16 ms·
The Dream Is Over: Music Labels Have Killed Their Digital Future
- jbarham 16y ago> Nobody’s going to pay Google $25 a year to store their music in a cloud. I'd pay that to be rid of iTunes.
- 1010011010 16y agoMe too. iTunes is just horrible. I'd love a non-iTunes way of getting my music onto an iPod.
- digitallogic 16y agoThen allow me to make your day: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_iPod_managers http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Comparison_of_iPod_managers
- jobu 16y agoThe iTunes UI is horrid, but I have yet to find anything that does everything iTunes can without being crashy, slow or non-intuitive.
- blehn 16y agoCan you elaborate? I think the store is frustrating, but I've found the player itself has been pretty stable and usable for the last 6-7 years on OSX (I have 40GB of music btw). It's a big ol' spreadsheet with instant search and drag+drop playlists.
- thegreatcurve 16y agoI find the spreadsheet-style interface pretty uninspired for something as personal as music. The linear list of albums/tracks breaks down very quickly once your library starts growing, and iTunes becomes a confusing, disorientating mess. To Apple's credit, they've been taking baby steps towards more interesting ways of browsing your library with Genius playlists and mixes, but they could and should do so much more.
- ugh 16y agoWhat are the alternatives, though? I quite like the three column browser for quickly finding music even if I only have a very fuzzy idea of what I would like right now. It scales quite well, even if you have a library with several thousand songs and a few hundred artists. Together with the hybrid cover view it doesn’t even look very much like a spreadsheet. Then there’s the grid view which also has its uses. I especially like to display albums by year which gives me a nice chronological overview. Coverflow is pretty worthless, though. I think that while iTunes gets the big picture somewhat right (at least as far as its audio library functionality is concerned) it gets many details spectacularly wrong. The UI for tagging feels ancient. Oh, and it’s modal. iTunes forces me to play column jockey. I don‘t want to change column widths just so I don’t get vertical scrollbars. iTunes should keep it all nice and tidy for me, kind of like Mail. That, and many other small details.
- 1010011010 16y agoiTunes opens lots of error dialogs, loses files and fails to play tracks when it's run in an account with an nfs home directory.
- thought_alarm 16y agoYes, trying out other music managers is a very good way to come to appreciate iTunes and how it works. I encourage everyone who thinks they're unhappy with iTunes to check out these other applications.
- lukifer 16y agoiTunes is a great personal media database, and a terrible everything else. The former is enough to make me willing to put up with the latter.
- icegreentea 16y agoThe Winamp iPod manager wasn't so bad. Sure, there was no drag and drop, but I always kept dropping in the wrong place anyways. The biggest problem was how it handled certain aspects of tags and labelling different from iTunes. It really wasn't a problem if all you ever used was Winamp, but if you started with iTunes, and switched to Winamp, it would just reorder your music (the most obvious example being 0-9 coming before/after a-z), and piss you off. Today, I use foobar to play my music. And I keep iTunes around to load my iPod. Cause as stupidly annoying as iTunes is, foobar gets it worse.
- bad_user 16y agoYes, but why can't I just drag and drop mp3 files on my iPod/iPhone directly from the file manager?
- aw3c2 16y agoBecause you purchased an Apple product.
- 1010011010 16y agoHmm: http://fusepod.sourceforge.net/ http://fusepod.sourceforge.net/
- jmtulloss 16y agoIf you have an iPhone, Android, or Blackberry, Rdio is awesome for getting music on there. Way easier than iTunes, if you ask me. Disclaimer: I totally work for them.
- capedape 16y agoThis will do it on windows: http://www.mediamonkey.com/ http://www.mediamonkey.com/ (I have no vested interest in this company other than continued development for my personal use) edit didn't see the comparison below, but this works very well with Iphone/pod/pad
- wccrawford 16y agoI think the question is: "What else do I get for that $25?" I hate dealing with my library of songs. If I could stream it to any device, any time, as well as have -any- other value-added service attached, I'd pay the $25 per year. By 'any device' I mean TV, PC, Android Phone, PS3 and more. Basically, any device that I can hook to the internet.
- rospaya 16y agoAs much as I hate dealing with a lot of files and ID3 tags, streaming music sucks for mobile devices for a couple of reasons: - 3G quality and speeds are guarranteed everywhere and every time. I was left with nothing but the songs I had on my SD card when I was on vacation on an island. - Constant streaming kills battery life, killing your phone and music player in one kick. - Because of massive roaming charges, you can forget using it outside of the country. If you don't travel much, have a good plan and don't mind the battery issue, it could be useful.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- guelo 16y agoIf Google's plan is to use Simplify Media's tech then it will probably be a plugin for Winamp and iTunes.
- Tichy 16y agoWhat happened to the YC startup that allowed you to store all your music in the cloud?
- spicyj 16y agoAre you thinking of Lala? It was acquired by Apple and subsequently shut down. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lala_(website) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lala_(website)
- agentultra 16y agoThe point about the labels doing it to themselves is probably only half the story. The other half is the culturally ingrained phenomena of "the dream." Many artists jamming in their basements dream of "signing," and expect a big advance, tours, radio play, and all of that old-world stuff. Many today of course realize that there's the Internet and they can afford to distribute their work for pennies and market to their hearts desire; but even those artists generally still think that "signing" is the next, big logical step. The big labels cannot change. The 80s and 90s left us with a market and taste for stadium tours, music videos, and times square billboards. Six decades of business have given us a model that requires a huge up-front investment for a risky, but lucrative return. The problem is the returns are becoming scarce. Yet I think big labels will continue to persist only because they're the loan sharks with the money. I think the author is pretty close to right that there's likely no one that will fund a start up that has anything to do with music. If you have an innovative idea that you think can improve the situation, create new markets, etc you'll have to do it on your own.
- kiba 16y agoThe big labels don't feel like changing, not that they cannot change. They are a bunch of human beings at all. Aren't human beings flexible enough to thrive anywhere on earth? Yet, some humans choose to die rather than adapt. The labels don't want to deal with the changing business. So they rather die.
- ethank 16y agoAgain, have you ever visited or spoken to anyone at a label? Next time you are in SoCal, email me. I'm serious. :)
- chris11 16y agoI'm not sure if you can answer this or not, but in your opinion what would it take to get some type of voluntary licensing going for music? I personally would rather pay a monthly fee than pay for each individual song or cd. I also want the ability to do what I want with the music. I don't want to have to work to get music on an mp3 player or worry about whether I'm going to randomly lose access to songs in library, which has happened with Ruckus.
- henrikschroder 16y agoGoogle music. Who cares? Oh right, you guys don't have Spotify. I don't know anyone that has it that bothers with iTunes or actually buying music anymore. Get the free version, and get any music anytime and the occasional ad. Pay a few bucks a month, and you get any music anytime with no ads.
- Disparity 16y agoWell, we do have Grooveshark. But it probably won't last. :(
- DevX101 16y agoIf it's lasted this long it will probably keep going for some time yet. They have a pretty clear song takedown policy, so any music being shared on grooveshark is likely being done so with the full consent of the label. Grooveshark is also paying the music owners royalty from a share of their ad revenue.
- Disparity 16y agoIIRC, Grooveshark only pays EMI royalties, and UMG is taking them to court. Sony and Warner have no deals. I'd be curious to see what Sony and Warner choose to do.
- jmtulloss 16y agoIt doesn't matter. UMG is the elephant in the room, they'll do whatever UMG does.
- jfornear 16y agoThe clock has already been ticking... [1] [1] Universal Music Group Now "Declaring Legal Jihad" Against Grooveshark... http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/stories/090310groovesharkumg http://www.digitalmusicnews.com/stories/090310groovesharkumg
- 16y ago
- pg 16y agoI came to this conclusion myself about 6 months ago, after Dalton Caldwell spoke at a YC dinner. I realized it was basically hopeless to start startups that touch label music, because even the ones that seem to be succeeding (in the sense of not being sued out of existence) are only allowed to live so the labels can suck investors' money through them. But by creating a startup-free zone around themselves, all the labels are doing is hosing themselves, because they won't have startups working to develop whatever would have been the new ways of delivering and using label music. They've created an anti-platform.
- sabat 16y agoonly allowed to live so the labels can suck investors' money through them That's true, but not as true as you might suspect. Pandora is profitable. Yes, they are certainly pumping a large amount of money to the record labels, but they're able to exist without driving their users away with over-advertising. I wouldn't do a (label) music-based startup today, though. Sad.
- pg 16y agoI don't know the details of Pandora's finances, but present profits tend not to be the whole story here. Many if not most of the startups that have deals with labels also have large debts to them. Plus the labels can change their terms. So you pretty much live on sufferance, for as long as you're useful to them.
- whopa 16y agoAFAIK, Pandora is classed as radio, and doesn't have to do direct deals with the labels. They pay royalties to SoundExchange, which in theory distributes the royalties to the content owners. The rates they pay are a lot lower than the rates companies like Rdio, Spotify, and MOG have to pay to the labels directly for on demand streaming rights.
- bl4k 16y agoPandora has been close to shutting down a number of times: * http://blog.pandora.com/pandora/archives/2007/03/riaas-new-royal.html http://blog.pandora.com/pandora/archives/2007/03/riaas-new-r... * http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08/15/AR2008081503367.html http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/08... they are at the mercy of the labels.
- ethank 16y agoPersonally, it's extremely simplistic to say that the labels aren't "changing" The ecosystem, the market, and working with artists engenders a much more complicated landscape than one might think. agentultra has some good points there.
- bambax 16y agoIsn't this just wishful thinking? Everybody hates labels, and so wishes them dead (and for the record, so do I). But just because everyone wants them to die doesn't mean they will die. Labels sit on content, and their monopoly is protected by the full force of the law. The number of startups in the field or the evilness of label people does seem a little bit irrelevant. There is only one way labels can die: if they cease to have a monopoly on music content -- which means, either the world gets rid of copyright, or (young, new and aspiring) artists stop signing with labels. None of this is happening anytime soon. (It may happen, but in a rather distant future.)
- ethank 16y agoA question, honestly: have you ever visited or spoken to anyone at a label?
- bambax 16y agoI have never visited, no. I know people from school who work at labels, but I can't say I meet with them often. Why the question? EDIT: oh, I understand the question, you work at a label. Well, I live in France, where "Hadopi" just went live. It's a government agency that monitors Internet traffic for copyright infringement and that can then cut off the Internet access of alleged offenders -- not because they themselves are convicted of copyright infringement, but because their Internet connection was used in this manner and they failed to prevent it. This law was inspired by and received the heavy support of professional organisations such as SACEM, etc. When an industry is instrumental in creating such legal monsters, I think it deserves the hate and contempt of the public, and more. Now, none of this has much to do with the subject of the article which was about the "digital future" of the industry. I just wanted to elaborate a little on the "hate" part of my initial post.
- olalonde 16y agoThe article never said labels were going to die. It just pointed out how they screwed their digital future.
- 16y ago
- eogas 16y agohttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1G3dzddZ6WE http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1G3dzddZ6WE
- endlessvoid94 16y agoI would absolutely pay google $25 to store my music in the cloud. I have 150GB of the stuff and keeping it on my laptop has become impossible.
- lukev 16y agoYou can do this already. Write a music player client that can stuff your music into an encrypted blob and push it out on Amazon S3 or something. $22.50/month for storage. The problem is that that monthly price is a bit high for most people.
- il 16y agoI think "Write a music player client that can stuff your music into an encrypted blob" is a bigger hurdle for most people than paying $25/month. Besides, doesn't Grooveshark already do this for free?
- lukev 16y agoWell, as a startup, I mean. There shouldn't be any legal hurdles, anyway - it's really just a backup system specialized for music. And I'll be honest, I have no clue what Grooveshark's business model is. I like it, but I don't see how the RIAA doesn't come down on them like a ton of bricks, and I really doubt the ads they show can cover what they ought to be paying in royalties.
- pg 16y agoThere shouldn't be any legal hurdles, anyway - it's really just a backup system specialized for music. I would not assume that.
- CoryMathews 16y agoGrooveshark has deals with a few of the major record labels. They get paid everytime grooveshark plays a song. They have been sued a couple times in the past and now have deals with most of these labels. Grooveshark makes money through their VIP, advertising, and promotions put on by the artists themselves. Technically they are not sharing music since you cannot download it, which is why I would guess they get around a lot of things that way.
- njharman 16y agoThe Dream was over a while back when digital music and Internet got popular. Apple iTunes store kind of brought it back except Apple as the dreamer not Record Labels. The Dream being control over distribution. Selling over and over the same product. Selling lots crap (most songs on album) on the backs of 1 or 2 hits. Being the gatekeeper between artists and their fans. Near monopolistic control over supply and demand. All of it, a cash fucking cow. Over, for the Record Labels. Although they're doing a damn good job at legislating their dream into law. Their government mandated welfare will live on similar to but more insidious than farm/corn lobbies subsidy program. And just like corn subsidy it(warping of copyright) will fuck the rest of us for decades.
- steveklabnik 16y agoIt seems to me like too many bands are trying to be startups. More bands should try to be lifestyle businesses.
- 66-75-63-6b 16y agoThis was a foregone conclusion when the labels set this policy several years ago. Clearly this former president of Grokster is still telling the same story. An interesting bit of insider info I have - a relative of mine is a young Sony VP. Apparently their senior executive still wants their digital people to explain things in terms of 8 tracks and tapes. No exaggeration.
- protomyth 16y agoI still don't get how an artist actually makes money on a streaming service. It seems pretty good for the labels, but not for the artists. I know people say artist should make their money off other things, but their are some good artists who do poorly in a concert venue.
- oo7jeep 16y agoSo what will music look like in 5 - 10 years? Still just iTunes and streaming? Lets not forget labels aren't sustainable businesses in their current form.
- pontifier 16y agoI can show you what I think it will be like. I have developed a media distribution system that is unlike anything that I have seen before. I will be opening it up to a limited number of people soon, and when I do, I can give you a code that will let you create an account.
- stcredzero 16y agoNobody’s going to pay Google $25 a year to store their music in a cloud. What if cloud hosting was bundled with MobileMe or the initial sale of an iPod? I bet Apple could get people to pay $12.50 additional hidden in the price of the iPod and $12.50 as an add-on.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoSomewhat related, what's the status nowadays of un-DRM'ing music you've purchased, say from iTunes Store, to play on other players, particularly on Linux? Is it possible? What if you don't have access to Windows or OSX (to burn an non-DRM cd)? Legal?
- ptomato 16y agoiTunes Store music isn't DRMed, at all. Neither is music from the Amazon music store.
- SkyMarshal 16y agoIt used to be, young grasshopper, it used to be. I still have a bunch of DRM'd iTunes music I bought years ago when all iTunes music was DRM'd, and want to be able to listen to on Linux now. And yes, Amazon is my savior for unecumbered music. I'm a very happy customer of theirs. But they weren't always around.
- run4yourlives 16y agoI don't know if it was just me growing up, but music changed dramatically right after Napster was forced to kill itself. Perhaps someone else can support this: "Music" has never been the same since then. It seemed so much more available, so much more pervasive, more frequently invasive to my life; better than it is now. Like I said, I've grown. But it seems that as the generation behind me moved online in a major way, the music didn't quite follow. Its not that you can't find great music these days, it's that - ironically - it is so much more difficult to do so. I don't see this ever changing really. The blip that was the 20 century music industry is dead and gone, replaced with essentially a long tail market of grains of sand of that - occasionally if you look hard enough - has a couple of diamonds hidden away in obscurity. But then again, maybe I'm just getting old.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- steveklabnik 16y ago"But I have a take on that - people only made money out of records for a very, very small time. When The Rolling Stones started out, we didn't make any money out of records because record companies wouldn't pay you! They didn't pay anyone! Then, there was a small period from 1970 to 1997, where people did get paid, and they got paid very handsomely and everyone made money. But now that period has gone. So if you look at the history of recorded music from 1900 to now, there was a 25 year period where artists did very well, but the rest of the time they didn't." - Mick Jagger: http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8681410.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/entertainment/8681410.stm
- run4yourlives 16y agoVery interesting quote, thank you!
- InclinedPlane 16y agoThe old guard is losing power, their business models are failing, their control is going away. A new dream is starting. A different dream than the fantasy of being "discovered" by a major record label and becoming rich and famous overnight (which translated into a reality that often didn't quite match up to the dream, for the bands or for their fans). A new dream where increasingly many artists are bootstrapping themselves into making a living from their music without big record labels interfering with their creative process, sucking the bulk of the profits away with little in exchange, and adding layers of corporate bullshit between artists and fans. Instead, bands are connecting directly with fans, selling music directly to fans, producing their own albums on their own schedules and releasing them however they like for whatever prices they wish to charge, and making the lion's share of the profits for themselves. This is happening right now. Spreading right now. Becoming the new way that music is produced and distributed. It's something to look forward to. The music industry is dead! Long live the music industry!
- olalonde 16y agoHow about funding a startup which would also act as a label? Long shot (you would need to sign big names) but the rewards would be huge.
- Groxx 16y ago>Nobody’s going to pay Google $25 a year to store their music in a cloud. I probably would. $25/year for my collection would make it by far the cheapest file hosting available, and as I have a couple machines and a couple OSes, being able to consolidate everything, synchronize everything, and actually keep my ratings of songs across different systems would be wonderful. Most places I go I can stream music, so I wouldn't even need to keep most / any of it on my devices.
- wyclif 16y agoRemember Google Wave and Buzz? Yeah, except the verdict on Buzz isn't in yet.
- throwawaymuso 16y agoThis is a throw away account, I would prefer to remain anonymous. I work for a digital music startup and am privy to the kinds of tactics and ridiculousness that the major labels engage in on a regular basis. I should note however that I am a developer, not one of the guys that do the deal cutting as primary focus. For example; they're well aware DRM does not work, but their insistence on the implementation of DRM is absolutely not focused anymore on the idea that they can stop piracy, but that they can implement market segmentation and suck the profit out of the kind of content that people actually want. Case in point; digital music startup that charges a subscription for global access to a large library of content from the major labels charges a flat fee to the customer and is charged by the record labels on a pay per play basis, thus the effective margin that the startup makes is a function of (average amount of plays per user / subscription cost per month) - price paid to record label for the play. It turns out that if you do not use DRM for your player the record label leaves you around a 10% per play margin (on quite a hefty monthly subscription fee). With DRM it's much much more profitable for the startup in question, they bank on DRM being so repellent to customers that the startup will pay the much higher rate for DRM free. They also micromanage the hell out of the details of implementation, for example they have a specific set of "acceptable DRM" standards which you must adhere to to be eligible for the rates in question. There have been negotiations running for months with them just to get approval to run the same kind of streaming clients as the web service provides available as applications to android / iPhone clients. When considering implementing AWS for site infrastructure one of the objections raised by the music companies was that "they don't want their music on the cloud". Effectively it chokes what it is possible to do in the market, inflates the prices, and makes the entire offering far less appealing. It does seem like they're headed for destruction but they seem just as steadfast in their refusal to amend their course.
- loanshark 16y agoWhy, hello there Grooveshark.
- robryan 16y agoGo me thinking, wonder how successful it would be if someone like apple wrote a program to determine people pirating music then sent then somehow got in contact to them with a link to buy, like the Microsoft anti piracy strategy with windows. On the whole would probably be more successful than the lawsuit path. Another idea for a service, something that scans a computer for pirated music, lets a user select which albums they would like to buy and offers a big discount.
- elblanco 16y agoMaybe the real answer is an entirely new label, having to start from zero (sign on new artists, establish new distribution channels, etc.), but with a corporate philosophy diametrically opposite the existing market and simply subvert the whole thing. Small labels like https://www.candyrat.com/ https://www.candyrat.com/ are signing on new and growing artists. it's not like the major labels have much in the way of good music to offer these days anyways
- pontifier 16y agoGod... This whole debacle is a true indicator that the patent office should just grant my patent already. I have a non-obvious solution that has solid legal grounding. If anyone is interested I am going to be handing out a bunch of trial membership codes to interested parties in a few days...