10 ms·
Let me steelman that argument. Libraries were invented because information was only available on printed (or hand written) books, which were very expensive and
by BurningFrog 8y ago
Let me steelman that argument.
Libraries were invented because information was only available on printed (or hand written) books, which were very expensive and scarce resources.
Now information can be available almost literally for free and instantly, to anywhere. If the institutional inertia of libraries didn't exist today, would they really be invented as they are?
https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man https://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Steel_man
- nxc18 8y agoAs they exist today: free access to computers and internet. Information is only literally free and instant if you have access to the internet, which isn't gauranteed especially for low income people.
- dsr_ 8y agoIn many places, libraries provide free access to computers and the Internet, especially for but in no way limited to low income people. Libraries adapt to the times, you know. And they still have books.
- robrenaud 8y agoFor a librarian's salary, one could subsidize lots of internet for low income people.
- toomuchtodo 8y agoOr we could take the intelligent route and use taxes to pay for both.
- kaitai 8y agoLibraries in the US serve an enormous homeless population. "Subsidizing internet for low income people" is easy to say but does not address the practicalities of providing internet to the homeless, for instance.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoLibrarians do much more than look for and put books on shelves.
- s73v3r_ 8y agoI wonder how many people saying, "We don't need libraries and librarians" don't get this. Probably all of them. Maybe if they were to shadow a librarian for a couple days, they'd be on the same page.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoHell, all I had to do was overhear a few conversations between librarians and customers to dispel the misplaced idea I had that librarians were an archaic form of Google's search product. It's embarrassing to admit that, but it's the truth.
- eric_the_read 8y agoHave you looked at public librarian salaries lately? A senior-- senior, mind you-- librarian at the Colorado Springs Library District is being offered $25/hr. I don't recall for certain by now, but I'm pretty sure I made more than that my very first year out of school and I'm practically decrepit by this site's standards.
- GW150914 8y agoFor contrast, a cop makes 2-3 times that much per hour for directing traffic.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoHow many Netflix subscriptions could we subsidize if they were just replaced with a sign? /s
- ryandrake 8y agoIf libraries were invented today, that would be immediately killed by the copyright and retail lobbies.
- JTbane 8y agoIt's funny to imagine publishers making the case against them- "You're gonna just let people borrow books for free!? How will I turn a profit?" It's also kind of sad that this logic is so prevalent with regards to software, films, music, etc.
- Spooky23 8y agoA: Libraries buy lots of books. Children's books would not exist with libraries. You'd probably find that without the library most of the deeper catalog for publishers would not be viable.
- chipotle_coyote 8y agoAt risk of "+1, yes, this," I was naively but genuinely surprised at how valuable library sales can be to books when I was researching that a couple years ago. For indie/small press, even a few hundred extra copies sold could be a substantial revenue bump -- and only a small fraction of libraries in the country buying just one copy of a book could do it. (Also, I'm pretty sure publishers know this, and I don't think anyone of them have made serious arguments against libraries. It's digital media and its zero-cost reproduction that gives everyone fits.)
- Spooky23 8y agoTo pile on — think of the Amazon Kindle business model. You often pay more for instant gratification. Even for popular books, it drives demand. You can wait 8 weeks to read the latest James Patterson, or buy it now. But would you buy the previous books in the series @ $20/ea?
- s73v3r_ 8y ago
- Apocryphon 8y agoThe counter-argument is that libraries provide vital services to communities as public facilities in addition to simply being collections of shared knowledge, and that physical space should not be so easily replaced by the virtual.
- BurningFrog 8y agoTrue, but I think of that as institutional inertia. Libraries were formed to share very expensive printed books in a common space. Over the centuries, books and information became very cheap, and now mostly the common space remains. It certainly has real value. Do we need to keep the pretense of the books as the real purpose for it?
- pdkl95 8y ago> It certainly has real value. Do we need to keep ... books as the real purpose ... Max Headroom, episode ABC.1.3 "Body Bags": Paula: "...what's that?" Blank Reg: "It's a book!" Paula: "Well, what's that?" Blank Reg: "It's a non-volatile storage medium. It's very rare. You should have one." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=me6oNB4M7N0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=me6oNB4M7N0 Books still work when the power goes out or the copyright cartels revoke - intentionally or not - your ereader's license. Widespread preservation of knowledge on non-volatile media is protection against future problems.
- seandougall 8y agoAs far as I'm aware, the only people pretending books are libraries' only real purpose are the people here arguing that the Internet should take their place. Libraries themselves certainly aren't pretending to be only about books; they're just physically built around the stacks because books take up so much more space than the other things they provide. That said, access to books is still a vital service. Not all printed publications are cheap, and not all books can be replaced by Wikipedia (even if you completely ignore fiction, as that argument does by necessity).
- Sharlin 8y agoInformation in itself is almost worthless. Knowledge is valuable. Libraries act as curated collections of knowledge. Sure, also entertainment but at least they are classified to distinct categories. The internet is chock full of information and almost all of it is garbage.
- sidlls 8y agoFree (except for the cost of bandwidth/internet access, including devices), instantly (unless internet service is poor or inconsistent or both), and anywhere (that has internet access), you mean. There's nothing improved about the argument, it's just obfuscated better.
- petra 8y agoThe internet, at least intermittently and slowly -which is enough for books, is more accessible than public libraries.
- sedachv 8y agoNot for everybody. I see a lot of poor and indigent people who are at the library using the desktops and loaner laptops to access the Internet.
- tivert 8y ago> The internet, at least intermittently and slowly -which is enough for books, is more accessible than public libraries. No. The internet almost always costs the individual money to access, unlike public libraries. That means the internet is less accessible to low income people. Also public libraries have evolved into one of the main ways that many people access the internet. It's foolish to advocate replacing public libraries with something that the public libraries actually provide for many of their patrons.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- s73v3r_ 8y agoOnly if you ignore the cost of a device and service.
- l9k 8y agoCompare internet to library: Free: Transportation to go to your library (2x train ticket, or car + gas): minimum ~$5 / day so $60 a month, plus library card if not free Instantly: ~30 minutes to go, 30 minutes to get back home, depending on where you live. Worst internet connection need a few seconds. Anywhere: you have to physically go to the one library and hope you find the book you're looking for. Nowadays you have internet access pretty much anywhere.
- NeedMoreTea 8y agoFree so long as you can afford the net and are happy to abandon your privacy then call it "free". If you're one of the 8% in the US without a bank, or 11% without internet, what now? Libraries also gave net access for those without. They probably wouldn't be invented as they are, but given those groups without access I would want them to be.
- wilsonnb2 8y agoIf banking and internet services are so vital that we justify the existence of libraries because they provide access to them, then the Government should be responsible for providing to it's citizens anyways. It's possible that libraries are the best way to do that but it's also possible that there are other, better ways.
- maxxxxx 8y agoAt least in LA books are only a small part of what the libraries do. They offer free internet, law workshops, language classes, access to 3D printers and a lot more. They are really community centers and in my view well worth it.
- zachrose 8y agoI’ll go the other direction. Public libraries have large and networked collections, physical and digital, that they let you borrow for free. Why do we need to buy from Amazon and subscribe to Netflix when in theory the libraries could provide all that content?
- chlvsl 8y agoThey're not free. They're taxpayer subsidized.
- darpa_escapee 8y agoThis is not informative. This is pedantic.
- chlvsl 8y agoI am sorry, I did not realize I had an obligation to constantly inform you about something. I will do my best in the future.
- sctb 8y agoYou've been posting mostly inflammation here and we ban accounts that do that. Please stop. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- chlvsl 8y agoSure! Can you point out what's been inflammatory? I mostly try to keep it to conversational fidelity, so I can see how what I post can be interpreted as trolling.
- imbruglia 8y agoWhen something becomes abundant how to manage that resource becomes more important not less. Otherwise you end up with the resource curse. When information is free having somewhere to study that information, that isn't your shared apartment, becomes more important. Having somewhere to meet people to talk about the information, that isn't a crowded coffee shop, becomes more important. Having the expertise to find the right information, that isn't necessarily blog posts nor research pappers, again becomes more important. Libraries are only useless to the extent that they haven't expanded. But in line with the resource curse it ends up being more lucrative to work in information technology rather than with information technology. So while many other industries are struggling the large tech companies are making bank by being part of the problem.
- Spooky23 8y agoWe live in a fundamentally broken society today where rent-seekers want to break it further. No libraries would never be invented today. People like Carnegie who thrived in the industrial revolution recognized that and understood that education and social evolution was the path to prosperity and peace. When he studied recent history in his day, he probably pondered the decades of chaos and suffering kicked off by the French Revolution. The modern plutocrat is mostly a strictly transactional affair, who has dumbed business down to resource extraction. I became involved in my city's library system a few years ago when they did a branch expansion that I was initially opposed to for money reasons. I flipped and am now a library fan. I discovered that it's an environment for learning, social interaction and collaboration. You have programs for little kids where they interact with books for the first time. The elementary kids start collaborating on computers and doing other programs. Older kids are building robots, reading manga, having fun in a meaningful, beneficial way. The failed promise of the internet that I bought into in the 90s is that access to information will set you free. Yet we find ourselves dominated by propaganda via things like Facebook -- Internet is the new TV. The reality is that information in the context of a meaningful environment is the magic. The library adds value and context to information. It's a situation where the value is greater than the sum of the parts.
- bobthepanda 8y ago> No libraries would never be invented today. They did reinvent them, but in the spirit of the times they're mostly located in neighborhoods that are already more educated, more wealthy, and already have public library access. https://www.treehugger.com/culture/little-free-libraries-raise-questions-about-privilege-and-philanthropic-intention.html https://www.treehugger.com/culture/little-free-libraries-rai...
- kasey_junk 8y agoIs the idea that “book boxes are replacements for libraries” widely held? I have one and that idea seems insane to me. The book box to me is a nice landscaping feature, a place to drink coffee with my neighbors, a signal about my politics, a way for us to unload books & my attempt to get rad comics to school kids. I’d never correlate it to a public lending library.
- EliRivers 8y agoNow information can be available almost literally for free and instantly Brilliant. I foolishly bought some books recently. Where can I read them for free instead, apart from the library? Is this going to involve piracy? I'm not sure I'm really into that.
- Sharlin 8y agoIt baffles me that people seem to regard ”information” as something fungible, as if blogs and social media and clickbait ”news” could magically substitute for a specific novel or textbook I’d like to read.
- yontherubicon 8y agoAgreed, Library Genesis and IPFS simply haven't advanced that far. I'd love to see digital archives of all the books ever written, but we're not there yet. Nevermind the fact that reading a physical book avoids much of the issues with blue light that screens produce
- notacoward 8y agoLibraries also have people who can help you find the particular information you want, or to understand it because of knowledge or language deficits. They offer a relatively safe and distraction-free place to absorb that information, which many lower-income people might not have at hime. They have works which haven't been made available online and probably never will be, often because of copyright. The list just goes on and on. Maybe the information you want and can use is available "almost literally free and instantly" but not everyone's as super privileged as you.
- kaitai 8y agoAs mentioned earlier, libraries now serve many other purposes. Delivery of information is not the only one. I recently used my library in an extreme heat wave as a way to get free air conditioning. It had the side benefit of giving my kid a place to practice walking, with many low shelves to use as handholds, and she got to chew on toys and books with other children and swap germs. And then I got to leave, and not bring any of that crap home except the germs, the kid, and a few good books.
- jdietrich 8y agoI think it might be a net benefit if we rename libraries "community resource centers". The argument against the old, narrow function of libraries falls apart if they're named in a way that reflects their current purpose.
- egypturnash 8y agoDid you RTFA before you jumped into the comments? Here, let me give you a quote. > Just this week, a woman stopped by our desk because she needed to be taught how to open a new tab in an internet browser. She returned a few minutes later and said, “Please write ‘stomach ache’ on this piece of paper for me. I don’t know to spell it.” The man waiting behind her had no idea how to open an internet browser to begin his first job search in years. I walked him through the process and helped him get to a job site. This was a few minutes of a 40-hour workweek. > I can’t imagine where this woman and this man would go without the library. Would Amazon really be willing to help them with all of their needs free of charge? Information is available “almost literally for free and instantly” to people who can afford a device that connects to the internet.
- Fomite 8y agoI'd add "...and know how to use it." Immersed as we are in it, I think people forget that the internet is a skill. Finding things and filtering the results is the result of experience.
- pandler 8y ago> Information is available “almost literally for free and instantly” to people who can afford a device that connects to the internet. ... and who have a sufficient working knowledge of how computers and the internet work in order to take advantage of that information. In line with what you and others have said, what I've observed at the libraries I've been to is that the people who get the most value out of libraries are the people that would otherwise be left behind by technology. I don't think that's something we can or should dismiss out of hand just because I/we don't personally get a lot of value from them. That is, unless we want to develop an underclass of people shut out from the rest of society.
- mmirate 8y agoAs long as the police still do their jobs, why does the existence of such an underclass worry you?
- 8y ago
- ekphrasis 8y agoWell, can you say how they actually are invented today? Please be aware of the distinction between public libraries (as is the general semantic implication when speaking of ”libraries”) serving the whole of the public; national libraries serving the whole of the public, creating systems for the retrieval of information and preserving the cultural memory of the world together with museums and archives; school libraries serving childrens’ and youths’ education; research libraries serving students, scientists, researchers and professionals in, for example, law, medicine, health sciences, industrial research on conducting research, referencing and preserving research data; hospital libraries serving the physically and mentally ill and disabled; and special libraries serving domain-based interests of for example artists, industry professionals and cultural institutions. Also be aware of the fact that Library and Information Science as a scientific multidisciplinary field researches topics such as information theory, machine learning, cultural heritage, sociology, linguistics, comparative literature, knowledge organization, information retrieval, computer science, pedagogy, critical theory, didactics. I also suggest a systematic literature study on the term ”information literacy”.
- loco5niner 8y agoDownloading e-books etc. at a minimum requires a device and knowledge of how to use that device. Libraries are intended to provide information to everyone.
- groby_b 8y agoI'd be very curious where you get free computers, free electricity, and free WiFi. Plus shelter from the environment. Oh. Right. That'd be the library. And the steelman is a bit weak in its limbs - you could certainly make the argument that the point of original libraries wasn't the scarcity issue, but the discoverability issue. ("Just travel to Alexandria" is almost certainly not significantly cheaper than paying a scribe to create a copy) We could also argue that they're the precursors of modern universities, because they offered a central place for scholars to gather. Both - building a community, and making knowledge more discoverable - are still major purposes for today's libraries. (If you thought searching the Internet for info is helpful, try a librarian)
- hakfoo 8y agoEven if information is free and infinite-- perhaps especially in this situation-- there's value in curation and expert research guidance. In a different timeline, libraries might not be buildings full of books, but there'd still be a purpose for librarians.