5 ms·
Relevant: due to Ohio v. American Express, merchants are generally unable to steer customers from using a particular card. For example if a merchant accepts Vis
by kccqzy 8y ago
Relevant: due to Ohio v. American Express, merchants are generally unable to steer customers from using a particular card. For example if a merchant accepts Visa at all, the merchant has to accept all Visa cards, not selectively choose the lower-fee cards; the merchant also cannot tell the customer to use Discover instead to save costs and only use Visa if that's the customer's only card. This anti-steering provision is originally invented by AmEx and now all four major networks have this requirement. And the SCOTUS just ruled that anti-steering provisions do not violate anti-trust regulations. So the only possible recourse is to outright stop accepting a particular payment network.
https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-1454diff_6579.pdf#page2 https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/17pdf/16-1454diff_6579...
- stickfigure 8y agoIt has been asserted elsewhere in this HN discussion that Visa charges merchants higher amounts for transactions with higher-end rewards cards. Assuming this is true, and these anti-steering provisions prevent merchants from discriminating, what prevents Visa from issuing cards with 200% fees? What's holding the cash back level at a mere 1-2%?
- spiznnx 8y agoI'm speculating that if that happened, we'd see more stories like this one.
- so33 8y agoCompetition with MasterCard, Discover, and Amex should hold them back from doing this, because at such punitive rates merchants would definitely stop accepting them. I believe Amex is only able to get away with its highest-in-the-industry rates because of the association of Amex cards with business expense accounts and high income earners. This is changing now (https://www.ft.com/content/715d785e-23fc-11e8-ae48-60d3531b7d11 https://www.ft.com/content/715d785e-23fc-11e8-ae48-60d3531b7...) especially after years of competition from banks like Chase, who have been working on creating what is essentially a structural clone of American Express’ network (https://www.reuters.com/article/us-jpmorganchase-creditcards-insight/jpmorgan-uses-its-might-to-cut-costs-in-credit-card-market-idUSKCN0R80B620150908 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-jpmorganchase-creditcards...).
- jackweirdy 8y agoSome of the Amex fee changes will likely have been as a result of a nudge from the EU ruling that includes their double-branded cards (e.g. British Airways AmEx) in the 0.3% fee cap in Europe which previously only affected visa and MasterCard.
- zmk_ 8y agoIn Europe at least, this would be regulation. There are max amounts on fees.
- endorphone 8y agoEveryone would immediately stop taking all Visas. They charge what they can get away with, and generally they can, or rather could, get away with the higher rates. A couple of percentage points was worth it if it made the sale, especially if there was a high likelihood that your customer only had that one method of payment. Now almost everyone has multiple cards, and many retailers are pushed to much lower margins, so we see the results that we see.
- stevesimmons 8y agoVisa actually does that from time to time, though not to the degree you suggest :). Here is one example from Australia, where 15 years ago I worked on credit card pricing and product design... When Platinum cards were introduced to Australia, the banks agreed to a high interchange rate for Platinum and an offsetting reduction in interchange on other cards. I forget the exact interchange rates; they were on the order of 150bp (1.5%) and 50bp, giving a weighted average around the then regulatory cap of 65bp. My bank was ready for this, so we moved most of our high-spending customers to Platinum ("in recognition of their status") and reaped a windfall from the higher interchange. Part of that was used to fund more loyalty rewards on Platinum. But most was pure profit... Over time, regulators got wise to this, and reduced the overall interchange rates to the minimum (possibly 35bp in Australia now). Essentially in Australia it is enough to covers the scheme running costs and disputes/fraud. Loyalty has to be funded in other ways (annual fees, cross-subsidies from other customer revenue, points caps, reduce value of points, making it harder for customers to redeem points, etc). This means customers in shops are no longer paying the cost of loyalty schemes even if they pay with cash. (Amex operates under slightly different rules from Visa and MasterCard because the legal relationship between the merchant, scheme, issuing and acquiring banks and customer is not the same. That is why Amex can often offer better rewards that Visa/MC in regulated markets like Australia, UK and Europe)
- amsilprotag 8y agoAmEx was one of Warren Buffet's earlier investments, and a proof-of-concept of investing in companies with defensible moats. This ruling comes 55 years after his initial investment, and the moat feels as deep as ever. Later businesses have perfected the art of winning the customer relationship and solidifying their lead with hardball terms for vendors (Walmart), merchants (Amazon), advertisers (Facebook/Google), developers (Apple/Google) and contractors (Uber).
- randomsearch 8y agoVery interesting quote from Musk: “saying you like moats is another way of saying you like oligopolies”. I like Musk’s focus on innovation, and I also thought this was interesting because it came from one of the PayPal+ group.
- bumholio 8y agoInvestors love them, consumers pay for them and regulators should prevent their abuse. Sounds like oligopolies alright.
- goc_ 8y agoIt's not a question of liking moats or not. Nobody has found any other routes to scale quickly. The moat is fundamental to producing the kind of scaling we see today.
- pmontra 8y agoBut how many moats there could be in world (or in any given market) ? Furthermore which should ask on which side of the moat are we and if it's good for us to be there. There was a post yesterday which fundamentally is about this issue https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17642551 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17642551
- juae 8y agoIt's a competitive world full of highly ambitious people. As long as the only tool they have to create/expand/defend their empires is moat building that is all they will robotically do irrespective of the cost. The pressure on them to do so is massive. And it's the easiest thing for them to do. So they do it. Ofcourse things constantly collapse. Ask Genghis Khan, the East India Company etc etc And after collapse everyone stands around like Alan Greenspan saying wtf happened?
- cm2187 8y agoBut are they allowed to charge a surcharge to a customer for using a particular card?
- bdowling 8y agoThe charge is to the merchant, not to the customer. In general, the price marked on the good factors in the credit card fees, because almost everyone uses credit cards. So, if a buyer uses cash or a debit card, he should always negotiate for a 1-2% discount. Edit: To clarify, some U.S. merchants do charge a "credit card fee" or enforce a minimum charge amount to all customers using credit cards for their purchases. I have never seen one charge a surcharge only to Visa users or only to Amex users.
- mcny 8y agoVisa should (and I think already does) prohibit charging extra for using visa versus other payment methods. Edit: seems like they make a distinction between charging extra versus giving a cash discount and the latter is more acceptable?
- cm2187 8y agoI have seen additional charges to the client on certain websites for using credit cards or amex. But I am in Europe, not in the US.
- daemin 8y agoIn Australia the government put in legislation to cap the maximum credit card surcharge that a merchant could charge the customer to the actual fee that they pay on the card. When I was there I remember things like $10 or $20 minimum and also anywhere up to 5-10% surcharge for paying with a card.
- maaark 8y agoThe UK did too. The cap is 0.
- 8y ago
- unethical_ban 8y agoWhen I heard about this ruling, I was shocked. Information and transparency in agreements should not be against the law.
- kevin_b_er 8y agoThe conservative-controlled court has generally ruled that a contract is a contract is a contract. A contract may void all rights and it may override the laws of the sovereign States. Contracts are the ultimate tool to subrogate rights into someone elses hands. Once you understand that you can accidentally sign away human rights, a corporation signing away its "right" to speech under corporate personhood also makes complete sense.