5 ms·
Inequality has other negative implications although they are far more indirect - misallocation of resources. To reduce to the absurd logical extreme while one t
by Nasrudith 8y ago
Inequality has other negative implications although they are far more indirect - misallocation of resources. To reduce to the absurd logical extreme while one technically might get the best students in the world by tutoring a handful of megawealthy kids with the budget of the entire US school system exposing all children would pay off far more just by giving them opportunity to advance more alone.
In addition that level of concentration has the power to corrupt systems to serve self-perpetuation of the interests of the wealth holder at the cost of everyone else. Horrifying third world corruption like lobbying against a reliable power grid because it would hurt the diesel and generator seller's profits despite it killing people and holding the country back.
Technically a robust system of law and justice could keep those controlled but money comes with myraid ways to undermine that. These are extreme examples but they demonstrate why it should be watched carefully.
- brobdingnagians 8y agoI think the really important point you make is the issue with corruption. If someone simply provides value and gets rewarded for it, that is great and they deserve the wealth; but it is the sad reality that most people with lots of money/power eventually seem to seek more power through any available means, which eventually becomes through by force of law and corrupting governments. The thirst for power and the hubris of seeing yourself as a kingmaker is a powerful temptation for a lot of people. I don't believe in forced redistribution or any of that (that usually just ends up making the problem worse). I think actually having a just system of laws which are enforced fairly and a culture that promotes virtue are the best guards against corruption.
- whalerider 8y agoJust for a point of clarification can you site a case where forced redistribution made the problem worse?
- anbende 8y agoThe Cultural Revolution and the rise of Soviet Russia resulted in widespread famine leading to the deaths of tens of millions of people in each country. It turns out that just handing the reins of power to an untrained and inexpert proletariat is not a good strategy.
- krageon 8y agoThe problem was forced distribution and how that is a bad idea. You've redefined it as "forced distribution by an untrained and inexpert proletariat and how it is not a good idea".
- whalerider 8y agoAgreed, my original question was not trying to conflate "poor people-proletariat" with "untrained and inexpert", I think that is a dangerous path of categorization.
- anbende 8y agoYou asked for times when forced redistribution of wealth caused problems. I complied. In the Russian case a major problem was that the means of production (farms and farm machinery) were taken from those who knew how to use and manage them (the landowners) and given to those who didn’t. This was an extreme example (landowners were massacred). More minor forms of wealth redistribution might be more viable. The bottom percentiles are substantially less trained an less educated than the upper percentiles. This is not a “dangerous conflation”. It is a fact. Education is strongly correlated with wealth. The bottom 50% are less likely to be educated either in college OR in a skilled vocation. You wouldn’t just put the janitor in the ceo role. Likewise, you wouldn’t target innovation and technical advance by cutting taxes to the the poorest citizens. You might cut taxes for other reasons (e.g., humanitarian)... And of course, increasing educational opportunities to the poor might help w innovation, but free education is not identical w wealth redistribution.
- anbende 8y agoRedistribution is always from the rich to the proletariat. “To” not “by”. I’ve pointed out that the proletariat is, on average, less expert and trained. You may disagree with this point, but I haven’t redefined anything. Instead, I’ve attempted to point out some ramifications of extreme equality. This is very different than having a strong social safety net..,
- AmIFirstToThink 8y ago"misallocation of resources" Resources... Somebody has it, you don't have it. But you want it. They don't want to give it to you. They came up with a way to collect it for themselves. You can't come with a way to get it from them, or collect it yourself. They use it the way they see fit. You will use it the way you see it fit if you ever get it. > These are extreme examples but they demonstrate why it should be watched carefully. Watch as much as you want. Control over it?, you are not going to be given rains just because you happen to be watching it. Wanters are wanting, havers are having, watchers are watching. World is running as desired by each one.