5 ms·
In the 60s, there was a rather famous project where scientists thought that solving image recognition will take them few months at most. It's 2018 and the best
by gambiting 8y ago
In the 60s, there was a rather famous project where scientists thought that solving image recognition will take them few months at most. It's 2018 and the best algorithms on the planet will answer with 99% confidence that a sofa in a zebra print is in fact, a zebra, unless they were very specifically trained against this scenario.
I feel this exact same thing is happening with autonomous cars - yes, it's possible to get them to be extremely good at recognising the road and surroundings - but the last few percent, those crucial few percent that make the technology actually usable, I don't see those happening for another 50 years at least.
- nostrademons 8y agoMy unpopular (to me, even) prediction is that wartime will be the catalyst that makes self-driving cars ubiquitous. In times of peace having a car that kills its occupant even 1/10,000 of the time is unacceptable. In times of war having a car (or more likely, truck/tanker/tank) with no occupant is a huge competitive advantage, because someone is actively trying to kill the occupant. Build something with even a 90% chance of crashing and you still win, because you can take people off the battlefield entirely while your opponent loses precious soldiers with every vehicle that's destroyed. Then after the war, people's risk tolerances get reset because quibbling over a 1/10,000 chance of death seems ridiculous when people have been actively trying to kill you for the last 5 years and a countable percentage of your friends are now dead. The way global politics is going we probably don't even have to wait 10 years for this.
- zazen 8y agoYou seem to have a war like WW2 in mind. But a war between big powers in the 21st century couldn't drag on for five years while you frantically work on new technology. Even without use of nukes, one side or the other is going to be flattened a lot faster than in the days when bombers used propellers. Now, a new Cold War, that might push technological competition, although you won't get that "reset" of people's attitudes that you're after.
- reitzensteinm 8y agoIt sounds more like he has a war like Iraq and Afghanistan in mind. Imagine resupply convoys being driven autonomously, capable of launching drones for defense. https://www.army-technology.com/features/feature77200/ https://www.army-technology.com/features/feature77200/ "[...] every 55,702 barrels of fuel burned in Afghanistan by the US military forces corresponded to one casualty."
- Cthulhu_ 8y agoI've seen a number of projects already for self-driving supply trucks, and even walkers from Boston Dynamics. There's a (probably highly scripted) one featured in a later episode of Top Gear, for example.
- zazen 8y agoWell, you probably won't have to wait 10 years for another non-peer war like that. I think he's envisaging a big peer war with mass mobilization ala WW1/WW2, but he imagines such a war would be like a big Iraq/Afghanistan. It wouldn't.
- larkeith 8y agoIt seems like it might be feasible for a proxy war (like the one in Syria) to escalate significantly, to the point where multiple major powers are contributing manpower and materiel directly to the front lines; In such a case, it may be possible for an extended war to take place, while still incentivizing deployment of autonomous weaponized platforms - which are already in development today [1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_autonomous_weapon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lethal_autonomous_weapon
- close04 8y ago> It sounds more like he has a war like Iraq and Afghanistan in mind. Imagine [...] So... that would make them exactly the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. If that were the case we wouldn't have to imagine, we'd have the results in the field already. So that war must be of a different kind. Not the kind where you already have technical superiority and have 0 incentive to develop it because you can already make truckloads of money by supplying current generation equipment to the front lines. It has to be a war where developing the new tech is the difference between your country existing or not a decade or more from now. That's a special kind of war. It could be a cold war but it's unlikely to have one of those in the same way the one from the 20th century unfolded. And if that kind of "hot" war is the only one that can bring these improvements I'd rather stick to driving my own car and labeling my own photo library :).
- golergka 8y agoFor this logic to work, both opponents need to value soldier's life equally high. Only western, first-world countries do this. Why would two different first-world countries go into a hot war one against the other?
- TeMPOraL 8y agoIsn't that mostly Hollywood illusion? That the Americans are the Good Guys, paragons of morality and protectors of all that is alive, while everyone in "backward countries" treats their own as cannon fodder?
- golergka 8y agoNo, I'd say from personal experience that Hollywood severely downplays reality here. Typical american movies feature villains and antagonists who are still pretty "americanized" in terms of culture.
- hutzlibu 8y agoWell, it depends. The armys certainly do value their highly trained soldiers and pilots. Just alone for.the fact that they invested a lot od time.and money in them. And during normal times also the ones of the average grunt, because the public does not like casualities. But in a serious war, nobody cares too much about a normal soldier.
- adrianN 8y agoProsthetics, exoskeletons, and brain-computer interfaces too.
- nicodjimenez 8y agoYour comment is insightful and hilarious.
- nostrademons 8y ago...and terrifying, I hope, once you get past the hilarity.
- nradov 8y agoThe military agrees with you. The DARPA Grand Challenge was what really got autonomous ground vehicle research going. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Grand_Challenge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Grand_Challenge The US Army is still putting funding into a variety of autonomous vehicle programs. For example they want to send a convoy of vehicles to resupply a remote outpost without putting human drivers at risk.
- squirrelicus 8y agoThe reasons I don't believe you're correct are (a) in war, most ground truck transport already involves transporting non driver humans. Boots are indefinitely the workhorse of occupation, (b) active remote control works great in situations where human drivers create extraordinary risk, (c) it might never even be possible to create self driving cars that perform better than humans, no matter how much the military wants it or how many years are invested.
- denzil_correa 8y ago> In the 60s, there was a rather famous project where scientists thought that solving image recognition will take them few months at most. What project was this?
- tome 8y agoProbably a reference to this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_vision#History https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Computer_vision#History
- code_duck 8y agohttps://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1425:_Tasks https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/1425:_Tasks
- FabHK 8y agoI thought it might have been a reference to (LISP inventor) McCarthy's famous Dartmouth Conference in 1956, where they thought that 10 people over 2 months could make "significant advances" in making machines "use language, form abstractions and concepts, solve kinds of problems now reserved for humans, and improve themselves". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dartmouth_workshop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dartmouth_workshop EDIT: Probably the Summer Vision Project, as Tome said in sibling comment. https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/6125 https://dspace.mit.edu/handle/1721.1/6125
- dalbasal 8y agoTo me, a fundamental question is "is this a problem?" Humans have similar problems too. Our intelligence is trained by experience and evolution to operate within certain parameters. More concerning to me is the fact that a human can conceptualize "couch" from a single example. ML algorithims needs to see thousands of couches before they can classify them.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- ksdale 8y agoPreface: I didn't intend for this to be so long... I just got on a roll... I'm not sure it's true that we conceptualize couch from a single example. We've all seen thousands of couches in many different contexts, homes, schools, doctor's offices, on TV. If you had a person who had never seen a couch or a zebra before, and all you could tell them was right or wrong, it would probably take them (a lot?) more than a single try before they could distinguish between couch and zebra without fail. The only reason it's easy for us is that we have this giant scaffolding built around zebras as living things that look like a horses and donkeys, and couches as inanimate objects that look like things people sit on and regularly have some pattern on them. I think people tend to underestimate just how much "training" in the ML sense goes into a human brain. After all, humans spend the first... decade? of life incapable of all but the simplest tasks. That's a decade in which our brains are consuming petabytes of information and processing it constantly. Watching my children grow up, the way they learn seems remarkably similar to the way computers learn. If you watch a baby learn to move, it is purely an exercise in going too far in one direction and then too far in the other direction, repeated for basically years until they're coordinated enough to move roughly like an adult by the time they're 3 or so. It's the same with words and concepts too, they're just guessing based on things they already know (and the guesses are often waaaay off, because they don't yet know much), but they're constantly filing things away into their frameworks until their frameworks get big enough that this too resembles the way adults learn. By the time we're adults, the human brain makes ML algorithms look pathetic, but that doesn't take into the account the decades long head start that our brains got.