3 ms·
Slack "won" because, at least at the time it rose, it was a better chat app for work that had a decent experience across platforms. A user could use it on macO
by ravenstine 8y ago
Slack "won" because, at least at the time it rose, it was a better chat app for work that had a decent experience across platforms. A user could use it on macOS, on Windows, in the browser, on Android, on iOS, and expect a very uniform experience. Very few gotchas, besides some quirks caused by the difference between what browser APIs can provide and what's expected by OS users.
I remember using HipChat and wasn't terribly impressed, but I was used to it. I then switched jobs and was asked to start using Slack. Naturally, in my head I thought "oh great, I gotta learn a whole new thing." That thought was gone by the end of my first day since virtually everything about it was better than workplace chats I've used in the past. (I don't know how HipChat is now but I'm sure it's improved since 2013).
Seriously, most chat apps at the time were pretty dogcrap. A lot of people judge it, especially today, by functionality over form. Personally, I put a somewhat stronger emphasis on form so long as the core functionality is solid. I don't really get the people who claim it's glorified IRC; yeah, guess what, most people didn't want to use IRC because they had to understand what IRC was, what IRC client to use, oops my client doesn't work on macOS, oh hey look someone from the Czech Republic is DDOSing the channel, etc. It's funny how nerds keep thinking "if only everyone was a nerd" and get disappointed when the average person doesn't want to use X nerd-thing. Like "the year of the Linux desktop", there was never going to be a "year of the IRC client". People want to open up an app and to send messages to people, and I agree with them.
These days, there's more serious competition in the arena, and that's because Slack redefined the standard.
- sanderjd 8y agoThanks for this refreshing comment. I had off and on responsible for figuring out how to do chat at my company for awhile just pre-Slack. Trying to get IRC to work the way we needed (which includes history and search) was a real pain, and the various proto-Slacks were an improvement but also noticeably less well executed than Slack when it hit the scene.
- bradknowles 8y agoSpeaking only for myself, I'm on multiple Slack channels, some related to certain SaaS companies whose products we use, and some that are personal. Internally, we use HipChat for our group within the company. I much prefer HipChat over Slack. To me, Slack is bloated, slow, and disorganized. I hate, loathe, and despise the way it tries to do what it thinks of as "threading". HipChat is simpler and faster to use. It's easy to connect plugins and administer. It's easy to add your own custom emoji, if you really need them. And it's easy to configure it to auto-hide animated GIFs, if you don't want to see them by default. There is nothing that Slack offers that I want. And plenty that it forces me to live with that I do not want.
- winrid 8y agoFunctionality wise Hipchat has not really changed since 2014 in any way that I can think of (been using it the whole time). Much more stable though.
- u801e 8y agoHow is it better compared to older chat applications like AIM, MSN messenger, Yahoo messenger, or gchat?