5 ms·
The fact that they have to explicitly state "effective" every time, along with a footnote that vaguely explains "Based on image sensor effective pixel specifica
by userbinator 8y ago
The fact that they have to explicitly state "effective" every time, along with a footnote that vaguely explains "Based on image sensor effective pixel specification method", strongly suggests that this isn't actually a 48MP sensor.
...and indeed, the link in the other comment here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17597939 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17597939 explains it best: "This requires processing to convert the 'Quad Bayer' data into an approximation of what a 48MP Bayer sensor would have captured."
- foobar1962 8y agoAll single-sensors cameras are like this. Each of the R-G-B sensitive photoreceptors in single-chip sensors are arranged using a Bayer filter pattern which looks like a mosaic. The filter pattern is 50% green, 25% red and 25% blue. The "pixels" of the final image needs to be calculated from this pattern (called de-mosaicing or de-bayering). There is not a 1-to-1 correlation between RGB pixels in the sensor and RBG pixels in the final image, and the final image size may depend on different algorithms to remove artefacts caused by the filter. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bayer_filter
- ivanech 8y agoThis sensor is different. R, G, and B each have their own 2x2 blocks which are arranged into the Bayer pattern over a 4x4 block. Conversion to the full 48 MP is a step beyond Bayer demosaicing.
- DrStalker 8y agoThere are exceptions like the Foveon sensor where the red, green and blue sensors are stacked behind each other or monochrome sensors with interchangeable filters used in scientific applications, but those are not found in common consumer level cameras. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor
- frozenport 8y agoThey also have some amount of cross talk, and overall are hard to justify compared to a conventional sensor.
- patrickg_zill 8y agoSigma does in fact sell Foveon sensor based cameras. The latest is the "SD quattro" (APS-C 1.5x crop from 35mm full frame) and "SD quattro H" (slightly larger, about 1.3x crop). I used an earlier Foveon the "quattro dp2" (APS-C, 45mm focal length equivalent), they have different characteristics from Bayer cameras. They get high marks from landscape photographers where the shooting uses the lowest ISO setting and fast operation is not required. They have less dynamic range, however given the amount of investment into Bayer tech vs. Sigma's spending on Foveon, that might just be due to more advanced engineering of Bayer and not something inherent in the Foveon design. The DP Review forum for Sigma cameras: https://www.dpreview.com/forums/1027 https://www.dpreview.com/forums/1027
- bitL 8y agoQuattro is unfortunately no longer "true Foveon", as they do something akin to 4:1:1 downsampling, making it more Bayer-like, IMO obliterating the main advantage so apparent on Merrill sensors - when I take a picture of a model face on a top-end Nikon, I can see "mushy" areas on the skin all the time when zoomed it, moire on clothes, whereas with Merrill I get unbelievable sharpness (like individual hair); I can't go back to Bayer as it can't be unseen and working with Bayer-like cameras just leaves a deep sense of artistic dissatisfaction. Also, when shooting clouds on Merrill, the dynamic range is way better than any camera I've seen; some call it "cloud camera" for this reason.
- Dylan16807 8y agoDoes the output from a Bayer pattern bother you like that when you shrink it to 50%? Because "100%" means two very different things between those kinds of sensor.
- 8y ago
- brudgers 8y agoThe Foveon sensors [1] have stacked diodes at each pixel instead of a Bayer (or similar [2]) sensor. The Foveon sensors don't require demosaicing. Some more recent cameras move the Bayer filter one pixel two additional times to capture and record each color for a single image [3] with some obvious limitations for moving subjects. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foveon_X3_sensor [2]: e.g. Fuji's X-trans, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fujifilm_X-Trans_sensor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fujifilm_X-Trans_sensor [3]: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/explora/photography/tips-and-solutions/pixel-shift-shootout-olympus-vs-pentax-vs-sony-vs-panasonic https://www.bhphotovideo.com/explora/photography/tips-and-so...
- magicalhippo 8y agoTrying to capture some nice sunset photos while on a bike trip yesterday got me thinking, with these high MP sensors could one use an augmented Bayer filter to get higher dynamic range? Instead of just the same RGB pixel filters all over, mix in pixel filters which are darker (passes less light). Then use this info during de-Bayering to construct a HDR image directly. Maybe a very silly idea, but would have been fun to play around with (maybe I'll write a simulator).
- foobar1962 8y agoYou’d be decreasing overall image resolution. HDR is as simple as taking multiple exposures and different EV values. It was often down with sheet film cameras, the two negatives being used to create the final print.
- magicalhippo 8y agoTaking multiple exposures is not always simple to perform with good results. It requires a fairly static scene and camera. And I doubt most people really need effective 48 MP mobile cameras. They could very well do with more dynamic range though.
- ipsum2 8y agoThey do this on certain cameras, look up "Dual ISO". Effectively they make every other line more sensitive, increasing dynamic range when they merge the lines together. It's not a perfect solution, moire and other artifacts increase, and you lose resolution. The trade-offs are often worth it, especially for video.
- magicalhippo 8y agoThanks, that search term did indeed show some interesting hits.
- chaboud 8y agoFuji did this with “Super CCD” sensors in the early 2000s. They used micro lenses, which had some overall sensitivity and angled aliasing challenges, but the results were impressive for the time. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_CCD https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_CCD
- Dylan16807 8y agoThe existence of de-mosaicing doesn't stop the question from being answered, it just means different use cases get different amounts of quality. Since they listed the image element size as .8 micrometers, we can do simple math to see that they're quoting the biggest possible number. There are 48M small color cells, 12M big color cells, and 3M RGGB cells. So your luma data is amazing, and your chroma data is garbage.
- namibj 8y agoWhat about using a color wheel and high readout speeds? Did anyone try how this works for video with an equivalent color wheel and a DLP? This obviously assumes the sensor is fabricated without a Bayer filter.
- snowwrestler 8y agoSome previous examples of "effective" megapixels: - The Nikon D1x had about 6 million rectangular photon wells on the sensor. But by doubling them up in processing (to make square final pixels), Nikon claimed about 10 million effective pixels. Needless to say, when actual 10 MP sensors debuted (sensors with 10 million photon wells), everyone stopped using their D1x's. - Fuji used a diagonal array of photon wells on the sensor in the Finepix S2 camera, and claimed that through interpolation, this provided 12 megapixels of effective resolution. Again, once actual 12 MP sensors debuted, the difference was obvious. - Sigma used a Foveon sensor with about 3.5 million photon wells in their S9, but because each photon well independently sensed red, green, and blue wavelengths (at different depths in the well), Sigma claimed a "3x factor" that allowed their software to produce about 10 million effective pixels in the final image. How'd that go... you guessed it, the vast majority of people preferred sensors with 10 million photon wells. In short, there are plenty of examples of using computer processing to produce a high number of "effective" pixels, but that doesn't mean the final image will meet user expectations. I predict a pretty obvious difference between an "effective" 48 MP image from this stacked sensor array, vs. an image from, say, a Nikon D850. That said, even though it's a compromise... compromises sometimes make sense. A D850 is very heavy and very expensive. EDIT to add: The D1x was good enough to convince National Geographic to use that camera for their first all-digital photo story. I went to the live event at Nat Geo headquarters where they had some 20x30 prints on display, and they did look amazing. I believe they took the D1x 10MP image and sized it up using Genuine Fractals. http://www.robgalbraith.com/multi_pageff3f.html?cid=7-6450-6561 http://www.robgalbraith.com/multi_pageff3f.html?cid=7-6450-6...