12 ms·
If I am a traditional 'tech' company - I can afford to lose money when I am investing it in my platform or technology. It's like borrowing money to invest in yo
by legitster 8y ago
If I am a traditional 'tech' company - I can afford to lose money when I am investing it in my platform or technology. It's like borrowing money to invest in your assets.
For MoviePass, they are losing money and passing it off to theaters - it's like borrowing money to buy more ingredients for a failing restaurant. You can't charge less than the marginal cost, it doesn't make sense!
I am trying to wrap my head around what MoviePass is trying to do - especially given the number of friends I have who say they would easily be willing to pay 2x or 3x for the service. The data they are gathering cannot be more valuable than the cost of a movie ticket.
I have to imagine they were making a play at building up a huge enough audience to strongarm theaters into lowering their rates. Well the joke is on them - everyone knows that they have no bargaining power. Plus, signing up was so hard, their audience is skewed towards power users and people persistent in their cheapness.
An emergency loan with no change to the service whatsoever? They are really having a deer in the headlights moment.
- acchow 8y ago> You can't charge less than the marginal cost, it doesn't make sense! It worked for Uber tho. And now they've raised prices in markets where they are established.
- slivym 8y agoUber has a network effect, so it's naturally monopolistic. Cinema passes have a network effect too (you only want the pass if the cinemas near you have it), but firstly it's much much weaker because you literally only need your local cinema, and secondly that's a network effect that helps the actual cinema, not a random middle man like moviepass.
- organsnyder 8y agoUber has a network effect, but it's not exclusive—hence the larger number of drivers driving for both Uber and Lyft. I don't see Uber's position as being very entrenched at this point.
- citrablue 8y agoUber also plans to cut costs significantly in the future w/ autonomous cars. May be a pipe dream, but if they believe in the successful widespread deployment of the technology, that means they just have to stay afloat until then. MoviePass could start to make their own movies, but that would require a substantial investment and isn't really comparable
- jacobush 8y agoWow that would be something... what would happen if Universal Pictures stepped in with a subscription model (or whatever Moviepass does) for their movies?
- reaperducer 8y agoWhy build when you can buy? Universal just has to buy MoviePass. Assuming it has the cash. From what I've read over the last few years, the big Hollywood studios are not cash-rich.
- mulletbum 8y agoI forgot where I read it, but I though Moviepass's ability to geolocate and push money onto a credit card was considered a good idea and could sold.
- stuckinarut 8y agoHardly seems like a large barrier. I would think the biggest issue would be finding the card company to partner up with, and then it doesn't sound like a very high barrier. For theatres it's even easier to offer an unlimited option since they can just have the accounts internally. Studios can partner with theatres, though that seems overly complicated (I went to Mission Impossible last night, so I need a paramount account?)
- SilasX 8y agoUber will not invent SDCs much sooner than the other companies, at which point they will have to cut their own prices too to compete with the other SDC companies. So there would be a very small window for monopoly profits.
- astrodust 8y agoIf by "worked" you mean "burned through ten billion in cash" then sure, it worked.
- pandasun 8y agoTrue, I think that maybe Uber found the fine line (could be pure luck) between creating enough buzz right before running out of cash (several times) and simply going bankrupt.
- astrodust 8y agoThat Q1 profit was interesting, but it's nowhere near a trend. They may need another ten or twenty billion, or maybe infinite billions because their business model is critically flawed.
- stuckinarut 8y agoExcept Uber was building a market. If I start a company that just subsidizes Uber rides I'm never going to make money. Unless Moviepass provides some actual value to theatres, they won't make money. Theatres aren't going to give them discount rates to Star Wars or Avengers 4 because those movies sell out anyway.
- pbreit 8y agoUber has a 30% take rate and zero marginal cost. Wrong example.
- dingo_bat 8y agoUber offers a real, irreplaceable service though. I can walk out of my apartment and be on the way to my office in an Uber pool in 5 minutes. The cost is basically 2x of the bus ticket I'd need to buy. As far as I know this service was being offered by absolutely nobody before Uber.
- surge 8y agoMaybe hoping to make their money back when people let their subscriptions idle during the off season for movies...but this is most attractive avid movie goers so I don't see this working. People who don't go to movies all the time likely won't get it.
- Jtsummers 8y agoThe problem with this idea is that (at $9.95) someone in my area needs to see one movie in the evening and they're ahead. Two movies, and MoviePass needs them to not see a movie for a full month to almost catchup, and they'd still be behind by $1.50. During the big movie seasons, it's easy to see 2-5 movies in a month. I've only seen 2 movies (since April) that I wouldn't have seen without MoviePass. I've seen 15 movies. MoviePass has paid $137.00 for me, and I've paid them $89.95 (I bought the annual pass, joke's on me now, but I did get enough in to be better than break even). If I'd done the monthly I'd have spent $38.80 over that same time, they'd be out $100. They'd need me to idle for 10 months to catch up.
- ironjunkie 8y agoyou didn't really break even as you said it yourself you would only have paid for two movies out of the 15. The question is, do you really value the other 13 movies at (70$/13) a piece ? In my case probably not.
- Jtsummers 8y agoPerhaps I worded that poorly. I saw 13 movies I would've seen regardless, and 2 I wouldn't have seen. So I did break even (a bit better than, actually). I, personally, enjoy going ot the theater, I always have. And in past years have seen at least this many movies (though with an emphasis on catching matinees and discounted options, like two-dollar Tuesday or whatever). Two movies (average) per month is not uncommon going back about 6 years for me, with some years being lower than others depending on the releases.
- stuckinarut 8y agoI've seen 1, maybe 2, movies with moviepass that I otherwise wouldn't have gone to the theatre for.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoThey already do strongarm some smaller theaters into getting a cut of concessions.
- clintonb 8y agoWhat leverage do they have to strongarm? If a theater is popular, that means MoviePass customers like the theater. MoviePass needs the theater more than the theater needs MoviePass. If MoviePass chooses not to pay for tickets at the theater, that’s a MoviePass problem.
- Jtsummers 8y agoIt becomes the theater's problem if the customers have alternatives. In my area, they don't. There are 2 theater companies and 3 theaters. But say you're in Atlanta, there are tons of theaters, and often not too far from each other. So the decision to go to theater X or theater Y could easily be determined by which one accepts MoviePass. Customer's line of thought: I've already paid for this service. It'd be stupid to see a movie without using it, because I'd be double paying (not entirely accurate, but this is the thinking). I can go 2 more miles and see the same movie at a similar time and not have to pay for the ticket. Sold! The problem for MoviePass is the customers will do that, and MoviePass can't actually afford the tickets (since most of their spending, now, seems to be from borrowed money).
- ironjunkie 8y agoIf MoviePass represent let's say 50% of your customer and suddenly they remove your theater from the list, I will bet you will lose about 90% of those MoviePass customers, so you will lose about 45% of your customers. I have a MoviePass, and when they removed a big AMC theater around my place a couple months ago, I simply drove two more miles to the Century theater. I have zero loyalty to a specific theater//chain, I care a little bit about better seats though. So yeah, their goal was to get that bargaining power by getting as many users as possible.
- gamblor956 8y ago
- jld 8y agoBecoming movie payola was the way I thought they would go. They could be an avenue for studio to discount tickets to specific films without some of the problems of traditional couponing. This could either just drive buzz, or could allow studios to goose opening weekend sales by paying MoviePass to push films, as well as reimbursing MoviePass the ticket cost. Probably not enough to become profitable though.
- stuckinarut 8y agoDidn't moviepass just show they aren't capable of pushing a movie with their big "Gotti" campaign?
- MusaTheRedGuard 8y agoIt's crazy. The data is basically worthless. I honestly don't know if they will survive for more than a few months. I was just thinking, what could they possibly do to survive as long as possible? They could introduce incentives to reduce the number of movies people saw a week? Maybe some kind of credit system, where customers built up points towards a premium membership. They could also start taking the most expensive users of their platform. For whatever reason they could. Ban users sharing accounts. Introduce friction somehow. Get them to reenter their payment info. The customer data is mostly worthless but it's scary. They could weaponize it. Announce to high use customers that they're going to sell non premium customer data. Might scare off some privacy minded customers. Strong arm theaters somehow? Send customers to certain theaters and away from others by dangling credits toward premium or some other incentive structure
- Robin_Message 8y agoWeaponizing customer data like that would literally be illegal in the EU, so doesn't seem like the best plan... Other ideas might work!
- martin_bech 8y agoMoviepass is not available in the EU.
- Robin_Message 8y agoOh okay, that's alright then /s
- jsgo 8y agotrue, but I think their point is that if the policy catches on there as popular, what is to prevent the US (or others) from implementing similar laws? Relying on a business model that could reasonably be illegal after the stroke of a pen by a legislator is not a good thing. And legislators are at least putting on the appearance of being concerned about user data after the Facebook/Cambridge Analytica thing would cause one to exercise even more caution.
- fullshark 8y agoThey are trying to buy customers at a loss, then get so big that they can shake down theaters + their own customers for more money. It didn't work.
- Shivetya 8y agoI was under the impression they were trying to have a big enough block of customers to take to the studios and try to get a percentage. As if their service would have sufficient numbers to sway debuts and over all movie numbers.
- chiefalchemist 8y ago"The data they are gathering cannot be more valuable than the cost of a movie ticket." When you install the app what does seek to access? Given that most movie theaters are surrounded by food & drink establishments then it would seem they're not too far from becoming a "niche" Groupon. That's got to add some revenue. Moi? The data is a privacy issue. But I'm a fringe minority. Most ppl see deal and convenience and ignore the risks.
- wildpeaks 8y agoThe Nerdwriter has a good video (short, just 6 minutes) about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w876zZZIb10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w876zZZIb10 The gist of it is, they're hoping to grow so big that movie theaters will have no choice but to negotiate with them, to share part of the revenues they bring theaters from people who normally don't come watch movies on a whim anymore.
- nodesocket 8y agoBut why not increase the membership fee marginally in the meantime to stay afloat? I suspect the vast majority of members would stay. Also as another user posted below, set a cap on the number of movies you can view per month and offer a premium unlimited membership upsell.
- SilverCurve 8y agoThey are starting to do it. One of their new features is charging a few dollars on "hot" show time.
- stuckinarut 8y agoI'd rather just get a ticket to a different movie twice, via moviepass, and just pay to see the "hot" movie normally. I hate this surge pricing bullshit. It's just scalping and I'd rather lose moviepass entirely than every contribute to that shit.
- lainga 8y agoIsn't that kind of rent-seeking?
- mi100hael 8y agoNot if they are providing a better customer experience along the way as well as drawing new customers to the market. "Rent-seeking" implies a desire to simply extract cash without providing any value to anyone.
- dlwdlw 8y agoNot saying it’s a good strategy but amazon seems to have done/is doing something similar. Each purchase is a loss when shipping is taken into account. But if the bleeding is slow enough the created ingress can be enough to shift the landscape so that there are new opportunities. Cultural lockin followed by price increases is a typical one. Like the hub and spoke model of pizza shops. Basically bet that spoke opportunities will appear if the hub is engaging enough.
- scarface74 8y agoAmazon has since stop losing money on shipping. Especially considering all of the money they make on Prime memberships.
- stuckinarut 8y agoAmazon's losses to shipping can actually be lowered by improving logistics, alternative delivery systems, and negotiating better contracts because of the massive volume. Plus I won't believe the "every purchase is a loss" narrative unless I see evidence. Especially recently.
- pbreit 8y agoAmazon has pretty much always been margin positive even after shipping so not a good comparison.
- sf_rob 8y ago>You can't charge less than the marginal cost, it doesn't make sense! The old joke is "Sure we have marginal losses, but we'll make up for it with volume!"
- klenwell 8y agoHow do you make money doing this? The answer is simple: volume. https://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/first-citiwide-bank-change-ii/n9703 https://www.nbc.com/saturday-night-live/video/first-citiwide...
- rtkwe 8y agoI mean the plan seems to be that except the marginal losses are supposed to go down as they reach higher volumes. Attract the heavy movie goers first and lose money on them till you can attract enough light movie goers that will buy this and forget about so you can afford the people seeing more than 2 movies a month. There's other ways to drop that marginal cost like getting deals from theaters on tickets for bringing people in (eg give us a better deal or we'll block our users from your theaters) and sell data. I don't think this is going to work out but I can see how this would look workable in a model and pitch.
- ams6110 8y agoThat might have worked before Netflix and Amazon Prime and other online movie services. The light movie goers are all online now. Only the heavy duty die-hards are still going to theaters to see first-run films. I haven't gone to a theater movie in over three years.
- reaperducer 8y agoAn emergency loan with no change to the service whatsoever? They are really having a deer in the headlights moment. Reminds me of a startup I worked with once. The goal wasn't to make a viable product. It was to make a big splash and get bought. 10 Start a product/service 20 Make a big hype and get lots of publicity 30 Get bought by some larger company that sees you as a threat/opportunity 40 Founders get big cash payout, everyone else gets the shaft 50 GOTO 10
- ironjunkie 8y agoThis unfortunately is probably the untold goal of 80% of startups around the Bay area that have unsustainable business models. What I find ethically borderline is that no founders will admit this, they will all pretend their goal is to make it a super successful sustainable company. As you said, the issue is that founders will usually get a moderate payout (a couple Million$), while even early employees will get almost nothing.
- balls187 8y agoThe problem isn't necessarily one of ethics, it's that employees aren't able to appropriately assess a companies business strategy. 1. What is your monetization strategy? 2. What is your plan for profitability?
- inetknght 8y agoI have to 100% disagree about your assessment of ethics. If you're hiding things from your employees so you can get your bailout and shaft everyone else, how is that ethical?
- balls187 8y agoYou're statement has an underlying assumption that founders are hiding things from employees. As stated above, I think its that employees aren't asking the right questions. It's like when purchasing a vehicle; it's up to the buyer to educate themselves. Savvy buyers get better deals. We'd like to think of our industry as a meritocracy; but it's still largely based on humans with monkey brains,and greed is a powerful incentive.
- talltimtom 8y ago“...be more valuable than the cost of a movie ticket.” That’s the gamble right there. You think a movie ticket is worth what the movie theaters is telling you. MoviePass is calling their bluff by undercutting them on their own service if they get enough of the market theaters will have to cut them a deal they can survive on.
- mehrdadn 8y ago> it's like borrowing money to buy more ingredients for a failing restaurant. Well, they're gathering people's information & movie consumption habits as well. I could imagine a similar business losing money on the movie cost but making up for it by exploiting people's data. Not sure how "well" they're doing on that front though.
- lechiffre10 8y agoI listened to a podcast from the CEO about what their ultimate objective would be. The idea is to at one point have MoviePass be sponsored or paid ( or get a cut) of recommending things aside from the movie experience. For example, you'd get a deal with Uber to get to the theater or a list of great restaurants to try close to the cinema. Package an overall experience. I also think the data collected from movies that people are most interested in seeing would be of great use to publishers ( Box-Office seems to already help satisfy that). Problem is I think their cash burn rate won't allow them to get to that stage soon enough and I can't really see a light at the end of the tunnel for them especially considering AMC has started its own similar experience.
- 15155 8y agoThis is a very hand-wavy, Web 1.0-esque monetization model. Acted-upon, local recommendations aren't worth as much as MoviePass is paying for customer movie tickets.
- londons_explore 8y agoMany subscription services start to make money as users start to use the service less and less but are too lazy to cancel the subscription.
- Reedx 8y ago> The data they are gathering cannot be more valuable than the cost of a movie ticket. Yeah, but they think they can get the loss low enough that it becomes feasible to overcome that with data. And it goes beyond just knowing what movies someone is watching. For example, they know the exact location and time of where people are going to be (the app requires location to work). So MoviePass can use that info to upsell their customers to restaurants/etc around the theater and even transportation there and back. Create packages around this.
- fotbr 8y agoIf I run a restaurant near a theater, why would I want their data? I already know the clientele that visits the area, whether that's relatively high-end, working folks on their one-movie-night-escape a week, high school kids on date night, etc. I can already trivially find show (and run-) times from the theater and plan to stay open later or otherwise staff accordingly. I can advertise, in the theater even, for not a whole lot of money, and reach the people who saw "movie x". Theaters are happy to take your money for a 30-second spot in between pre-roll movie trivia clips. If I'm an uber/lyft/taxi driver, the same thing applies -- it's easy to find out when movies are out, so it's easy to be in the area. I guess I just don't see the value in "exact location and time" (at the theater, shortly before the movie starts) or any other data they can provide. What am I missing? What use-case is there for that data that makes it worth paying for?
- Reedx 8y agoOh, I didn't mean that they'd sell the data. But that MoviePass would use it themselves to generate more revenue from their users. Instead of just movie tickets, they'll combine it with other things. Dinner and a movie. Movie then a ride home. Stuff like that. I think their plan is to take commissions.
- pbreit 8y agoIt’s the dumbest thing I’ve ever seen and I’m still bullish on subscription commerce in general. A multi-brand theater pass doesn’t make much sense. Chains are much better off offering their own subscription. I’ve heard theaters pay distributors per ticket sold (not per screening or day) so it doesn’t have the dynamics of a perishable good. I don’t understand who would lend it money or buy its shares at this point.
- acjohnson55 8y agoBut isn't the marginal cost of a movie seat pretty low for the overwhelming majority of showtimes? I think they're banking on eventually becoming a reseller of inventory the chains themselves can't move.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> You can't charge less than the marginal cost, it doesn't make sense! You can if you are dumping to achieve a monopoly and/or monopsony where you will then have pricing power on one or the other side of the transaction you are in the middle of. But that's a game you either win completely before you run out of money or die horribly; there's no glidepath to a sustainable but not dominant position. And MoviePass seems very close to the die horribly outcome.
- zebraflask 8y agoThe deer in the headlights moment might be when this outfit decides to pay for movies that people want to see. I assume HN knows that most Hollywood movies are deliberately made for export to Chinese and Indian audiences.