3 ms·
I get that the trade imbalance meant that BEIC/Britain looked for something other than silver to trade. But wasn't Qing (?) China closed? AIUI they traded with
by pbhjpbhj 8y ago
I get that the trade imbalance meant that BEIC/Britain looked for something other than silver to trade. But wasn't Qing (?) China closed?
AIUI they traded with Chinese merchants at designated ports, trading opium to get tea. The Chinese then traded the drugs on.
Three things that don't make sense to me in the "traditional" telling of "Britain purposefully created opium _addiction_ across China".
* One, that opium addiction was a new idea, opium was widely used in Britain.
* Two, how did merchants at the ports create demand in the interior, surely they met demand outcompeting local sources on cost and so widening the market.
* Three, after Britain was shut out of the trade China seemingly already had a massive local supply.
These things tend to make me think that in some measure the Chinese closed the ports in order to prevent cheaper product from supplying an already established and widespread market. And yet, I've read, once that BEIC supply was stopped the Chinese maintained the market with local supply.
Are their letters/papers where controllers of BEIC talk about addiction? Did they 'just' look for a large market that they could undercut?
It seems more like a tale of amoral merchants (of many nationalities), rather than evil Britain. But I'm from the UK (which does and has done plenty of evil things, selling weapons to the Saudis when we know they're using then to kill civilians, for example).
[banter] Of course the British are still addicted to tea, but we diversified our supply somewhat. Having comestibles disposed of in the sea seems like a repeating theme - perhaps the Dutch will sink our potato shipments after Brexit.[/banter]
- stephenhuey 8y agoWhen the emperor banned opium, the British sold it to smugglers. When the Chinese seized 20,000 chests of trafficked opium to stop it from being sold, the British attacked China and made them sign an agreement to buy tons of stuff from the British, including opium. http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-36781368 http://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-36781368
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSo Britain stopped trading, and traded legally with Chinese people who themselves smuggled the opium ... see to me that sounds like the smugglers are doing the worst thing there? The Chinese seized and destroyed opium from merchants from several countries, Britain sent forces to release merchants, ships, goods and was demanding compensation for the destroyed opium, which compensation they then fought to acquire. If the Emperor/Lin Xehu(sp?) at any time ordered that selling tea to foreigners was illegal(?), then it looks much worse for the outside forces; if not then it looks like balance of trade was a prime motivation on both sides, rather than (im)moral considerations. (https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/opium-war-1839-1842 https://www.nam.ac.uk/explore/opium-war-1839-1842 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6304d1/what_caused_the_first_opium_war_ive_read_several/ https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/6304d1/what_... based on other tertiary sources I've read seem like good synopses.)
- partycoder 8y agoStop complicating things. This is very simple: 1. The British planted opium then transported it to China and traded it. 2. The Chinese told them it was illegal. 3. They continued trading it. 4. The Chinese seized all of it. 5. They declared war so they could continue trading it. I don't see the confusion or debate here. What the British were doing was very simple: illegal drug trade for profit. What others were doing is a separate debate and does not absolve the British from anything. Don't mix things.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>Three, after Britain was shut out of the trade China seemingly already had a massive local supply. As mentioned, smuggling became a huge business, and it wasn't too hard. The UK had a massive land border with China, China has a huge coastline with pirates controlling the seas/major rivers, which also allowed towns to ignore Beijing's orders. There was not a major local supply. > Two, how did merchants at the ports create demand in the interior, surely they met demand outcompeting local sources on cost and so widening the market. The Yangtze and Yellow rivers.
- pbhjpbhj 8y agoSo why did the Chinese merchants exchange their tea for opium? If they didn't already have a market for it, did they set about creating the market. AIUI the opium was traded in local ports, then smuggled to the interior by locals (because other ethnicities couldn't get access). Is that wrong; could you cite sources. Are you saying British merchants navigated the Yangtze and Huang He in order to initiate opium use, just to trade tea ... why didn't BEIC choose some other product (whatever drug was being used, for example) if opium wasn't already in demand -- it must have taken decades to create that demand, especially as they might AIUI be killed just for being there (in the interior) and stood out from the crowd quite considerably. It seems somewhat analogous to blaming North African nations (Kenya, Ivory Coast, etc) for my coffee/chocolate use, Nestlé are still evil, but I'm the one buying it.
- boomboomsubban 8y ago>So why did the Chinese merchants exchange their tea for opium? If they didn't already have a market for it, did they set about creating the market. The market built up over the century before the war by introducing it then importing enough to make it affordable. >AIUI the opium was traded in local ports, then smuggled to the interior by locals (because other ethnicities couldn't get access). Is that wrong; could you cite sources. The opium was generally traded in ports, but more as different boats were needed. Access was not a major issue. I don't know what sources you want, river deltas have been trade hubs for millennia. >just to trade tea ... Why didn't BEIC choose some other product (whatever drug was being used, for example) if opium wasn't already in demand -- it must have taken decades to create that demand, especially as they might AIUI be killed just for being there (in the interior) and stood out from the crowd quite considerably. "Just to trade tea" made them filthy rich in Britain, it's like saying the Spanish conquered Peru "just for gold and silver." There weren't other British products the Chinese had interest in, and the British decision to push opium happened sixty years before the war.
- partycoder 8y agotl;dr. The British planted, transported and traded drugs for profit, and as a consequence ruined millions of lives, and counting. This is a solid historical fact. The British were drug dealers, and many modern drug dealers exist because of the British. Period. Don't try to dilute or deflect the blame. It happened, it continues to cause harm today, and it will never be forgotten. Live with it. I cannot care less about revisionist arguments.