4 ms·
Having a highly trained, standing army is part of what keeps us out of war. Without it, we would soon be invaded and taken over. Historically, every time Americ
by DoreenMichele 8y ago
Having a highly trained, standing army is part of what keeps us out of war. Without it, we would soon be invaded and taken over. Historically, every time America shrinks its military, it winds up dragged into a war and having to ramp back up rapidly.
There is no similar need for driverless cars. I'm American. I've lived without a car for over a decade.
I don't see why we can't do more testing before putting lives at stake. I don't see why driverless cars killing people as part of their development is a thing we need to accept.
Your assertion in no way clears up for me why we should shrug at the idea of people dying for this thing.
- Fricken 8y agoHaving highly trained autonomous vehicles will keep us out of car crashes, currently we just sort of lie down and take it. As though we had 10 9/11 scale tragedies every year and just kind of threw our arms up and said "whatever, nuthin' we can do" And for the record I don't drive either, haven't since I was a young man.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI don't personally see that as justification for accepting training deaths here. I'm not talking about stopping the development of driverless vehicles. I'm just telling you that your argument seems like a non sequitur to me. There are training deaths in the military precisely because humans are being trained to do dangerous things. Why can't driverless vehicles be trained without killing people? That's the thing you aren't actually answering.
- Fricken 8y agoI'm not defending Tesla or Uber, they're the ones that have killed people, and I think they both were (and in Tesla's case still are) behaving irresponsibly. Cruise and Waymo have both done tons of closed course testing, that's where they validate their respective systems against mission critical stuff like knowing when to slam on the brakes. But eventually they've got to go out into the real world and learn to deal with real traffic on real roads. I wish I could tell you the risk was zero, but it isn't and never will be.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Cruise and Waymo have both done tons of closed course testing, that's where they validate their respective systems against mission critical stuff. But eventually they've got to go out into the real world and learn to deal with real traffic on real roads. Waymo has been doing that longer than anyone, though.
- Fricken 8y agoTechnically Waymo has been acting like cowboys longer than anyone. They smartened up and got serious about safety around 2015, but before that they were winging it. It was just a goofy science experiment back then. The Google self-drivng car project was under the leadership of Sebastien Thrun and Anthony Levandowski, and as hardcore engineering types their thinking was 'We'll save more people than we kill', and it was as simple as that.
- tigershark 8y agoAnd though there is no fatality for waymo, while we already one for Uber just at the beginning of their program.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoWell, to my ear that sounds like "People will still die in car wrecks and I don't even have data substantiating my assumption that fewer people will die than is true currently, but I somehow feel that if robotic vehicles are killing people, that's automatically better than if a human is behind the wheel."
- Fricken 8y agoWe wouldn't be doing our due diligence if we didn't try. Otherwise it's pretty much a guarantee that 30-40,000 people will die on America's roads next year and every year after that.
- 8y ago
- vasilipupkin 8y agoBecause it’s impossible to guarantee that an algorithm will be 100% effective in preventing deaths. So, you either are for driverless vehicles and are willing to accept some risk, or you are against driverless vehicles driving on roads. It has to be one or the other.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoYou can fail to be against something without being for it. I find it strange that people seem to have a problem with my question but no one but me seems to have a problem with someone simultaneously claiming that we need to treat training deaths as shrug-worthy while assuming that driverless vehicles will clearly eliminate huge numbers of deaths annually once they are out there. This is the first suggestion I have heard that human drivers actively need to be eliminated instead of driverless vehicles being yet one more option in an increasingly diverse transportation ecosystem. Although I no longer have a driver's license, the implication that someone might desire to outlaw human drivers someday for supposed safety reasons while simultaneously justifying accepting death by driverless vehicle seems somewhat disturbing.
- vasilipupkin 8y ago“You can fail to be against something without being for it.” Not sure what that means, but testing autonomous vehicles will result in deaths. So, you either decide zero deaths are acceptable and don’t test, or allow some deaths and test. There is no third option in this case
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFYI: All caps on the internet is generally considered to be yelling and is a violation of HN guidelines.
- vasilipupkin 8y agoI changed it to comply with guidelines. Feel free to respond to substance.
- thereisnospork 8y agoIts simple: opportunity cost. If a testing plan was going to accelerate the adoption of autonomous cars which are twice as safe as human drivers by one month it would save the lives of approximately 40,000/2 / 12 = 1,666.6 people. To stop the aforementioned testing plan because it is expected to kill 1, 10, or even 100 people will increase the expected number of premature deaths. There is of course an optimum between training deaths vs. future lives saved, accounting for uncertainty, and etc. but the number of expected training deaths will never be zero and considering the large number of future deaths currently expected, the optimum is likely to be much higher than zero.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoGood answer. Have an upvote. But, your answer implicitly assumes the total elimination of human drivers and their replacement by autonomous vehicles. This strikes me as unlikely.
- DennisAleynikov 8y agoit's not unreasonable given the same opportunity cost argument that most people will switch to and prefer autonomous vehicles if they are shown to be inherently safer more predictable drivers. This is a huge risk to long haul truck drivers since those jobs are already long and grueling as it is. Their livelihood is threatened by the fact that robot truck drivers don't sleep. It's not a matter of if it will be replaced but when, since logistics are a huge business and nothing to mess around with.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoI have no doubt that truck drivers jobs are under threat. But you are justifying this assumption with yet more assumptions, not hard data. For example: If they are proven to be inherently safer. I'm literally just rather tired at the moment and also finding this argument wearying. But actual reality has a really long track record of failing to conform to human predictions of that sort. When antibiotics were discovered, it was predicted to be the end of human disease. Fast forward to today and the articles we routinely read are about the crisis of antibiotic shortages, antibiotic resistant infections and whatever will do now? When the first air planes came out, they had square windows. So did the first jets -- until they began falling from the sky as if some Cthulhoid horror had ripped then to pieces in the sky. Then they changed the windows to rounded designs. Human ability to accurately predict the future is notoriously lousy.
- darpa_escapee 8y ago> Having highly trained autonomous vehicles will keep us out of car crashes I hate to be the guy who says, "Citation please," but yours is an assumption without evidence. For all we know, autonomous driving safety might plateau at a rate that's lower than that of human drivers.
- kevin_thibedeau 8y ago> Having a highly trained, standing army... ... is why we go to war every 10 to 15 years to justify the MIC spend instead of returning to a pre-WW2 stance.
- paulcole 8y ago> we should shrug at the idea of people dying for this thing. We already shrug at the idea of people dying in cars everyday.
- fucking_tragedy 8y agoNot really. MADD was effective at getting drunk driving legislation passed in the states, and likes to claim responsibility for decreasing automotive deaths by one half. There are people out there who aren't shrugging their shoulders and are actively doing something about people dying in cars.
- paulcole 8y agoYes really! 30,000+ people die in cars every year in the United States. That's roughly the same number killed by guns but how many news stories do you see about car deaths?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 8y agoSomeone left this comment and apparently deleted it while I was looking for and failing to find citations for actual numbers of lives saved by ambulance, for example. I have redacted their handle, but I want to leave my reply here: Because people's lives are at stake right now. Every year 10s of thousands of people die due to cars. Delaying innovation that would prevent deaths dooms those 10s of thousands of people to death in the future. You say that as if, clearly, cars never save lives. It's all downside. Ambulances save lives. Fire trucks save lives. Those are the easy, obvious answers. But I would argue that lives are also saved and enhanced by access to jobs, access to better quality food because of our complicated infrastructure, access to better medical care, etc. You aren't counting when things go right. You are only counting when they go wrong.
- tigershark 8y agoThere are fatal accidents caused by ambulances and fire trucks, do you want to outlaw them because you cannot guarantee that there won’t be a fatal accident during their use?
- stuckinarut 8y ago> Having a highly trained, standing army is part of what keeps us out of war The US is in a state of constant war. Having a large standing army enables US imperialism, it's not for protection.
- credit_guy 8y ago> why we should shrug at the idea of people dying for this thing I was going to say "nobody's shrugging", but then I remembered the killing of Elaine Herzberg by the Uber self-driving car. Maybe the wheels of justice are turning slowly, but right now it looks awfully similar to the Government just shrugging at that incident.