6 ms·
Maybe true if you’re targeting the senior talent who got in early enough to buy houses and have kids, but all the 20-somethings I know (myself included) plan to
by closeparen 8y ago
Maybe true if you’re targeting the senior talent who got in early enough to buy houses and have kids, but all the 20-somethings I know (myself included) plan to get out within 5 years, barring a drastic increase in compensation. I suspect there is a large, untapped market of disaffected young engineers who moved here to start their careers but would move to a second-tier city for the right job.
- joefranklinsrs 8y agoThere are still alot of cheap real estates along the BART and caltrain stops https://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit-stop https://www.estately.com/bay-area-home-affordability-transit... Pittsburg/Bay Point $430,000 Blossom Hill $657,000 San Jose $680,000 And the largest job growth recently has been East Bay, around Pleasanton. If you are young and starting out, making $110-140k, try living in east bay or san jose and rent a room for $1k - 1.5k, you should be able to save enough money for a down payment for a house soon enough. The stories I've heard for people that couldn't afford their rent, are people living in $3k apartments in SF.
- closeparen 8y agoSure, you can always trade off privacy and commute time to make the numbers work out. But not having to do that is an incredibly compelling form of compensation that companies can provide at minimal cost by offering work elsewhere. This is not a thing for white collar workers almost anywhere else in the US.
- WillEngler 8y agoLet me try and complicate this :) First, I submit that $430,000 is still expensive. Instead of buying the median home in Pittsburg and commuting 60+ minutes on BART to downtown SF, I could add an h and buy a huge home in my favorite neighborhood in Pittsburgh PA for about the same price and have a chill bicycle commute: https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Pittsburgh-PA/pmf,pf_pt/house,condo_type/11288076_zpid/26529_rid/ https://www.zillow.com/homes/for_sale/Pittsburgh-PA/pmf,pf_p... (Obvious and legitimate objections: fewer job options, snow.) This is just me trying to say, $430k for that arrangement does not strike me as "cheap" given alternatives in other metros. I agree that with a tech salary it's possible to save up for a down payment and buy in the Bay Area. But the risk seems unacceptable to me. Paying ~$1M for a house is a big bet that the Bay Area housing market stays hot. I don't want my wealth to be so tied up in a hyperlocal bet like that. I see things going one of two ways (and this is probably over-simplistic). Option 1: A $1M starter home is the new normal. Prices stay flat or keep rising over the long haul. In that case my investment is sound. But I don't want to live in that kind of place. Where will my kids' teachers live? How will I cope with the moral ickiness of living in a place where housing costs create extreme spatial segregation of the professional class from the service class? Option 2: The vision painted above is unsustainable. Something has to give (maybe a big financial crash; maybe just state-mandated upzoning that quickly increases housing supply) and the value of my investment drops by a lot. Either way, I'm planning to save up on the West Coast and use my nest egg back in the Rust Belt.
- joefranklinsrs 8y agoYou make compelling arguments. For me, a house isn't an investment but it's a place where I house my family. (sure, houses in silicon valley have gone up 1.5-2X in a few years. However, stocks have gone up 2-10X). If you're young, there's no point of getting a house. If you are close to have a family, one of the most important thing is KEEPING your job. If you are remote in Pittsburg, and you have to get a new job, it might take a few months of interviewing and flying in for interviews to find a remote job that pays your old salary. Do you want to risk that even to your family? most likely you wouldn't. You have 18 years of mortgage and college tuitions to pay for.
- WillEngler 8y agoAgreed on most of what you're saying here. > For me, a house isn't an investment but it's a place where I house my family. I really want to view the world this way :) I wish housing were a boring commodity that depreciates in value over time like a car. With prices being what they are, I am _forced_ to think of housing as an investment because of how much of my net worth will be tied up in it.
- fro0116 8y agoExactly this. A house _is_ an investment, regardless of how someone wants to think about it. Buying a house involves a significant opportunity cost over renting since it requires locking up capital (a down payment, or the entire value of the house if buying in cash) in an illiquid asset that could have been invested in liquid assets like stocks (that have historically performed better than real estate over longer time horizons for most housing markets, and often more than makes up for the fixed costs of renting once maintenance costs, taxes, and mortgage interest rates are taken into account, but that's only tangential to the point I'm trying to make). Also, most people buy their houses on mortgages, so they're investing with 5-10x leverage over the down payment and paying interest for that leverage. This level of leverage would be considered outright insane for any other long term investment, but most people won't even think twice before locking a large majority of their net worth behind a down payment. This puts their financial well-being at the mercy of the whims of the local real estate market due to the 5-10x amplified gains/losses, and practically removes their ability to meaningfully diversify and de-risk their portfolio. Now of course I'm not saying buying a house can never make sense financially or otherwise, just that refusing to think of it as an investment can be dangerous because it can blind you to the nuanced risk/reward calculations involved in one of the most impactful financial decisions you can make in your lifetime. For myself, the right time to buy a house would likely have to be when I've saved up enough money that the upfront investment for the purchase of the house is about 30% of my net worth if I'm buying with cash, or less than 10% of my net worth if I'm buying with a mortgage, to counteract the extra exposure to real-estate from the 5-10x leverage. That may mean that the time to buy a house in the Bay Area may never come for me, but I'm perfectly fine with that because the alternative would compromise my ability to keep my investments reasonably liquid and diversified, which could prove to be disastrous in these uncertain financial times ahead of us.
- aphextron 8y agoHave you ever tried commuting from Pittsburg/Bay Point? Have you seen what $680k will buy you in San Jose? These are not at all practical suggestions. The outlook for a 20 something engineer in the Bay Area is absolutely brutal. The people who got in 10 years ago are doing ok so long as the housing market keeps up. But there's nothing left here for anyone trying to start a life.
- joefranklinsrs 8y ago> commuting from Pittsburg/Bay Point? As I mentioned, the biggest job growth recently have been in east bay. You'll likely have good chances finding jobs closeby. > $680k will buy you in San Jose Google is heavily investing in downtown San Jose, buying up lands. There's also the transbay joinup of BART and caltrain.
- closeparen 8y agoThe current optimistic estimate for Caltrain Downtown Extension (and we know what happens to estimates for transit-related projects in SF) is 2027.
- jmspring 8y agoThe Bart commute from Pittsburgh to Pleasanton isn’t a short hop.
- fooker 8y agoA similar property near downtown Salt Lake City is $250k. For the right job, I would absolutely prefer that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- iman453 8y agoWould you have any source for the largest job growth being around Pleasanton. Would love to read up more on it.
- trevyn 8y agoFWIW, Purchasing a house and having children are no longer desirable goals for a substantial number of people. Looking at trendlines and extrapolating is a pretty good way to see the future.
- closeparen 8y agoThe goal is shifting from “large suburban house” to “central urban condo,” I suppose, but is there evidence for decline in desire to have kids? Actual both rate can be explained by people delaying gratification for economic reasons.
- nimish 8y agoThis was the same "millennials don't want to do X" argument you heard a few years ago. That started to stop once millennials got enough cash to do X. A major, major confounding issue is simply not having the money. Of course you'll see a trend of fewer people buying homes if home prices are so high that fewer people can afford them.
- WillEngler 8y agoI think some smart companies in "third tier" cities are tapping this. There are some hilarious targeted ads I see for an Austin company (HomeAway) that prominently shows the median home price in Austin and a link to their open jobs. Similarly, Duolingo (Pittsburgh-based) put up a billboard in SF advertising the prospect of working in tech AND owning a home: https://venturebeat.com/2018/03/23/duolingo-to-silicon-valley-workers-move-to-pittsburgh-where-you-can-actually-afford-a-home/ https://venturebeat.com/2018/03/23/duolingo-to-silicon-valle...
- lsc 8y agoThe problem with second-tier cities, as I see them, is that you have to move every time you get a new job, if you are maximizing your income/career. (I mean, not doing that is totally valid, but it's important to factor in the "I took a worse job because it was closer to the house that it would be expensive for me to abandon" thing into your expense/utility calculations. keep in mind that reduced job choice can mean increased stress and unpleasantness as much or more than it can mean simply getting less money.) I think if you work in tech, silicon valley is pretty unique in that there are so many really desirable employers within a short distance. I'd be comfortable buying a house here even if it meant that it makes it really expensive if I want a job more than 15 miles out.
- closeparen 8y agoThe novelty of eye-popping direct deposits has worn off; the rate at which I shovel money from venture capital to real estate brings me no particular joy. Maximizing income can only inch me closer to the quality of living situation I'd have elsewhere. The point at which I'd be done increasing housing budget, and actually free to increase other investments or luxury consumption, does not appear attainable. (Consider savings for a down payment as part of housing budget here. And if I could buy a starter home, my next priority would be fixing either the commute time or neighborhood safety compromise that made it a starter home). I'm not sure why maximizing income in the Bay Area is worthwhile. The pay here, while much higher in nominal terms, seems to level off well below my level of comfort for standard of living (and my parents who got me accustomed to it were in much less lucrative fields). I stay becuase I like the work and the company, because why not take this opportunity while I'm young? But it's an indulgent youthful adventure, not a sustainable long-term plan.
- lsc 8y ago>I'm not sure why maximizing income in the Bay Area is worthwhile. The pay here, while much higher in nominal terms, seems to level off well below my level of comfort for standard of living so, assuming you are a medium density type and can stomach an apartment with reasonable soundproofing, you are spending $3000/month on rent here, for a reasonably okay 1 bedroom apartment. (if you are willing to take a hit in quality, you can get more bedrooms or even a bad single family home for about that price) So you move to a second-tier city and you get the same thing for $1500/month. Now, I don't make twice here what I would in a second-tier city, but I do make rather more than an extra $1500 a month.