5 ms·
This is a great outcome, but it is amazing that the appeal opinion requires 40 pages when, in essence, the question is only whether people subject to US laws mu
by rahimnathwani 8y ago
This is a great outcome, but it is amazing that the appeal opinion requires 40 pages when, in essence, the question is only whether people subject to US laws must pay to know what the law is.
What's interesting about the case and the legal opinion is that public.resource.org's use is considered fair use, but it's still the case that public.resource.org must pay to get an initial copy of each standard, before it can be published on that site.
So access to the law is still not free of charge.
- rayiner 8y agoIt's not an easy case at all (and in fact, the court punts on the big-picture question, deciding the case instead on fair use). There are two separate issues: (1) "whether people subject to US laws must pay to know what the law is," and (2) whether a legislative body can deprive the private entity of copyright protection in a work by incorporating that work by reference into a law or regulation. Answering "yes" to the first question does not resolve this case, where a legislative body incorporated a private entity's technical standard by reference, without the private entity abandoning copyright in that work. The question is, what happens now? Does the copyrighted work automatically become public domain (what public.resource.org argued)? Or does the copyright remain valid, but instead we find the legislative body in violation of its obligation to ensure public access to the law (and, perhaps, find the law invalid on that basis)? It is not necessarily the case, as public.resource.org argued, that the requirement of public access automatically eliminates copyright in standards that have been incorporated by reference. It may instead create an affirmative obligation on the part of legislative bodies to enter into appropriate arrangements with the private entities that develop the standards.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoYes, I didn't mean to suggest it was an easy case. I only read half the opinion but can see that there are several issues, and many citations of precedent to support the opinion. But, as a non-lawyer, the fact that this level of analysis of statute and case law is required in order to make such a small step toward making the law accessible, is amazing. (EDIT: I mean, I understand that it is this way, but don't feel it should be this way) I say it's a small step because: - as you say, the court confirmed fair use, but did not consider the question of whether copyright is extinguished - each referenced standard is still locked behind payment until and unless this site or another pays for a copy and scans it If, as you suggest might be the case, it is the "obligation of legislative bodies to ensure public access to the law by refraining from incorporating obligations from sources that are not publicly accessible", then what becomes of those laws which reference standards which are not publicly accessible today? Do they become unconstitutional or void, until such time that the standards do become publily accessible? Would publication on public.resource.org be enough to count as 'publicly accessible'? And if it turns out that copyright is actually extinguished due a document's to incorporation (by reference) into law, would the former copyright owner have grounds to seek damages against the legislature? EDIT: in your subsequent edit you sort of answered one of my questions "(and, perhaps, find the law invalid on that basis)"
- rayiner 8y agoLet's step back. What is the principle we seek to vindicate? That principle is that the law should be accessible to those who are charged with following it. Courts, however, rule on specific cases, not general principles. This case requires 40 pages because that big-picture principle is only tangentially implicated, and the court and the parties have to engage in some contortions to get to it. Public.resource.org isn't charged with failing to follow a law that was not publicly available. That would be the straightforward test case, and the straightforward resolution would be to find the law invalid on that basis. Instead, what the court had before it was a copyright infringement action, where public.resource.org argued, as a defense, that distributing these standards should not be copyright infringement because they are necessary for people to understand the law. That adds an additional wrinkle--the court needs to not only address the end goal (making the law accessible), but the specific means public.resource.org chose to achieve that goal (distributing copyrighted standards). The complexity of the opinion, thus, arises out of the wrinkles of the test case brought by public.resource.org. I also submit that a lot of complexity arises from the fact that the court really doesn't want to do the most straightforward thing, which is to say: that the standards continue to be copyrighted, but these laws are all invalid for incorporating obligations by reference from works that are not public accessible. What really happened here is that over decades legislatures worked themselves into a pickle, publicly incorporating these standards without thinking about the implications vis-a-vis copyright and public access. Now, the court is stuck trying to avoid the outcome of declaring all these laws invalid.
- rahimnathwani 8y agoThank you for the further explanation. I'm intrigued by this part "... isn't charged with failing to follow a law that was not publicly available ... the straightforward resolution would be to find the law invalid on that basis." Are you aware of any cases where this has been tested? How would one go about finding such a case if it exists, or satisyfing oneself that no such case exists?
- TheCoelacanth 8y agoThe most straightforward outcome would be for the standard to be public domain, the laws to remain valid and for the former copyright owner to take the government to court if it doesn't like having its standard incorporated into the law.
- cryptonector 8y agoIt's not like legislatures are taking novels or source code for various OSes, apps, ..., and incorporating it into law in order to vitiate the relevant copyrights. These are laws written by third parties to be laws. In any case, both (1) and (2) could be answered "no" and still resolve this case -- legislatures would then have to rewrite those laws or acquire the copyrights on them. And, as you point out, (2) could be answered "yes, when the work is intended by its owners to be incorporated into laws" (which would immediately cease to be the case). Besides questions of how the courts have ruled / should rule on these issues, on what grounds, and so on, there's a policy question. I don't think we should want the law to not be in the public domain as a matter of policy. Question for the lawyers of HN: can governments take copyrights via eminent domain? Statutorily or constitutionally? Perhaps only national governments rather than State/provincial?
- test6554 8y agoWhat if someone writes a new law as a literary work about banning soft drinks or limiting sugar. They write hundreds of these literary laws in many different forms using lots of varying language with the specific intent to copyright it so that it makes it very difficult to draft an actual bill that bans soft drinks or limits sugar use in processed foods without violating some soda company's copyrights.
- YawningAngel 8y agoReproducing a document you did not reference coincidentally is not a copyright violation
- rayiner 8y agoASTM, etc., are composed of people who develop standards and use standards independently of any incorportation into any laws. ASTM predates the federal legislation encouraging incorporation of privately developed standards, on which public.resource.org relied, by almost a century. The laws are recognition of standards the industry had already designed for itself. ASTM members are mostly companies that design products to, and build according to, the standards. The monetization strategy of charging for the standards thus is simply the building industry taxing itself to support standards development. The interesting thing about this case is that there are three things (the standards model, open access laws, and reliance on expert technical standards) that all are desirable, standing alone. It’s the interaction between them that gets hairy.
- camgunz 8y agoI don't mean to come across as indignant or whatever, but I don't believe this case is complicated at all. US laws are public domain, and the legislature erred in assigning copyright for something in the public domain. This happens all the time, it's called plundering the commons, and the only reason the court "struggles" with it is that to identify it as such threatens to upend centuries of the practice (or, honestly, call out its own practice). The case itself isn't complicated. The corrupt intertwining of corporate interests and the US government is just a gross mess.
- rayiner 8y agoYou’re confusing the facts. The legislature didn’t assign copyright to something in the public domain. The standards were preexisting, privately developed and copyrighted. You’re asking for the exact opposite of “plundering the commons”—you’re asking for private property to be taken for public use without compensation.
- crankylinuxuser 8y agoSo, a serious question: We have eminent domain for property and the like. Why isn't it used for copyright/patents for purposes of the public good?
- rayiner 8y agoThe government does use eminent-domain like powers for patents: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_patent_use_(United_States) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Government_patent_use_(United_.... But using eminent domain costs money (the government must pay "just compensation"). That's a hard sell here. Take, for example, the ASTM standard on diesel fuel (an example used in the opinion). Only companies selling diesel fuel have to know what's in the standard--they are the ones charged with following the law, not Joe Everyday on the street. Using eminent domain would vindicate the abstract principle that the law should be freely accessible, but as a practical matter it would just save a few bucks for big companies that can afford to pay for the standards.
- tedajax 8y agoSorry to me this is the easiest decision on the planet. Free access to laws. I don't care about the bad business model of a company charging for something that shouldn't be charged for.
- adrianmonk 8y agoIt's easy to decide where you stand (at least for me it is) on the question of whether access should be free. It's less obvious what is the correct way to implement that. It would be perfectly reasonable for the state to just pay the standards body a fee for, essentially, help in writing the law. Legislatures already pay lawyers to formulate the legalese of regular laws, so paying for such a service would hardly be weird or out of place.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- pwg 8y agoReading through the meat of the 40 pages, the appeals court did two things: 1) reversed the lower courts summary judgement So public.resource.org ("PRO") "won" in the sense that the lower courts summary judgement was reversed, so PRO no longer has their hands tied by that summary judgement, for the moment. 2) remanded the case back to the lower court, because they found that there existed genuine issues of material fact such that the case was not suitable to be decided by summary judgement. And they remanded the case back to the lower court to analyze those genuine issues of material fact more carefully. What this means is that the case is not over, in fact, it has only just begun, because the appeals court has directed the lower court to analyze PRO's copying of the various standards under the copyright fair use doctrine to determine if each instance was, or was not, fair use. So this is not a "win" outright as in: one can copy the standards because they are referenced by the law. In fact, in more than a few locations in the decision the appeals court went out of their way to state that such a simple decision outcome was not possible for cases such as this. So the case continues, and PRO has more work to do to show, almost to a standard by standard basis, whether their copying was fair use based upon the standard, the law that incorporates it, and the directions given by the appeals court. However, the appeals court did indicate that there were quite a number of instances where, were the case facts developed sufficiently for them to render a decision on the merits, that many of PRO's copies might very well be seen as fair use copies. Other copies, maybe not so much. So it is a step in the right direction, but the situation is far from settled. edit: fix typo
- testplzignore 8y agoI found these bits quite entertaining: > the district court will need to develop a fuller record > Instead, it might consider directing the parties, who poorly served the court by treating the standards interchangeably, to file briefs addressing whether the standards are susceptible to groupings that are relevant to the fair use analysis. Pretty much calling out everyone involved on their laziness. I can imagine the judge shaking his head in disappointment when writing this opinion.
- alasdair_ 8y ago> it is amazing that the appeal opinion requires 40 pages when, in essence, the question is only whether people subject to US laws must pay to know what the law is. This is actually a tough case. Someone, or some organisation, spent a lot of time and money making a standard and protected it by copyright. They did not ask to be part of a law - that was something the people who made the law decided - and really, the people who made the law should have licensed the standards.
- rahimnathwani 8y ago"They did not ask to be part of a law" How do we know that they did not ask?
- DannyBee 8y ago"They did not ask to be part of a law". This is mostly false, actually. They exist as model codes to be a part of building codes in a lot of cases. They serve no other purposes. Nobody is sitting around making building codes as a hobby that are accidentally getting incorporated into law. Additionally, in the case such a thing did happen, the authors would have have recourse - not against the public, but against the government, for a taking.
- pwg 8y agoWhile I can't cite a source, it also would be very believable to learn that lobbyists from some of the larger standards orgs (the ones that more or less stand alone, like e.g. the NFPA) are encouraging politicians to actually reference "the standard" rather than write "law language" to define something already present in the standard. Potentially with a "back of the mind" thought by the lobbyist of "this will drive more sales for us".
- Anechoic 8y agoit also would be very believable to learn that lobbyists from some of the larger standards orgs [...]are encouraging politicians to actually reference "the standard This is true thought by the lobbyist of "this will drive more sales for us". This is not. The money just isn't all that much, the industries want standards incorporated into laws to that organizations have one well-tested set of rules to follow across the country, rather than having to follow dozens/hundreds/thousands of variations across various jurisdictions.