4 ms·
The unreasonable effectiveness of Soccermatics? (2017)
- vanderZwan 8y ago> The fact that non-mathematicians can produce sharp and correct criticism of an applied mathematician’s work shows us that the success of mathematics does not rest on its abstract beauty. The ability of researchers not versed in the subtleties of mathematics to help develop models contradicts Wigner’s ‘unreasonable effectiveness’ argument. It tells us that people not trained in mathematics are also able to give deep insights to the subject. Mathematics is not there to be discovered, it is part of the patterns of reasoning in all of our brains. The key insight. It kind of reminds me of how physicists like Robbert Dijkgraaf (I think) have argued that physics and other fields are now contributing to mathematics through their own outlandish needs for weird maths.
- lucideer 8y agoI found this article a bit odd; in my mind, some parts seemed to contradict others in strange paradoxical ways. For example, from your quoted section: > Mathematics is not there to be discovered, it is part of the patterns of reasoning in all of our brains. Isn't that the very definition of elegance? He later says, talking about A.J. Ayer's definition of "non-sense": > Wigner freely admits that his idea about maths comes from a feeling that can’t be verified by known scientific methods Elegance, while there is often a wide collective understanding of what it means in mathematics, is essentially a subjective, aesthetic property; an intuitive one. Is this not exactly what: (a) Wigner means in that quote, (b) A.J. Ayer means in his definition, AND (c) the author refers to as "patterns of reasoning in all of our brains"?
- goldenkey 8y agoWe like compression. That's our main requirement. We may not like hard coded constants in our physical theories but thats only because we'd prefer a single constant that uncompresses to all six. Or a single law about laws that uncompresses to the entire theory. Constructor theory [1] We also like symmetry but symmetry is just a way to identify attack surfaces for compression. [1] https://www.edge.org/conversation/david_deutsch-constructor-theory https://www.edge.org/conversation/david_deutsch-constructor-...
- severine 8y agoIs this an article or a book teaser? (DDG !libgen soccermatics) Ah, looks very good!
- thom 8y agoThere's two editions of Soccermatics, and his new book Outnumbered.
- IshKebab 8y ago"The unreasonable effectiveness" is the new "considered harmful". Be more creative!
- alanbernstein 8y agoYou should write an article called 'The unreasonable effectiveness of "The unreasonable effectiveness" considered harmful'
- patrickk 8y agoFor those interested in this sort of thing, 'packing' and 'impect' are also interesting to read about, developed in Germany but it still hasn't widely spread into the mainstream like more traditional stats like possession, pass completion %, or meters run. These traditional stats very often do not explain why team A or B actually won the game. Therefore, two new statistical measures were developed, which better explain why a particular team won a game. Packing is the measurement of how many opposition players are beaten by a pass (or dribble or other move). Impect is the number of deep lying defenders beaten, which is obviously more valuable compared to high pressing strikers. The key insight is that defenders beaten, particularly deeper-lying defenders are the measurement needed to identify who is expected to win (and therefore assessing the value of passing players, or defenders). http://bundesligafanatic.com/20160610/impect-packing-the-future-of-football-analytics-is-here/ http://bundesligafanatic.com/20160610/impect-packing-the-fut...
- Harvey-Specter 8y agoThat was a really interesting read, thanks for sharing it. > Impect disregards all passes that go backwards or don’t beat any defender. It’s a correct assessment, a pass that doesn’t travel forwards, doesn’t help you score. Can’t argue with that. This is a really odd statement. Plenty of passes don't go forward but absolutely do increase the likelihood of scoring. For example, the final pass here [0] is backwards, might even allow an additional defender time to track back (-1 packing?) but opens up the space required to take a shot and score. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0oihU_fLas https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0oihU_fLas
- hinkley 8y agoIsn’t a pass going backward about avoiding a defender they can’t get past? Useful backward passes fall into at least two categories. The ones that eventually result in an impect, and the ones that run down the clock at the end of the game.
- harlanlewis 8y agoAnd a third category, whatever Spain was doing against Russia.
- dpleuler 8y agoFunny to stumble across this on Hacker News. I'm the analyst mentioned in the article. Happy to answer any questions about our weird little industry.
- gadders 8y agoHow did you end up in your current line of work? Ever used any of your stats for gambling?
- dpleuler 8y agoI stumbled into it largely by coincidence and luck. As you could imagine, there aren't many people that study computer science who were also relatively high level soccer players. I'm very fortunate to occupy the very narrow intersection of that obscure venn diagram. I stumbled across some high resolution soccer data during college and began writing a blog that became popular in soccer analytics circles. The company that produced the data that I was scraping eventually hired me to their data science team. I spent a few years with them before I was recruited to my current team. I have never worked in gambling but there are a few people in my sort of role that have that sort of background. It requires a pretty similar set of skills. I am not sure that I could beat the market by a large enough margin to make it worthwhile. It's quite efficient. But for the most part, I'm more interested in understanding the underlying mechanics of tactics than I am interested in predicting the result of games.
- gadders 8y agoThanks for your reply. Is your blog still going?
- r2d2-c3po 8y agoDo you have any recommendations for how a hobbyist can get more into the field? Someone who has a technical background, but works in a different field unrelated to sports at all. Any reading material to get familiar with some of the stats and metrics that are used in the industry?
- everdev 8y ago> The ability of researchers not versed in the subtleties of mathematics to help develop models contradicts Wigner’s ‘unreasonable effectiveness’ argument. It tells us that people not trained in mathematics are also able to give deep insights to the subject. This would seem to be consistent with the notion of "common sense" that it's possible even for an average person to be able to ask meaningful questions and cast doubt on subjects they're not specifically trained in.
- syastrov 8y agoNewton developed the mathematics of calculus to solve physics problems. That goes against Wigner’s hypothesis. I believe that it is difficult to pinpoint where inspiration comes from. However, mathematical rigor can often help. You could also argue reductionalistically that, since we all live in a physical universe, we are always inspired by something physical.
- brootstrap 8y agointeresting read. some of the passing diagrams and such are quite interesting. arsenal fan fyi, COYG and FOYS (ef off) spuds fans. with wenger gone arsenal will overtake =) from a blog post, shows passing networks and has some vector fields overlaid on the soccer pitch. https://www.fourfourtwo.com/features/soccermatics-how-mesut-ozil-so-good-and-why-wenger-relies-ramsey https://www.fourfourtwo.com/features/soccermatics-how-mesut-...
- codethief 8y agoRelated research on basketball: https://www.physics.umass.edu/events/2015-09-09-statistics-basketball-scoring-and-lead-changes https://www.physics.umass.edu/events/2015-09-09-statistics-b... (arXiV: https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.03509 https://arxiv.org/abs/1503.03509) I had the pleasure of attending the mentioned colloquium by Sid Redner back in 2015 and I was absolutely blown away by the effectiveness of a simple random-walk model.