3 ms·
It's a bit harsh to want to end the whole industry, no? By all means let's get some proper safety standards for these things, but banning them outright seems e
by yellowapple 8y ago
It's a bit harsh to want to end the whole industry, no?
By all means let's get some proper safety standards for these things, but banning them outright seems excessive.
- ghaff 8y agoYou don't really deserve the downvotes you're getting. This is a widespread tourist attraction and I'd have to see some statistics to conclude that it's an especially unsafe one. That said, they deserve a serious look at what could be practically done to retrofit for greater safety (flotation, sorry but you get wet if it rains, wear PFDs) and otherwise set stricter operating guidelines.
- MBCook 8y agoThe article says there are versions that don’t have the top, that would fix most of the issue. Wearing lifevest you’d be able to get out safely instead of being trapped inside.
- ghaff 8y agoI suspect that would help a lot. Literal capsizing would still be an issue but filling up with water and sinking would be much less of one.
- evil-olive 8y agoThat would address most of the concern about the boats sinking, because every passenger could safely wear a floatation device. However, they're unsafe in other ways. The 2015 crash in Seattle, which killed 4, was caused by a snapped axle. When I read that the duck design was "stretched" by someone with zero engineering training, that sounds awfully suspicious. An additional concern is the the safety & maintenance records themselves. As part of the settlement in Seattle, the company admitted to 463 separate violations: https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/ducks-admits-to-463-safety-violations-to-pay-222000/ https://www.seattletimes.com/seattle-news/transportation/duc...
- wahern 8y agoFrom a 2016 news article: Philadelphia's fleet of 20 to 25 duck boats have been involved in three fatalities in five years, he said. "If you compare those rates to the number of fatalities per mile driven in a passenger car, you are talking about rates of fatalities literally thousands of times higher." (http://www.philly.com/philly/business/396220791.html http://www.philly.com/philly/business/396220791.html) If you search Google news (use a date range prior to this month's accident) you'll see regular deadly incidents going back years. The NTSB did a huge review after a 1999 incident with 13 deaths. Conclusion? They're death traps. Duck boats swamp easily and sink like a stone. If there's a canopy people get dragged straight to the bottom. The industry is huge and economically important. So perhaps just grandfather existing duck boats as long as they don't have a canopy. If you want a fancy duck boat with windows and a canopy, then buy a properly designed boat that isn't a death trap. EDIT: Reading through the Google News results it seems these things are more deadly on land than in water.
- jethro_tell 8y agoYes, they are hard to drive in urban areas, which is a shocker considering they were designed to drive on the ocean/beach. In Seattle we have them and they have a pretty bad record about hitting people in crosswalks, even running over a guy on a harly. They are so far above traffic that you just can't see that shit. Not to mention a couple of years ago when the axil popped off and ripped a tour bus in half killing a few kids and sending a good number to the hospital. Amphibious tours in amphibious cities would be great, but I doubt you could even get those things approved now, and no one actually has the money to make a new fleet and profit. It is also probably note worthy that the original design was made for a situation where loss of human life was already expected.
- c22 8y agoGrowing up in a family of commercial fishermen/sailors I have often heard complaints that the drivers of these things possess limited boating experience and routinely cause interruptions or annoyance for other waterborne vessels. I've never ridden one, though, or captained a boat in my life, so feel free to file this wherever you keep your unsourced anecdotes.
- jessaustin 8y agoBan the use of anything designed and constructed during WWII for amphibious transport of the public. There's no way you'll ever get enough flotation in there. If someone wants to invest enough to develop a new amphibious vehicle to replace the existing stock, that's fine, but I doubt the market would support such an undertaking. Thus the industry would disappear without any excessive action.
- thawkins 8y agoI don't think the original purpose was to be able to behave like a boat, more for fording deeper rivers in combat situations.
- chrisbennet 8y agoMy Dad used them to transport cargo from ship to shore when they were constructing an air base in Thule Greenland. They are for getting stuff ashore in places where there isn’t a harbor.
- tstrimple 8y agoWe certainly can't let a little death get in the way of profit now can we?
- yellowapple 8y agoBy that logic, we should just ban rollercoasters; they're inherently unsafe, obviously, and it's a lost cause to try to make them more safe. Never mind that we've spent more than a century doing just that. No reason why duckboats can't get the same treatment.