5 ms·
>They're a part of the same suite of apps that provide the "Android experience" The thing they were fined for was >[Google] has required manufacturers to pre-
by wongarsu 8y ago
>They're a part of the same suite of apps that provide the "Android experience"
The thing they were fined for was
>[Google] has required manufacturers to pre-install the Google Search app and browser app (Chrome), as a condition for licensing Google's app store (the Play Store);
How is the Play Store related to the Google Seach app or to Chrome? One is an app store, one is a seach bar and one is a browser. They have nothing in common and don't interact in any meaningful way (except perhaps the interaction between the Google Seach app and Chrome, but that relation isn't part of the ruling).
This is clearly Google using the dominance of the Play store to push other, completely unrelated apps.
>zero customers want a vendor to do anything different
The first thing I do with a new phone is to try to get rid of that google search bar on the home screen (I open a browser to seach the web ...), I don't use mobile chrome, and I prefer rooted CyanogenMod / LineageOS over stock Android. So I am clearly impacted by all three offenses Google was fined for. I suspect I am not the only one.
- zaroth 8y ago> How is the Play Store related to the Google Seach app or to Chrome? “Related to” does not mean that they are the literally same thing. They are clearly related as a suite of applications which form the core experience of what is called “Android”. The law doesn’t say that if it is technically possible to unbundle a set of options from a product offering to be sold al la carte that companies must do that. These are all essential components of one product — a mobile OS. Mixing and matching, for the vast majority of users, is neither practical or expected, and absolutely negatively impacts the brand.
- wongarsu 8y ago> Mixing and matching, for the vast majority of users, is neither practical or expected, and absolutely negatively impacts the brand. Microsoft should be delighted then that they can force Internet Explorer on everyone again. > They are clearly related as a suite of applications which form the core experience of what is called “Android”. That argument doesn't hold for Chrome. The core experience of Android is the AOSP browser (aka Android Browser). Later Google started to use their monopoly to force the inclusion of Chrome alongside Android Browser, followed by the removal of Android Browser in Android 4.4. And even now, the only reason Chrome is part of the "core android experience" is because Google pushes hard to make it that way. There are plenty of other good mobile browsers. >These are all essential components of one product — a mobile OS But Google doesn't licence the OS. They donated the OS to Open Source, and use their licencing agreement for the App store to control unrelated parts of the OS experience
- endorphone 8y agoMicrosoft should be delighted then that they can force Internet Explorer on everyone again. Microsoft does force Internet Explorer cum Edge on everyone. They never stopped. When the EU forced them to offer a trivial "justify a giant fine" selection tool it did essentially nothing in regards to browser share. It keeps getting cited as the precedent, and while it is in the "EU makes some fat bank" way, it did absolutely nothing for consumers. And that's for an OS that was tremendously more entrenched, whereas I recently swapped out my GS8 for an iPhone 8 with nary a hiccup (and as an aside still enjoy all those Google services). There is so much bullshit happening throughout this discussion. Elsewhere people are claiming that Chrome became popular because Google pushed it on their homepage, which is just ridiculous, revisionist nonsense. Chrome became popular because it earned word of mouth as a lighter, faster browser. It exploded. The same happened with Firefox. Because the platform was open and allowed you to choose whatever you want to run. Just as I can and do run Firefox on Android. Further, vendors/carriers only abuse the right to put in alternatives. It is traditionally called crapware.
- sbuk 8y ago> …which is just ridiculous, revisionist nonsense. As is your version of events. As with all extreme points of view, the truth lies somewhere towards the middle.
- jhasse 8y ago> They are clearly related as a suite of applications which form the core experience of what is called “Android”. I'm using Android every day and never once opened Chrome (instead I'm using the Lightning browser) or used the Google app to search (I'm just searching directly in my browser). So IMHO that's definitely NOT the core experience of Android, while the Play Store is.
- phobosdeimos 8y agoSame. The Android experience is being able to choose your own browser, media player, email app etcetera. I know ecosystems make corporations a lot of money and some people prefer them. And they can choose an iPhone or Pixel.
- endorphone 8y agoNeat. So the OS allowed you to choose alternatives and to avoid Chrome wholly. So you're fully of the opinion that the EU argument has no merit then, right? Of course, saying it's a part of the Android/Google Experience is from the average consumer. You know that you have the Chrome browser if you so choose. Yes, you can go to the Play Store and install Firefox. Unlike on iOS where the browser alternatives are facades.
- jhasse 8y agoIt's the same argument as with Microsoft vs. the EU regarding IE: Defaults are important when you have a monopoly.
- joshuamorton 8y agoI'm pretty sure that an important part of the Microsoft argument was that you couldn't uninstall ie and it was used by certain system functions even if you set a different default. That's an important distinction. (Im a Googler, but that's not particularly relevant to this comment)
- jhasse 8y ago
- ckastner 8y ago> Mixing and matching, for the vast majority of users, is neither practical or expected, and absolutely negatively impacts the brand. Firefox has over a 100 million downloads according to the Play Store, so that argument at least doesn't work for bundling Chrome.
- barbegal 8y agoBut that is 100 million out of over 6 billion Android phones shipped [1] which means around 2% of users install Firefox. [1] https://www.statista.com/statistics/263445/global-smartphone-sales-by-operating-system-since-2009/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/263445/global-smartphone...
- pas 8y agoPlay store shows Chrome installed 1b+ times, with 9M ratings, Firefox has 3M ratings and 100m+ installs. So it can easily mean 950 million installs for Firefox.
- itsmenotyou 8y ago> How is the Play Store related to the Google Seach app or to Chrome? - They're not, and the attempt to claim they are part of a mobile "suite" is the same sort of obfuscation Microsoft used when they argued a web browser (IE) was an essential part of a desktop OS. This ruling seems obvious to me.
- endorphone 8y agoSo good of you to cut right through the nuance. But of course to an Android buyer, it is all a part of the experience with the device. They know what to expect and what is there. "he same sort of obfuscation Microsoft used when they argued a web browser" And Microsoft was right. Windows has Explorer or Edge. It still does. The EU giant fine did absolutely nothing but made them realize that cashing in big on American companies is essentially free. Of course I still download Firefox, just as you can do on Android.
- stingraycharles 8y ago“But of course to an Android buyer, it is all a part of the experience with the device. They know what to expect and what is there.” The problem is that by not giving the choice makes this anti-competitive behaviour. What’s wrong with giving Samsung the ability to make a deal with Yahoo to install Yahoo as the default in their Android phones? If they claim it’s all part of their integrated experience, then they should provide the necessary APIs/SDKs for other search providers to integrate properly. We’ve been over this before, it’s anti-competitive behaviour, and it lacks choice.
- bad_user 8y ago> But of course to an Android buyer, it is all a part of the experience with the device. Only if the device is advertised as being an Android, which is a trademark that you cannot use without Google’s agreement. You can’t use anything Google related actually, besides AOSP, so I don’t see how Google can make that argument with a straight face. And on Microsoft... they could easily block any competition just like Apple is doing on iOS. That you are able to install Firefox on it, be thankful to previous antitrust fines they got ;-)
- skratlo 8y ago> I prefer rooted CyanogenMod / LineageOS over stock Android Well then, that's your choice, and with that you admit to belong to some 0.0001% of Android users who are willing to open up their phones to all kinds of security exploits, and reduce its value to some laughable percentile, as is known, with CyanogenMod / LineageOS most of the good part go to hell, camera goes to hell, performance goes, ... and you get what? Glowing aura of open source user
- wongarsu 8y ago>with CyanogenMod / LineageOS most of the good part go to hell, camera goes to hell, performance goes All that goes to hell because Google prevents almost all first party support for LinageOS (or any other forks), which is why Google gets fined now. In a theoretical world where Google didn't do the things they are fined for, LineageOS might work much better on a wider range of hardware and thus have much more mainstream appeal.
- Piskvorrr 8y agoAnd I get a phone that's six years old and still works as designed, despite bloat pouring in from app vendors. I understand that I should have dumped that as a brick of e-waste to a landfill, seven years ago. Imagine a very uncivil rant starting from here, on where you should stuff your privileged SV advice.