflated misrepresentation of stock value based on current selling price, 26 CFR 1.170A-1(c)(3) [1]: > (3) If a donor makes a charitable contribution of property, such as stock in trade, at a time when he could not reasonably have been expected to realize its usual selling price, the value of the gift is not the usual selling price but is the amount for which the quantity of property contributed would have been sold by the donor at the time of the contribution. So the so-called 'loophole' implied by the $500 million example doesn't actually exist. Assuming the full $500 million was actually deducted at its full value seems to be either fuzzy speculation on the part of the author, or something that will undoubtedly be heavily scrutinized/challenged in a future IRS audit based on the legal definition of 'value' of a charitable contribution. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.170A-1 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.170A-1
- hundt 8y agoOh, good catch. The IRS instructions on valuing charitable gifts of stock supports your interpretation: https://www.irs.gov/publications/p561#idm140501157972816 https://www.irs.gov/publications/p561#idm140501157972816 > determining the value of large blocks of stock usually requires the help of experts specializing in underwriting large quantities of securities, or in trading in the securities of the industry of which the particular company is a part i.e. it's not just "(market price) x (number of shares)" Although when I looked at the article it seems that they do not actually claim that he was able to deduct $500 million. They strongly imply it by saying that "his tax savings were pegged to the shares’ all-time high" but in terms of the actual deduction they just write that he "likely saved millions of dollars" which is accurate.
- captain_perl 8y agoJust wait until you find out about the The California Land Conservation Act, commonly known as the Williamson Act. A Who's Who of Apple executives exploit this to build mansions on nearby "ranches": https://www.sccassessor.org/index.php/tax-savings/tax-reductions/farmers-and-ranchers https://www.sccassessor.org/index.php/tax-savings/tax-reduct...
- compsciphd 8y agoI created a donor advised fund at the end of 2017. Looked at my assets and basically said, I'll put away 4-5 years worth of charitable donations. 1) With the tax changes going down, the benefit this year would be greater than any future year 2) with the changes increasing the standard deduction and limiting the SALT deduction, even if I would itemize in the future, it be less valuable. i.e. it's just for billionaires (or even millionaires)