3 ms·
Fwiw, the SR-71 was not engineering excellence. It was slapped together to do what needed to be done. It literally leaked jet fuel onto the ground when it wasn'
by 0xbadcafebee 8y ago
Fwiw, the SR-71 was not engineering excellence. It was slapped together to do what needed to be done. It literally leaked jet fuel onto the ground when it wasn't in the air, in order to allow the metal body panels to literally stretch and close gaps in its skin when it was in flight (because physics). The air frame couldn't handle a takeoff with a full fuel tank, so it had to be filled up right after taking off. 90% of the parts manufactured didn't work. It was difficult to maintain and eventually developed a "speedy" one-week turn-around time to get it to fly again after a mission, assuming a base had the specialized tools and support staff to do so.
The SR-71 is an example of how the sheer will to get something done can indeed accomplish great feats, if at great cost and complexity. It's also an example of how innovation is no guarantee of success; since the Blackbird was retired, we still have no airplane as fast as one built in the 1960's.
A great plane is just what it needs to be. It may not be the most minimal it could be, but it will be the most effective. Another example, the A-10 Warthog, is not "minimal", but it is an amazing plane.
I think to get the best result based on the desired outcome, you have to pursue craftsmanship and excellence through continuous education, practice, and improvement, and not worry how it looks so much as how well it works. Complexity is a sin, except when it is necessary.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAgreed. I have read a bit about Skunkworks and they are really good at building planes quickly but the SR 71, the U2 and F117 are all very difficult to.maintain and/or tricky to fly. Not suitable for mass production and use.
- tonyarkles 8y agoIt’s funny you mention the U2. If I’m remembering right, the U2 went from idea to flying in 18 months. That is my benchmark for what 18 months of development by a talented team looks like. And yes, you’re right, it’s not an airplane for mass production, but it filled a niche and did a damned good job of it.
- thatfunkymunki 8y agoThe U2 is still flying today, albeit for a different mission, and the USAF is having a hard time fielding anything that comes close in capability.
- Lio 8y agoTo restate the point that a lot of people are making here, engineering is about trade offs. If it wasn't it would be science. If the requirements for something are highly specialised, you're only going to make only a small number of them and you have a hard deadline to do it by then you shouldn't be wasting time on mass production considerations. That's a trade off and I think they dealt with it correctly. The AK-47 is built to be mass producible and reliable in the field. It's a great success in those terms. The U2 and SR-71 are build to different criteria but are also great successes.
- GauntletWizard 8y agoDisagree. The SR-71 represented a pinacle of engineering, not because it did everything right but because it made appropriate tradeoffs. Leaking fuel on the ground was an appropriate tradeoffs for dealing with the constraints of materials science. It traded efficiency for speed. It traded nearly all else for speed because that's what the mission profile called for, and it did it dang well.
- fermienrico 8y agoI couldn't disagree with you more. I am presuming you have neither read the history of SR-71, nor have a good understanding of the trade of engineering. I am ex-Lockeed employee and even though SR-71 was a distant historical project when I was working there, there were internal discussions about the engineering excellence behind the plane's performance. I worked in stress analysis team where we frequently joked about how we don't need to deal with thermal expansion like in the SR-71. You can choose to call it "Slapped together" and brush over the sheer ingenuity of the technologies that made SR-71 successful, or you could try to read up on the insane amounts of __engineering excellence__ that took to make it achieve its mission as a recon aircraft. Its mission wasn't to be a commercial aircraft, its mission was to go as high, far and fast as possible - Reconnaissance and to return safely by literally outrunning missiles. Therefore, refueling and leaking fuel are appropriate trade-offs. Skunkworks engineers were perfectly aware of the trade offs you mention - that is integral to __any__ engineering discipline from semiconductor to aviation. That __does not__ imply the lack of engineering excellence. Leaking fuel is __the__ most popular fact about the SR-71. But you omit or you are unaware of the ingenuity that went into making the Ramjet engine, material science, hypersonic regime that was completely new and nothing had flown at that speeds before, etc...there is just so much to say, I am having a hard time coherently replying :-) I apologize if my response was a bit harsh - I am just passionate about this topic!
- wwweston 8y agoI'm not sure you and the parent disagree much. "Engineerings excellence" might well describe a product that performs its function reliably with a minimum of intervention or fuss over a long period of time. When something "just works" like this, it's an achievement. "Engineering excellence" might also describe the "sheer will" combined with expertise and carefully chosen tradeoffs that makes something as unlikely and amazing as the SR-71 possible at all. The parent seemed to exclude it from excellence, perhaps on the grounds that it doesn't meet the criteria I describe in the previous paragraph, but it seems to me they're talking about the project with respect for what they were able to accomplish, and if so, this is essentially a semantic point about whether any engineering operation worthy of respect fits in the box of engineering excellence, rather than a question of whether the SR-71 was amazing.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- eltoozero 8y ago> we still have no airplane as fast as one built in the 1960's. Either that or we got very good at keeping secrets, getting stelthy, or the need for this “form factor” was depreciated with the advent of space based tech. Heck there’s probably a Robocop-style human brain in that CIA space plane[0]. [0]: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boeing_X-37
- seanmcdirmid 8y agoThe blackbird failed because something else could do its job better and cheaper (satellites). We still don’t have simply means we still don’t need (at the high cost where it is possible).
- _pmf_ 8y ago> Fwiw, the SR-71 was not engineering excellence. It was slapped together to do what needed to be done. For whole industries, this is the definition of engineering. Anything that is done but is not needed is frivolous extravaganza.