5 ms·
Cars destroy the environment (with the infrastructure needed to accommodate them) and are one of the primary drivers of climate change. We need technology to ma
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
Cars destroy the environment (with the infrastructure needed to accommodate them) and are one of the primary drivers of climate change. We need technology to make them obsolete, not to make more of them that can drive themselves (or not).
- eboyjr 8y agoThanks for playing Devil's Advocate. This technology applies to mobile transportation in general and it doesn't necessarily have to effect greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, I believe the infrastructure for producing cars applies to such a broad category in regards to driving climate change. The manufacturing industry needs to independently solve this problem.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoFor the record, I'm not playing Devil's Advocate. I believe self-driving cars are a terrible idea that is only piling more environmental damage on top of what ordinary cards already do. >> This technology applies to mobile transportation in general and it doesn't necessarily have to effect greenhouse gas emissions. Well, I don't know that there is any way to drive a fleet of some millions or billions of cars (once self-driving cars have been adopted widely, that is) that doesn't rely on burning fossil fuels, either directly or indirectly (to charge batteries etc). So how are they not going to affect greenhouse gas emmissions?
- darawk 8y agoSo, you would like to just get rid of cars? Do you have any idea the level of human suffering that would cause? If you're not proposing something as silly as eliminating them entirely, then you should want to make them more efficient.
- eanzenberg 8y agoThe pinnacle of thinking: let’s allow worldwide suffering so sea levels dont rise 3m in 100 years.
- bumholio 8y agoThe pinnacle of spin: paying 50c more for a gallon of gas in US will bring untold suffering to those desperate people in Africa who have no cars, no electricity and are generally carbon neutral by virtue of using dried dung as their only energy source.
- perl4ever 8y agoAfrican countries both utilize and export a certain amount of petroleum, FWIW. Not that it's an unmixed blessing.
- nugget 8y agoWon't autonomous driving eliminate something like 80 to 90 percent of private vehicle ownership, which is well on the way to obsolete? Once people are less tied to private vehicle ownership and open to any effective form of transportation, then adoption of new technology could become easier.
- simion314 8y ago>Won't autonomous driving eliminate something like 80 to 90 percent of private vehicle ownership, which is well on the way to obsolete? We do not know that this will happen, people won't like using public cars. Also the number of cars is not important as the number of kilometers those car run, the companies will try the best to maximize the number of kilometers the cars will run to maximize the profits so we may have people using cars even more instead of walking or public transport
- jogjayr 8y ago> we may have people using cars even more instead of walking or public transport You're aware buses are large automobiles right? Lyft Line with self-driving cars is effectively a more nimble, efficient, usable, and cheap bus network.
- simion314 8y agoYes, can you assume so good faith from my part and let me know what part of my argument is not clear or what you disagree with. My point is that if we get cheap or convenient cars to drive us around then this would increase number of kilometers done by cars. About buses you have say 30 people using a bus and the bus is driving 10 km, if people would use cars and say they will be 3 people in a car you get 10 cars x 10 km = 100km, so you get 9 more vehicles on the road , you get the more energy consumed since a bus is not consuming 10 times more then a car.
- jogjayr 8y agoMy apologies, I'm a bit annoyed by comments everywhere on this discussion that don't count shared taxis as public transport. I wrote in another comment that without congestion pricing or aggressive expansion of HOV lanes, the efficiency gains of self-driving cars would not be realized. Even without that we'd still have the increased road safety gains. > About buses you have say 30 people using a bus The problem is that it's difficult to match transport demand and supply perfectly because the bus is such a large unit of transport. The more common scenario is a close-to-empty (off-peak times, unpopular routes) or bursting-at-the-seams (peak times, popular routes) vehicle. Because the self-driving car is a smaller, more granular unit of transportation, you can deliver more targeted supply to the places where there's demand, at the exact times when there's demand.
- jliptzin 8y agoHumans destroy the environment, maybe we should get rid of them. I don't see how greenhouse emissions is relevant to this conversation. Obviously, we'd prefer to all be driving around (human operated or otherwise) in vehicles powered 100% by clean energy, and certainly people are working on that, but that's independent of whether or not those vehicles are operated by humans.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> Humans destroy the environment, maybe we should get rid of them. I belive genocide is against the law in most civilised societies, but, be my guest.
- gpm 8y ago<Not that it matters> Genocide isn't the right term here. Genocide is to wipe out a national group [0]. Rather we are looking for a word that means "to extinct a species" or alternatively "to extinct our own species". It looks like "extinguish" or "eradicate" is the closest word we have to the former [1]. I'm not aware of any word for the latter. <It matters even less, but> You could argue that to eradicate humans you would have to commit genocide several times. [0] https://www.etymonline.com/word/genocide https://www.etymonline.com/word/genocide [1] https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/253505/is-there-a-verb-form-of-extinct#253513 https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/253505/is-there-...
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> I don't see how greenhouse emissions is relevant to this conversation. More cars means more emissions, the industry wants to sell more cars by loading them with self-driving features, therefore the issue of emmissions is relevants. I mean, that's kind of like saying "I don't see how coronary heart disease is relevant to this conversation that's about selling more hamburgers", or "I don't see how diabetes is relevant to this conversation that's abot selling more sugary drinks".
- bumholio 8y ago
- nostrademons 8y agoIf you want to make them obsolete you need a rival technology that possesses all of the attributes that make people choose cars over mass transit, notably convenience, scheduling & destination flexibility, privacy, and cargo capacity. Failing that, self-driving cars as a service preserve all of these while also being significantly better for the environment. You don't need parking lots, because utilization is close to 100% and they go back to a depot when not required. It's easier to electrify the fleet, because the service knows exactly how far the trip will be and can bring the car back to a charging station while it has no passenger. You can share rides when multiple passengers have destinations that are close without them needing to go to the exact same place. You can have pods that dock with each other in motion (benefitting from better aerodynamics) but preserve privacy and split off to different destinations when needed.
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago>> If you want to make them obsolete you need a rival technology that possesses all of the attributes that make people choose cars over mass transit, notably convenience, scheduling & destination flexibility, privacy, and cargo capacity. Actually, since the goal should be the preservation of the environment that is supporting our continued existence, what is needed is mass transit, which is the least damaging form of (mechanised) transport we know of; not a technology to replace it with privately-owned and operated vehicles. I mean, I understand that's never going to happen, but that's only because we are collectively incapable of making the right decision on this one.
- bumholio 8y ago> what is needed is mass transit, Why mass transit and not walking more or personal blimps shaped like giant Trump babies? To make them more than your opinion, you need to put some numbers on those statements. And the numbers work much worse than you think: between the low energy efficiency and low occupancy at non-rush hours, the massive infrastructure and the longer routes due to non-optimal layout, mass transit is better than American gas guzzlers but nothing to write home about. Here's some numbers put up by people who share your opinion - and that do not even take all these effects into account: https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/11/can-we-please-stop-pretending-cars-are-greener-transit/3960/ https://www.citylab.com/transportation/2012/11/can-we-please... So for in-city transport, mass transit is a hard sell on environment alone. (Intercity transport like trains are great though, and there is a strong convergence there, self driving cars pair well with fast trains, giving the best of both worlds: flexibility, speed and low footprint)
- boulos 8y agoFwiw, the Jaguar i-Pace that Waymo will be using in addition to the minivan is all electric. Getting people into electric vehicles gives us the option to recharge them via power generated by renewables. That's a great way to reduce the rate of climate change, even if it's a small step. (The minivan helps if it really gets people to drive with more people per ride)
- tuxdev 8y agoAutonomous cars could allow space currently devoted to idle car storage to be reused for denser development patterns, which would reduce the need for car-based transport in the first place.