3 ms·
This seems incredibly stupid. If you use excess electricity to pump water backward at the dam, you may as well just shut off the flow through the dam instead. T
by phkahler 8y ago
This seems incredibly stupid. If you use excess electricity to pump water backward at the dam, you may as well just shut off the flow through the dam instead. That would be more efficient and cost nothing to implement.
If we're talking about so much excess capacity that the dam would be closed AND water pumped back up, that would be interesting. But wouldn't the river go dry? It's not like there's a lake below the dam for that.
This whole thing seems more political than practical. I'm guessing the private producers will somehow get a financial benefit from this at the expense of the taxpayer.
- tonyedgecombe 8y agoI'm not sure why you are being downvoted, you are correct. If the normal state of the dam is to generate electricity then the obvious response to excess supply is to stop the flow. No need to pump anything back uphill unless the excess exceeds the normal capacity of the dam.
- brokensegue 8y agonope. maybe read the article and you'll get it
- mmt 8y ago> If the normal state of the dam is to generate electricity It isn't, at least not in the sense that you likely mean. That seems to be a common misconception about the Hoover Dam. Its ability to generate electricity is completely secondary to its primary purpose: controlling the flow of water (e.g. flood control, irrigation). Unless/until there is a lower reservoir (as proposed by the project in the article) that takes over that primary function, changing the flow through the dam for any electricity-related reasons is simply not an option.
- maxerickson 8y agoIt depends an awful lot on the lag between demand and excess supply. It might use the noon sun to pump water that was used to meet morning demand.
- phkahler 8y ago>>It depends an awful lot on the lag between demand and excess supply. It might use the noon sun to pump water that was used to meet morning demand. You could just shut off the dam at noon instead. Then run it full tilt in the morning.
- maxerickson 8y agoI don't think a facile analysis of the economics is interesting. For instance, if you shut the dam off, then it is generating $0 revenue for that period. Is that a better use of capital than adding seemingly redundant pumps to recapture some of the (time shifted) flow?
- UncleEntity 8y agoThey can't just "shut off the dam at noon" because of all the downstream users, a dry river bed isn't much of a tourist attraction.
- Dylan16807 8y agoA pump causes the exact same problem, except a few miles downstream.
- dctoedt 8y agoYou might have two simultaneous problems: The water level of the lake behind the dam might be lower than desired, and the rate of water flow into that lake from the upstream river might also be lower than desired. In that case, it'd be advantageous to use the excess power to recapture some of the "downstream" water and pump it back into the lake, thereby restoring the lake level more quickly than would be possible with just the (inadequate) incoming upstream river water.
- walshemj 8y agoThe advantage with pumped storage is its fast response you can turn it on in so much faster than other types. The idea here is you would use power from several days ago
- the_duke 8y agoPumped-storage hydro[1] is an established concept and is in active use all over the world (Europe, US, Japan, ...). Austria for example has a lot of hydro (over 70% of total production!) including multiple pumped-storage installations. There's huge excess capacity at night here thanks to all the hydro, so you might as well use it for something useful. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pumped-storage_hydroelectricit...
- downandout 8y agoThe proposal isn’t to use the dam’s excess power to pump the water back uphill. They want to use excess power from other solar and wind plants to effectively store any excess energy that they produce. Since these alternative sources cannot consistently produce energy 24 hours per day, and the times that they are able to produce it do not necessarily match up with consumer demand, they need to store it somehow. This is being proposed as a more efficient and cost effective form of storage than batteries (though I am curious how much energy will be lost due to evaporation after the water has been pumped in Hoover dam’s hot climate and other inefficiencies).
- sschueller 8y agoIt is quite common in Europe and in fact Switzerland has a few just for that purpose (Pumpspeicherkraftwerk). Interactive Map [1] [1] http://www.uvek-gis.admin.ch/BFE/storymaps/WK_WASTA/index.php?lang=en http://www.uvek-gis.admin.ch/BFE/storymaps/WK_WASTA/index.ph...
- Rexxar 8y agoDon't call things you don't understand stupid. Ask for explanation, then you can (sometimes) do a judgement.