6 ms·
Thanks for being careful to say "free at the point of delivery" - that was always one of the core principles of the UK NHS and everyone knows its not "free" - w
by arethuza 8y ago
Thanks for being careful to say "free at the point of delivery" - that was always one of the core principles of the UK NHS and everyone knows its not "free" - we all pay for it in our taxes - which I'm personally quite happy about.
- thfuran 8y ago>we all pay for it in our taxes - which I'm personally quite happy about The problem is that there seem to be entirely too few people in the US willing to pay for some benefit that other people receive, even if it would help them too. There are just so many people hung up on how "unfair" it is to have to pay for someone else's food stamps or health insurance or whatever.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoMaybe because when we do that we pay a dollar for every cent of benefit delivered. The answer to a corrupt and inefficient system is not to shovel in more money. If we were getting $.050 on the dollar you'd see a lot more people willing to kick in.
- Daishiman 8y agoThe solution is to actually care about accountability, not to send less money.
- dsfyu404ed 8y agoYes but the first is a prerequisite of the second. Reversing the order just makes the problem worse.
- snikeris 8y agoI don't have any problems with paying money for other people's benefit, but I do have a problem when I'm forced to do so. Would it be fair if I took money from you and gave it to someone else who needed it more? Why is it fair when the government does it?
- snikeris 8y agoCurious that I'm downvoted for coming out as one of the "many people hung up on how "unfair" it is". If you disagree with me you could at least answer my questions or try to change my mind.
- arethuza 8y agoI didn't vote you down - but I suspect the downvotes are because that is the often repeated "taxes are bad" argument. All I would offer to counter your argument is: "Taxes are the price we pay for civilization"
- kaitai 8y agoYou're downvoted because so many people say it's "unfair" except for the 911 services they value, the fire department, roads, water, plowing in places with snow... It seems it's fair if it's services you use or fail to appreciate as services at all, and unfair if it doesn't serve you directly. And if you've thought in so little depth about the fairness and benefits of these services, the yield of an online discussion has a low expected value.
- snikeris 8y agoI believe the OP was talking about welfare services (taking from the productive and giving to the unproductive): > food stamps or health insurance or whatever. The services you listed benefit all members of society: > the 911 services they value, the fire department, roads, water, plowing in places with snow
- snikeris 8y agoMore downvotes. /shrug so much for discussing dissenting opinions. My point is that it is unfair to the productive to take by force the product of their labor and give it to those who are unproductive. If you doubt this and you have children, try an experiment. Children have a good sense of fairness (it's inborn). Take (without their consent) something they earned (and value) and donate it to Goodwill. Afterwards, when you tell them what you did, you can explain to them it's for the good of society if you want. See how they react.