11 ms·
How Fake Money Saved Brazil
- frossie 16y ago"He said, 'Well, I've just been named the finance minister. You know I don’t know economics, so please come to meet me in Brasilia tomorrow,' " Bacha recalls. So, three things had to happen: 1. A politician had to admit his ignorance 2. Some bright spark technocrat somewhere had the right solution to a seemingly impossible problem. 3. The right politician asked for help from the right technocrat They're not kidding. It is a miracle.
- rbanffy 16y agoI can tell you it was a really remarkable time. The only minor inaccuracy is that we only impeached one president.
- gamble 16y agoIt only works the first time you try it. Afterward, everyone with a stake in the country's direction realizes that having a technocrat who shares your views and has personal access to the administration is a great way to influence policy. The money spigot opens, and pretty soon having the 'right' opinion is far better for your career than independence. Survivor bias eventually ensures that the technocracy is dominated by people with the 'right' opinion. And that's when you'll know that your country has achieved parity with the United States.
- rbanffy 16y ago> It only works the first time you try it. Once for every generation. Don't overestimate people's ability to remember. Besides, if you do it correctly, you only need to do it once. I don't trust the current favorite candidate to keep doing it right, BTW.
- joe_the_user 16y agoNo, It really only works once. Just like the New Deal only worked once and now every scam just claims it's the New, New Deal. Sure, the populace might have a memory of a generation but the technocrats have a longer memory and after first success, the next effort is dogged by the realization, "look what I'm going to get, look who I get to be..." (as the gp said, it's the careers of the technocrats one has to look at). I say this looking at the horrible, awful fail of the current president, a fail of what could have been the renewal of the country but by this very mechanism was fore-ordained to be a lurid catastrophe. Roosevelt sold out a lot to Wall Street too, btw, he just had a clean enough start to make his approach work. Really, These deals only work once per country...
- TGJ 16y agoThe New Deal never worked but oddly enough, it's trying to happen again. Bad deals happen over and over. The ones that work, the ones that require effort only happen once. http://newsroom.ucla.edu/portal/ucla/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonged-Depression-5409.aspx http://newsroom.ucla.edu/portal/ucla/FDR-s-Policies-Prolonge...
- jj_aa 16y agoMore accurately, some of the New Deal (deposit insurance, fiscal & monetary expansion, leaving the gold standard) worked, but some of it hurt. The fact that many countries suffered for just as long and worse, if not longer, without analogous policies makes me wary of the authors' modeling. > Recovery came only after the Department of Justice dramatically stepped enforcement of antitrust cases nearly four-fold and organized labor suffered a string of setbacks, the economists found. That wouldn't have been around 1939-45 or so, would it?
- dsspence 16y agoWhat part of the New Deal is 'oddly' happening again? $300 billion of the $862 billion dollar stimulus were either tax cuts or credits. Here is a link seemingly debunking that guise of an academic study: http://www.openleft.com/showDiary.do?diaryId=10644 http://www.openleft.com/showDiary.do?diaryId=10644 Fair warning it might cause cognitive dissonance.
- sethg 16y agoIf you’re a politician, it’s easier to admit your ignorance when your five predecessors who claimed to know what they were doing got brutally mugged by reality.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- rlander 16y agoAnd it definitely felt like one. You have no idea how much the country changed (for the better) because of this improbable miracle. Nobody believed it would work because the whole country had lost faith in "magical" economic reforms like the one before it, the Collor Plan. Imagine you wake up one day and all of your bank accounts are frozen - that's what happened to my parents (and most of the population) on March 16, 1990 when the Collor Plan was announced. It's your money, but you can't spend it - sorry. My father had been saving money in order to buy a new house. Years later he recovered less than 1/10 of the original sum. Lots of small businesses (including family and friends) went broke. When I talk to my parents about pre-real days it feels like they were born in a different country than I was.
- yardie 16y agoWow, I guess that explains the uptick in the brazilian population in South Florida during that time. One year of school I only knew one brazilian kid on the bus. The next year over half the bus was brazilian. Big migrations like that usually happen because of economic reasons or war. I just never put 2 and 2 together until now.
- ricardo_sdl 16y agoMy father lost some money because of Collor Plan too. I'm 25 and is hard to imagine how my parents went through those rough times.
- Asdfg 16y agoThere is no such thing as a "real value" as measured in a vacuum. Value only comes in relation to something: a commodity or a basket of goods. What they did in Brazil was to establish a new currency which the government promised not to inflate, then as inflation destroyed the previous currency, the way was open for the new one. This is how inflation was ended in Weimar Germany, post-WW2 Hungary, '90es Serbia/Romania/Russia. Only Zimbabwe handled things so poorly that the national currency vanished completely. Even if people learn the value of their inflating money with respect to more stable things, inflation STILL eats away at the value of their savings. It does them no good to learn prices are stable (with respect to an arbitrary standard) except to learn they are indeed getting poorer. Also, freezing bank accounts and banning the trade of foreign currency only makes matters worse. People not being able to access their money does make them poorer still. 1. You can't inflate at leisure without destroying the currency. 2. You can't have a peg to a foreign currency if you keep inflating faster than that currency's central bank. 3. You can't then cover up for the misdeeds of the government by denying people access to their savings.
- swombat 16y agoOf course there is no "real value". However, inflation is not solely the result of the government's wishes to inflate the currency (as examples of hyper-inflation obviously show). Inflation is also simply in the minds of the people using the currency. If everyone expects high inflation, and keeps raising their prices to match their expectation of inflation, then inflation will happen - the raising of prices will ensure that. And if you try to fix that by force, as you pointed out, the inflation accelerates even more, because it's now happening in a black market with even more waste. The way they fixed inflation in Brazil was, it appears, by changing people's expectation of what should happen to currency. They had to get everyone to believe that the brazilian currency can be stable. The mechanism they used to do that was the cheap trick of creating an alternative currency and calling it "real". It may be a cheap trick, but from the look of it, it worked.
- Experimentalist 16y agoNo, inflation is not only in people's minds, it's a real measurable monetary phenomenon. Sellers can raise prices but if there is not enough money to pay the price then no transactions occur, The sellers would then have to lower their price to sell the items. In other words an increasing rate of inflation throughout the economy can only occur if there is enough money/credit available to pay the higher prices. You need more money available, an increasing money supply. What's wrong with this NPR article is for everybody to think a "cheap trick" is what made it work. No, the tight fiscal policies (ie balanced budget) enacted by Brazil at the same time made it work. The ideas in this article, coupled with Krugman's debt default idea is sending you down a river to a waterfall.
- tkeller 16y ago"Brazil's inflation rate hit 80 percent per month. At that rate, if eggs cost $1 one day, they'll cost $2 a month later." Really.
- noelchurchill 16y agoIt's like this article was written by a high schooler.
- rbanffy 16y agoI am an engineer. I frequently do such approximations ;-) For most uses, like prices of eggs, it's close enough.
- chrismealy 16y agoThe article never mentioned it, but it's a called a wage-price spiral.
- anodari 16y agoIt's a 100% real story. I lived in these days. I had to put a feature called "currency change" in my softwares because every year we had to divide by 1000 all values in databases. One major work was to adjust fields sizes because currency values are allways causing data overflow.
- rbanffy 16y ago> we had to divide by 1000 all values in databases Those were the days! It's absolutely impossible for me to say how much I paid for my first car. I know it were 4000 monetary units, but I cannot recall its name nor how much it cost. That's weird.
- brc 16y agoIt's an interesting story but the frightening thing is the comments of people wondering out loud what's wrong with inflation, or asking for more inflation in the USA. Out of control inflation is a terrifying, society-destroying phenomenon. Stable and prosperous societies rely on stable money values.
- KiwiNige 16y agoA friend of mine who lived in Peru around this time told me that when he got paid he would literally run as fast as he could to change the money to US$ because the longer he took to change it, the less it was worth.
- guelo 16y agoTrue but there is also such a thing as money being too tight which is the current situation in the US.
- swaits 16y agoMoney isn't tight in the US. It may not be flowing as much as it once did, but it's still loose and cheap.
- sethg 16y agoThe people who are asking for more inflation in the USA are asking for something in the 2% range, or (for those who are truly bold) asking for prices to rise to the level they would be at if inflation had remained in the 2% range for the past five years or so. Stable money is good, but so is providing people with an incentive to spend and invest, rather than incentives to hoard cash and default on their debts.
- diego_moita 16y agoSorry, but this is playing with fire. What scientists, technocrats and economists forget is that public policy is rarely driven by rationality. It is driven mostly by private interests, demagoguery, blind ideology, prejudice and the public misconceptions. The idea of taking a little bit of a very dangerous medicine is something that no one should take lightheartedly.
- noahc 16y agoWhat are the implications of this for startups? Has a startup ever benefited from using a fake currency? In what ways?
- rbanffy 16y agoIt's a very interesting story of out-of-the-box thinking at country-scales. Most impressive indeed. It's about gaming the market. It really drives the idea that the market is only a shared somewhat consensual hallucination.
- noahc 16y agoWhich would explain lead investors and other ideas about market signaling. It also explains recent posts on lying on stage and PR efficiency.
- rbanffy 16y agoOn a market crash, all that vanishes is what never actually existed. It's when we wake up from that consensual hallucination. The catch is that not all people wake up at the same time.
- dstein 16y agoInflation is a useful tactic to make RPG style games addictive. I worked with someone who built a popular facebook RPG game, and part of what made it popular was that as you became an established player the amount earned per day rose exponentially. As the game became more and more popular the virtual economy started to hyperinflate almost out of control, and the established players started hitting the MySQL integer limits. The author never expected that would ever be possible, but the exponential rate of inflation plus the exponential rate of new players joining created a giant pyramid scheme.
- limist 16y agoGood story, reminds me of a favorite quotation: The greatest shortcoming of the human race is our inability to understand the exponential function. — Albert Bartlett
- csomar 16y agoIt's a matter of governement control (assuming your are not connected to the outside world/Internet and don't have, therefore, a real-time currency update). Let's assume gov. X, printed an additional $3bn. Will prices increase? No, they won't. The gov. can use this money, to do things, like building roads, schools... These expenses has to be considered as investments; if roads are built, industry will benefit and exports will increase lowering the inflation that the gov. had already made. So the gov. can print as much papers as they want. It's paper in the end. But the ROI of the money they spent/printed, is going to decide if inflation will happen or not (in the future). If inflation is spiking, it means the gov. lost control over the banking sector and a new currency needs to be made to return confidence to people and companies.
- bd_at_rivenhill 16y agoThe government could do things like building roads, but they are usually just using that extra paper to pay off their debts, which makes investors demand a higher interest rate to hold the debt, which leads to a vicious cycle. Inflation is caused by the speed of money creation exceeding the speed of creation of real value, and the banking sector is not the only actor in the money creation process.
- coliveira 16y agoThat was the problem in Brazil, money was created not to invest but to pay existing debt.
- forinti 16y agoNot really. Brazil's inflation had an extra factor helping it: lots of prices (as well as salaries) were automatically revalued by "triggers". The plan wouldn't have worked if the government hadn't also dropped all these mechanisms.
- dzorz 16y ago80% per month sounds crazy, but it is not even close to top 6: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation#Worst_Hyperinflations_in_World_History http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation#Worst_Hyperinfla...
- pavlov 16y agoHeh. I always assumed that the name of the currency, real, has the meaning "royal". Instead, it's literally the same as the English word. What an interesting story. Have any other governments suffering from high inflation tried this? Instead of calling it a fictional unit, they could also just use an existing currency like the euro for the transitional period, then switch to a new national currency that has an initial exchange rate of 1:1 against the euro. (I'm picking the euro because it has a fairly neutral image, with over 20 countries using it already.)
- wmf 16y agoI would assume that the Brazilian real is named after the Portuguese real which does mean "royal". It is an odd name in a democratic country, though.
- Qz 16y agoNot totally odd considering Brazil started out as an Empire (after independence).
- compay 16y agoExactly - Brazil's history and relationship with Portugal bear little resemblance to the USA's relationship with the UK. Brazilians in general are, if not proud, then at least amused by their country's royal history, and most major Brazilian cities have streets named after famous royals. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Empire_of_Brazil#Independence http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Empire_of_Brazil...
- sportsTAKES 16y agoYou are correct that 'real' means royal but it also means true or authentic (similarly in English). I think that probably more accurately describes their intention behind the meaning of the name. When I lived in Brazil in the 1990's, shortly after the currency changed from Cruzeiros to reais, the exchange rate was around 1.5. Today, it's 1.69 - there have been some relatively mild fluctuations since then but it has stayed remarkably stable.
- devmonk 16y agoHopefully the U.S. won't ever have to deal with this type of issue (out of control inflation). I'm very surprised that inflation hasn't hit the U.S. yet in a big way, but from what I hear that is because China and the U.S. are buying U.S. treasury bonds in a big way.
- cbernini 16y agobut the big problem for you guys is: it's expected that China holds something around 1 trillion of the US GDP in treasury bonds. So whenever they feel the US economy isn't trustworthy anymore, selling these will hit like a train. their growth rate is really high right now, so it's a delicate situation.
- rglullis 16y agoThe problem is not even in selling. They would need someone to sell to. Once China stops buying it will be the beginning of the spiral down in the prices of US bonds. China is the only emerging market that needs the US economy going and for the American consumer to keep its purchasing power. China can only stop buying when their domestic market gets big enough to sustain the hit that it will eventually come.
- gamble 16y agoThe Chinese can't stop buying bonds if they want to keep their currency depressed relative to the dollar. Moreover, they have no intention of stopping the gravy train - tanking the US economy (further) would only hurt their own largest market, and no other large market is as willing to accept one-sided trade and currency policies as the US.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- asmithmd1 16y agoThe Fed bought up 1 trillion in mortgage debt and no one blinked -- that is why mortgage rates are 4%. If China started dumping their T bills the Fed would just buy them up. It wouldn't hit like a train -- more like a tricycle.
- meric 16y agoWow. Last night I was thinking... if I was a supermarket manager in an inflation-ridden country, how would I save money by not changing price tags everyday? And my answer was to set one of my products as "1 Unit" and just price every other product in multiples of that "Unit". That way I only had to change the price of a single product! And then today I read this! What a coincidence! I never would've thought you could scale up this technique up to do it to the whole country!
- ataggart 16y agoDuring the hyperinflation in the Weimar Republic, grocers dealt with this by changing the organization of their stores. Instead of grouping like-kind items together, they grouped like-priced items, then they would just bump the prices for each aisle.
- tomjen3 16y agoThat is certainly one solution, but what happens when the government puts a limit on how much you can charge for bread? The best solution is the one my current supermarket uses - the price tags on the shelves are a cheap LCD display, so all they have to do to update the prices are to push the new prices from a database.
- noonespecial 16y agoSo they used the real, which was fake, to make the money that was real fake, so they could make real money out of the fake real. Dr. Seuss would be proud.
- yannk 16y ago"From there to here, from here to there, funny things are everywhere!" I have been introduced to this masterpiece by reading some of the books to my daughter and it's a real delight, apparently as much for her than it is for me. I wish I had these books where I grew up.
- michael_dorfman 16y agoDr. Seuss would be proud. Or Baudrillard.
- swah 16y agoAn extra level of indirection? Reminded me of the quote: "All problems in computer science can be solved by another level of indirection"
- jjs 16y ago"All problems in computer science can be solved by another level of indirection" —Butler Lampson, quoting David Wheeler
- tkeller 16y ago"... except for the problem of too many layers of indirection." (David Wheeler's corollary)
- anthonyb 16y ago...except too many levels of indirection.
- barrkel 16y agoI think you can solve that, to some degree, with a cache (if it's performance that's troubling you) or a simplified facade (if it's the complexity of the deep stack). Yes, those are indirections.
- anthonyb 16y agoThen you have cache invalidation problems (one of the two known hard problems in CS), as well as impedance mismatch issues with your facade.
- diego_moita 16y agoThe article doesn't tell lies, but it certainly spices up a lot the story. Some points to clarify: * The "finance minister who knew nothing about economics" was actually a very respected sociologist, a senator and a very intelligent and skilled politician. He later became known as president Fernando Henrique Cardoso. I.M.O. one of the best 3 presidents this country had. * What Edmar Bacha, Pedro Malan and others did was to break inflation's inertia/momentum. A lot of people already knew it was necessary; but no one else knew how to do it. * The article doesn't comment on the strict and cautious monetary policy implemented by Fernando Cardoso. It was as much important as the "fake money" trick. * Big inflation was a huge tax on the poorest people. Because they were poor, they didn't have the knowledge and means to protect against rising prices. It is because inflation ended that they began consuming more and the country increased their internal markets. [Edit]Wikipedia has a more comprehensive explanation about what we call here Plano Real : http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_real http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plano_real [/Edit]
- cbernini 16y agoIt's also valid to mention that the impeached president also ended up helping out in one way: he froze the saving accounts, since one way to stop inflation is to cut down the buying power of the population.
- diego_moita 16y agoThat is what classic theory says and, in truth, for a brief period of time, inflation receded when Collor (the impeached) froze savings. However the fact is that it recovered back again to high levels during Collor's mandate. The cut down in buying power was achieved mostly through fiscal policy, not consumption restriction.
- cbernini 16y agoWell, I was 7 back then, so I really said what someone else explained to me. That was my bad.
- nandemo 16y ago
- butu5 16y agowonderful article.. I really love it :) it raises lots of question how this is possible, how many people get impacted.. Anybody did any significant financial loss?? or few people know about this able to take any benefit?? but this is definitely a bold decision and executed well towards result..
- c00p3r 16y agoThis is really about a different point of view. The miracle is that they managed to teach the masses to look differently at the same thing. Say, the price of a cheap food is always correlated with the cost of unskilled labor (there will be over-supply or under-supply otherwise), so, you can always easily escape a hunger unless you're sick or disabled. That is how poor people in a poor countries are surviving. In the simple words, the conditions and relations are the same - rich getting richer and so on. ^_^ What is wrong is the digits written on pieces of a paper. Think in terms of absolute values and there is no inflation or deflation or market crashes. You just have nothing to lose. You takes pieces of paper in exchange for your time and effort, you gives pieces of paper in exchange for a food and booze. If you're earning more than you're spending it doesn't matter what digits are written on the pieces of paper. If you're spending more than you're earning - you're in trouble. Especially in inflation, when your debt will be recalculated to stay ahead of it.
- winter_blue 16y agoThere's no such thing are fake money, only false promises. Money is debt on the side of the government. Fake money therefore, is debt that the government defaults on.
- varjag 16y agoAnyone here who experienced post-Soviet currency collapses would instantly remember prices in У.Е. ("convention unit", in reality a legal way to put U.S. dollar price tag), monthly re-indexed МРОТ ("salary unit"), and so on. Alone they did not help anything, until economy and fiscal policies fundamentally changed.
- barmstrong 16y agoI don't understand something about this story. Hyperinflation is primary caused by government printing money right? So if switching to another currency helped stop this...I get how it could help people changing their perceptions, but wouldn't the root cause be that the government stopped printing money with the new currency? It seems like it would have been almost as effective if they had simply stopped printing more of the original currency until things stabilized? Maybe I'm missing something. But the article seems to put too much weight on this clever idea of shifting to a new currency. While if monetary policy had stayed the same with the new currency I don't think it would have made any difference. The monetary policy here was the important part, not the new currency.
- quadhome 16y agoI had the same question. The Wikipedia article on the URV lead me to "Inertial inflation." In the medium-to-long term, economic agents begin to forecast inflation and to use those forecasts as de facto price indexes that can trigger price adjustments before the actual price indices are made known to the public. This cycle of forecast-price adjustment-forecast closes itself in the form of a feedback loop and inflation indices get beyond control since current inflation becomes the basis for future inflation (more formally, economic agents start to adjust prices solely based on their expectations of future inflation). At worst, inflation tends to grow exponentially (leading to hyperinflation). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_inflation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_inflation
- barmstrong 16y agoInteresting, thanks for posting that (it is probably what the author is basing it on)...although it's probably more accurate to call this one theory of how it could happen. The reasoning behind it doesn't fully make sense to me. Simple reason: people spending money as fast as they can (the shot in the arm that can accelerate hyperinflation) has a natural limit: when people have no more savings! So I don't think it's correct to call this a positive feedback loop. It has a natural limit that could be reached quite quickly under hyperinflation. Indexes can only takes things so far too - if you (as a business owner) follow them and nobody can afford your products, you'll quickly figure it out and drop prices. So it seems weird to say indexes could cause hyperinflation over any medium-long time frame.
- motters 16y agoAll money is of course "fake" in that it only has value if people believe that it does. Economics could be thought of as a branch of psychology, with "real value" being connected to the transient and sometimes hard to quantify needs, wants and desires of people.
- sethg 16y ago...and now that Brazilians are no longer so spooked by inflation that they spend money as soon as they receive it, three Brazilian banks are among the world’s top ten credit issuers. (http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2010/10/04/130329294/life-on-the-installment-plan?ft=1&f=93559255 http://www.npr.org/blogs/money/2010/10/04/130329294/life-on-...) One liberal wonk wonders if this is a sign that the country is facing a consumer debt bubble. (http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2010/10/tomorrows-credit-bust/ http://yglesias.thinkprogress.org/2010/10/tomorrows-credit-b...)
- known 16y agoWill this trick work in America?
- patrickgzill 16y agoIt is coming to the USA. It is called the SDR.