8 ms·
Another Expansion of Copyright
- al_ramich 8y agoDon't know much about No on S. 2823 but you would think that more focus should be on enforcing what's there already than to add more restrictions and rules.
- thesimon 8y agoOh, Walt Disney copyright expiring again?
- Mindwipe 8y agoThis wouldn't touch any Disney content. So no.
- r3bl 8y agoFull text of the CLASSICS Act (since it's not referenced in the campaign page): https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/2393/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/239...
- dotancohen 8y agoThe fine article does not make a convincing argument to opposing the copyright extension. They just whine that the record companies will "wring out more money" from pre-1972 works. If that were the whole argument, then I would actually be in favour. It seems that the EFF position is "we want free music", and does absolutely nothing to address culture and access to culture.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoIf you've not managed to recover a sufficient wage for your work in 1972 from 46 years of publicly enforced monopoly then I think the public should have a right to cease offering you that monopoly. If you have, then why do you need this protection? 20 years at most IMO, anything longer damages cultural progress. Copyright is nothing like a natural right, so it's not really the EFF's place to make a convincing argument against it, more the proponents should be convincing the public to extend this favour.
- dotancohen 8y agoI happen to agree with you. But you and the article are preaching to the choir. I'm saying that the article fails to make an argument that would convince someone ignorant of the intricacies.
- anticensor 8y agoMy proposal: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17463018 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17463018
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoTo me that's a bit hard, one needs to balance things so as not to disproportionately harm individual inventors/creators. It would be great IMO to link renewal to revenue, but too difficult in practice (and too many potential loopholes). One problem with early, high cost, renewal fees is that companies know they can wait out an individual; you're not going to pay a £M renewal without already having done serious revenue. It can take a long time to get a new technology, or a new book, or whatever, to market -- the IPR system needs to enable individual creators.
- DanielBMarkham 8y agoI did a quick search on the Senator who sponsored this bill and was unable to find a recent news article where he explained his support for it. I don't know enough about how the Senate interacts with the news media to determine if that's unusual or not, but it sure seems weird to me. If you're going to propose legislation with such a broad impact, why not speak up about it? This is something that a lot of folks want to talk about.
- flak48 8y agoThey don't speak up exactly because they don't want others to discuss it or debate it.
- ianai 8y agoIt’s Chris Coons, a D from Delaware. I don’t see much in his past to explain bringing it forward - other than he campaigned for Reagan in the 80s and later went D. I’m hoping this is some 3D chess move, but that seems doubtful. He’s taken a great move to unearn people’s distrust.
- falcor84 8y ago>...unearn people’s distrust That's one of the most confusing double-negatives I ever saw. Could you please clarify what you meant here?
- ianai 8y agoTypo
- richmarr 8y agoThere's an overview of some of his opinions on this page, which doesn't have a date on it but I'd guess dates from his 2015 patent bill. He may have changed his thinking some since then. https://www.coons.senate.gov/issues/intellectual-property https://www.coons.senate.gov/issues/intellectual-property
- SaltyBackendGuy 8y ago
- mikelward 8y agoThere are 23 Democratic cosponsors, including California's Senators Feinstein and Harris, and 22 Republican cosponsors. https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/2823/cosponsors https://www.congress.gov/bill/115th-congress/senate-bill/282...
- cmurf 8y agoPeople should be more suspicious of bipartisanship, and increase scrutiny. It annoys me to no end as student of political science that people think bipartisanship is inherently good, and that aggressive ideological battle diminishes the conversation. All good things in politics come from vociferous arguing, and only later comes some sense of compromise. This bill and its bipartisan sponsorship is not the result of debate followed by compromise.
- TooBrokeToBeg 8y ago> All good things in politics come from vociferous arguing I would hope you recognize the opposite. The natural inclination is to increase aggression to try again when battles are fought viciously and lost. The idea of losing as commonplace and safe is not reinforced enough. While I don't trust a single representative (very bad sign), I also don't think the arguments should be full of frothing.
- cmurf 8y agoActually I'm far more suspicious of the opposite. Sure it can happen that there is dispassionate lawmaking that benefits most people and harms almost no one. But I'll continue to argue that this is only due to many prior frothing arguments, which distill out the crap, and leave only the salient arguments, and the skilled arguers. Watch a debate in the British Parliament and then watch a U.S. Senate hearing. It's difficult to take the U.S. Senate or House seriously because there is so little frothing. It's docile, servile, and subservient, and their master is the dollar. In self-rule, ultimately the buck stops with the citizens. Not only voters, but all of the citizens. The state of affairs is due to the combined effect of action and inaction. The blame ultimately rests with them, same as the buck rests with the shareholders of a company.
- dreamling 8y agoIt's not just about 'yay free music', though it would absolutely impact streaming services. This would have a huge impact on remixers, hip hop beat track artists, original music creators, and people who cover old standards. The way it is now, it's difficult enough for creative people to use the music that falls under free use as it is. For example, an animator used Annette Henshaw recordings from the 20s that were no longer under US Copyright, and spent over 9,000 hours creating animation that synced up to the music, only to still end up in a copyright battle over the recordings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sita_Sings_the_Blues#Copyright_problems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sita_Sings_the_Blues#Copyright... Check out the movie, it's pretty fab, https://archive.org/details/Sita_Sings_the_Blues https://archive.org/details/Sita_Sings_the_Blues , but would it exist under the new CLASSICS act? I doubt it. Youtube already removes ad revenue/or the music for videos that use some recordings of music from the 30s and 40s using the Content ID system of ownership (not copyright). and that doesn't even cover how passing this act would affect companies, artists, people who've been using these works as the basis of their work for years. Will they have to get multiple retroactive mechanical licenses? https://www.harryfox.com/license_music/what_is_mechanical_license.html https://www.harryfox.com/license_music/what_is_mechanical_li... Or will the record companies just claim their works/revenue from the works?
- mariushn 8y agoSee also The Right to Read: https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]