6 ms·
The fine article does not make a convincing argument to opposing the copyright extension. They just whine that the record companies will "wring out more money"
by dotancohen 8y ago
The fine article does not make a convincing argument to opposing the copyright extension. They just whine that the record companies will "wring out more money" from pre-1972 works. If that were the whole argument, then I would actually be in favour.
It seems that the EFF position is "we want free music", and does absolutely nothing to address culture and access to culture.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIf you've not managed to recover a sufficient wage for your work in 1972 from 46 years of publicly enforced monopoly then I think the public should have a right to cease offering you that monopoly. If you have, then why do you need this protection? 20 years at most IMO, anything longer damages cultural progress. Copyright is nothing like a natural right, so it's not really the EFF's place to make a convincing argument against it, more the proponents should be convincing the public to extend this favour.
- dotancohen 8y agoI happen to agree with you. But you and the article are preaching to the choir. I'm saying that the article fails to make an argument that would convince someone ignorant of the intricacies.
- anticensor 8y agoMy proposal: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17463018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17463018
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoTo me that's a bit hard, one needs to balance things so as not to disproportionately harm individual inventors/creators. It would be great IMO to link renewal to revenue, but too difficult in practice (and too many potential loopholes). One problem with early, high cost, renewal fees is that companies know they can wait out an individual; you're not going to pay a £M renewal without already having done serious revenue. It can take a long time to get a new technology, or a new book, or whatever, to market -- the IPR system needs to enable individual creators.
- anticensor 8y ago3.5 years are enough to raise an apprentice/intern to a junior level self sufficient proficiency (once you have a junior worker, you are expected to efficiently produce or perform your innovation). There are no renewal fees in first 3.5 years in my proposal.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> It would be great IMO to link renewal to revenue, but too difficult in practice (and too many potential loopholes). Charge proportional to declared value, with the declared value also an offer to accept payment from any combination of parties to buy the work into the public domain at that price. (It's not exactly based on revenue, but based on value to the copyright holder, but that's close enough to the same thing.)
- zyx321 8y ago* The incumbent can instantly kill any new competitors by buying their core technologies into the public domain. * If you're creating something for the first time e.g. a small indie game, you need to know before you release it whether or not it will become the next minecraft.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The incumbent can instantly kill any new competitors by buying their core technologies into the public domain By buying them out at a price set by the competitor involved, sure, and only after the first renewal is due, sure. Of course, a monopolistic incumbent can have the public (instead of tolerating monopoly rents) and prospective competition band toether to buy it's technology out into the public domain for competition to use, too. > If you're creating something for the first time e.g. a small indie game, you need to know before you release it whether or not it will become the next minecraft. Well, no, because we are talking about the method for setting a renewal tax for copyright, not an initial one. So you have to have an idea of how valuable it is to you before the first renewal. (I like the 4-12 year granted period proposed upthread, but using the declared value approach I would probably go with annual renewals with a long limit—maybe even the current maximum—rather than 6mo renewal with a 21 year cap.) I might keep the idea of having an exponentially escalating fee by doing that for a required floor to declared value of a work (maybe even instead of a maximum time limit.) Have a nominal floor at the first renewal (say, $1 in today's money) and increasing by 50% each year, with the annual fee as 5% of the declared value. Sure, you can keep renewing as long as you want, but after 50 years of renewals you're at a $32 million minimum renewal fee.
- sp821543 8y agoAre you suggesting that whould apply to all intellectual property?
- boomboomsubban 8y agoThis is a short page urging you to contact your senator, their full argument is linked to on the page. I doubt it will change your opinion though, as your opposition seems to be based on the idea they're hiding something from you.
- oytis 8y agoWhat can be a convincing argument _for_ copyright extension? Apart from "we want more money".
- Sniffnoy 8y agoThe point of copyright is to incentivize the creation of new works, at the expense of making those works less available. Adding additional copyright restrictions to existing work from decades ago does nothing to incentivize the creation of new works. It's all cost and no benefit.
- AnimalMuppet 8y agoIt all makes perfect sense to me now. Someone has developed a time machine. If copyrights are longer in the past, they will have incentive to go back into the past, create new works there, and use the profits to fund the operation of their time machine. That's actually the only scenario where this copyright extension will cause the creation of new works. Barring that, yes, it's just a money grab by copyright holders (most of whom are not even the artists who created the works).
- pmoriarty 8y ago"The fine article does not make a convincing argument to opposing the copyright extension. They just whine that the record companies will "wring out more money" from pre-1972 works." Their argument is that the government extending copyright should be balanced by some public good (such as releasing more works in to the public domain). Without such a public good being served, this is just a money grab by the copyright holders. These are generally are not the creators or artists, but rather publishers and other corporations. So if your support for this legislation hinges on the illusion that its the creators or artists who will be the primary beneficiaries of it, you might want to reconsider.
- TaylorAlexander 8y agoIP law is an artificial government created monopoly on information that benefits the wealthy at the expense of the masses. Their article is not meant to persuade you of that, but to inform concerned people about how to contact their representatives.