5 ms·
As an artist, this article makes me so upset. The people doing the actual work should be getting credit. Of course the people coming up with the ideas should
by pmoriarty 8y ago
As an artist, this article makes me so upset.
The people doing the actual work should be getting credit.
Of course the people coming up with the ideas should be getting credit too.
When one person comes up with the idea and another with product, it's a collaborative work and credit should be shared.
Artists who try to pass off a work they merely collaborated on as exclusively their own are despicable.
- psergeant 8y agoIf the technicians want credit, they should put it into the contract. If their input into it is a bought-and-sold commodity, which it seems to be, then they’re being paid in lieu of credit. Ghost writers will get paid different amounts depending on if they get to self-attribute or not.
- OscarCunningham 8y agoI guess the technician also gets paid regardless of whether the piece is well-received or sells for a high price. So the artist is also taking all of the risk.
- friendzis 8y agoNot to undermine the technicians, but there is a certain view to it. Let's say an artist comes up with an idea for an intricate lounge chair. It takes them two days to sketch it on paper. Art technician and manufacturing engineer work together to draw "schematics" of the chair in some CAD software to actually manufacture the chair, which takes them full two months of labor. Would their work be more or less significant if it was generic stool?
- jp555 8y agoIsn’t this kinda like the the difference between a chef and a cook? Many cooks work for a chef, and some grow on to become chefs.
- mattkevan 8y agoNot necessarily. It's the same as with many creative fields. An architect comes up with the overall concept and, if they're famous, gets their name on the building. But they still have a roomful of structural engineers figuring out how to stop it falling down. Or a musician. Creating an album takes a team of session musicians, producers, engineers etc. But it's the artist's name that goes on the front.
- rainbowmverse 8y agoIt's possible to do an album on your own, but it takes knowledge of every step in the process. Otherwise you end up with levels all over the place, and people stop listening at the first song that's too much louder than the others.
- extralego 8y agoMajor difference between making an album and handing it off to a producer or sound engineer. Pretty poor comparison.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- 7952 8y agoIn software development I tend to believe that the idea is not particularly valuable. The real value is being able to implement an idea effectively. That is what makes a great product work. It is striking how differently the art technicians in this article think. They see the idea as having all the intrinsic value. More cynically I wonder if it is really the marketing value of a big name rather than the quality of ideas that count. A great idea by an art student is far less valuable than a great idea from a famous painter or sculptor.
- lizardskull 8y ago“Very little is actually about execution, because the execution's primary purpose is to represent the idea. It's the actual idea that contains the values.” This quote from the article is a strange reflection of what the world of software development teaches.
- pastage 8y agoMy take on it is that it is the artist that brings the idea and make it come to light, they do this by letting other people do the work but they are still the visionaries and in charge of the execution of art. Good examples of ideas and execution is plentyfull in both software and art, just because you get both of them right doesn't mean you will succeed.
- extralego 8y agoThis just doesn’t represent reality of contemporary art. It’s a bullshitters game. These artists almost never even have a vision that is important to them. They behave as such, but the project motivations are consistently reflexive. They are just a response to what they thing will help their recognition. This is just not about expression. Historically, this is extremely wrong. Renaissance artists were the technicians of course. That’s what they were known for. This is the rot of an industry built on extracting funds from overly wealthy patrons with no limit to the amount of dishonesty.
- 8y ago
- protonimitate 8y agoI wish the crews would receive more credit as well. A good analogy would be if Hollywood films didn't list credits and pretended that only the director worked on the film and did everything by themselves. It would be insulting for people to believe that a director did 100% of the work on one of their films and ignored the entire crew. Not sure why this doesn't apply to the art world where teams are way more common than people believe.
- illwrks 8y agoDo you know the names of the people who produced the marketing campaigns that sold the film to audiences? Highly unlikely, no one ever knows those names....
- protonimitate 8y agoI don't understand the point you are trying to make.
- rewgs 8y agoIt's still partially this way, though. Credits in films are often unreliable or incomplete. Rather than simply being a record of history, credits are political and mingled with money, just like everything else.
- pnathan 8y agoI would agree, very strongly (I do a fair bit of fine art painting besides my software engineering day job). If so and so has the idea and so and so executes it, the there is a director and an artist working under the director. It seems extremely clear that to use assistants for more than grunt work and calling the finished product your own solo piece is quite dishonest. If we're all so obsessed with the Romantic ideal of the lone genius ala van Gogh, that's both ahistorical and silly of us.
- leavingreddit 8y agoAs a former artist I agree. I think what people don't see when they compare art to another industry like software, engineering or architecture in their examples is just how much work will go into a specific piece of art and just how corrupt the current art establishment is. Technical skill is hidden away to the point where people don't even really know the involvement of artists when it comes to stuff like art technicians. In fact I had a tough time convincing people I know that cgi isn't "all done by computers" and that actually the level of raw artistic skill in videogames is unbelievably high. I think it's right to be upset about credit being apportioned fairly. If a person is able to pretend they created a work of art whilst someone else profits off of it then that behavior will only be encouraged. Fundamentally though the decision does rest with the individual artists in question who offer their work up to people who give them no recognition. Ultimately if they're ok with it then perhaps there isn't a problem, but if not, then they should find a way in which to work where they are fairly rewarded for their efforts. Expecting the system to change or expecting people to stop taking advantage of others is unlikely to change anything.