4 ms·
Why do the 1.4 billion people living there put up with it in the first place? Why they have just made Jinping a lifetime president? Why are they fine with their
by manigandham 8y ago
Why do the 1.4 billion people living there put up with it in the first place? Why they have just made Jinping a lifetime president? Why are they fine with their own Chinese tech companies doing this already?
It would help to understand the geopolitical causes of this environment instead of the constant faux outrage over Google doing what any business does, which is provide services in accordance to the laws where they operate.
I do not want a world where a few major US tech companies become political powers. This effort should be directed towards the government forces where it matters.
- starbugs 8y agoIf you reach a certain scale you effectively are a political power, whether you want it or not. What you do and under which circumstances you offer your business is a political statement, whether you want it or not. There's no way out. You will be held responsible for what you do and what you don't do.
- pas 8y ago> There's no way out. You will be held responsible for what you do and what you don't do. And that's fair actually. After all, with great power comes great responsibility. (At least in strict utilitarian sense action, non-action, private-public policies and so on are undoubtedly very much fall under the same consideration. That is, is it possible for the big company to do something? To maximize its utility function? If yes, then they should, right? Now it's up to the people to keep that function useful for them.)
- cryoshon 8y agoit is common for people to genuinely not care about the freedoms they are denied. for instance, there is likely a law on the books in the USA which prohibits you from having your cattle graze on various lands. you would be incrementally more free if there was not that law, but do you care? no, the issue is not relevant to your life, nor is it relevant to any life you could imagine yourself realistically having from the starting point of the present moment. if you were a cattle farmer the issue would be more salient -- but there's still no guarantee that you would be railing against the law. now, imagine that the prospect of democracy was what was forbidden, as it is in china. it's abstract, and the benefits are purely hypothetical for the chinese -- but there are hypothetical liabilities that come with democracy too, which might seem just as salient if you don't start from a position of being in favor of democracy.
- pas 8y ago> I do not want a world where a few major US tech companies become political powers. They already are political powers because they are major companies. Tech and US doesn't really matter here. Google is among the biggest companies of the world. (Alphabet is currently 3rd on whatever 2018 list I just found.) When a company this big moves results in a lot of currents shifting, and that means economies can change. And that's very much political. (Especially when it means cross-border business, and imported/exported competition and so on.)
- nailer 8y ago> Why do the 1.4 billion people living there put up with it in the first place? I have a close friend who's a member of the communist party, but we speak about these things frankly. This is my own opinion after talking with them 0. There was an uprising in 1989, and the people who protested were mown down with machineguns 1. The generation afterwards are conditioned to tie the communist party with China's new prosperity. Ie, the wealth you enjoy has only been possible thanks to the leadership of the communist party. 2. The people have no concept of how/why they would rule. It's a job for someone else. Setting the laws is viewed as a thing for experts, and if you wanted to set the law you'd join the communist party.
- manigandham 8y agoI've seen these same sentiments expressed by many in and from China. They enjoy what they have and do not have the same interest in democratic practice as the West, for better or worse. That's why I question what the outrage is all about, when the very people living there have already made their choice.
- nailer 8y agoBecause people living in PRC are people and deserve the right to govern themselves. Hell, the principle that the people are the rightful rulers is part of the PRC's name. The people living there include those on May 35th that died for the freedom to choose who they vote for, as well as those in Hong Kong who are still frequently kidnapped.
- WillPostForFood 8y agoYou seem to be ignoring his first bullet point about being mowed down by machine guns, which is somewhat at odds with they “enjoy what they have” and do not have the same interest in democracy.
- mozey 8y agoWhat is the difference between censorship and management of spam, fake news, sock puppet accounts etc?
- manigandham 8y agoIsn't there a big difference? It's removing fake junk vs hiding truthful information.
- nostalgeek 8y agoWho decides what Junk is? who guards the guardians?
- manigandham 8y agoThere is such a thing as objective truth.
- nostalgeek 8y agoI disagree, facts do exist, the truth has always been a valuable asset for the ones who knows it. This is what most modern journalists or glorified bloggers don't get.
- manigandham 8y agoWhat exactly are you disagreeing with then? Or did you reply to the wrong post?
- betterunix2 8y agoSimple: when you "manage" real news as if it were fake news, you are engaging in censorship.
- neom 8y agoChina is emerging a country with a massive amount of people, while providing relative increase in standard of living and creating opportunity for large swaths of people. China has had a large uneducated population for a long time. They are doing it using a system that has often been shunned or ostracized. Western nations have historically done everything in their power, directly and indirectly to subvert alternative systems taking root. To me China makes sense: Keep the people focused. Create a modern resilient communist social structure that will stand globalization. As much as possible, keep the west and western influences out during incubation.
- che_shirecat 8y ago1) it's part of the social contract. freedom of speech is relatively new phenomena, and the history of the US has shown both the upsides and downsides of that right. standing in a town square and criticizing the king/emperor/lord would have gotten you imprisoned or killed for most of human history, from the times of the Roman emperors to the monarchies of more recent times. modern chinese trade certain rights that many in the West would consider "unalienable" for the efficiency of a tightly ruled authoritarian government that has been seen as instrumental in bringing two decades of unprecedented growth / lifting 500M people out of poverty. 2) the very fact that china has 1.4B makes the existence of an authoritarian government much more easier to understand. without defending the actions of the PRC, from a purely utilitarian standpoint censorship and state control of the media allows for greater social cohesion and the avoidance of ideas and movements that can spread and cause mass hysteria. china is very aware of its own history of such movements and the havoc they've created (the Taiping Rebellion for a great example).
- kevin_b_er 8y agoYes. They know if they do not control what the population may hear, say, or do, they themselves may fall like the bad governments of the past.
- betterunix2 8y ago"Why do the 1.4 billion people living there put up with it in the first place? Why they have just made Jinping a lifetime president? Why are they fine with their own Chinese tech companies doing this already?" China is not a democracy, that's why. This should not be a shocking revelation. It is also easy to forget that there was a civil war in China after the Japanese withdrawal, and the American-backed Republic of China lost (they retreated to Taiwan; this is why such a small island is such a big deal to China). That was when the choice was made, and the Chinese people have not had a choice since then. "It would help to understand the geopolitical causes of this environment" Have you been living under a rock? China has one of the best-documented systems of censorship and propaganda, operated at the largest scale in human history. The Internet has greatly aided both of those efforts -- the great firewall for censorship, the 50-cent army for propaganda. This has been explored ad nauseum, and there has been plenty of news about how the Chinese have refined and developed their various methods.