15 ms·
How the Car Keeps Americans Apart
- mariodiana 8y agoI feel bad if my comment ends up being the first one, because I'm coming to suggest a book that I immediately thought of as I got halfway through the article. If you want to read about human society and how much of it we're missing, read The Great Good Place, by Ray Oldenburg. (I believe it came out in the late 1980's.) There is a chapter on suburbia, and what an awful mess that has made of human sociability, particularly because you have to get in your car to go anywhere. It's one of those books that lots of people have read, but many more people have heard of and mean to get around to reading. It's very good and very thought-provoking. I read it more or less when it came out, and it has stayed with me ever since. (I did re-read it about 10 years ago.) With respect to the article, the automobile is one of those things that has changed society so thoroughly—and which seemed like such a great idea at the time—that most people can't even imagine the impact or what they've lost. We just take it for granted.
- sillysaurus3 8y agoI hope the first HN comment is always a book suggestion. :) I recently got rid of my car after four years of living in a city. I don't know why I held onto it for so long, but my life has improved dramatically. Not only can I go anywhere I want, but I never have to worry about permits, tickets, or parking. This lifestyle can't work for people outside of cities, though. There's no way to get anyplace without a car, and there isn't enough density to make uber very effective. No one wants to wait a half hour for a ride. Being in a city has downsides, but for this reason it's wonderful. There's even an app now where you can just use someone else's car. (Getaround, I think?) I've used it twice: one when I needed to go buy something about 20 miles away, and another to go on a trip a hundred miles away. And the price was very low.
- pdonis 8y ago> This lifestyle can't work for people outside of cities, though. Exactly. Which means that, if cities are designed sanely, they will be more attractive to people who don't want cars (when I lived in a city during college, I never had a car and never missed having one), and suburbs and rural areas will be more attractive to people who do (as I do now since I like having a detached house and an actual yard).
- tdfx 8y agoThere's also Turo, which seems similar to Getaround by your description, as well as hourly rentals through Zipcar. And the established rental players like Hertz and Enterprise have started trying to emulate the smaller startups with flexible locations and hourly billing. And there's always Uber. My lease is up next year and I can't wait to get rid of my car. I won't be replacing it. My car payment is rather high, but even with just the insurance, city parking/tickets, gas, tolls, and maintenance costs, I'm pretty sure I can Uber/Lyft everywhere I need to go for less money and rent a car on the occasion I really need one.
- briandear 8y agoUber with car seats for 4 kids is a pain. With kids, a car provides a “base” for when you go out — you can carry everything you need without having to tote it all around once you arrive at the destination. Public transport for older kids is fine, but with small kids, it’s a nightmare, especially in NY where apparently only a few subway stops have elevators and they’re generally filled with piss.
- MarkusAllen 8y agoIn a city, how do you handle buying a socket wrench to fix something in your house? (It sounds like a MAJOR hassle.)
- sillysaurus3 8y agoAmazon prime 2hour delivery. $22 has it at my doorstep in two hours. If I want it faster than that, or cheaper, I walk to the home depot a mile away.
- kalleboo 8y ago15 minute bike ride to the hardware store
- couchand 8y agoI walk a block to the locally-owned hardware store and give my dollars to my neighbor, obviously. What do you do, throw your money into the giant corporate black hole?
- c22 8y agoI just use the socket wrench at the community makerspace 5 blocks from my house.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoBike to one of the 3 (or 4?) hardware stores in a 10-15min radius. The closest one is barely 5 minutes away, but it's a bit expensive. If I need something specialized, I either take public transit all the way there, or ride my bike to the S-train station and bring my bike on the train.
- ACow_Adonis 8y agoI walk down to the hardware store, i purchase it, i walk back :| If i want to go to the really big hardware warehouse, I catch the tram from just outside my house. And if i need big things for some reason, I book the share-van, drive there, load it into the back, drive home, unload it, park the van, walk away.
- kaybe 8y ago
- mikekchar 8y ago> This lifestyle can't work for people outside of cities I'm not sure. You have to look to other places in the world to see examples of lower density living, though. I live in rural Japan in a small town. Officially I think it is officially 25K people, but that's only because it is more efficient for a single city hall to service a larger area. In reality, I think that it is closer to 5-10K in the town itself and then a spattering of people around the outskirts. The main street of the town is 6 blocks long, if I remember correctly. I live 2 km away from the "hustle and bustle" of the town ;-) I live in a 3 story walk up apartment building surrounded on 3 sides by rice fields. Here and there, there are similar small apartment buildings, single family homes and small farms. In the walkable area, there are 3 grocery stores, a variety of restaurants, some clothing stores, some hardware stores, one electronics store, many bars (Japan is a drinking society), etc. There are many factories in the area (including TDK, Suzuki, and a few other big ones). There are dentists, doctors, etc, etc, etc. I have to walk to the "down town" to catch the bus to the nearest big city, which I probably do once a month or so. However, that's it. Near the main street, it is mostly houses and shops, but by the time you get out my way (which is only a 20 minute walk) more than half of the land is farmland. The main street is right by the beach, too, so it only spreads in one direction. That should give you an idea of how small it is. There are definitely places where it would be very difficult to live without a car, but it's pretty darn rural here and it's extremely comfortable to live if you are able bodied. If you have a bike, you can even easily ride to the next town (or the one after that). When I was teaching in the high school here, most of my students rode from 2 or 3 villages away, because there weren't enough students in the area to fill up the school. So depending on your definition of "city", I think it's completely doable. You just have to intentionally design the towns to be accessible. (It also helps that farms in Japan are extremely small, by law).
- earloflexus 8y agoThe author did a great job of arguing the case that transportation preferences map semi-neatly to red tribe / blue tribe distinctions, but it doesn't convince me that cars cause Americans to be apart. I'm sure Americans would be closer together if more things were walkable for more people and I don't oppose investments in walkability. However, some people don't want that, some people are thrilled to drive a big vehicle and burn a gallon or three of gas to pick up a case of beer and log of chewing tobacco. What virtue do we need to inoculate into Joe Sixpack to get him to participate in a the vegetarian version of personal transportation?
- adrianN 8y agoWe could start by pricing in the damage cars do to the environment. A first step would be raising taxes on fuel until Joe Sixpack thinks twice before burning a gallon of gas to get his beer.
- dixie_land 8y agosounds like Joe Sixpack got nice MPGs, would've cost me 3 gallons round-trip XD
- claydavisss 8y agoAmericans want to be "apart"! Most people in America see high-density living as a negative. Most want a yard and a garage. The country is huge - you can fit three UKs into the state of Texas alone. We have the space, we have the roads, we like our yards. I have moved our family into progressively rural environments and will continue to do so until the distance to basic necessities is intolerable. In most rural environments there is no meaningful traffic so people aren't that down on being in their vehicles.
- ta1234567890 8y agoMaybe you mean American corporations and people in power love space and their cars and the money they make off of selling and developing those things? For example, LA used to have a great train network for public transportation until the automobile industry made sure to tear it down so people would be forced to drive cars. In SF/BayArea people want zoning to change so there can be more housing/apartment buildings. Who's blocking that from happening? Homeowners who think that would devalue their properties. Also, doesn't seem like people in NYC value cars or yards that much (at least not over living in NYC).
- claydavisss 8y agoNo living in the country is actually not a vast alt-right conspiracy.
- maccam94 8y agoWell, not alt right... De-urbanization was spurred by housing shortages post-WW2 and federal policy seeking to stabilize the housing market. The FHA was created to insure home loans that met a long list of requirements[1], which had biases towards increasing consumption (including cars) and racial segregation. The marketing and growth of suburbia was then promoted by various business interests that would benefit from that increased consumption[2]. The new suburban lifestyle led to the rise of modern conservatism[3]. Most (~85% [3]) of the US lives in metropolitan areas, so rural lifestyles are not typical and it would be vastly less efficient if everyone lived there rather than in cities. 1: https://marketurbanism.com/2017/09/12/financing-suburbia-how-government-mortgage-policy-determined-where-you-live/ https://marketurbanism.com/2017/09/12/financing-suburbia-how... 2: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/made-by-history/wp/2017/07/20/the-false-promise-of-homeownership/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.ed2710a026a0 https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/made-by-history/wp/2017/... 3: http://americanhistory.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780199329175.001.0001/acrefore-9780199329175-e-64 http://americanhistory.oxfordre.com/view/10.1093/acrefore/97...
- yosito 8y agoAnecdotally, I always loved having a car and the sense of independence and freedom that came with it. Then at the age of 25, I moved out of the country to a small, walkable town in Latin America where I either walked, drove my scooter, or took motorcycle taxis everywhere. After two years of living there, I moved back to the US, bought a Jeep, and was super excited to have the autonomy and ability to travel between cities easily in a day. I didn't have a commute at the time, so I never really had to drive in traffic. A year later, I ditched my car again and spent a whole year traveling around the world. I got around by walking and taking trains and taxis. By the time I got back to the US, I hated driving. It felt so isolating and boring. Then I got a job where I had to commute for an hour and a half a day in heavy traffic. It was one of the most miserable periods of my life. I started resenting having to drive anywhere. I started resenting places that weren't walkable. I started resenting how roads designed for cars break up and eliminate public space. Finally, two months ago I sold my car and committed to a car-free lifestyle, probably for life. It's completely changed how I do things; I spend more time out of the house, I spend more time socializing, and of course, I walk more. I went from walking less than a mile a day to walking an average of five miles a day. I'm much happier with this lifestyle, and I hope I'm never forced to go back.
- roymurdock 8y agoWhat happens if/when you have kids. I’ve seen many people biking around Amsterdam with their kids in protective bike high seats. But this is unheard of in many US cities. Minivans are the usual solution. Would you teach them to take public transport or try to live within walking distance of everything? Obvs doesn’t apply if u don’t plan on it, but curious if anyone has found a solution in US cities.
- DoreenMichele 8y agoFor one, the geography of car use tracks with income and wealth: Car-dependent places are considerably less affluent. Metros in which a higher share of people depend on their cars to get to work are poorer, and those where more people use transit or bike or walk to work are considerably more affluent. I always hated driving. I gave up my car more than a decade ago. I am happy to see stats like this. In spite of how sprawling the US is, I think it is a myth that we have no choice but to build a car-centric America, a myth that serves as self-fulfilling prophecy. And I hate hearing it.
- pdonis 8y agoWe don't have to build either a car-centric America or a non-car-centric America. We can, if we choose, build an America that has places for people who want cars, and places for people who don't. That was supposed to be a key idea of America--that not everybody has to live the same way.
- sampo 8y agoYou can spring up a new, distant, car-based suburb on a pristine land. The deer and the groundhog who used to live there, don't get a vote. But usually, people who already live in a city of, say, density X, are pretty strongly opposed to building more and increasing the density to 1.2 X. Also, those 0.2 X new residents naturally are only moving in in the future, so they don't get to vote, either. Somehow, the attitude of the people who get to enjoy the dense, walkable neighborhoods, would need to change so that they'd be more open to sharing their lifestyle with more new people.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoIncreasing density in cities is not the only way to get people out of their cars. It is very possible to expand cities outwards, while still maintaining walkability and bikeability. Expanding public transit alongside the city is one of the best ways.
- 8y ago
- Agustus 8y agoThose who are able to afford to live in affluent areas have high income jobs and can purchase the land surrounding their workplace, enabling non motorized conveyance or transit. The low and middle class, are forced out of the area, however these middle to low income jobs still exist and they need to be accomplished; think how far out a janitor is pushed away from a high income residence area before they can afford a place. An example of this is San Francisco's suburb expansion with the streetcar's development. As the streetcar line expanded, the lower income folks could afford better residences as opposed to having to live in a walking distance to their job, which drove up costs as individuals competed for residences. The automobile enabled individuals to find affordable residences and provided middle income and lower income individuals the power to find jobs not within walkable distance of a residence or rail line. The automobile has been a net good for society, especially the low income or middle class.
- Arn_Thor 8y agoYou're describing a chain of events that happened, but doesn't necessarily had to occur. Firstly, the mechanism you describe where people bid up housing near transit corridors also happens near highways and traffic corridors, though it is more dispersed. This effect can and has been mitigated by combining rail transit with buses or trams leading to rail stations. It is of course more effective in less suburbanized areas where density is higher. That's not to say that there's something inherently wrong with the American suburban model, it just doesn't scale well. So much space is wasted on parking lots for vehicles that stand empty most of the day. And rush hour traffic is just not fixable beyond a certain point, no matter how many lanes are added to the highways. It's just flat-out wrong to claim that non-car commutes only benefit the affluent. That's entirely dependent on how the economics of the community are set up. If there's a will to have everyone commute by public transit, there are many ways to achieve it.
- KozmoNau7 8y ago>"So much space is wasted on parking lots for vehicles that stand empty most of the day" Don't forget that these stretches of black asphalt act as giant heat accumulators, soaking up the sun during the day and keeping temperatures uncomfortably high after the sun goes down.
- arenaninja 8y agoI'm a little torn. I don't remember my apartment days fondly (except during college and in Houston where apartments can be LARGE). Noise/smell/bugs from neighbors is awful to deal with, crummy stairwells (never an elevator), fighting for a parking spot and hauling groceries was a hassle. But I dislike driving for a commute, I've done as little as 30 minutes and up to 1.5 hours of commute, it's very stressful to be constantly alert for a good chunk of your day just to get from A to B. I think I've found the best of both worlds; a house that's my family's own space, and Houston Park and Ride stations. I drive 10 minutes to the station, leave my car there and commute on a bus to my job. The stop is about 5 blocks from the building I work at, I'm relatively stress-free and I can choose to make good use of the time spent riding the bus (generally reading books, news, sports, etc.). The bus gets there at the same time I would have in spite of the stops it makes because it uses the HOV when I would be stuck in traffic on the freeway
- zjaffee 8y agoI think all of the things you mention can be addressed, it's just that cities often build apartments as a way to increase density only when it's needed rather than to think things through in a density/walkability first way. Cities can have family sized apartments, with the needed amenities in a way that's designed both for cars/walking/biking/ect.
- passthefist 8y ago> Noise/smell/bugs from neighbors is awful to deal with, crummy stairwells (never an elevator), fighting for a parking spot and hauling groceries was a hassle. That's unfortunate. One of the things I love about my apartment (Chicago) is that I've got friendly neighbors, it's well kept, there's decent parking, and I've got a deli and 2 grocery stores in walking distance. I'm a big fan of park and rides though, esp if it connects to rail. They seem like a good compromise to help alleviate congestion from a city and work to collect from lower dense areas where there's not enough density to support rail.
- beaverbeats 8y agoThe American car culture is the best thing that happened in the world since the big bang. Now get out of my way!
- ta1234567890 8y agoAlso, according to this research/experiment, driving to work is one of the unhappiest activities that people perform in their lives: https://www.ted.com/talks/matt_killingsworth_want_to_be_happier_stay_in_the_moment/transcript?language=en https://www.ted.com/talks/matt_killingsworth_want_to_be_happ...
- mlindner 8y agoA lot of people don't want to live in the middle of cities. I don't understand why people who live in cities think everyone wants to live there. I want to own several acres of land to have room to do the things I want to do. I don't want to live in a condo where I have to be careful about noise levels and with no ability to have a big party at my house because of lack of room for the guests.
- antt 8y agoOne thing I have always found odd is how no one talks about treating cars like guns. Both have reasonable use cases. Both are fun to tinker with. Both are the main ways people kill other people. And you shouldn't need to use either daily in a civilized society. That's not even talking about the rest of the problems mass car ownership creates, from climate change to destroying neighborhoods to the health crisis sitting instead of walking creates.
- BRAlNlAC 8y ago>And you shouldn't need to use either daily in a civilized society. This is either some next-level elitism or a false argument. Does the recluse have no place in society? What about the logger, or the Tractor operator? What about the surgeon who is on call, do you want them to bike to the hospital at 2 AM? I sure as hell don't. If your argument is that no individual should have to own a car, we already live in that America. If your argument is that no one should have to own in a car, get real.
- antt 8y agoTractors, trucks, ambulances and motor bikes are not cars. > we already live in that America. Perhaps you should visit the old town centres in Europe, or the country villages. You can see what a society built around not using cars looks like.
- BRAlNlAC 8y agoI have been to old town centers in Europe, you really ought to tone down your elitism. What I meant when I said "tractor drivers getting to work" is people like my friend who grades and compacts pads for new homes. He drives a 4x4 pickup down a dirt road sometimes for 10+ miles to get to his tractor so he can start working. How does mass transit work for new construction?
- antt 8y ago> Both have reasonable use cases. Building is a reasonable use case for cars while protecting yourself from polar bears is a reasonable use case for guns [0]. I don't understand why you, and a large number of other people, are being willfully obtuse about this. 10+ miles on dirt roads to get to a tractor is not someone who lives in civilization, it's someone out in the wilderness. [0] https://www.cntraveler.com/story/alaskan-town-kaktovik-polar-bears-and-tourists https://www.cntraveler.com/story/alaskan-town-kaktovik-polar...
- starpilot 8y agoAlways suspicious of these preaching to the choir type articles. Like we've been gamed and figured out, and this is dressed up clickbait.
- nimbius 8y agospeaking as an engine mechanic for a small chain of auto repair shops, it feels like americans have grown outright apathetic to the commute offered by cars --any car-- in this age. How do i figure? Maintenance. My most common customer comes in complaining about a noise or a smell and stares at her shoes when asked when the last major service was, what the mileage is, or when the last oil change was. Its almost like drivers have learned to internalize their hatred of the commute into the car itself. Like they just dont want to think about any of it. Bare brake pads, scored rotors, and boiled oil are all so common it hurts. I once had to spend two weeks rebuilding most of a partially seized engine because a customer couldnt understand why his two year old car idled so rough. a $40 oil change could have prevented what ended up being $8000 in parts and service.
- analog31 8y agoI'm glad for the light on the dash that blinks when my car needs an oil change. And I'm lucky to have an honest mechanic who keeps me up to date on issues without gouging me. I've become apathetic about driving too. It's become mostly unpleasant due to congestion. What you say cuts pretty close for me: A car is an appliance. But also, cars have gotten so reliable that it's easy to stop thinking about what's going on under the hood.
- antod 8y agoI can understand the feeling though. Even though I don't commute by car any more, I see the same thing in how I treat my mountain bike vs how I treat my commuter bike. My mountain bike is for fun and gets cleaned/maintained etc after I use it in the weekends. My commuter bike is used during the week either first thing in the morning or early evenings before getting home for a meal and seeing my family. It's kinda a necessary evil and resented a bit compared to my mountain bike. I want it to just work and not have to think about it (until it annoyingly doesn't).
- boxcardavin 8y agoI started commuting by ebike full time last year and now when I do drive in traffic I notice how crazy my road rage gets. I get so upset at the insanity of sitting in this giant box that is 25x my body weight as I crawl in orderly queues with other people doing the same thing. In a world without cars we could have small EVs (bikes, scooters, pods) that all had no crash safety features and all weighed under 500lbs. Average speeds on freeways around cities are below 30mph these days anyways, why are we doing this still? Anyways, I'm workin on it.
- matttproud 8y agoIf you’re interested more in this topic, may I recommend the following books: - The Geography of Nowhere https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geography_of_Nowhere https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Geography_of_Nowhere - Suburban Nation https://books.google.ch/books/about/Suburban_Nation.html?id=UZ0-0X4aiwQC&redir_esc=y https://books.google.ch/books/about/Suburban_Nation.html?id=... Much of the car-bound design resulted from zoning and simple the-rode-to-hell-is-paved-with-good-intentions. The problem is fixable, but it will probably take much clamoring over a generation’s timespan to undo the damage.
- geoka9 8y agoIn my city we have a great transit system which often gets disrupted by the traffic jams caused by personal cars. I can understand that not every city can provide a good transit system, but for cities like ours I wonder if the problem can be solved by creating dedicated bus lanes that are always separate from other lanes throughout the city. When you're stuck in traffic and see the buses whizzing through without delay, it's easy to make the decision to ditch the car and start using the transit.
- adrian_mrd 8y agoA great Dutch ‘invention’ is what is known as a Bakfiets - effectively a longer, heavier bicycle with a large ‘bucket’ (bak) at the front that can carry two children and/or lots of shopping or goods. Also worth noting is the huge environmental cost of cars - not just in carbon monoxide, huge array of components and metals they require to build, impact on climate change, etc., but also how they create ‘nature barriers’ dividing land corridors for flightless animals. Witness roads in the middle of otherwise pristine forests or road networks that clear huge swaths of wilderness. I’ve frequently thought how the true cost of cars has been understated, possibly due to the assumed bias that cars are positive pieces of technology, lobbying efforts by vehicle manufacturers, a bias against public transport, etc. Cars are in many ways, the precursor to the most private of popular, self-focused technologies: the mobile phone. Cars benefit a private (individual, family) need generally over a public one. It is your car and your ‘asset’. Whilst there are, of course, ‘public cars’ (taxis and ride-sharing), they are not the norm in most cities, in most suburbs, in most places. We should, as a society, spend more time debating the merits of cars and road networks - especially factoring in the downsides for those with physical disabilities and those on low incomes. edit: fixed spelling mistake, added last three paragraphs.
- repiret 8y agoLots of pictures on the Dutch Wikipedia: https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bakfiets https://nl.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bakfiets
- KozmoNau7 8y agoWe've had similar bikes to the Bakfiets here in Denmark since 1929, the "Long John" as it was originally known. It's no surprise really, considering the very similar flatness of our countries, that bicycle culture is so big in both our countries. Nowadays, I think people are more comfortable riding the three-wheeled cargo bikes, or Christiania Bikes, as they're commonly known. You can transport a surprising amount of stuff on either type, especially the e-bike versions.
- systemtest 8y agoI live in a neighbourhood formed between 1910 and 1930. When I looked it up in the photo archives, I saw how the road was a single piece spanning the entire width of the street, front door to front door. I saw how children and people just walked and played on it. A horse carriage moving through it. Nowadays from left to right it's a small side-walk, parked cars, a road for cars, a small strip for cyclists and another small side-walk. I really want to go back to having just a big wide lane for general use.
- maerF0x0 8y agoI find there are a number of things I cannot do without someone having a car. 1) Go hiking, snowboarding, mountain biking 2) Drive fast on road courses 3) Come home from the airport after midnight 4) Purchase more than 2 bags of groceries (including TP, laundry detergent et al) 5) Go on road trips 6) Isolate myself from the mentally ill or obnoxious behaviors and smells I'm surrounded by, including their fecal matter 7) Isolate myself from the constant crime that I am surrounded by 8) Isolate myself from the constant excessive sound that I am surrounded by 9) Easily move around tools and supplies to maintain my home on and on it goes. A life without a car is a life of either hiring everything out (expensive), doing without (no hikes for me) or constantly renting (what's the point?)
- flatline 8y agoIf you live in a walkable area, that means a city, and if you ever want to get out of the city you’ll need a car, or a serious dedication to biking. There are exceptions, I had no trouble getting out of the city on foot in Boulder for example, the bus will even take you out to semi-rural areas. A motorcycle is one potential solution but they are incredibly dangerous and not very practical in many parts of the country due to weather.
- maerF0x0 8y agoYeah I actually have a motorcycle as a way to deal with #2 :P I accept the risk. All the gear all the time.
- Karrot_Kream 8y agoUnless you're paying for a private track, #2 makes the road less safe for others that want to use it and cost more to repair. It's the textbook example of abusing the commons.
- stronglikedan 8y agoThey specifically say "road courses".
- 8y ago
- chiiidog 8y agoI'm torn. I hate driving to work but, living in Colorado, I can't imagine not having a car to drive up to the mountains. Ideally, I could use public transit for getting around in town and just use my car when I need to either transport things or leave the city. Unfortunately, the closest light rail stations to my home and work are about 1 and 2 miles respectively--a long walk. I've recently considered the combination of riding a bike and taking the light rail though.
- enraged_camel 8y agoHow often do you drive to the mountains though? Even if it’s once a week, there are cheaper options than owning a car - options which may also end up being more convenient if you take into account no longer needing a parking spot.
- KozmoNau7 8y agoDefinitely try riding your bike to the light rail station, 1-2 miles is a very comfortable riding distance.
- kaybe 8y agoAn electric scooter could be good too, depending on the road surface.
- GiorgioG 8y agoI personally love driving - but I work from home. Nothing makes me happier than remote starting my F150 and hearing its V8 roar from inside the house through several walls/doors. Have kids? When your kid spikes a fever at 1am and you have no car and you need to go buy some children’s ibuprofen, what are you going to do? I can run to my local 24/7 grocer or Walmart and be back in 10 minutes flat. My son had a bad reaction to a doctor prescribed medicine and had a seizure early one morning. We were at the hospital in 15 minutes thanks to the modern automobile. We don’t live in a city because we consciously chose the suburbs. I grew up in a walkable city and getting my first car was still one of the highlights of my youth. Now my kids play soccer and they practice and play 4 days/week all over the local area. Good luck doing that without a car. The freedom/flexibility a car provides us as individuals is unprecedented in human history. You can drive from NY to LA in 41 hours and you are on your own schedule. For the folks that don’t like driving, you have plenty of cities to choose from where that’s doable. That’s the beauty of modern society - the choice is yours and we don’t have to judge/demonize one another’s choices.
- dionidium 8y ago> When your kid spikes a fever at 1am and you have no car and you need to go buy some children’s ibuprofen, what are you going to do? I could hit 3 bodegas from my front steps with a rock. I don't need to start a truck to get Ibuprofen.
- GiorgioG 8y agoI’m happy for you but not everyone lives in such a place that has that many options within spitting distance.
- dionidium 8y agoSure, but the point is that nothing in your post was made possible by the automobile. People in walkable cities do everything you mention and they did all those things before the invention of the automobile. If you build a suburb so that you need a car, then, sure, I guess you'll need a car. But that's not because any of those activities require a car. It's just that your town was built to require it! If we put a dome over your town and sucked out all the oxygen, then you'd also need spacesuit to perform all those tasks, too. But it wouldn't be because any of those tasks require a space suit. You'd need the space suit because we sucked out all the oxygen.
- briandear 8y agoThere is an assumption that I actually want to interact with random members of the community. I don’t. Cars give me the freedom to choose my interactions and just generally be left alone. I don’t like waiting at bus stops, I don’t like having to watch my bag carefully or worry about forgetting things. I also don’t have to be exposed to whatever cold is making the rounds. I also don’t have to deal with psychotic, drug addicted homeless harassing me for money. Nor do I have to ride on a bus that makes twenty stops before it gets me to where I need to go. For me, cars represent freedom. If I want cold AC, I can do that. If I want to make a random diversion, I can do that too. Try to stop by Home Depot on the way home from work using public transit. Not only do you have to figure out the route and wait for the bus and possibly transfer and then tote whatever you buy back to a bus stop to do it all in reverse. If that makes me a bad person, then I am ok with that.
- BooneJS 8y agoThis is true of larger cities and metros, but the size of the US is too large to get rid of cars. I’m currently on a road trip through at least 7 states, and the car is the only way I pull that off.
- adrianN 8y agoIf the main use of cars were seven state road trips I don't think people would complain about being stuck in rush hour traffic or having to drive twenty minutes to the nearest grocery store.
- BooneJS 8y agoMy point was that cars are versatile people moving machines. They’re very imperfect, but they go almost anywhere. HN seems to have an assumption that what’s good for the Bay Area can be exported everywhere, but that’s simply not true.
- King-Aaron 8y agoI have three cars. I have a four wheel drive, for going out to collect fire wood, go camping, and do generally outdoors things with. I have a race/track car for being a general nuisance to society and shooting flames at people. And then I have a silly little automatic Honda for doing errands around the city when I need something cheap to operate and nimble around tight streets and things. Having these cars all fit particular requirements I have. However I still end up riding my push-bike or taking the bus, because the normal day-to-day commute doesn't always require storage capacity. I can certainly understand the reasons that people can be sufficiently happy with doing without a car. I can also understand the reasons why people are forced to need a car. I don't, however, like seeing people vilified or interrogated for being on either side of that fence.
- bluetomcat 8y agoExactly, owning a car doesn't actually oblige you to use it every day. I also have two garaged cars (a sports coupe and an economical diesel estate), located within a 30 minute walking distance from my home, because parking space is scarce. I use the estate for long trips and the coupe for short weekend trips. While driving, I enjoy every bit of it. I also enjoy keeping both cars in top shape. During the week, I solely walk and the temptation to use the cars is reduced because of the long distance to the garage.
- dixie_land 8y agosimilar experience, I use my Jeep to go anywhere city or jungle and the Mustang for the strip and simply for nice summer days. My drive to and from work is long at 1 hour each way but I found it still time well spent catching up on news on the radio. Once in the city I actually enjoy walking everywhere even for distance that my city friends would drive or take an Uber to. If driving doesn't put a smile on your face you simply have the wrong vehicle.
- walrus01 8y agoI would encourage anyone who wants to compare two very different cities to drive and ride the rail systems around Seattle and Vancouver. Vancouver has had a fully automated light rail system since 1986. New lines added in 2000 and 2009. There's significant high rise condo and apartment density around many stations. City council a very long time ago cancelled a plan to build a freeway from east vancouver to downtown. Seattle is sort of the opposite of that, it's very much more car dependent. The new light rail line helps a lot but its entry into service date was 22+ years after Vancouver's. In my experience in Vancouver a great deal more people live a lifestyle that doesn't involve owning a car. Gas is a lot more expensive and insurance is more expensive. Many "normal" people commute daily on transit. This is from 2002 but I don't think there's anything about it which is less relevant today, regarding suburban architecture/urban design and the lifestyles associated with extensive suburban sprawl: https://www.weeklystandard.com/david-brooks/patio-man-and-the-sprawl-people https://www.weeklystandard.com/david-brooks/patio-man-and-th...
- chadcmulligan 8y agoThis is interesting and relevant - Walkable cities https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wai4ub90stQ&frags=pl%2Cwn https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wai4ub90stQ&frags=pl%2Cwn
- KozmoNau7 8y agoAs a preface, I will admit that while I hate traffic, I do generally love driving. Not for any particular reason, just the act of making a machine obey my whims and take me where I want to go, ideally with AC and a good stereo. It satisfies some primal need in me, and I enjoy being the driver when we're on vacation, in a rental car. However, I am now in the third car-free period of my life, and I am not likely to buy a car again anytime soon, unless circumstances force me to do so. I grew in up a small town in the countryside, where I will certainly admit that not having a car would have been a major setback. But I've since lived in slightly bigger towns, where a car-free existence was easy, and now I live in Copenhagen, where the bicycle is basically king. The only reason I had a car here was because I thought I couldn't do without it. I see a lot of comments about people not wanting to interact with other people, and expressing fear of diseases, psychopathic homeless and people and a whole host of other -- frankly rather paranoid -- ideas. I use public transport and bike every day, and you absolutely don't have to interact with people, if you don't want to. And besides, people watching can be fun. There are some really bizarre and interesting folks out there.
- JDiculous 8y agoThis is honestly the main reason why I can't see myself settling down in the US. After 5 years living in Manhattan, I find the American suburbs extroardinarily isolating and depressing. Sure I could live in the city, but living in any city big enough to be interesting is too expensive for my tastes. I don't like being dependent on the paycheck of a high salary job (especially in workaholic NYC/USA where you get little time off). So in the meantime I've left the U.S. in search of cheaper cities that still have high quality of life, and walkability is a huge component of that.
- mmirate 8y agoSure, bicyxles are great and all - but I dare you to try even a half-mile commute via bicycle during the Florida summer if your job involves presenting yourself in a non-slobby manner.
- shankr 8y agoYou guys are spoiled. It doesn't even get in high 35 degree Celsius (95 degree Fahrenheit). I grew in a area where 35 was degree was the average temperature with lot of humidity, and we biked to our school. We didn't even have AC in most of the places. At least in USA, AC is so much more common. Also biking early in the morning is different from doing it during the afternoon. I suppose most of the people go to the work during the morning. We did bike to school around 8-9 AM. We felt heat starting around 10 AM. So there are ways to avoid baking under the Sun, and still able to bike.
- mmirate 8y agoSpoiled, eh? Well excuse me for wanting to be able to focus my thoughts onto something other than the ambient temperature, and for wanting to not drown in my own sweat. Seriously, now that uncomfortable weather is largely a solved problem in the modern world, we really would do better to move on to less mundane problems that have yet to be solved.
- twoquestions 8y agoIt'd be nice to not have to drive, but people hate people not behind the wheel of a car around here. Taking a bike on the road is taking your life in your own hands, people go out of their way to injure or kill cyclists around here, and the cops don't care. The sidewalks are also deliberately designed to be unpleasant, if they're present at all.
- mmirate 8y agoI don't hate those people per se (and I'm not stupid enough to attempt to harm them). What I hate is that they are usually moving far more slowly than what I and the people behind me would prefer, and that they do so even when passing them by is not possible. I'm not paid per-hour to commute, and I'm sure as hell not paid to sit behind some shit-for-brains who thinks it's a great idea to block an entire direction of a two-lane road with his slow-ass single-speed bicycle, whilst there is a solid wall of oncoming traffic.
- EADGBE 8y agoI don't think it's necessarily a bad thing; just what we've developed our vast infrastructure around. My commute is 30 miles one way. Luckily, I go against all the traffic, so it's a rather relaxing commute. It's one of the few times I get 30-40 minutes to myself a day. We spend many weekends at my in-laws' place on the lake. Even though it's in the same state, it's a completely different view, weather, and life style. It's about a 200 mile drive and many great conversations have happened on that commute. I went to college in a completely different state about an 8 or 9 hour drive. It was perfect because I wanted to be away from everyone I knew. I wanted to be self-sufficient. When I was too poor to afford a plane ticket, I could always afford the 3 tanks of gas it took round-trip to drive home whenever I wanted; at any pace I wanted. The reflecting time I had on that commute was pivotal to my career and life choices. Plenty of out-of-state family vacations have been haphazardly planned over long weekends and a few days of PTO. We never need to worry about leave time, TSA security checkpoints, our fluid bottles being too large, my guitars I bring with me, or anything else. We just get in the car and go. One of my bucket-list items is as-complete-as-possible trip down Route 66. I want to see America as it was, before vast interstates took you through nowhere to get where you were going. Roads (and therefore cars) are an integral part to understanding the vastness of the United States. If you haven't experienced it, I highly recommend it. Lastly, our rental properties all require handyman work. Access to a truck bed most weekends out of the year has saved me countless hours and money renting and borrowing. I only wish electric vehicles were more available, absolutely no other qualms about the Americans-and-Cars debate.
- wufufufu 8y agoThis article and some of the comments in here come off as extremely entitled to me. My background is I grew up in the suburbs away from any major city (closest city <200k people) and now I live walking distance to work in a major city. I still have a car, but I don't need it, and some of my coworkers don't have cars. The author never shows anything but correlation between transportation method and demographics. It's much more likely that wealth determines your proximity to work / transportation method than vice versa. This whole article just seems like a thinly veiled "I ride a bike to work and I hate cars -- they probably all voted for Trump cause they're poor and uneducated. Why don't they just get rich and smart and then they can walk to work and we don't need cars anymore and we can all live next to parks?" > “But it is increasingly clear that in addition to wasted time and productivity, reduced quality of life, and even fatalities, the automobile takes another toll. It may be that cars are not only the chief destroyer of our communities, but are tearing at the nation’s political and social fabric.” I posit that cars allowed population expansion because resources across a larger area became accessible and that we would have less people in existence if Fordism never happened. So blaming that innovation for wealth inequality is like blaming mass food production for wealth inequality. Why doesn’t everyone just have their own garden with chickens and quinoa? Why would anyone ever eat fast food? Why would anyone eat processed foods? > “The car and car-dominated infrastructure propelled suburbanization and white flight. They split our society into white, affluent suburbs and poor black and minority cities.” What? I’m pretty sure cities are segregated also, sometimes intentionally in history. This comes off as a pretty weak argument, but I could be convinced with more evidence.
- godot 8y agoI grew up in Hong Kong, one of the densest place in the world. Most of my childhood, getting to places was either walking or taking a bus (with family). I moved to the US / SF Bay Area in my teens and while here, experienced living in both the suburbs and the city, as well as my college town ("deep suburbs", if you will). My feeling is that living in the suburb (either where I currently live in a suburb in the bay area, or my college town) is way more pleasant than the city (either HK or SF). I felt this way before I had kids, and I feel this way even more now after having a baby. Yes, you have to drive everywhere. It seems that for some people, "having to drive everywhere" is automatically a negative point, by definition. IMO, it's only negative when you do that in San Francisco, where traffic is everywhere, and you can't park anywhere or have to pay exorbitant parking fees. Take some anecdotes of my current life now. People in SF and cities love to bring up the point of being able to walk to coffee shops, restaurants, bars, parks, and not having to find parking (which is an SF problem). I don't drink, so bars and DUI is not a thing for me. I reach my favorite coffee shop in 10 minutes of local driving (no traffic any time of the day, any day of the week), and there's always ample parking, and there's never a line. Same for all the restaurants I frequent in the east bay (Fremont/Newark/Union City area). Places in the city always have a line; whereas the longest line I've had at my coffee shop was 2 people in front of me. There's always seating available there, unlike most coffee shops in SF. I spend $3 on my favorite coffee there, not $6. This same example works similarly for every other aspect of life really, whether it's restaurants, parks, even urgent care/ER at the hospitals. Drive to get there in 10-15 minutes, there's always parking, no line at the place, and it's cheaper. Same applies for friends, even those who live a city or two away (Milpitas, San Leandro, Castro Valley) -- 15-30 minutes to get there, no traffic. I live in an older part of town, where houses are generally 50+ years old, so you can imagine the kind of neighborhood. I know each one of my neighbors by names. It's not like I grew up here too; I've only lived here for 5 years since I bought the house. Pulling from my own experience, I really don't see how the car keeps us apart, and how living in the city is better. Everything is more expensive, there's more wait time, more transportation time, and people are ruder in general because everyone is understandably frustrated with everything, whether it's patience, gentrification issues, homelessness, etc. In the suburb crawl, everything is the opposite of all of above. People are nicer to each other. I commute to the city for work (because the jobs are mostly in the city), and it's the least favorite part of my life.
- remusrm 8y agoWhat insanely selfish, regressive and obtuse article. Why not just move to an un contacted tribe! Its small, might have to shack up with your cousin, no need for a car, but who will bring in the cup of coffee? Hell who will be able to afford paying the rent or mortgage with a Starbucks job. What if you work for a construction company that makes his area you keep salivating over?