4 ms·
This is a perfect example of "AI gone wrong" even though there was no AI involved. The costs of insurance are based on actuarial tables, which are really just
by jedberg 8y ago
This is a perfect example of "AI gone wrong" even though there was no AI involved.
The costs of insurance are based on actuarial tables, which are really just calculations based on large chunks of historical data, much like an AI. And much like an AI, the result essentially magnifies the biases that already exist in the data (biases that may be accurate or may not be).
The tables, nor the AI, care about ethics or perception. They are simply the result of the inputs given.
Do men really have more tickets and accidents? Maybe. Or maybe they just get caught more.
It just highlights how careful we have to be about biases, real or accidental, as we rely more and more on mathematical models based on data.
- tathougies 8y agoThis has nothing to do with AI. Men have been charged more for car insurance (at least in America) for many years. I mean, when my brother got his license almost 15 years ago, he was charged more, and so was I when I got mine.
- jedberg 8y agoYes I know, that's why I said "even though it has nothing to do with AI".
- quxbar 8y agoMen measurably impact the bottom line of insurance companies more. Actuarial math is not 'AI', there's no 'magnification of bias'. The whole point of the calculation is to eliminate bias so that the company makes sound decisions. Please don't generalize things that you haven't made an effort to understand. When you say stuff like this, you're making it harder to fight actual bias in the world, because you make people not take your point seriously.
- jedberg 8y agoI have a pretty deep understanding actually. Please explain to me how making an actuarial table with different data sets would get you the same answer without bias.
- lykr0n 8y agoBias, according to google: > prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another, usually in a way considered to be unfair. Data can't be bias. It can be a misrepresentation or inaccurate, but not bias. If I have an accurate data-set that say ethnic group X in area Y has a higher rate of violence, and because of that I make the choice to charge higher premiums for group X- is that bias? No. You can't scream bias when you don't like the conclusions the data draws. Drawing conclusions from data isn't bias-ed(?) but using only that data might be.
- jedberg 8y agoSo if I gave you a dataset that only had women in it, and from that you concluded that men never have accidents and should therefore have a $0 insurance rate, you wouldn't say that the data was biased against women?
- lykr0n 8y agoI would say the data is inaccurate.
- jedberg 8y agoGiven that it is impossible to have a 100% accurate dataset for real world events, wouldn't every dataset be inaccurate to some measure? And wouldn't the level of inaccuracy represent a bias of some sort?
- lykr0n 8y agoThere is a whole field of mathematics on how to figure this out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sample_size_determination https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sample_size_determination And yes, nothing is 100% accurate. The census isn't 100% accurate, but it's good enough. A 95% accuracy is the generally accepted target, which is what you have a statically significant. If you have a target population of 330 Million people, you only need 40k people to hit a 95% confidence value with a 0.1 confidence interval. Again, this has all been figured out, formulated, and settled. You keep using the word bias and I don't think you know what it means. If the data is inaccurate, it's inaccurate. If I wanted to sample the US population, but only used people from Long Island and only polled 10 people, that's not a bias dataset- it's inaccurate. Conclusions drawn from inaccurate data are inaccurate. Bias data would be statistics cherry-picked to showcase one view point over another. The dataset itself isn't bias, but maybe the presentation is. As I said before, good (and this is important) data can't be bias- what you do with it can be. Saying "Men are more likely to be bad drivers" is a factual statement. "All Men are bad drivers" is a bias one. See the difference?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- kansface 8y ago> Do men really have more tickets and accidents? Maybe. Or maybe they just get caught more. The internet seems to indicate that men do cause more accidents, but they also drive more on average. Insurers would only be interested in the likelihood of a payout, so they should rationally charge men more. Also, men get far more DUIs (big payout). * NOTE: not a rigorous investigation of the numbers.
- friedButter 8y agoWomen get pregnant more than men, but get charged the same medical insurance rates. Women take maternity leave more than men, but legally you cannot pay women less. How come in scenarios where women cost more, it is mandated that men and women must pay the same, but not in cases where men cost more?
- kansface 8y agoWomen may get pregnant more, but iirc men have higher mortality rates at all stages of life - I'd also guess way more accidents from risky behavior work related or otherwise. Women also earn less money, and most consumer price discrimination seems to target them (pink shirts cost more than blue shirts) so maybe it sorta works out?