10 ms·
Civilization VI removes Red Shell ad-tracking software
- cbg0 8y agoThey did get quite a few negative reviews on the Steam store page about this issue, and there's also a large thread with users complaining ( https://steamcommunity.com/app/289070/discussions/0/1709564118762025388/ https://steamcommunity.com/app/289070/discussions/0/17095641... ) which probably led to this action. As an aside, complaints might have been even more numerous if the game were actually good, as of now Civ 5 has a peak of 30K users playing daily, while Civ 6 a peak of only 20K.
- wolfgke 8y ago> As an aside, complaints might have been even more numerous if the game were actually good, as of now Civ 5 has a peak of 30K users playing daily, while Civ 6 a peak of only 20K. A question to the gamers on HN: What makes Civ5 in your opinion/in the opinion of many gamers better than Civ6?
- mschuetz 8y agoBeen a while since I've played Civ6 but I didn't like some of the weird game mechanics. For example, some of the city boosts required you to permanently sacrifice tiles, which made the boosts a lot less interesting. Graphics were cool, though. Personally, I prefer Civ4 a bit over Civ5, and don't like Civ6 at all.
- airstrike 8y agoThanks, I thought I was alone in this. I don't like to permanently sacrifice tiles and honestly this feels like adding another layer of micromanaging and distracting players from the bigger 4X picture which to me is where the fun in Civ lies. Civ 5 was a mess when I originally played it and Civ 4 still plays much more seamless. I honestly didn't mind stacking units and I think it makes perfect sense for a video game -- not to mention it made the AI much simpler and therefore much less stupid when comparing vanilla versions of Civ 4 and 5 (or 6, for that matter)
- Bartweiss 8y agoI always thought the Great Person tile improvements in Civ5 were really interesting, because they felt like a big, rare sacrifice - you had to pick a tile to weaken for a different payout. Converting it to a standard feature of development makes for strange gameplay, even if it makes a lot of thematic sense. Still beats the Beyond Earth development experience for me, but that's not really saying much...
- wincy 8y agoI think it’s just way cheaper? I’ve played both and if I didn’t have a lot of cash I probably wouldn’t have Civ 6. So Civ 5 is “better” in the sense of a way longer development cycle with a bunch of expansions. Civ 6 has some pretty graphics though.
- rataerix 8y agoGenerally for the Civ games the new one doesn't become overly popular till a few expansions are released. It was the same when Civ V came out, a lot of people were saying Civ IV was better. Civ VI is a good game I think most people will switch eventually, just takes some time.
- AndyNemmity 8y agoIt is more about modding outside of the general player base that already played, and dropped it. The sustained users are ones that have good mods that improve the AI, and other aspects of the game. Civ 6 hasn't released the DLL, so us as modders, are in a holding pattern. Most of the major modders have quit (as have I) until the DLL is released. As an AI modder, I just can't improve the AI without the DLL.
- crag 8y ago// The sustained users are ones that have good mods that improve the AI, and other aspects of the game. Civ 6 hasn't released the DLL, so us as modders, are in a holding pattern. Most of the major modders have quit (as have I) until the DLL is released.// That's it right there. The Civ5 mod(s) "vox populi" is a must in any game I play. And it changes much of the game. Not possible to do in Civ6. Also, I don't like the cartoon graphics of Civ6.
- TheRealDunkirk 8y agoThe way it feels on my 2014 MPBr, I figure one those new, fully-spec'd MBP's ought to be able to play it acceptably... on medium settings.
- wjp3 8y agoMaturity, game mechanics, mods. Civ6 will eventually be the same, probably once Civ7 is released.
- AndyNemmity 8y agoOnce the DLL is released. Modders can't make proper mods until they release the DLL. Civ 4, was released immediately and had an amazing mod community. Civ 5 was delayed release, and the modding community got into a groove afterwards for some amazing mods. Civ 6, who knows. The longer they wait, they more they have to rely on their game to drive play. And the AI for example, is a trainwreck that needs help
- lwelyk 8y agoThe AI in Civ 6 is kind of a mess, I have civs on the other side of the globe I've never interacted with more than a scout passing by once dozens of turns before just declare war on me. Then nothing happened for 3 dozen turns because they couldn't reach me and they sued for peace. That happened multiple times.
- AndyNemmity 8y agoI'm an AI modder for Civ. Civ 4, Fall From Heaven AI, Civ 5. Civ 6 hasn't released the source for the DLL, so none of the AI modders can do anything about it's AI. We have the tools, we're aware of how it works, we're just completely held back until Firaxis releases it. Base Civ 5 AI is terrible. Modded Civ 5 AI is glorious. Every single AI modder has quit, waiting for the DLL. I don't even know if we get everyone back the longer they wait. Really disappointing.
- jcurbo 8y agoDo you have a recommended AI mod for Civ V? It'd be interesting to get back into it with something like that. I've only ever really played vanilla Civ. (since 2...)
- 24gttghh 8y agoI have heard good things about the 'Vox Populi' mod, and I've been meaning to try it soon.
- mdaniel 8y agoFor convenience, I believe these are the links: * https://forums.civfanatics.com/forums/community-patch-project.497 https://forums.civfanatics.com/forums/community-patch-projec... * https://www.reddit.com/r/civvoxpopuli https://www.reddit.com/r/civvoxpopuli
- hiccuphippo 8y agoAre Civ5 AI mods allowed when the game comes from Steam? Doesn't Steam do some sort of integrity checking for the game files?
- smacktoward 8y agoIt's pretty common to see this with games from Firaxis (the developers of the Civ series). They tend to design each new title around a couple of Big Ideas, but they don't fully shake out the ramifications of those ideas during development. Instead, they put the game into the hands of players and then listen to them to figure out what's working and what isn't. Then they release a big expansion pack a year or two down the road that fixes the things that didn't work. Civ 4 wasn't really "complete" until the release of the Beyond the Sword expansion; Civ 5 wasn't until the Brave New World expansion; XCOM 2 until the War of the Chosen expansion; and so on. As a result, it's not unusual for people to vocally prefer an older, already-expanded Firaxis title to its newer, still rough-around-the-edges successor at the successor's initial release. Lots of people strongly preferred Civ 4 over Civ 5 for years, until Firaxis fixed the big complaints they had with the latter. I expect at some point we'll see expansions to Civ 6 that address the major issues people have with it now, and then Civ 7 will come out and we'll all have to listen to people longing for the good old days of Civ 6 for a year or two.
- Semaphor 8y agoFor me, it's mainly because of Communitas -> Community Balance Patch -> Vox Populi (rebrandings and changing devs over the many years) it's what makes Civ V really worth playing (Windows-only because the SDK was only released for the windows Civ version). Far superior AI, balance and more features. But also because Civ VI feels like it's much more combat focused.
- red_admiral 8y agoCan someone confirm if I've understood this right? When you view a red shell enabled ad, a script on the page (or perhaps the ad server itself, based on HTTP headers) computes a fingerprint of your browser (IP address, browser version, fonts installed, screen size etc.) and stores (ad_id, fingerprint) in a database somewhere. When you install and run a red shell enabled game, it computes the fingerprint of your machine and sends (game_id, fingerprint) to the server, which stores this in another table. By joining these tables on the fingerprint, you can get some info on which ads are correlated with which game purchases. Apart from this, red shell does NOT modify your browser settings, inject code into all pages you visit, add a browser toolbar, constantly run in the background, MITM your TLS or anything else like that. [EDIT: not trying to defend red shell here, just checking whether I need do a full reinstall of my PC to get rid of this thing]
- durzagott 8y agoAre you implying this somehow makes it ok?
- red_admiral 8y agoNo - what part of my post are you interpreting like that? I'm happy to edit if I'm giving the wrong impression. I just want to know how worried I need to be about my own gaming PC at the moment.
- durzagott 8y ago"Apart from this, red shell does NOT modify your browser settings, inject code into all pages you visit, add a browser toolbar, constantly run in the background, MITM your TLS or anything else like that." This is the part that made me think you were defending it. My apologies for misunderstanding.
- ekianjo 8y ago> I just want to know how worried I need to be about my own gaming PC at the moment. Not sure if you play on Linux at all, but a good way to start is to run Steam in firejail. It isolates that environment from the rest of the OS. https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Firejail https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/Firejail
- ilitirit 8y agoFunnily enough (and not that it makes it OK) you didn't have to accept the agreement to play the game (just click "I don't agree" or whatever the option is). Not sure if they still continued harvesting data though...
- stamps 8y agoDoes anyone have a list of the domains these guys use? I'm curious if these are in the DNSLB easy lists or the lists used by PiHole. If they aren't I'd like to add them to my blacklists on Pfblocker-NG.
- red_admiral 8y agoredshell.io is already in uMatrix' list of blocked domains, so it looks like the easy lists are up to date.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- comice 8y agoDoes the game show adverts in-game? Is the game free or do you pay for it? Sounds insane! I'd be upset enough about the ads nevermind the added salt of tracking!
- airstrike 8y agoThe game retailed at $60¹ but you may be able to find it for a little less if you keep an eye out for sales __________ 1. https://www.gamestop.com/pc/games/sid-meiers-civilization-vi/130608 https://www.gamestop.com/pc/games/sid-meiers-civilization-vi...
- Bartweiss 8y agoNo ads in game - this is supposed to be a campaign effectiveness tracker. Since you buy these PC games through Steam there's no easy way to associate an ad impression with a resulting purchase like there is on mobile. Red Shell creates a device fingerprint for each ad and each play session and compares the two sets to see which ads were followed by purchases. So on one hand, no ads in game and unlike Superfish or something it's perfectly reasonable info for devs to want. But on the other hand, it's achieved by way of a deep fingerprint which is uniquely identifying, and which could in theory be matched to other device fingerprints elsewhere. I'm glad to see it gone, but I'd be fine if it came back as something fancy like a client-side hash of the data; the ad correlation is fine with me, the retained fingerprint isn't.
- KaoruAoiShiho 8y agoI think something like Red Shell is obviously good for society and consumers are hurting themselves by overreacting. Better targeted ads == less money wasted on ads and more money spent on development == less people annoyed by ads they're not interested in == better games. Shame.
- Bartweiss 8y agoThis seems like a misunderstanding of the complaint. I know people do oppose targeted advertising, but that's not why they're mad about Red Shell. The way Red Shell targets ads involves building and storing full device fingerprints when you play a game. It's a privacy risk totally separate from the targeted advertising question. And yes, individual devs could do that also, but at least I've chosen to deal with those devs, and my data can't be tracked across different games by different companies. If Red Shell switches to something like a device-side hash of the fingerprint, so that it can recognize returning users but not give out (or lose) the underlying data, I'd feel vastly better about it. Basic targeting analytics don't bother me, and "did this game ad work?" is vastly more justified than most tracking. I just don't want it tied to an externally-stored device fingerprint.
- KaoruAoiShiho 8y agoI guess I don't understand in what way that's a privacy risk. They have the device fingerprint, isn't that just the device id, like a name? This is only meaningful if paired with another piece of information, like your personal identity or other tracking. In this case it's game sales which I think is definitely a positive thing. I mean if they were tracking other things or keylogging or something I would be mad but...
- foepys 8y agoThey are apparently also logging the Steam ID which is unique for each Steam account. In my eyes the Steam ID is PII as very few people with more than one game on it will change their Steam account.
- fpgaminer 8y agoI set up a separate gaming rig specifically to isolate these kinds of problems. That's where I run all my games and nothing else. You'd think it'd be more expensive to have another machine specifically for gaming. But the slowing of CPU advancements means that old systems can be usefully repurposed. I grabbed the husk of an older desktop from a few years ago, its CPU and memory being more than enough for gaming. Threw my GPU over to it (not needed for work or personal desktop usage), and I had a dedicated gaming rig for "free". Now I don't worry about scummy studios releasing malware masquerading as games. For those more technically inclined, you can do a gaming VM. That used to be my setup prior to having a separate machine. GPU passthrough allows you to give your GPU to the VM. I had it running under Ubuntu, with Windows as the guest. Near identical performance. That was a cool setup, but kept breaking on OS updates so I decided to just use a separate physical machine. But these are ultimately just defenses and are no excuse for knowingly running malware. Gamers should make it a point not to buy games or other software that plays loose with their privacy. These studios should be ashamed of themselves. But it's impossible to always know ahead of time what horrors lie within your software. So at least I sleep better at night knowing these "games" at least have their own cesspool to writhe around in.
- ryandrake 8y agoNice setup. I run all my games from a separate partition with its own copy of Windows, but your way is even better. I’m not looking forward to the world where we need a separate machine for each piece of software in order to ensure privacy, but sadly we are heading there.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]