8 ms·
One Year Without AMP
- willio58 8y agoI doubt removing amp actually helped your search results. If there’s evidence of this out there I’d like to see it. Like you said, it’s probably the fact that you’ve written more (and maybe better) articles in the past year.
- ImaCake 8y ago>I doubt removing amp actually helped your search results. The author doesn't say this. In fact the author has carefully worded their conclusion so they don't say this! From the article: >Still, I feel very confident that disabling AMP did not have a negative impact on my search traffic.
- willio58 8y agoI said that disabling amp probably didn’t have a positive impact. The writer is saying that they are confident that disabling amp did not have a negative impact. Two different statements.
- lightswitch05 8y agoI block AMP and its related domains in my aggressive blocking hosts list[1]. I've found many AMP related sites are purely for marketing, or 'news' articles that are thinly veiled ads. I haven't missed it at all. I also don't use Google, so perhaps that it part of it, but I applaud your decision to remove AMP. The web isn't meant to be centralized in this way. [1] https://github.com/lightswitch05/hosts/blob/master/tracking-aggressive-extended.txt https://github.com/lightswitch05/hosts/blob/master/tracking-...
- bhhaskin 8y agoNot sure why you are being down voted. You aren't wrong.
- dang 8y agoPlease read the site guidelines, which ask you not to post comments about voting on comments. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- JoshMnem 8y agoI block AMP pages too. Unfortunately, Google artificially slows down AMP pages so that they literally take 8 seconds to load if you block the AMP JavaScript. (Check the inline CSS.)
- SquareWheel 8y agoAre you sure that isn't just a timeout function in case AMP fails to load? edit: Dug up the code. <style> body {animation:-amp-start 8s steps(1,end) 0s 1 normal both} @keyframes -amp-start{from{visibility:hidden} to{visibility:visible}} </style> <noscript> <style> body {animation:none} </style> </noscript> The timeout function is turned off if JS isn't available, so JS being disabled shouldn't be a problem. I'm guessing this is actually to delay page paint so it doesn't display when half-loaded.
- anoncoward111 8y agoIf they don't allow you to fix this fallback, it's a punishment
- bastawhiz 8y agoIn fairness, blocking the external half of the code while not blocking the inline part of the code is on you. You could just as easily block/disable the <style> tag that adds this in addition to the AMP JS.
- JoshMnem 8y agoBlocking inline CSS is more difficult than blocking external resources.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- detaro 8y agoparent said > block the AMP JavaScript not, > JS being disabled
- joegahona 8y agoThe site I work on had a slight bump up the first month after disabling AMP, and we've had pretty flat traffic from SEO ever since, which feeds the conspiracy theorists that "AMP helps your search positioning."
- partiallypro 8y agoIt's not a conspiracy theory, I've worked with Google engineers over the phone and email for an agency...and this is one of their pitches. They now will even help you build the AMP pages, or just build them for you.
- dannyw 8y agoYeah. We had a google employee tell us to build AMP to rank higher.
- joegahona 8y agoI was on a Hangout with two product managers of AMP, and they told me exactly the opposite. This was Oct 2017. The exception is the news carousel, which appears at the top of search results and also contains only AMP. As of right now, however, it's only news content, and I don't work for a news site.
- partiallypro 8y agoMy last call was a month ago, this was for a general home page of a site. If what they told me is not true, or what they told you is not true...Google needs to get their employees on the same page. But it appears from some of our experiences that it has helped rankings, which I find annoying and a bit baffling.
- endorphone 8y agoHow does traffic staying flat after disabling AMP feed a conspiracy theory? That seems like a counterpoint. And to the various other comments, Google's position that they are very open about is that users become accustomed to AMP sites being so fast that they start to favor them, so the click through rates should rise with AMP. If true, that seems entirely fair. AMP is fascinating to me because it's something we can't discuss with any honesty at all. Instead it's over the top rhetoric where people with their outrageously abusive and unwelcoming sites complain that AMP is unnecessary because they could, like, make their site less abusive if they wanted. Any notion that AMP doesn't solve a real problem is just a non-starter derived from fantasy.
- arkadiyt 8y agoHere's a Firebase talk where the dev accidentally admits Google gives preferential ranking to AMP pages and then he immediately gets cut off: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puUqJTJVz5A&feature=youtu.be&t=2055 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=puUqJTJVz5A&feature=youtu.be...
- tannhaeuser 8y agoUh-oh, don't let the EUC know about this. Seriously, what do people expect when they go searching on the world's largest ad network? Google would never send them to the pages with the most ads on it, would they? It's time for a distributed, oblique search index if DDG doesn't serve the needs.
- nine_k 8y agoWhile I like the idea of a distributed search engine, I wonder how would it work with mobile devices. With a desktop, and even laptop when plugged in, you have relatively easy time to run something like a search node of such a network that scans spiders some pages in the background. On a mobile phone, it's not really possible.
- JoshMnem 8y agoI think "don't be evil" was a good slogan, because at least it tried to encourage a culture of doing the right things, even if it's difficult to define "evil".
- petee 8y agoWithout time to hunt down the articles, I was fairly sure Google has been publicizing that they were going to give AMP priority for a long time now, no?
- partiallypro 8y agoAbsolutely, everyone knows that AMP pages are ranking higher in Google and are rewarded. We are getting requests for it at my job for that very reason. We even have contacts at Google that will schedule AMP calls with you and build the pages for you. It's no secret. I unfortunately have to do it for our customers, but privately I view AMP as a Google controlled cancer on the web.
- kyberias 8y agoIt is never explained but I believe AMP here means Accelerated Mobile Pages.
- heyoni 8y agoReddit uses it and it is awful, because it never remembers your choice to not use the app, and will keep asking you.
- aikinai 8y agoReddit's incessant up-selling is completely unrelated to AMP; they do it on all of their pages. And just another anecdote, but I like Reddit's use of AMP. The pages load super fast, the top comments are all accessible, and there's a big button at the bottom to load the full page if you want.
- heyoni 8y agoI just mean that if you dismiss it on their full page, it’s gone (for a while - not forever), but comes back with every click on their amp pages.
- cylinder714 8y agoA reminder: one can go to https://old.reddit.com/r/test/ https://old.reddit.com/r/test/ to access the old site, and https://old.reddit.com/r/test/.compact https://old.reddit.com/r/test/.compact to see a mobile-friendly version.
- crtasm 8y agoAlternative to .compact is https://i.reddit.com/r/test https://i.reddit.com/r/test
- sincerely 8y agois it better than i.reddit.com ?
- 8y ago
- amgin3 8y agoAMP is terrible and it is ruining the web for desktop users. I frequently get linked to AMP pages while on my desktop, and have never come across one that provides a link to the non-AMP version of the page and often the URL to the non-AMP version cannot be derived from the AMP URL. What's wrong with using CSS media queries to have a responsive design? Or if you absolutely need a separate mobile site for some reason, at least give a link back to the full desktop version of the page.. I get that AMP is supposed to help optimize page loading for mobile devices, but for most sites I don't think it is necessary to go to the extremes of AMP in 2018. Most places in the world have decent enough internet speeds and mobile data allowances that pages do not need to be super tiny all the time.
- jwilk 8y agoAn AMP document is required to contain: <link rel="canonical" href="..."> pointing to the regular HTML document.
- amgin3 8y agoExcept that doesn't put a physical link in the document. Why should I have to dig into the source code of the page just to find the link to the normal page?
- jwilk 8y agoSome non-mainstream browsers (ELinks at least) make <link>s visible. This is occasionally useful, but most of the time it just wastes space. :-/ You might want to use this web extension to make automatic AMP → HTML redirects: https://github.com/da2x/amp2html https://github.com/da2x/amp2html Or you could use this bookmarklet: javascript:window.location=document.head.querySelector('link[rel="canonical"]').href
- nelsonic 8y agoThis article is not scientific or conclusive and offers poor advice for people wanting to accelerate their content. I am keenly interested in the effectiveness of AMP (Accelerated Mobile Pages) as a content discovery, delivery and filtering system because I "feel the pain" of slow content each/every time I use a 3G (non-wifi) connection. Yes, AMP was developed/sponsored by Google, but that does not make it "bad"... If anything it means Google knows that slow mobile pages "hurt" the web and they are trying to help "fix" the often painful waiting times for loading content on mobile. AMP is an "open-source initiative" however to be "compliant" a page MUST include the AMP JavaScript file: https://ampbyexample.com/introduction/hello_world https://ampbyexample.com/introduction/hello_world For people who are "privacy conscious" this is an obvious "red flag" because you are basically forced to include/load a "tracker" which means Google knows what content is being read. For the vast majority of Publishers who already use Google Analytics including the AMP JS on the page is not a concern. (you are already sending all your usage data to Google...) The OP concludes with: > "I would highly recommend small time bloggers and publishers like myself to avoid wasting their time on AMP." I question the OP's suggestion to avoid AMP as for most "small time bloggers and publishers", having extra content discovery & distribution for not that much extra effort, is well worth the time. Google Does NOT "slow down" AMP pages, much to the contrary, in our experience of Deploying AMP for several content-heavy websites Google both give better ranking and promote AMP pages in the SERPS. (Yes, this is "favouritism" for AMP content, but it's also better for the Users who searched for that content!) Alex's relatively* "flat" traffic (see graphs in article) and the fact that he has been writing more content: "A lot of it can be attributed to me writing additional articles in the last year" Means that the conclusions of the article are "unscientific" at best. I would counter-argue that if he actively supported AMP his traffic would be higher. (and since his blog is ad-supported, he should re-consider...)
- JoshMnem 8y agoAMP is one of the biggest threats to the future of the WWW at the moment. It's an attempt to appify the web on Google's own domain and dictate how you monetize your site. Hand-optimized HTML pages are faster than AMP pages. Here are some links: https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/05/19/open_source_insider_google_amp_bad_bad_bad/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2017/05/19/open_source_insider... https://80x24.net/post/the-problem-with-amp/ https://80x24.net/post/the-problem-with-amp/ https://daringfireball.net/linked/2018/01/09/amp-will-still-suck https://daringfireball.net/linked/2018/01/09/amp-will-still-... https://danielmiessler.com/blog/google-amp-not-good-thing/ https://danielmiessler.com/blog/google-amp-not-good-thing/ https://www.google.com/search?q=amp+sucks&num=100 https://www.google.com/search?q=amp+sucks&num=100
- martin-adams 8y agoI was at a Google sponsored hackaton focusing around page speed. They were pushing AMP. What I feel was completely missing at the time was data, testing results and case studies showing where it has improved a business ROI. They have some published now but it’s really so high level that you can’t conclude your business will get similar results. Some measure click through rate, others conversion rate or bounce rate. It’s not like for like. I feel like the data was deliberately vague. I work in ecommerce and need to know this improves conversion rate and average order value. That’s what drives revenue and profitability.